Daniel 7 can't support Amil's Timeline Pertaining to Rev 6:9-11, Rev 20:4

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,162
372
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Quite foolish.

Mat 10:8-23
  • Heal the sick, cleanse the lepers, raise the dead, cast out devils: freely ye have received, freely give.
  • Provide neither gold, nor silver, nor brass in your purses,
  • Nor scrip for your journey, neither two coats, neither shoes, nor yet staves: for the workman is worthy of his meat.
  • And into whatsoever city or town ye shall enter, enquire who in it is worthy; and there abide till ye go thence.
  • And when ye come into an house, salute it.
  • And if the house be worthy, let your peace come upon it: but if it be not worthy, let your peace return to you.
  • And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart out of that house or city, shake off the dust of your feet.
  • Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city.
  • Behold, I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves: be ye therefore wise as serpents, and harmless as doves.
  • But beware of men: for they will deliver you up to the councils, and they will scourge you in their synagogues;
  • And ye shall be brought before governors and kings for my sake, for a testimony against them and the Gentiles.
  • But when they deliver you up, take no thought how or what ye shall speak: for it shall be given you in that same hour what ye shall speak.
  • For it is not ye that speak, but the Spirit of your Father which speaketh in you.
  • And the brother shall deliver up the brother to death, and the father the child: and the children shall rise up against their parents, and cause them to be put to death.
  • And ye shall be hated of all men for my name's sake: but he that endureth to the end shall be saved.
  • But when they persecute you in this city, flee ye into another: for verily I say unto you, Ye shall not have gone over the cities of Israel, till the Son of man be come.
When we are persecuted in one church, we don't say it's all over, we flee to another. We never give up and never stop preaching. Keep going until there are no more churches, no more who will listen, no more who will hear. Sure, this is the time God is judging, but God has assured us that it will be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgment, than for that city. That's not our business, that's His.

Second, you can't argue a doctrine from silence. There is no scripture that says stop preaching the gospel when you are hated, persecuted, in great tribulation or when seeing the abominations in your church. We come out, and we mourn, but we do not abandon our calling. So, why would we silence ourselves? The wicked will make sure the gospel is silenced, we don't have to, nor should we do it ourselves, because that's contrary to what God wants of us.

Selah!
Amos 3:7 Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets.

If you can know when Satan is loosed then that conversation I proposed in the post above would be accurate.

If you can’t know when Satan is loosed then Amos 3:7 shows why we might think you have the wrong interpretation.
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,162
372
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Absolutely not. I'm not adding Satan's little season after the thousand years. It's already there in the text. This is so incredibly stupid. You are completely wasting your time with this nonsense. In no way, shape or form is this comparable to adding a time gap within the 70 weeks.
Talk about a strawman. Nobody is accusing you of adding Satan’s little season. You are adding time to how long the rest of the dead stay dead. They live after the thousand years, they live during Satan’s little season.

They will live again after the thousand years just as the text states. It just so happens that Satan's little season happens first as well. So what? LOL! What a joke.
That’s the same logic as arguing Christ arose after 9 days. LOL.
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,135
975
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
[*]Heal the sick, cleanse the lepers, raise the dead, cast out devils: freely ye have received, freely give.

For example, how many times in your spiritual journey have you done any of these things? Or why bring this up if it's not applicable in your case? The Bible says to be doers of the word not be hearers only. As for me, I have done none of those things listed above. But I'm not the one submitting any of those things as arguments for my view.
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,135
975
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I agree with you. Here’s a conversation that TS might have with his neighbor after he thinks Satan is loosed …

Bob) hi TS how’s it going?
TS) good.
Bob) you’ve witnessed to me in the past but now I’m ready to accept Jesus as my savior.
TS) I’m sorry Bob, Satan was loosed out of the pit yesterday.
Bob) I’m serious, I believe Jesus is the Christ and according to John 3:16 I’m now saved.
TS) no, it’s too bad for you Bob, you can’t be saved now, you’re gonna be cast into the lake of fire.

The same convo between SI and a neighbor might go like this

Bob) high SI how’s it going?
SI) good.
Bob) you’ve witnessed to me in the past but now I’m ready to accept Jesus as my savior.
SI) The millennium ended yesterday and satan's little season began. But no worries, you can still be saved today and be part of the first resurrection and live and reign with Christ a thousand years.
Bob) You mean similar to something @Douggg was teaching, that events of the 5th trumpet happen during the 7th trumpet?
SI ) No, his view is illogical. You can't have events taking place forward in time if the events already happened earlier in time. But you can for sure go backward in time. That it is not illogical even if the events are happening after the time that already expired, you can still experience the time that already expired in the past in the present .
Bob ) I changed my mind. I don't want to be saved after all. I can't trust that something that is illogical that it is correct somehow.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Goodness sakes...... I'm arguing that the passage, as a whole, of Revelation 20:4-5 refers to a physical resurrection of those that were killed by the beast. ζάω means living, and the context (passage as a whole) defines how its being used.

