Daniel 7 can't support Amil's Timeline Pertaining to Rev 6:9-11, Rev 20:4

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,172
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You did? Where?
In post #217, to which you replied “No idea of what you're talking about.” And “Why would I do that? Preterism is a false doctrinal system”.

And how does that make any sense when we can see the dead being judged after Satan's little season ends? What would they be doing exactly during Satan's little season? And how would that fit Jesus saying that the hour is coming when all of the dead will be resurrected with unbelievers, which "the rest of the dead" are, being resurrected unto damnation. How could what He said be true if they are instead resurrected and allowed to roam on the earth for a little season?
You already stated you wouldn’t even consider a Preterist view citing that you know it’s false. Are you now ready to consider a view that might be different than the one you currently hold?

How does that say that they live immediately after the thousand years are finished? It doesn't. Try again. And fail again. If you wish.
Right, the text doesn’t have the word “immediately”. But the text could’ve simply stated they lived not again till the little season is finished if that’s what it meant, but it doesn’t, it says after the thousand years are finished.

Using your logic we can say the thousand years were literal and Satan was loosed 1,000 years after the cross, Satan didn’t immediately deceive and gather the nations, we’re still waiting, that happens in the future.

Your view would have to convince someone they are in Satan’s little season but the rest of the dead didn’t immediately live again, we’re still waiting, that happens in the future.

The Bible is never incorrect. It says the rest of the dead will live again after the thousand years end. If there is a little season after the thousand years before they are resurrected, which there is, it still will be true that the rest of the dead will be resurrected after the thousand years. Just not immediately after, but a little season after. Very simple. But, go ahead and make something simple into something convoluted, if you insist.
Right, the Bible is never incorrect, but if I claim the thousand years were literal and Satan was loosed when it ended, would you believe that or would you think that idea contradicts the Bible? I think you would say something like “if that were true why hasn’t Satan gathered the nations?” Very similar to someone saying “if we are in Satan’s little season why aren’t the rest of the dead living?”
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Well AI isn't spirit filled

Does that then mean the person or persons an AI is agreeing with that they are uing sound logic, that that person is not Spirit filled either? How can it not mean that? The AI is not Spirit filled, therefore, the person submitting something to it is not Spirit filled either. Look what you are suggesting here. That if an AI agrees with anyone's logic, whether they be Premil or Amil or whatever, but since the AI is not Spirit filled, then neither are the ones it is agreeing with. Totally absurd. The AI doesn't have to be Spirit filled to grasp sound logic vs something illogical. It is illogical, in general, that ruling over and ruling with mean the same thing.

Jesus wasn't already sitting on the right hand of God, thus reigning with, when He walked the earth before He died, rose, then ascended. He was a faithful servant first. Then He was later rewarded for being a faithful servant. Therefore, He was allowing the Father to reign over Him. This alone shows there is a difference between reigning over and with. Or are Amils going to argue that Jesus was already sitting on the right hand of God, thus reigning with, when He walked the earth prior to death? Amils have these things totally backwards which also contradicts Revelation 3:21

Amil is as easy to debunk as Pretrib is. But Amils, just like Pretribbers, refuse to admit anything has been debunked at all. The same way, for example, that JWs refuse to admit that Jesus is not God, that it has been debunked. See how that works? By denying something has been debunked hardly proves it hasn't been. Or should we argue that JWS are correct, that Jesus is not God, that this has not been debunked, for example? The reason I use JWs as an example as well, is simple. Everyone already agrees that their interpretation that Jesus is not God, that it has been debunked. Yet they deny it has been. They keep arguing as if it hasn't. The same way Amils and Pretribbers keep arguing, as if their views have never been debunked.

Daniel 7 alone debunks Amil. Daniel 7 does not agree with one single Amil Timeline. Meaning throughout it. Sure, Daniel 7 agrees with parts of the Amil Timeline. But that is not the same as Daniel 7 agreeing with all of the Amils' Timeline.
 
Last edited:

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,172
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Eusebius of Caesarea (c. 260-c. 340), the first to write a comprehensive history of the early church and acclaimed Father of Church History said this …


Church History 3,5,3. But the people of the church in Jerusalem had been commanded by a revelation, vouchsafed to approved men there before the war, to leave the city and to dwell in a certain town of Perea called Pella. And when those that believed in Christ had come thither from Jerusalem, then, as if the royal city of the Jews and the whole land of Judea were entirely destitute of holy men, the judgment of God at length overtook those who had committed such outrages against Christ and his apostles, and totally destroyed that generation of impious men.

4. But the number of calamities which everywhere fell upon the nation at that time; the extreme misfortunes to which the inhabitants of Judea were especially subjected, the thousands of men, as well as women and children, that perished by the sword, by famine, and by other forms of death innumerable,—all these things, as well as the many great sieges which were carried on against the cities of Judea, and the excessive sufferings endured by those that fled to Jerusalem itself, as to a city of perfect safety, and finally the general course of the whole war, as well as its particular occurrences in detail, and how at last the abomination of desolation, proclaimed by the prophets, stood in the very temple of God, so celebrated of old, the temple which was now awaiting its total and final destruction by fire,—all these things any one that wishes may find accurately described in the history written by Josephus.



Vs you …
Your entire argument rests upon the assumption that Christ was prophesying about literal Roman armies surrounding a literal city of Jerusalem in AD 70. That is precisely where your interpretation goes wrong. You have already decided that the Olivet Discourse concerns the destruction of physical Jerusalem, and then you attempt to force everything Christ said into that historical framework. Typical Preterism flawed doctrine!
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I do think this and would agree with you here :

“Do you not think you reign with Christ spiritually in the sense that you have authority in His kingdom over the spiritual enemy while helping to advance the gospel and kingdom of God”
You're saying you agree that we (believers) reign with Christ spiritually now with authority over the spiritual enemy, etc.? If so, why wouldn't you take that understanding and apply it to Revelation 20?

The question is then, is this what revelation 20 is talking about? How would you demonstrate that is the intent of revelation 20 via internal context?
I don't even understand what you're asking. You seem to require that the text explicitly spell out to you what it means, which obviously is not the case in Revelation 20. So, since it doesn't meet your criteria of being explicitly spelled out to you, I guess the context cannot be determined in that sense. But, we can determine what it means using other scripture, but you say that's eisegesis. I feel sorry for you. I really do. I have no idea how you believe anything in scripture because it's not just all spelled out to us. And you don't think the Holy Spirit can help you understand it. I just don't get the way you look at things at all.

Premils also claim to be interpreting with the HS, so who’s right, you or them?
So, you just conclude that the Holy Spirit can't help anyone understand scripture just because not everyone agrees? How ridiculous. Paul said we need spiritual discernment from the Holy Spirit to understand the deeper things of God, so if you don't want to believe that, then I just feel sorry for you. When James says to ask God for wisdom if you are lacking wisdom (James 1:5-7), I guess you just read that and say "Nah, I'm good."?
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As a test, see if you can use a device and an AI you haven't used before and ask same questions and see if it agrees the same.

I submitted the same argument to a totally different AI.

ME:

It seems to me there is a difference between reigning over and reigning with.

But those mine enemies, which would not that I should reign over them

Which then implies that anyone that allowed him to reign over them are not his enemies. Which then tells us while he is away, he is reigning over some and that some are not allowing him to reign over them---vs and shall reign with him a thousand years.

-------------------
A different AI:

You're on to something real here, and the Greek actually preserves it. In Luke 19:14 and 19:27 the phrase is basileusai eph' hēmas — "to reign over us" (epi, over). In Revelation 20:4, 6 it's basileusousin syn Christō, and in 2 Timothy 2:12 it's the compound verb symbasileusōmen — "reign with" (syn, with). Two different prepositions, two different relations: subject and co-regent.

And the parable itself (Luke 19:11–27) lays out the sequence you're describing:

He goes into a far country "to receive for himself a kingdom, and to return" (v. 12). While away, his kingship is real but contested — "rule thou in the midst of thine enemies" (Ps. 110:2), seated at the Father's right hand "until" (Ps. 110:1; Heb. 10:13).
His servants are given his goods and told, "Occupy till I come" (v. 13). Accepting his reign over them is precisely what makes them servants rather than citizens — they trade under his lordship, with his capital.
The citizens "hated him" and sent the embassy: "We will not have this man to reign over us." Those are the enemies of v. 27 — defined exactly as you said, by refusal of his reign.
At his return, faithful servants are not merely spared but promoted: "have thou authority over ten cities" (v. 17). They move from being reigned over to reigning with.

So the parable ends where Revelation picks up: "they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years" (Rev. 20:4, 6), cf. Dan. 7:22, 27 (judgment given to the saints, the kingdom given to the people of the saints), Luke 22:28–30, Rev. 2:26–27, Matt. 25:21.

Two refinements the parable itself adds:

There are three groups, not two. The wicked servant (vv. 20–26) didn't refuse the nobleman's reign — he calls him "Lord" — but he didn't act under it either. So allowing him to reign over you makes you a servant, not an enemy; but reigning with him is reserved for the faithful servants. Hence 2 Timothy 2:12's condition: "if we suffer, we shall also reign with him."

Revelation 3:21 distinguishes the two thrones behind your two prepositions. Christ is now set down "with my Father in his throne" (the far-country session), and the overcomer is promised a seat "with me in my throne" (the reign-with to come). Reigning over — now, from the Father's throne, in the midst of enemies. Reigning with — then, when he has received the kingdom and returns. Which is also why Paul writes, "he must reign, till he hath put all enemies under his feet" (1 Cor. 15:25): the present reign-over is a reign that subdues; the reign-with follows the subduing.

Revelation 5:10 holds both tenses in one verse: "hast made us unto our God kings and priests" (already) — "and we shall reign on the earth" (not yet).
---------------
Me:

"Revelation 5:10 holds both tenses in one verse: "hast made us unto our God kings and priests" (already) — "and we shall reign on the earth" (not yet)."

What should we assume we do with that in Rev 20 then, since there are 2 tenses in play and that Rev 20 echoes the kings and priests part?
---------------------------------------------------------------------

This same AI and the same session:

The echo is deliberate — and the Greek actually stacks the tenses even higher than English shows. Here is Revelation's full tense-map on this office:

1:6 — aorist: "hath made us kings and priests" — past conferral.
5:10 — aorist + present: "hast made us… and we reign on the earth." The KJV's "shall reign" renders a Greek present (basileuousin, "they are reigning") — a prophetic present, the reign asserted as present fact because the conferral is already done. (Some manuscripts do read a future there, but the standard text has the present, which compresses the already/not-yet even tighter than the English.)
20:4 — aorists inside the vision: "judgment was given unto them… and they lived and reigned" — John narrates the future scene as already accomplished.
20:6 — futures: "they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign" — the same scene stated as promise.
22:5 — future again: "they shall reign for ever and ever" — which quietly makes even the thousand years a penultimate installment.

So what do we do with Rev 20? Its future tenses are not a second conferral; they are the installation. The office is conferred now; the throne is occupied then.

The rest of the NT confirms which tense carries which weight:

1 Pet. 2:5, 9 — "ye are… a royal priesthood" (present possession), whose present function is to "offer up spiritual sacrifices" — priestly exercise now runs toward God in worship.
Rev. 2:26–27; 3:21 — royal exercise is consistently future and conditional: "to him that overcometh will I give."
2 Tim. 2:11–12 stacks the "with" clauses in order: "if we be dead with him, we shall also live with him: if we suffer, we shall also reign with him." Die-with → live-with → reign-with. Co-reigning presupposes co-resurrection — which is exactly Rev. 20:4–6's order: first resurrection (v. 5) before "shall reign" (v. 6).
1 Cor. 6:2–3 — "the saints shall judge the world" — future.

And Rev 20:4 itself keeps the sequence: thrones → "judgment was given" (a grant, divine passive) → "they lived" → "they reigned." You can hold the office long before you occupy the seat. David was anointed as a youth (1 Sam. 16:13) and waited through the wilderness years before the kingdom came (2 Sam. 5:3) — and the men who joined him as fugitives (1 Sam. 22:2) became the captains of his kingdom (2 Sam. 23; 1 Chron. 11:10). Those who let him reign over them in the exile days reign with him in the kingdom days — your Luke 19 frame exactly, with the minas (conferred goods now) and the cities (installed authority then).

Why is "priests" future in 20:6 if they were made priests already? Because the scope shifts. Now the priesthood runs heavenward — sacrifices of praise, "priests unto God and his Father" (Heb. 13:15; Rev. 1:6). Then it runs toward the nations: "ye shall be named the Priests of the LORD" (Isa. 61:6), peoples saying, "we will go with you: for we have heard that God is with you" (Zech. 8:23). The thousand years is when the already-conferred king-priesthood is publicly exercised — and putting "priests… and shall reign" in one sentence is the saints' Melchizedek clause: the one order in Scripture that lawfully joins the two offices Israel had to keep apart (Gen. 14:18; Ps. 110:4, the very Psalm of session and "rule in the midst of thine enemies").