According to Thayer's outline, the word ζάω means
  1. to live, breathe, be among the living (not lifeless, not dead)

And more specifically in the context of Revelation 20, Thayer's Lexicon defines it as: "restored to life" or "to no longer be dead".

to be no longer dead, to recover life, be restored to life: Matthew 9:18; Acts 9:41; so of Jesus risen from the dead, Mark 16:11; Luke 24:5, 23; Acts 1:3; Acts 25:19; Romans 6:10; 2 Corinthians 13:4; opposed to νεκρός, Revelation 1:18; Revelation 2:8; ἔζησεν came to life, lived again, Romans 14:9 G L T Tr WH (opposed to ἀπέθανε); Revelation 13:14; Revelation 20:4, 5
I disagree with Thayer's interpretation of Revelation 20:4, which is all that is. Tell me why the word "anazao" is not used in verse 4 like it is in verse 5 if it's referring to the bodily resurrection of the dead.
Sure, if thayer's is wrong (because of course the random guy on the internet is right over a lexical source), then just provide another lexical source that defines ζάω as "spiritual life" in in the context of revelation 20:4.
As if I'm familiar with several Greek lexical sources? I'm not. In doing some research online about this, it does not seem that any other Greek lexical sources try to interpret Revelation 20:4 the way Thayers's and BDAG do. They just give definitions of the word and do not indicate one way or another how it is used in Revelation 20:4. Those definitions do not include being alive after previously being bodily resurrected from the dead. The word means to live or to be alive without indicating one way or another if someone was previously dead. Just because a couple of Greek resources decided to give their opinions on what the word means in Revelation 20:4 does not prove anything.

Since, according to you, Thayer's is wrong, here's the BDAG lexical entry:
"of dead persons who return to life become alive again: of humans in general (3 Km17:23) Mt9:18; Ac9:41; 20:12; Rv 20:4, 5;"
There is something you're missing about my argument here. I don't deny that the word can be used to described someone as being alive after previously being dead. But, the word itself does not imply one way or another if the living person was previously dead. I'm saying that the word is not used in direct relation to the actual resurrection of the dead and not used to imply that someone living was formerly dead. Other Greek words like anastasis, anazao and others are used for describing the resurrection of the dead. There is no specific word to describe someone being alive who had been resurrected some time prior, so that's why the word "zao" can refer to them because that is the word generally used to describe someone being alive or living their lives.

Take Matthew 9:18, for instance. It says this...

Matthew 9:18 While He spoke these things to them, behold, a ruler came and worshiped Him, saying, “My daughter has just died, but come and lay Your hand on her and she will live.”

So, in this verse the word "zao" is used to describe someone living who was previously dead. But, that does not mean the word "zao" itself tells us she was previously dead. The word just means to be alive or to be living.

Later, it says this about the girl...

Matthew 9:25 But when the crowd was put outside, He went in and took her by the hand, and the girl arose (Greek: egeiro).

When referring to her actual resurrection from the dead, it does not use the word "zao", but instead uses the word "egeiro". The word "zao" is never used to describe the act of someone rising from the dead nor is it used to indicate that someone living had previously been dead at some point. In Revelation 1:18, the word "zao" is used to refer to Jesus being alive and it mentions that He had previously been dead, but the word "zao" itself is not what tells us that He had previously been dead. This is what you apparently don't understand.

Can you provide a lexical entry that specifically lists revelation 20:4 in ζάω's usage for "spiritual life"? Still waiting on this.
I can't find any other lexical entries that specifically lists Revelation 20:4 at all in relation to that word.

Its that easy. Just one lexicon that agrees with what you are arguing.
LOL. You have identified the only 2 lexicons that I know of that even attempt to define the word in relation to Revelation 20:4, so how can I do that?

But I have a feeling you won't and will continue to drag this out with lol's, laughing emojis, ad hominems, being annoyed, etc......
I don't care what you think. I really don't. You believe false teaching and it's sad that you are unteachable.

Do you not know that context often provides the meaning of a word? ζάω is not the same word as ἀνάστασις, but ζάω can be understood as living (dead persons returning to life) in certain contexts.

ζάω on its own doesn't mean spiritual life, but context can tell us when it does.
I don't trust your ability to understand context at all, so you saying this is meaningless to me.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Can you provide clear and explicit gospel/epistolic teachings that dead souls are reigning in heaven?
Paul taught in passages like 2 Corinthians 5:6-8 and Philippians 2:21-24 that he expected to be present with Christ in heaven immediately upon his physical death. And other scriptures like 1 Peter 2:5-9 and Revelation 1:5-6 refer to the current status of believers as priests of God and Christ. So, why would that status change once a person physically dies and their soul goes to be in heaven with Christ?