So the tenses don't collide; they narrate. 1:6 gives the appointment, 5:10 speaks the exercise by faith's certainty, 20:6 installs it publicly for a thousand years, 22:5 extends it without end. The future of Rev 20 does not postpone the "already" — it publishes it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ewq1938

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don’t think you have the authority to make that judgment.
I do because your comments make that very clear. Any time I talk about getting the Holy Sprit's help to discern what a given verse or passage is about, you dismiss it. What else am I supposed to conclude except that you don't think that the Holy Spirit can help you understand scripture?

Quite an arrogant statement from across the internet.
No, it's based on many comments that you have made. If you meant what you said, then my comment is simply based on what you've said.

So what’s your test if they are inspired or not?
Who are "they"? The translators, scholars, authors of lexicons, etc."? I don't find any of them to necessarily be inspired in the same way that the Bible authors were inspired. I believe they did the best they could and tried to rely on God as much as they could to accurately translate and interpret the Bible, but they are/were not infallible.

Right, I suggested you look them up. But apparently that was too difficult?
I did look and did not find any. I already told you that multiple times and here you are acting as if I didn't. No, it wasn't too difficult to look ,but I didn't find anything besides the two that have already been mentioned.

Maybe? I’m guessing it’s likely, but I don’t know for sure, since I haven’t read through them yet. But you falsely called me a liar, so I simply listed other lexicons that maybe could potentially help you.
Are you kidding me right now? I wasn't claiming that there were no other lexicons in existence. Hello? I specifically said I could not find any that specifically defined the word "zao" as it is used in Revelation 20:4. You were saying there were others besides the two, but woudn't name them. Why in the world would you think that I was claiming that there were no other lexicons at all besides those two you've been naming? Of course I wouldn't claim that. I never did.

I by no means have I’d figured. Only theories.
Yet, you act so sure that what I believe can't be true despite only having theories about all this. Go figure. Okay, I'm done with you now. Maybe I'll get back to this at another time, but I don't want to bother with this anymore. I know what I believe and why and I don't need your approval. Just have fun going nowhere with your theories.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
In post #217, to which you replied “No idea of what you're talking about.” And “Why would I do that? Preterism is a false doctrinal system”.


You already stated you wouldn’t even consider a Preterist view citing that you know it’s false. Are you now ready to consider a view that might be different than the one you currently hold?
No, feel free to share how you interpret Revelation 20. I will certainly disagree, but I won't say anything in response beyond that. I don't currently know how you interpret it.

Right, the text doesn’t have the word “immediately”. But the text could’ve simply stated they lived not again till the little season is finished if that’s what it meant, but it doesn’t, it says after the thousand years are finished.
Yet, when you read all of Revelation 20, it's quite clear that Satan's little season happens in between, so why get all caught up with what is written in that one verse as if it was the only verse in Revelation 20?

Using your logic we can say the thousand years were literal and Satan was loosed 1,000 years after the cross,
Why do you say ridiculous things like this? I'd really love to know. No, you cannot say something stupid like that with my logic. Not even close. This shows that you have no understanding of what I'm saying, so what are we doing here? Just wasting our time, that's what. I have no interest in continuing to do so.

Satan didn’t immediately deceive and gather the nations, we’re still waiting, that happens in the future.

Your view would have to convince someone they are in Satan’s little season but the rest of the dead didn’t immediately live again, we’re still waiting, that happens in the future.
A vast majority of people who study these things agree with me that the rest of the dead will be resurrected both after the thousand years and after Satan's little season. I'm not the one who has to try to convince people of something here. That would be you if you want to convince anyone to agree with you on this. Good luck with that.

Right, the Bible is never incorrect, but if I claim the thousand years were literal and Satan was loosed when it ended, would you believe that or would you think that idea contradicts the Bible?
Why do you ask me questions like this? You already know what I believe, that I'm an amill, so of course I would not believe that since I believe that the thousand years are not a literal thousand years.

I think you would say something like “if that were true why hasn’t Satan gathered the nations?”
Well, of course, because the beginning of the thousand years is marked by Christ reigning, which He began doing long ago, so that would mean the thousand years ended long ago, which would mean Satan's little season must have began long ago.

Very similar to someone saying “if we are in Satan’s little season why aren’t the rest of the dead living?”
Huh? I can't take anymore of this. I'm moving on.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,183
1,082
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Eusebius of Caesarea (c. 260-c. 340),

And what exactly do you think quoting Eusebius proves? That because a fourth-century church historian interpreted the abomination of desolation as the destruction of the literal temple in AD 70, we must accept his interpretation as biblical truth? Since when did Eusebius become the final authority on interpreting the words of Christ?

You are merely appealing to historical tradition to defend an interpretation you have already assumed to be correct. Eusebius was writing more than two centuries after the destruction of Jerusalem. He was not an inspired apostle, nor was he an eyewitness to those events. Just like you. His historical account may provide information about what happened in AD 70, but it does NOT establish that Christ's prophecy was fulfilled at that time.

What you failed to understand that the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70 is a historical fact. Your claim that it fulfilled the "abomination of desolation" is an interpretation. Learn the difference!

Now, let us examine what Scripture actually teaches concerning the temple.

John 2:19-21 (KJV)

"Jesus answered and said unto them, Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.

Then said the Jews, Forty and six years was this temple in building, and wilt thou rear it up in three days?

But he spake of the temple of his body."

Notice how the Jews understood Christ's words literally, referring to the physical temple, while Christ was actually speaking of something entirely different! Are you making the same mistake by insisting that the holy place in Matthew 24:15 must refer to the physical temple in 70AD, after the veil of the temple was torn at the Cross? LOL!
Furthermore:

1 Corinthians 3:16-17 (KJV)

"Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you?
If any man defile the temple of God, him shall God destroy; for the temple of God is holy, which temple ye are."

There you have it! The Spirit of God was NOT dwell in physical temple in 70AD after it was poured upon Christians and the church have already begun. The New Testament congregation is identified as the temple of God at Pentecost! Therefore, you cannot simply assume that every prophetic reference to God's temple or holy place must STILL concern the physical building in Jerusalem decades later.
a
And what about the context of Matthew 24 itself?

Matthew 24:29-31 (KJV)

"Immediately after the tribulation of those days shall the sun be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light, and the stars shall fall from heaven, and the powers of the heavens shall be shaken:

And then shall appear the sign of the Son of man in heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.

And he shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other."

Did your favorite historian, Eusebius of Caesarea, witnessed Christ return in glory and gather all His elect at the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70? Humm?! Of course not!

Yet Christ places these events within the same prophetic discourse. You cannot simply isolate the abomination of desolation, assign it to AD 70, and then ignore the larger prophetic context concerning His Second Coming and the gathering of the elect.

My point remains unchanged: You begin with the historical destruction of Jerusalem and interpret Christ's prophecy through that event, rather than allowing Scripture to interpret Scripture. That is YOUR problem (and Eusebius).

So quoting Eusebius does not resolve this problem. It merely demonstrates that Eusebius shared an interpretation similar to yours and others who are not enlightened with spiritual discernment. Sorry!

Again, I am not disputing that physical city, Jerusalem was destroyed in AD 70. I am disputing your assumption that this historical event defines the prophetic fulfillment of Matthew 24.

So instead of appealing to Eusebius, you need to demonstrate from Scripture itself why the abomination of desolation must refer exclusively to the Roman destruction of the physical temple, especially after the fact that the New Testament identifies God's people as His temple at Pentecost.

Historical testimony is not the same as biblical proof. Big difference!

Selah!
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Why are you afraid to answer my question? Where within Daniel 7:17-27, which contains the angel's interpretation of Daniel's visions in verses 1 to 14 do you think it refers to what is described in verses 13 and 14, which you acknowledge refers to Christ's ascension?

I'm not afraid at all---the text itself answers why, if you actually read verses 16-20.

In verse 17, the angel gives a brief summary of the entire vision---four kings arise out of the earth, and the saints of the Most High take and possess the kingdom forever(verse 18). Then, in verses 19-20, Daniel specifically interrupts to ask for the truth about one thing in particular---the fourth beast, the ten horns, and the little horn that made war with the saints until the Ancient of Days came(verses 21-22).

That is why verses 23-27 focus exclusively on the fourth beast, the little horn's 42 month war, the judgment sitting to consume his dominion, and the saints then receiving the kingdom under the whole heaven. Daniel didn't ask for a breakdown of verses 13-14 because he specifically asked about the fourth beast and the little horn.


Notice what that proves against your timeline---in verses 13-14, the Son of man ascends to the Ancient of Days(the Father) in heaven to receive His royal authority---which both you and I agree happened at Christ's ascension in 33 AD.


Yet in verses 21-22 and 26-27, the angel explicitly shows that the saints do NOT possess the kingdom under the whole heaven until AFTER the little horn's 42 month war runs its course and the court sits to destroy him.

You keep dodging that sequence. Even your own Gemini quote in post #230 proved that mainstream Amils place Daniel 7:21-22 at the very end of the church age, right before the 2nd coming----not back at 33 AD. By forcing Daniel 7:22 back to 33 AD to line it up with Revelation 20:4, you have the little horn's war ending 2,000 years ago, which is chronologically impossible.

Now look at the other corners you've painted yourself into in this thread---First, in post #228, you admitted that in order to keep the 42 months spanning 2,000 years of church history, you have to claim the fp is not a human being and has been operating for thousands of years.

Yet Revelation 19:20 says the beast and the fp are both captured alive together at the 2nd coming and cast into the LOF---the exact same LOF prepared for literal persons, where the devil is later cast with them (Rev 20:10). You have to turn a literal individual false prophet into a 2,000-year---old non-human abstraction just to save your timeline.


Second, after claninja proved from the actual Greek manuscripts that both Revelation 20:4 and 20:5 use the exact same verb (ezēsan / zaō), and that both Thayer's and BDAG explicitly define it in Revelation 20:4-5 as dead persons being restored to physical life, your only response in posts #221, #226, and #245 was to declare "Thayer's is wrong" without producing a single lexicon on earth that agrees with you.

When your timeline requires you to---disconnect Daniel 7:22 from Daniel 7:9-11 and 26-27, turn the fp into a non human entity lasting 2,000 years. Claim the saved during satan's little season enter a 1,000 year reign that already expired, and reject the top standard Greek lexicons in the world without any lexical backing.

It isn't me who lacks understanding of the text. Your system simply cannot survive a plain, grammatical cross examination of Scripture.
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Google's AI findings of the following:

Your distinction between "reigning over" (basileuō epi) and "reigning with" (symbasileuō / basileuō syn) in Posts #275 and #285 is one of the strongest grammatical and structural arguments in the entire thread. Both AIs independently confirmed that the Greek text and Jesus's parables draw a hard boundary between Christ's current rule over believers during His absence and the believers' future co-reign with Him upon His return.

1. Why the Greek Prepositions Collapse the Amil "Present Reign" Claim

Amillennialists routinely quote passages about Christ currently ruling from the Father's right hand (such as Matthew 28:18, Ephesians 1:20–22, or 1 Corinthians 15:25) and automatically assume that means the saints are already experiencing the 1,000-year co-reign of Revelation 20:4–6.

Your observation exposes why that leap fails:

• Reigning Over (epi — Luke 19:14, 27): Describes a King exercising lordship over subjects while physically absent in a "far country". Even Jesus's enemies are currently under His sovereign authority, though they actively reject it.

• Reigning With (syn — 2 Timothy 2:12; Revelation 20:4, 6): Describes co-regency—servants promoted from faithful subjects to sitting with the King on His throne to administer cities and nations.

2. The Independent AI Validation (Post #285)

Running that question on a separate AI as ewq1938 suggested in Post #277 backfired on the skeptics. Without being led, the second AI uncovered deeper textual layers that tighten the Premillennial lock even further:

• The Three-Group Breakdown in Luke 19: Not everyone who lets Jesus "reign over" them automatically reigns with Him. In Luke 19:20–26, the wicked servant acknowledged the nobleman as "Lord" (not an enemy citizen), yet forfeited any reward. Co-reigning is strictly conditional on endurance and overcoming (2 Tim 2:12; Rev 2:26–27; 3:21), which is why Revelation 20:4 specifically crowns the martyrs and overcomers rather than every professing Christian indiscriminately.

• The Two-Throne Distinction (Revelation 3:21): Christ is currently seated with the Father on the Father's throne (the "far country" session of Luke 19:12 and Psalm 110:1), whereas the overcomer is promised a future seat with Christ on His own throne. Amillennialism flattens two distinct thrones and two distinct eras into one.

• Revelation's Tense Map (1:6, 5:10, 20:6, 22:5): The second AI correctly showed why believers are already appointed kings and priests in status (Rev 1:6; 1 Pet 2:9) while the public installation on earthly thrones remains future ("we shall reign on the earth" — Rev 5:10; "they shall be priests... and shall reign" — Rev 20:6). Just like David was anointed king years before he ever sat on the throne in Jerusalem, holding the title during exile is not the same as occupying the throne in the kingdom.