Strong's is a concordance, not a lexicon. Strong's provides all the ways that a word was translated in english and where you will find them, specifically for the KJV. I'd recommend learning the difference between concordances and lexicons and their different uses (especially the proper way to use them).
I showed a list of Strong's definitions. He defined the word like this: ζάω záō, dzah'-o; a primary verb; to live (literally or figuratively):—life(-time), (a-)live(-ly), quick.

Nothing there about coming back to life from the dead. The word means to live or to be alive. It gives no indication one way or another whether the person who lives and is alive was previously dead or not.

yes, for real. If you were arguing what "ζάω" means in revelation 20:4 by using thayer's, it would seem obvious to include the section where thayer's defines ζάω in revelation 20:4.
I didn't see that at first. It's a lot of text. I was looking at the main definitions of the word that are given rather than looking at it's description of specific verses. The main definitions I saw didn't say anything about the word meaning to come to life or to be alive after previously being dead.

Sure, just provide a lexicon that demonstrates otherwise.
As far as I can tell, there are only 2 lexicons that specifically indicate how they thought the word was used in Revelation 20:4. This is not the way to discover the truth of this matter. Those are interpretations of the verse, not strict definitions of the word. There is no reason at all to think that the word specifically means to be alive after previously being dead at some point. I don't believe such a word even exists. It can be used to refer to someone who is alive after previously being dead, but the word itself gives no indication of that one way or another. So, it's a matter of interpretation.

Aren't the souls resting and waiting, or are their beheaded souls in heaven reigning?
What does this even mean? You think they are up there just laying around doing nothing? In Revelation 6:9-11 they are told to rest yet a little while longer while their fellow servants and brethren were killed as they were. but it's not saying they are to just lay around doing nothing while waiting for their deaths to be avenged. It's talking about them resting easy and not worrying about how long it would be until their deaths are avenged. It's not talking about them literally resting. We're not given much information at all about what things are like right now in heaven, but the idea that the souls of the dead in Christ are just up there resting while doing nothing is hilarious.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The same convo between SI and a neighbor might go like this

Bob) high SI how’s it going?
SI) good.
Bob) you’ve witnessed to me in the past but now I’m ready to accept Jesus as my savior.
SI) The millennium ended yesterday and satan's little season began. But no worries, you can still be saved today and be part of the first resurrection and live and reign with Christ a thousand years.
That is not what I claim. I have said many times that the thousand years has a beginning and an ending, so I would not tell someone during Satan's little season, which comes after the thousand years, that they can reign during the thousand years. That obviously makes no sense. You guys are making utter fools of yourselves with your misrepresentations of what I believe. Have you no shame?

Do you believe that Christ stops reigning when the thousand years ends despite scripture teaching that He will reign forever (Isaiah 9:6, Revelation 1:5-6)? Do you believe that people can be saved during Satan's little season?

Bob) You mean similar to something @Douggg was teaching, that events of the 5th trumpet happen during the 7th trumpet?
LOL. Such foolishness. My belief that people can be saved during Satan's little season, in light of passages like 2 Peter 3:9-12 that you referenced yourself, is not comparable to Douggg's nonsense at all.

SI ) No, his view is illogical. You can't have events taking place forward in time if the events already happened earlier in time.
You are blatantly misrepresenting my view by saying that I believe those who are saved during Satan's little season would reign during the thousand years. I have never said that. Why do you go out of your way to make a fool of yourself in your many failed attempts to refute Amil? Do you just enjoy that or something?

But you can for sure go backward in time. That it is not illogical even if the events are happening after the time that already expired, you can still experience the time that already expired in the past in the present .
I've never claimed this. Stop misrepresenting my view. Grow up.

Bob ) I changed my mind. I don't want to be saved after all. I can't trust that something that is illogical that it is correct somehow.
This is utter foolishness. You are slandering me and my beliefs. You should be ashamed of yourself.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Talk about a strawman.
Yes, you would know a lot about that since all you do is make strawman arguments.

Nobody is accusing you of adding Satan’s little season.
Except for you, you mean? You have said that I'm adding a time gap to the thousand years and you said what I'm adding is Satan's little season. Do you forget what you have said?

You are adding time to how long the rest of the dead stay dead.
No, I'm not. The text is clear that they will be resurrected after the thousand years without saying how long after that would be. It goes on to show that Satan's little season happens first. That's not a case of me adding anything. The text itself indicates they will be resurrected after the thousand years and after Satan's little season. Do you not believe that is the case? It shows them being resurrected and judged after Satan's little season in Revelation 20:11-15.