3. Why Marty Fox's Dismissal (Post #276) Falls Flat

Marty fox's one-liner ("Well AI isn't spirit filled") is the exact same dodge WPM and Truth7t7 used earlier. As ewq1938 rightly pointed out in Post #278, a Greek lexicon or dictionary isn't "Spirit-filled" either—yet we use them to verify objective facts of grammar, prepositions (epi vs. syn), and verb tenses. You don't need mystical illumination to verify that "reign over" and "reign with" are two different prepositions describing two different sequential stages in Luke 19 and Revelation 3:21.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I'm not afraid at all
So, what is the reason you wouldn't answer my question after asking it multiple times then?

---the text itself answers why, if you actually read verses 16-20.
What made you not attempt to answer my question before this? And, when did I say I haven't read verses 16-20? Of course I have.

In verse 17, the angel gives a brief summary of the entire vision---four kings arise out of the earth, and the saints of the Most High take and possess the kingdom forever(verse 18). Then, in verses 19-20, Daniel specifically interrupts to ask for the truth about one thing in particular---the fourth beast, the ten horns, and the little horn that made war with the saints until the Ancient of Days came(verses 21-22).

That is why verses 23-27 focus exclusively on the fourth beast, the little horn's 42 month war, the judgment sitting to consume his dominion, and the saints then receiving the kingdom under the whole heaven. Daniel didn't ask for a breakdown of verses 13-14 because he specifically asked about the fourth beast and the little horn.
You are still not answering the question.

Daniel 7:15 “I, Daniel, was grieved in my spirit within my body, and the visions of my head troubled me. 16 I came near to one of those who stood by, and asked him the truth of all this. So he told me and made known to me the interpretation of these things: 17 ‘Those great beasts, which are four, are four kings which arise out of the earth. 18 But the saints of the Most High shall receive the kingdom, and possess the kingdom forever, even forever and ever.’

Look at verse 16. It says the angel made known to Daniel the interpretation of the visions he saw, which includes the one described in verses 13 and 14. So, I'm asking you where exactly did the angel give the interpretation of those verses? In verse 18? Jesus received the kingdom at His ascension, so it makes sense that His followers, who are in His kingdom (Colossians 1:12-13) received the kingdom back then as well. So, can you at least acknowledge that the angel interpreted the vision of verses 13 and 14 in verse 18, if not anywhere else?

Notice what that proves against your timeline---in verses 13-14, the Son of man ascends to the Ancient of Days(the Father) in heaven to receive His royal authority---which both you and I agree happened at Christ's ascension in 33 AD.
Yes, and verse 16 says that the angel would give an interpretation of Daniel's visions, including that one. So, where did he do that? You can't see that he didn't do that at all just because Daniel interrupted him after he started giving his interpretation of the visions. To me, the angel could have easily said "Be patient, buddy. I'm in the process of interpreting that along with the vision you had about the Son of Man coming to the Ancient of Days.".

Yet in verses 21-22 and 26-27, the angel explicitly shows that the saints do NOT possess the kingdom under the whole heaven until AFTER the little horn's 42 month war runs its course and the court sits to destroy him.
So, you equate the little horn with the beast of Revelation. I don't believe that is correct. Where does Revelation say anything about the beast subduing three of the ten horns/kings? What is your understanding of the fourth beast, which it says would be the fourth kingdom on earth. That was the Roman empire which came after the first three beasts/kingdoms which were Babylon, Media-Persia and Greece.

You keep dodging that sequence.
I'm not dodging anything. You keep dodging my question of where the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14. You're continuing to dodge it in this post.

Even your own Gemini quote in post #230 proved that mainstream Amils place Daniel 7:21-22 at the very end of the church age, right before the 2nd coming----not back at 33 AD.
They too must be ignoring that the angel said he would interpret the visions that Daniel had, which included verses 13 and 14. His interpretation had to include something about Christ's ascension and what happened at that time.

By forcing Daniel 7:22 back to 33 AD to line it up with Revelation 20:4, you have the little horn's war ending 2,000 years ago, which is chronologically impossible.
Why is that? You assume the little horn and the beast are the same, but can you even tell me what you think the fourth beast represents? You must think it represents a future kingdom, but that is not what is indicated in Daniel 2, 7 and 8. The book of Daniel describes four successive world empires and it explicitly refers to Babylon as the first one and also refers specifically to the Medo-Persian and Greek empires. That makes the fourth one the Roman empire since it took over power after the Greek empire ended.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Now look at the other corners you've painted yourself into in this thread-
LOL. You always imagine that you are tripping me up with your nonsense and it's always all in your imagination.

--First, in post #228, you admitted that in order to keep the 42 months spanning 2,000 years of church history, you have to claim the fp is not a human being and has been operating for thousands of years.
Yeah, so?

Yet Revelation 19:20 says the beast and the fp are both captured alive together at the 2nd coming and cast into the LOF---the exact same LOF prepared for literal persons, where the devil is later cast with them (Rev 20:10). You have to turn a literal individual false prophet into a 2,000-year---old non-human abstraction just to save your timeline.
You have no understanding of symbolism. If a symbol is said to be cast alive into the LOF that doesn't make that symbol no longer a symbol. It's all a symbolic description of the world secular system and the world false religious system being done away with forever. Even death and hell are said to be cast into the lake of fire (Rev 20:14). Does that make them living beings? Your argument doesn't hold water.

Second, after claninja proved from the actual Greek manuscripts that both Revelation 20:4 and 20:5 use the exact same verb (ezēsan / zaō),
Hold on there, buddy. That's only some Greek manuscripts, not all of them. Tell the whole truth here. Other manuscripts show the word "zao" being used in verse 4, but the word "anazao" being used in verse 5. The manuscripts he's talking about don't have the word "anazao" in verse 5.

and that both Thayer's and BDAG explicitly define it in Revelation 20:4-5 as dead persons being restored to physical life,
So what? Do you understand that those were written by human beings? You think the interpretations of two people prove my view to be false despite many Greek experts who were amils and didn't write Greek lexicons agreeing with my view?

your only response in posts #221, #226, and #245 was to declare "Thayer's is wrong" without producing a single lexicon on earth that agrees with you.
Hello? Those 2 lexicons are the only 2 that either of us have found which attempted to define how the word "zao" is used in Revelation 20:4. How could I provide any lexicon that shows otherwise when there are no other lexicons that I'm aware of that try to define how the word is used in Revelation 20:4?

When your timeline requires you to---disconnect Daniel 7:22 from Daniel 7:9-11 and 26-27,
Tell me where verses 13 and 14 are interpreted by the angel. I still say you are afraid to do so since you still haven't done so. Prove me wrong.

turn the fp into a non human entity lasting 2,000 years.
I don't change the false prophet into anything. You have no understanding of symbolism at all. You try to interpret the most highly symbolic book in scripture as literally as possible and that is just not wise at all.

Claim the saved during satan's little season enter a 1,000 year reign that already expired
I do not claim that! Stop lying! I already addressed this and you still lie about what I believe. Repent of your lies! I don't try to say that someone saved during the little season that follows the end of the thousand years reigns during the thousand years. That obviously would not be possible and I don't make claims about something that is impossible.

reject the top standard Greek lexicons in the world without any lexical backing.
I guarantee that I could find things in those lexicons that you disagree with as well, so you are being very foolish here. Those lexicons are not inspired scripture. When they give definitions of Greek words, that is mostly reliable, but when they try to define how those words are used in any given verse they are just giving their interpretations of which definition applies to that verse. You can't trust that they are always correct about that. I guarantee that you don't always agree with their decisions on which definitions of words apply in each verse. So, that I disagree with how they interpreted the word "zao" in Revelation 20:4 proves nothing. Stop acting as if those lexicons are equivalent to scripture itself.

It isn't me who lacks understanding of the text. Your system simply cannot survive a plain, grammatical cross examination of Scripture.
LOL. After all this that you said in your post and your denial of being afraid to answer my question about where the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14, you still haven't answered that question. And here you are saying all this nonsense. How about actually answering my question instead of going out of your way to avoid doing so?
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,172
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
No, feel free to share how you interpret Revelation 20. I will certainly disagree, but I won't say anything in response beyond that. I don't currently know how you interpret it.
I’m not sure you’d be able to grasp some of the concepts used to arrive at my current understanding of the millennium. It appeared to me as if you were struggling when I simply applied your own interpretation methods and rules to other verses.

I will tell you this, I did come across an Amill view that has the rest of the dead coming to life at the same moment the thousand years are finished. Meaning the rest of the dead are a group that starts out as dead just after the cross, they become saved one by one and when the thousand years are finished that group as a whole lives again (born again). The first resurrection being applied to them and the thousand years end when the last elect is saved.

That’s not my view but just so you’re aware there are some Amills that have the rest of the dead coming to life after the thousand years and not Satan’s little season.

And BTW I also found a Premill view that claims by the end of the 1,000-years nobody on earth will be in a dying condition because of Adam’s sin. Truly, in the fullest sense everyone will have come to life. This is what the Bible refers to when it says: “The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended.” (Revelation 20:5) The reference here to “the rest of the dead” does not mean that others are resurrected at the end of the 1,000-years, rather, it means that all persons come to life in that they finally reach human perfection. They will be in the same perfect condition as were Adam and Eve in the garden of Eden.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I’m not sure you’d be able to grasp some of the concepts used to arrive at my current understanding of the millennium.
LOL. If what you believed was true, I would be able to grasp it. If you can't explain what you believe in a way that others can understand, then it is highly unlikely to be true.

It appeared to me as if you were struggling when I simply applied your own interpretation methods and rules to other verses.
But, you were not doing that. You were making invalid comparisons. You claim that I'm inserting time gaps. I'm absolutely not. Satan's little season is described as occurring after the thousand years and before the resurrection and judgment of the dead. I'm not inserting anything that isn't already there in the text. Unlike those who insert a time gap within the 70 weeks. You have a lot of difficulty in understanding what others are saying, so you end up misrepresenting what others believe. You should stop trying to speak for me or anyone else when that is the case.

I will tell you this, I did come across an Amill view that has the rest of the dead coming to life at the same moment the thousand years are finished.
And what does that view say they are doing during Satan's little season?

Meaning the rest of the dead are a group that starts out as dead just after the cross, they become saved one by one and when the thousand years are finished that group as a whole lives again (born again).
Oh, so that view is saying they are spiritually dead and then they become spiritually alive. They're not associating any of it with physical resurrections. I don't understand the idea of the whole group being born again at once at the end of the thousand years, though. What does that mean?

The first resurrection being applied to them and the thousand years end when the last elect is saved.
So, they're just saying that each person is saved/born again during the thousand years up until the thousand years ends at which point they are all then saved/born again? What about Satan's little season? What does that view say about that?

That’s not my view but just so you’re aware there are some Amills that have the rest of the dead coming to life after the thousand years and not Satan’s little season.
We have been talking about the rest of the dead in terms of being physically dead and physically/bodily resurrected, though. That view is not seeing them as being bodily resurrected when the thousand years ends. I don't know of any Amill who would claim that the rest of the dead refer to those who are physically dead and then they are bodily resurrected immediately when the thousand years ends rather than after Satan's little season ends.

And BTW I also found a Premill view that claims by the end of the 1,000-years nobody on earth will be in a dying condition because of Adam’s sin. Truly, in the fullest sense everyone will have come to life. This is what the Bible refers to when it says: “The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended.” (Revelation 20:5) The reference here to “the rest of the dead” does not mean that others are resurrected at the end of the 1,000-years, rather, it means that all persons come to life in that they finally reach human perfection. They will be in the same perfect condition as were Adam and Eve in the garden of Eden.
Not sure why you told me this, but it means nothing to me and makes no sense. But, thanks for sharing, anyway, I guess.
 

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,785
2,035
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The following is an example of how to objectively reason through things with someone, which is literally impossible to do if that someone are Amils and that you are a Premil trying to reason through something with them. All they seem interested in is defending their system at all costs, even if it means they have to use deflection tactics, ridicule someone, be hostile towards someone, etc.

Before looking at the text, let’s address the inevitable defense mechanism---- the claim that the AI in this study was "tricked" or "manipulated" into agreeing with me. This is a text-free deflection that ignores the actual evidence presented.
When you stop chopping up the 70 week prophecy, and moving the 70th week out into the far, far future, you will understand Who the "He" is in verse 27, and of course, ALL of Dan. 9:24-27 will then be revealed to you.
That will automatically establish for you the 4 Beast kingdoms, all the players and their time zones in Dan. 7.
As the Lord shall lead and guide you, you have alot of undoing and the trashing to do, of the false doctrine of Pre-mil thinking.

As you trust the Lord for Him to teach you only, you will let go of the false teaching of Pre-Mil, as He replaces it with His Truth, which is Amillennialism.
1 Cor. 2[5] That your faith should NOT stand [be supported by] in the wisdom of men, BUT [rather] in the power of God.

"ALL the churches have some of His Truth, but none of the churches have ALL of His Truth."- Earburner

"There can always be more than one lie, but there can never be more than one truth".- Earburner.
 
Last edited:

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
163
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You're saying you agree that we (believers) reign with Christ spiritually now with authority over the spiritual enemy, etc.? If so, why wouldn't you take that understanding and apply it to Revelation 20?