They live after the thousand years, they live during Satan’s little season.
Say what now? No, they are dead during the thousand years, which is why it says they will live again after the thousand years (hello?) and they are alive during Satan's little season as well because it doesn't talk about them being judged until after Satan's little season. Other scripture talks about the dead being resurrected and then judged, so it's not as if they would be resurrected and get to live during Satan's little season before being judged.

That’s the same logic as arguing Christ arose after 9 days. LOL.
Not even close. The text itself in Revelation 20 supports my understanding that the order of events is the thousand years followed by Satan's little season followed by the resurrection of the dead and judgment. There is no text saying that Christ arose after 9 days. Get serious. You are spewing nothing but nonsense at this point. Do you not have any desire to be taken seriously? Is this just all a big joke to you?
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,162
372
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Except for you, you mean? You have said that I'm adding a time gap to the thousand years and you said what I'm adding is Satan's little season. Do you forget what you have said?
You are adding the time it takes to fulfill Satan’s little season to the length of time the rest of the dead remain dead.

No, I'm not. The text is clear that they will be resurrected after the thousand years without saying how long after that would be. It goes on to show that Satan's little season happens first. That's not a case of me adding anything. The text itself indicates they will be resurrected after the thousand years and after Satan's little season. Do you not believe that is the case? It shows them being resurrected and judged after Satan's little season in Revelation 20:11-15.
So then using your same logic the thousand years could be literal because it doesn’t say how long after the thousand years Satan’s little season starts, right?

Say what now? No, they are dead during the thousand years, which is why it says they will live again after the thousand years (hello?) and they are alive during Satan's little season as well because it doesn't talk about them being judged until after Satan's little season. Other scripture talks about the dead being resurrected and then judged, so it's not as if they would be resurrected and get to live during Satan's little season before being judged.
I already gave you several scenarios where it’s possible the rest of the dead live during Satan’s little season but as always anything that doesn’t fit your narrative you just reject and you’re doing that now.

Not even close. The text itself in Revelation 20 supports my understanding that the order of events is the thousand years followed by Satan's little season followed by the resurrection of the dead and judgment. There is no text saying that Christ arose after 9 days. Get serious. You are spewing nothing but nonsense at this point. Do you not have any desire to be taken seriously? Is this just all a big joke to you?
The text doesn’t support your view, the text literally says the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years are finished. The Bible would be incorrect during Satan’s little season because the rest of the dead wouldn’t be alive at that time.

What do you think the word “until” means? <2193> heós ἕως, a particle marking a limit, and

I. as a conjunction signifying

1. the temporal terminus ad quem, till, until(Latindonee,usquedum); as in the best writings a. with an preterite indicative, where something is spoken of which continued up to a certain time: Matthew 2:9(ἕως ... ἔστη (ἐστάθη L T Tr WH)); (1 Macc. 10:50; Wis. 10:14, etc.).
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,135
975
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You are adding the time it takes to fulfill Satan’s little season to the length of time the rest of the dead remain dead.


So then using your same logic the thousand years could be literal because it doesn’t say how long after the thousand years Satan’s little season starts, right?


I already gave you several scenarios where it’s possible the rest of the dead live during Satan’s little season but as always anything that doesn’t fit your narrative you just reject and you’re doing that now.


The text doesn’t support your view, the text literally says the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years are finished. The Bible would be incorrect during Satan’s little season because the rest of the dead wouldn’t be alive at that time.

What do you think the word “until” means? <2193> heós ἕως, a particle marking a limit, and

I. as a conjunction signifying

1. the temporal terminus ad quem, till, until(Latindonee,usquedum); as in the best writings a. with an preterite indicative, where something is spoken of which continued up to a certain time: Matthew 2:9(ἕως ... ἔστη (ἐστάθη L T Tr WH)); (1 Macc. 10:50; Wis. 10:14, etc.).

But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished

Here is is what we start out with. Prior to the beginning of the millennium there is the dead in their graves. They consist of both the saved and the lost. Only the saved among them rise from the dead in the beginning of the millennium. The rest of the dead don't..

Where is the next place Revelation 20 shows that anyone rises from the dead, thus lives again?

Acts 24:15 And have hope toward God, which they themselves also allow, that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust.

Does satan's little season sound like it can fit this--there shall be a resurrection of the dead--the unjust?

Or does Revelation 20:11-15 sound like it can fit this---there shall be a resurrection of the dead--the unjust?


When Revelation 20:11-15 occurs, is the thousand years already finished or not? That is all the text requires, that the thousand years have to be finished before the rest of the dead live again. That can mean at the end of the millennium. And that it can mean after a gap following the millennium. Which of these do the texts support? Not what speculation supports, but what the text supports?