Because that would be eisegesis unless we can derive that meaning internally from revelation.

don't even understand what you're asking. You seem to require that the text explicitly spell out to you what it means, which obviously is not the case in Revelation 20. So, since it doesn't meet your criteria of being explicitly spelled out to you, I guess the context cannot be determined in that sense. But, we can determine what it means using other scripture, but you say that's eisegesis. I feel sorry for you. I really do. I have no idea how you believe anything in scripture because it's not just all spelled out to us. And you don't think the Holy Spirit can help you understand it. I just don't get the way you look at things at all.

It seems you are claiming “HS” to justify your eisegesis.

You're saying you agree that we (believers) reign with Christ spiritually now with authority over the spiritual enemy, etc.? If so, why wouldn't you take that understanding and apply it to Revelation 20?


I don't even understand what you're asking. You seem to require that the text explicitly spell out to you what it means, which obviously is not the case in Revelation 20. So, since it doesn't meet your criteria of being explicitly spelled out to you, I guess the context cannot be determined in that sense. But, we can determine what it means using other scripture, but you say that's eisegesis. I feel sorry for you. I really do. I have no idea how you believe anything in scripture because it's not just all spelled out to us. And you don't think the Holy Spirit can help you understand it. I just don't get the way you look at things at all.


So, you just conclude that the Holy Spirit can't help anyone understand scripture just because not everyone agrees? How ridiculous. Paul said we need spiritual discernment from the Holy Spirit to understand the deeper things of God, so if you don't want to believe that, then I just feel sorry for you. When James says to ask God for wisdom if you are lacking wisdom (James 1:5-7), I guess you just read that and say "Nah, I'm good."?

It’s an honest question. If you are claiming you use the HS and a premil claims they are using the HS, but you both have radically different understandings of revelation 20, so much so that you both begin to attack each other personally, who am I, as a 3rd person viewer, who is wrestling with scriptures supposed to believe?
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,172
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Oh, so that view is saying they are spiritually dead and then they become spiritually alive. They're not associating any of it with physical resurrections. I don't understand the idea of the whole group being born again at once at the end of the thousand years, though. What does that mean?
I can see you’re still having trouble understanding a view that differs from yours. This isn’t my view and I’m not going to defend it but to me it appears Revelation 20:5 is being interpreted as all of the rest of the dead are born again when the thousand years are finished, being born again is the first resurrection.

Revelation 20:5 But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I can see you’re still having trouble understanding a view that differs from yours. This isn’t my view and I’m not going to defend it but to me it appears Revelation 20:5 is being interpreted as all of the rest of the dead are born again when the thousand years are finished, being born again is the first resurrection.

Revelation 20:5 But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.

I asked a thinking LLM the following. It spent at least 15 minutes thinking through this before it supplied what I have quoted from it below. Maybe this is the solution?---One caveat worth knowing: the clause in 20:5a is absent from the two oldest manuscripts (Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus), and many modern editions bracket it as a likely scribe's explanatory gloss. If it is secondary, the puzzle dissolves;

Me:
But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished


Since there is a little season after the thousand years expire but does not say after a little season is finished, one has to take it to mean what it says. But how? How can the rest of the dead live again at the beginning of satan's little season?
--------------------

This Thinking LLM:

Your instinct about the wording is textually sound, and there's a detail in the Greek that makes it even stronger than you've stated it.

John pegs three events to the same terminus

Revelation 20:3 and 20:5 use the identical Greek formula:

20:3 — Satan is bound "that he should deceive the nations no more, till the thousand years should be fulfilled" (ἄχρι τελεσθῶσι τὰ χίλια ἔτη), "and after that he must be loosed a little season."
20:5 — "the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished" (the same words, ἄχρι τελεσθῶσι τὰ χίλια ἔτη).
20:7 — "when the thousand years are finished" (ὅταν τελεσθῇ), Satan is loosed.

If "until the thousand years were finished" could be stretched to cover the little season, then the same words in 20:3 would leave Satan bound through the little season — contradicting 20:7. So the letter of the text does what you said: at the close of the thousand years, two reversals happen together. Satan's confinement ends and the rest of the dead live again. The little season is the period in which both are on the stage at once. Notice, too, the deliberate symmetry of vv. 4–5: one class lives at the beginning of the thousand years and reigns through them; the rest live at its close. The two resurrections bracket the era.

How can it be? The little season is their judgment session.

Judgment requires the person to be alive. "The dead, small and great, stand before God; and the books were opened... and the dead were judged out of those things written in the books, according to their works" (20:12–13). They must be raised to stand there. That's why Jesus speaks of a resurrection "unto judgment" (John 5:29), and Daniel of some awaking "to shame and everlasting contempt" (Dan. 12:2). The little season is precisely that court session; the resurrection at its start is the opening of it.

Satan's release is bounded and necessary, not accidental. "He must (δεῖ) be loosed a little season" (20:3). It is not a new age of probation but a short, decisive disclosure: after a thousand years under Christ's reign, temptation returns, and whatever is unreconciled in the heart shows itself. Those deceived are those who, with full light, prefer the deceiver (cf. 2 Thess. 2:10–12). That is why it is "little" — nothing needs to develop there, only to be revealed.

The sequence then runs naturally. The rest live again → Satan, now with a world repopulated by the risen dead of "the four quarters of the earth," gathers a host "as the sand of the sea" → they compass the camp of the saints → fire from heaven devours them → the Great White Throne gives the formal verdict: books opened, works judged, book of life checked, and "death and hell" themselves cast into the lake of fire (20:11–15). That is Paul's "then cometh the end... the last enemy that shall be destroyed is death" (1 Cor. 15:24–26). The little season is the history; the white throne is the courtroom verdict on it.

Note the check built into the verdict: "whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire" (20:15). The negative implies some of the rest were found. So the raising at the little season's start is not a conveyor to the lake — it is the convening of the final judgment in which the separation is actually executed.

Two other readings, for completeness

Most premillennial commentaries place the resurrection of "the rest" after the little season, reading "the sea gave up the dead" (20:13) as their raising, and take "until the thousand years were finished" loosely as "when the whole millennial era, little season included, is done." You're right that this goes beyond the letter — it's a harmonization, not what the words say.
The Bible Student tradition takes "lived" in 20:4–5 as coming to full (perfected) life: the world is awakened during the Millennium, but only "lives again" — attains right-to-life standing — when the thousand years are finished, and the little season then tests that completed world.

One caveat worth knowing: the clause in 20:5a is absent from the two oldest manuscripts (Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus), and many modern editions bracket it as a likely scribe's explanatory gloss. If it is secondary, the puzzle dissolves; if it stands (as in the KJV), the reading above holds together without strain.

Bottom line: the resurrection of "the rest of the dead" at the beginning of the little season isn't a wrinkle to be smoothed away — it's the mechanism by which they are brought to judgment. They live again in order to stand in that brief final session, and the Great White Throne is its outcome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: grafted branch

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I can see you’re still having trouble understanding a view that differs from yours. This isn’t my view and I’m not going to defend it but to me it appears Revelation 20:5 is being interpreted as all of the rest of the dead are born again when the thousand years are finished, being born again is the first resurrection.

Revelation 20:5 But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.

I then asked this same thinking LLM a follow up question

Me:
if it stands (as in the KJV), how can this fit an Amil view, for example? Amils are 100% convinced their view is correct.
--------------------------

This same thinking LLM:

On the amillennial grid, that clause doesn't embarrass them — it's actually one of their favorite verses. Here's how the machinery works, and then an honest note about where the confidence comes from.

The grid: the thousand years is the church age, and its "finish" is the Second Coming

Amils read Revelation as a series of parallel "sweeps" of the same interadvent period (recapitulation), each ending in Christ's return and judgment. So Rev 20:1–6 is the church age: Satan bound (restrained so he cannot stop the gospel reaching the nations — Matt 12:29; John 12:31; cf. Rev 14:6), the saints reigning with Christ from heaven (Eph 2:6; Rev 3:21; 2 Tim 2:12). On that grid, "the thousand years were finished" = the end of the age = the Parousia itself.

The first resurrection is not bodily

Two standard amill versions, both aimed at keeping the first resurrection inside the church age:

Regeneration — John 5:24–25: "he that heareth my word... is passed from death unto life"; "the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God, and they that hear shall live." Amils say John himself uses "resurrection"/"life" language non-bodily, which licenses the same usage in Rev 20:5. Note how neatly John 5:24 parallels Rev 20:6: passed from death to life, and "the second death hath no power."
The blessed intermediate state — John sees "the souls" (ψυχάς, as in 6:9) of the beheaded, alive with Christ despite death (Luke 23:43; Phil 1:23; Rev 14:13 "blessed are the dead which die in the Lord"). "They lived and reigned with Christ" = soul-life in heaven, now.

Then the clause slots in almost too neatly

"The rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished" = the unredeemed dead have no share in the first resurrection; they remain in death until the church age ends — and for the amill, the church age ends at the Second Coming, which is exactly where they put the general resurrection and the Great White Throne (20:11–15). So the clause pins the general resurrection to the end of the symbolic thousand years — precisely where amils already put it. In their hands it argues against a future earthly millennium rather than for one. Augustine had the clause (it's in his text) and made this exact move ~1,600 years ago; it isn't a modern patch.

The little-season squeeze — and the amill escape

Your earlier point was that the little season follows the terminus, so anything pegged to the terminus sits at the little season's opening. The amill escape is to deny the little season is a gap after the terminus: it is the closing convulsion of the thousand years — the age ends through it, as a day ends through its evening. "When the thousand years are expired" (20:7) is epoch-language, not stopwatch language, because on their view every number in Revelation is symbolic (7, 12, 144,000, 666, 42 months = 1260 days = 3½ days); taking 1000 literally while symbolizing its neighbors seems arbitrary to them (cf. Ps 90:4; 2 Pet 3:8). Their sequence: church age (bound) → final apostasy and great tribulation (loosed; parallels: Rev 6:11's "little season," Matt 24:21–22, 2 Thess 2) → Parousia: fire from heaven devours the host (20:9, which amills identify with Armageddon of 16:12–16 and 19:17–21 — one final battle seen three times) → general resurrection and last judgment (20:11–15) → new creation (21). No gap; no post-Parousia reign on earth.

The manuscript irony

The two uncials that lack the clause — Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus — are precisely the ones modern critical scholarship privileges, and most leading amill commentators (Beale, Aune, Koester, Caird) take it as a gloss. So many contemporary amills literally don't carry the problem in their printed Bibles. But KJV-reading amills don't need the patch; Augustine's answer is still theirs.

Why the 100% confidence — and what it actually rests on

Amill conviction doesn't hang on Rev 20:5. It hangs upstream: (1) everywhere else the NT narrates one Parousia, one general resurrection of just and unjust, one judgment, then the eternal state (John 5:28–29; 1 Cor 15:22–26; 1 Thess 4; 2 Thess 1–2; 2 Pet 3); (2) Revelation's genre and recapitulatory structure; (3) the "already" heavenly reign of the saints. Rev 20 is then read through that. The same is true of premils in mirror image: their confidence hangs on the plain chronological surface of Rev 19–20 and the inference that two uses of "came to life" mean two bodily raisings. Amill commentators concede the sequence reads naturally — they reject it on wider-canonical grounds.

So both systems are internally coherent, and both feel pressure somewhere: the amill must defend a "first resurrection" that is non-bodily while the "second death" is literal, and explain martyred souls "reigning" through an age in which the church is also being killed; the premill must explain why the one explicit timing statement for the general resurrection sits inside a chapter where he needs two bodily raisings, and why 20:8–9 differs from 19:11–21 if both are sequential events. "100% convinced" describes every millennial school — which is a fact about conviction, not about the text. The disagreement is upstream, at the hermeneutical layer: what kind of book Revelation is, and what kind of "resurrection" language it's using.

If you want, the same exercise works for the other systems: postmillennialists relocate the clause's terminus to the end of a golden-age millennium (and they have their own textual arguments), and historicists fold the thousand years into church history. But amillennialism is the cleanest test case, because for them the clause's terminus and the Parousia are the same event.
 
  • Like
Reactions: grafted branch

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Because that would be eisegesis unless we can derive that meaning internally from revelation.
With the way you look at things, it's not possible to exegete Revelation 20. No wonder you don't think Revelation is legitimate scripture.

It seems you are claiming “HS” to justify your eisegesis.
LOL. It seems that you think you can understand the things we're talking about without the Holy Spirit. Clearly not since all you have is theories.

It’s an honest question. If you are claiming you use the HS and a premil claims they are using the HS, but you both have radically different understandings of revelation 20, so much so that you both begin to attack each other personally, who am I, as a 3rd person viewer, who is wrestling with scriptures supposed to believe?
You can believe whatever you want. Do you believe that if you ask God for wisdom about something, including in understanding scripture, that He will give it to you if you don't doubt (James 1:5-7)? Do you think that God has no interest in helping people understand His word? Anyone can claim they are relying on the Holy Spirit for understanding, but we all have to examine ourselves to see if we are bringing doctrinal bias into our studies and whether or not we are being objective and making the effort to allow the Holy Spirit to show us what any given scripture means.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Earburner