If we place them living again at the beginning of satan's little season, where do we place those in verse 9 living again? Or should we assume they are never resurrected in order to be part of the resurrection of the dead--the unjust? They bypass resurrection followed by judgment altogether.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,162
1,075
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Amos 3:7 Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets.

If you can know when Satan is loosed then that conversation I proposed in the post above would be accurate.

Not at all! God will NOT let His people know the day and hour Satan comes out of bottomless pit. And we also do not know when the last Elect is secured. We do not KNOW when what day and hour Christ will return. That is not what Amos is about. It is about the kingdom, the signs of Christ's return, and if we indeed in the short season. So no you are not accurate.

If you can’t know when Satan is loosed then Amos 3:7 shows why we might think you have the wrong interpretation.

You don't even know what Amos 3:7 talks about.

I don't think God is working to make it harder for Christians to understand. Now as far as people who aren't really saved, yes it's a stumbling block, and they're not going to really understand anyway. Many can understand intellectually, but they will never understand what is spiritually discerned.

As for God keeping it from church people who are not really saved, that may be a possibility because God does declare that he sends strong delusion to those who refuse to receive truth. So is there evil in a city, and the LORD hath not allowed it? No. There is a divine purpose and reason for everything. So there is obviously some deliberate "action" of God working in that instance of 2nd Thessalonians with God His sending them liars to deceive them, as judgment upon them for their obstinance.

I don't believe God is keeping it from "His people." And the rest of the people of the congregation read the Bible as the confusing parable it is to them, and so they can't discern it anyway. You have to remember, all this is Spiritually discerned. Which means the working of the Holy Spirit within us has to be the one that reveals the Bible's truth to us. We don't understand because we are smarter, or are a harder worker, or because we are more educated. It's only by grace of God that anyone has wisdom to understand the word of God Spiritually. That an angel is nothing but a messenger literally is a truth that is blocked by years of indoctrination, traditions and depending upon the ideas of those who went before. Not because Scripture actually says it. Just as those who can't see the falling of the churches, the loosening of Satan, the rise of false prophets and christs, the drying of the river, the whore and her relationship with the beast, etc. God reveals it to us by His Spirit, not by man's teaching, holding onto tradition or warnings from the pulpit. The church is in trouble:

Amos 3:6-7
  • "Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?
  • Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets."
God always looks out for His servants (True Chosen Elect/Two Witnesses) and He reveals his plans and judgments to them beforehand. Not the exact day and hour when Satan was bound, loosened, or when the last Elect was secured. The problem is, the the Lord's people, the corporate children or professed Christians like here, just keeps reviling them, persecuting them and calling those who come with truth, blasphemers, Gnostics, too much spiritualizing, etc. Sounds familiar? Always has, always will! Till He come!
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,162
1,075
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
For example, how many times in your spiritual journey have you done any of these things? Or why bring this up if it's not applicable in your case? The Bible says to be doers of the word not be hearers only. As for me, I have done none of those things listed above. But I'm not the one submitting any of those things as arguments for my view.

Wait, first, tell me exactly what Christ mean when he said in Matthew 10:8 to see if you know what you are talking about?

[*]Heal the sick, cleanse the lepers, raise the dead, cast out devils: freely ye have received, freely give.
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,162
372
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished

Here is is what we start out with. Prior to the beginning of the millennium there is the dead in their graves. They consist of both the saved and the lost. Only the saved among them rise from the dead in the beginning of the millennium. The rest of the dead don't..

Where is the next place Revelation 20 shows that anyone rises from the dead, thus lives again?

Acts 24:15 And have hope toward God, which they themselves also allow, that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust.

Does satan's little season sound like it can fit this--there shall be a resurrection of the dead--the unjust?

Or does Revelation 20:11-15 sound like it can fit this---there shall be a resurrection of the dead--the unjust?


When Revelation 20:11-15 occurs, is the thousand years already finished or not? That is all the text requires, that the thousand years have to be finished before the rest of the dead live again. That can mean at the end of the millennium. And that it can mean after a gap following the millennium. Which of these do the texts support? Not what speculation supports, but what the text supports?

If we place them living again at the beginning of satan's little season, where do we place those in verse 9 living again? Or should we assume they are never resurrected in order to be part of the resurrection of the dead--the unjust? They bypass resurrection followed by judgment altogether.
If you allow time gaps in the scriptures I think you can have a consistent argument. You can argue for the next definition of the word “until” in Revelation 20:5.

b. with ἄν and the aorist subjunctive (equivalent to the Latin future perfect), where it is left doubtful when that will take place till which it is said a thing will continue (cf. Winer's Grammar, § 42, 5):



Then you can look at Daniel 9:27 and apply that same kind of definition to the word “until” <5704> as far as, even to, up to, until, while.

Daniel 9:27 And he shall confirm the covenant with many for one week: and in the midst of the week he shall cause the sacrifice and the oblation to cease, and for the overspreading of abominations he shall make it desolate, even until the consummation, and that determined shall be poured upon the desolate.

In other words if we say the word “until” in Revelation 20:5 allows us to essentially add time to when the rest of the dead live again, we can say the word “until” in Daniel 9:27 essentially allows us to add time to the 70 weeks. Especially since you have all of Daniel 9:27 taking place within the 70 weeks.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,162
1,075
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The same convo between SI and a neighbor might go like this

Bob) high SI how’s it going?
SI) good.
Bob) you’ve witnessed to me in the past but now I’m ready to accept Jesus as my savior.
SI) The millennium ended yesterday and satan's little season began. But no worries, you can still be saved today and be part of the first resurrection and live and reign with Christ a thousand years.
Bob) You mean similar to something @Douggg was teaching, that events of the 5th trumpet happen during the 7th trumpet?
SI ) No, his view is illogical. You can't have events taking place forward in time if the events already happened earlier in time. But you can for sure go backward in time. That it is not illogical even if the events are happening after the time that already expired, you can still experience the time that already expired in the past in the present .
Bob ) I changed my mind. I don't want to be saved after all. I can't trust that something that is illogical that it is correct somehow.

What a hoot! Davidpt, apparently you have completely missed the point of what I (or probably SI) have repeatedly explained.

Where have I ever claimed that I know the day the millennium ends, when Satan is loosed, or when the last Elect is sealed? Nowhere!

I have consistently warned that no man knows when the last of God's Elect will be secured, when Satan will be loosed for his little season, or when the millennium, as you understand it, reaches its conclusion. These are events within God's sovereign timetable, not dates that I claim to know or can announce to my neighbor.

Your sarcastic illustration depends on putting words in my mouth that I have never said. You have invented a scenario in which I supposedly know that the millennium ended yesterday and then proceed to tell someone that salvation is still available. That is not my teaching; it is a straw-man argument of your own making.

Furthermore, you seem to confuse understanding the prophetic sequence of events with claiming to know the exact timing of their fulfillment. Those are two entirely different things!

I can explain what Scripture teaches about the binding and loosing of Satan, the sealing of the Elect, and the little season without pretending to know God's appointed timetable.

So before constructing another imaginary conversation to ridicule my position, perhaps you should first address what I actually teach rather than attacking a position you invented for me.

Try dealing with my actual argument for a change. Selah!
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,796
4,306
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
That is not what I claim. I have said many times that the thousand years has a beginning and an ending,
The words "Thousand Years" doesn't have a beginning or end, it does nothing more than explain that the subject is in the Lord's eternal spiritual realm in 2 Peter 3:8, Rev 20:4-7 where earthly time doesn't exist where one day is a thousand years, it appears that you want to apply the Lord's eternal realm "Thousand Years" to this earthly realm

Below in Rev 20:7 states "The Thousand Years Are Expired" means nothing more than the subject is moving from the Lord's eternal realm into the earthly realm, its that simple

(Thousand Years) = The Lord's Eternal Realm

In Love, Jesus Is The Lord

Revelation 20:7-8KJV
7 And when the thousand years are expired, Satan shall be loosed out of his prison,
8 And shall go out to deceive the nations which are in the four quarters of the earth, Gog, and Magog, to gather them together to battle: the number of whom is as the sand of the sea.
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,162
372
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Not at all! God will NOT let His people know the day and hour Satan comes out of bottomless pit. And we also do not know when the last Elect is secured. We do not KNOW when what day and hour Christ will return. That is not what Amos is about. It is about the kingdom, the signs of Christ's return, and if we indeed in the short season. So no you are not accurate.
In Luke 21:20-21 it says when you see Jerusalem being surrounded by armies then flee. The Lord revealed to His servants His secret, they fled, and they lived. That historically happened and Amos 3:7 was true at that time.

You have a spiritual scenario where the church is surrounded and believers are to flee. Except you don’t have believers being able to know exactly when to flee or exactly when the two witnesses are killed or exactly when they rise up and preach judgement to the apostate church. If Amos 3:7 doesn’t apply then I have to question your view, because historically it did apply.

How are you ever going to know if the two witnesses have already risen after 3.5 days? All it would take is one person to become saved and you’d have to say the two witnesses have not yet died.

A person believing your view has to do mental gymnastics to know what kind of witness they’re supposed to be. Have the two witnesses died yet?
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,796
4,306
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
A person believing your view has to do mental gymnastics to know what kind of witness they’re supposed to be. Have the two witnesses died yet?
He doesn't believe that the two witnesses of Rev Chap 11 will be literal prophets with physical bodies that die, he claims the two witnesses symbolically represent the church and its witness to the world
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
793
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I disagree with Thayer's interpretation of Revelation 20:4, which is all that is. Tell me why the word "anazao" is not used in verse 4 like it is in verse 5 if it's referring to the bodily resurrection of the dead.

Well, “ἀναζάω” (anazao) appears in the Textus Receptus at Revelation 20:5 because of Erasmus's editorial work. Erasmus used Greek manuscript 2814 (Minuscule 1) and the Latin Vulgate to reconstruct portions of Revelation missing from his Greek manuscript. While, manuscript 2814 does contain Revelation 20:5, it does not read ἀνέζησαν from what I could find? Instead it reads ἀνέστησαν (“they came to life/rose again”), rather than ἀνέζησαν. As to why he changed to ἀναζάω, I don’t know. There aren’t many commentators on exactly why, maybe scribal error? Maybe Latin vulgate instead? That being said I couldn’t find any evidence for g326 “anazao” present in revelation 20:5 prior to Erasmus’ editing of it.

Regardless, The overwhelming majority of Greek manuscripts read ἔζησαν (ezēsan, G2198), not ἀνέζησαν (anezēsan, G326). If you go on blue letter Bible and click on MGNT instead of TR, you will see g2198 in revelation 20:5, not g326.

So you are argument about g326 really isn’t a valid argument.

As if I'm familiar with several Greek lexical sources? I'm not. In doing some research online about this, it does not seem that any other Greek lexical sources try to interpret Revelation 20:4 the way Thayers's and BDAG do. They just give definitions of the word and do not indicate one way or another how it is used in Revelation 20:4. Those definitions do not include being alive after previously being bodily resurrected from the dead. The word means to live or to be alive without indicating one way or another if someone was previously dead. Just because a couple of Greek resources decided to give their opinions on what the word means in Revelation 20:4 does not prove anything.

Remember, a biblical dictionary is different than a concordance which is different than a lexicon. A lexicon will give meaning within a specific context. There are more lexicons than just thayers and BDAG, but I haven’t found yet that doesn’t agree with thayers or BDAG in regards to revelation 20:5.

There is something you're missing about my argument here. I don't deny that the word can be used to described someone as being alive after previously being dead. But, the word itself does not imply one way or another if the living person was previously dead. I'm saying that the word is not used in direct relation to the actual resurrection of the dead and not used to imply that someone living was formerly dead. Other Greek words like anastasis, anazao and others are used for describing the resurrection of the dead. There is no specific word to describe someone being alive who had been resurrected some time prior, so that's why the word "zao" can refer to them because that is the word generally used to describe someone being alive or living their lives.

Take Matthew 9:18, for instance. It says this...

Matthew 9:18 While He spoke these things to them, behold, a ruler came and worshiped Him, saying, “My daughter has just died, but come and lay Your hand on her and she will live.”

So, in this verse the word "zao" is used to describe someone living who was previously dead. But, that does not mean the word "zao" itself tells us she was previously dead. The word just means to be alive or to be living.

Later, it says this about the girl...

Matthew 9:25 But when the crowd was put outside, He went in and took her by the hand, and the girl arose (Greek: egeiro).

When referring to her actual resurrection from the dead, it does not use the word "zao", but instead uses the word "egeiro". The word "zao" is never used to describe the act of someone rising from the dead nor is it used to indicate that someone living had previously been dead at some point. In Revelation 1:18, the word "zao" is used to refer to Jesus being alive and it mentions that He had previously been dead, but the word "zao" itself is not what tells us that He had previously been dead. This is what you apparently don't understand.

Right, but what’s the context of revelation 20? Resurrection.

That’s why the bdag and thayer’s define it as being restored to life, no longer dead.

Can you provide any lexicons that support your definition and context?

I can't find any other lexical entries that specifically lists Revelation 20:4 at all in relation to that word.
LOL. You have identified the only 2 lexicons that I know of that even attempt to define the word in relation to Revelation 20:4, so how can I do that?

I think you like to study the Bible seriously. I have faith that if you are serious, you would be like the bereans, and not rely on your own personal framework.

I don't care what you think. I really don't. You believe false teaching and it's sad that you are unteachable.

uggggh, generic statement that could be said of you as well. Come on SI you can do better than that.

I don't trust your ability to understand context at all, so you saying this is meaningless to me.

Exactly!!! That’s why I’m providing lexicons (thayer’s and BDAG) that define “lived” as being restored to life, no longer dead due to the context. It’s not my own personal made up definition. Instead, I leave that to the experts. Which, I know, I know, you claim are wrong without any evidence…..

Sooooooo why should I trust your claim, which isn’t backed by anything?
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You are adding the time it takes to fulfill Satan’s little season to the length of time the rest of the dead remain dead.
The text itself does that. I'm not adding anything that isn't there in the text. You are wasting your time making a completely inane argument.

So then using your same logic the thousand years could be literal because it doesn’t say how long after the thousand years Satan’s little season starts, right?
It doesn't specify whether the thousand years is literal or not, so that is up for interpretation. As far as it not saying how long after the thousand years Satan's little season starts, I think it's implied that it starts immediately when the thousand years ends. But, if you want to be very technical about this then there are always multiple possibilities whenever the text doesn't explicitly spell things out for us. But, I think it's safe to assume Satan's little season starts when the thousand years ends, as a vast majority of interpreters agree.

I already gave you several scenarios where it’s possible the rest of the dead live during Satan’s little season
You did? Where? And how does that make any sense when we can see the dead being judged after Satan's little season ends? What would they be doing exactly during Satan's little season? And how would that fit Jesus saying that the hour is coming when all of the dead will be resurrected with unbelievers, which "the rest of the dead" are, being resurrected unto damnation. How could what He said be true if they are instead resurrected and allowed to roam on the earth for a little season?

but as always anything that doesn’t fit your narrative you just reject and you’re doing that now.
LOL. You are truly hilarious with your incessant nonsense. Keep it up. It's entertaining. You are trying to hard to trip me up and are failing miserably, but keep trying, if you insist.

The text doesn’t support your view, the text literally says the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years are finished.
How does that say that they live immediately after the thousand years are finished? It doesn't. Try again. And fail again. If you wish.

The Bible would be incorrect during Satan’s little season because the rest of the dead wouldn’t be alive at that time.
The Bible is never incorrect. It says the rest of the dead will live again after the thousand years end. If there is a little season after the thousand years before they are resurrected, which there is, it still will be true that the rest of the dead will be resurrected after the thousand years. Just not immediately after, but a little season after. Very simple. But, go ahead and make something simple into something convoluted, if you insist.

What do you think the word “until” means? <2193> heós ἕως, a particle marking a limit, and

I. as a conjunction signifying

1. the temporal terminus ad quem, till, until(Latindonee,usquedum); as in the best writings a. with an preterite indicative, where something is spoken of which continued up to a certain time: Matthew 2:9(ἕως ... ἔστη (ἐστάθη L T Tr WH)); (1 Macc. 10:50; Wis. 10:14, etc.).
The word does not mean that the event or time period that doesn't happen until another event or time periods ends necessarily has to happen immediately after the first event or time period ends. That's your assumption, but that is not what the word means. The overall text clearly shows that Satan's little season occurs after the thousand years ends and then the resurrection of the dead and judgment occurs following that. If you can't see that, then I feel sorry for you because it should be obvious. If you can see that, but you're just trying to be annoying and are playing games here, then I would feel sorry for you for that reason as well.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Right, but what’s the context of revelation 20? Resurrection.

That’s why the bdag and thayer’s define it as being restored to life, no longer dead.

Can you provide any lexicons that support your definition and context?
Did you not read everything I said? I said that there aren't any other lexicons that I know of that even attempt to indicate how the word is used in Revelation 20:4 specifically. But, the main definition of the word that I see in the lexicons I did look at is that the word means to be alive or to live and I don't believe the word implies anything one way or another as to whether the person who is alive or living was previously dead. Do you think otherwise? If so, how do you determine when the word is being used to describe someone who is alive and wasn't previously dead or whether it's being used to described someone who is alive and previously dead?

I think you like to study the Bible seriously. I have faith that if you are serious, you would be like the bereans, and not rely on your own personal framework.
My personal framework is based on my overall personal study of the entire Bible. Hello? That is being like the Bereans.

Exactly!!! That’s why I’m providing lexicons (thayer’s and BDAG) that define “lived” as being restored to life, no longer dead due to the context. It’s not my own personal made up definition. Instead, I leave that to the experts.
LOL. So, you think two sources are enough to prove something. You can't be serious. Are you always that easily convinced? Small sample sizes are all you need to be convinced of something? You can't be serious. There are other Greek experts who agree with my understanding of Revelation 20:4. Just because they didn't write Greek lexicons doesn't mean they are not reliable experts. So, this proves nothing one way or another. The word itself means to be alive or to live. Whether or not the person or people who are said to be alive or living were previously dead is not something that is indicated by the word itself. Can you acknowledge that much? These interpreters decided that it refers to people being bodily alive again after being bodily dead, but that's just their interpretation. The word itself gives no indication of that one way or another.

Which, I know, I know, you claim are wrong without any evidence…..

Sooooooo why should I trust your claim, which isn’t backed by anything?
My claim is backed by a good number of Greek experts who were/are amillennialists. But, if they didn't write Greek lexicons, I guess their interpretations don't mean anything to you? You talk about being like the Bereans. You're not doing that. Instead, you're letting two Greek lexicons tell you what a verse means. You're not studying it for yourself to see if what those two sources said are true or not.