Conversation with An Atheist

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

soberxp

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2025
2,771
960
113
43
Xi'an
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
China
Gender
Male
Exactly, that's where "I don't know" comes in handy.
That's the difference between me and a lot of people here. I don't fill in the gaps in my knowledge with God did it, I go with the best available evidence.
We have no way of knowing anything for certain... My attitude is subject to change..
So what keeps you trying to be here?
On a Christian chat forum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrangler

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
God didn't care for man's created,cuz man didn't creat anything real for the unreal.as the lie never be real since the serpent said the first lie in the Gen.

What ?!

Gen 6:5 The LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.
Gen 6:6 And the LORD regretted that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him to his heart.
 

soberxp

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2025
2,771
960
113
43
Xi'an
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
China
Gender
Male
God doesn't care for what man creates, because man cannot create anything real out of the unreal—just as the lie was never real since the serpent spoke the first lie in Genesis.

Gen 6:5 The LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.
Gen 6:6 And the LORD regretted that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him to his heart.
Therefore, Yahweh should have just made more angels in heaven from the start; then there wouldn't be all this crap to deal with later.:confused

And I will be one of the angles.:D
 
Last edited:

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
God doesn't care for what man creates, because man cannot create anything real out of the unreal—just as the lie was never real since the serpent spoke the first lie in Genesis.


Therefore, Yahweh should have just made more angels in heaven from the start; then there wouldn't be all this crap to deal with later.:confused

I assume you do understand that God did not wanted to create creatures with no free will programmed to love Him, God did not want fake love. He wanted creatures with free will that would love Him in return because God loves us, REAL love, His very essence.

So the real issue is that God gave all His creatures free will and free will may go any direction.

Ever heard of the The Cycle of Opposites by Plato ?

The first argument is based on the cyclical interchange by means of which every quality comes into being from its own opposite. Hot comes from cold and cold from hot: that is, hot things are just cold things that have warmed up, and cold things are just hot things that have cooled off. Similarly, people who are awake are just people who were asleep but then woke up, while people who are asleep are just people who were awake but then dozed off.

By analogy, if good exist and can be experienced and measured than evil must exist also else no comparison can be made. Same with love, the opposite must be true. Same with sin. God is holy, but the opposite must exist. And the latter became reality when the devil (with his free will) rebelled and became the opposite of God.

And God said to A&E, don't go there (that tree) else you also will experience the opposite of Me (the devil) and eventually you will die.

But for A&E the good (God), the love (God), the intimate direct relationship with God was not good enough for A&E, instead they listened to the devil and insisted to know the difference between good and evil and let's face it, God gave them what they wanted, out of Paradise they landed on a different place Earth, a perfect place to experience both good (God) and evil (devil).

A&E made a deal with the devil and the consequences were devastating.
 

soberxp

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2025
2,771
960
113
43
Xi'an
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
China
Gender
Male
I assume you do understand that God did not wanted to create creatures with no free will programmed to love Him, God did not want fake love. He wanted creatures with free will that would love Him in return because God loves us, REAL love, His very essence.

So the real issue is that God gave all His creatures free will and free will may go any direction.

Ever heard of the The Cycle of Opposites by Plato ?

The first argument is based on the cyclical interchange by means of which every quality comes into being from its own opposite. Hot comes from cold and cold from hot: that is, hot things are just cold things that have warmed up, and cold things are just hot things that have cooled off. Similarly, people who are awake are just people who were asleep but then woke up, while people who are asleep are just people who were awake but then dozed off.

By analogy, if good exist and can be experienced and measured than evil must exist also else no comparison can be made. Same with love, the opposite must be true. Same with sin. God is holy, but the opposite must exist. And the latter became reality when the devil (with his free will) rebelled and became the opposite of God.

And God said to A&E, don't go there (that tree) else you also will experience the opposite of Me (the devil) and eventually you will die.

But for A&E the good (God), the love (God), the intimate direct relationship with God was not good enough for A&E, instead they listened to the devil and insisted to know the difference between good and evil and let's face it, God gave them what they wanted, out of Paradise they landed on a different place Earth, a perfect place to experience both good (God) and evil (devil).

A&E made a deal with the devil and the consequences were devastating.
So, is Jesus the only one who ascended to heaven? The Bible mentions a few others. So we're stuck here because of our free will. But I always think: if I were an angel, I probably wouldn't have followed Satan, right?

Or maybe I'd be a foolish angel, naively reaching out to pick the fruit from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, and then turn into a human. Is that why we all ended up on Earth?
 
Last edited:

soberxp

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2025
2,771
960
113
43
Xi'an
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
China
Gender
Male
I assume you do understand that God did not wanted to create creatures with no free will programmed to love Him, God did not want fake love. He wanted creatures with free will that would love Him in return because God loves us, REAL love, His very essence.

So the real issue is that God gave all His creatures free will and free will may go any direction.

Ever heard of the The Cycle of Opposites by Plato ?

The first argument is based on the cyclical interchange by means of which every quality comes into being from its own opposite. Hot comes from cold and cold from hot: that is, hot things are just cold things that have warmed up, and cold things are just hot things that have cooled off. Similarly, people who are awake are just people who were asleep but then woke up, while people who are asleep are just people who were awake but then dozed off.

By analogy, if good exist and can be experienced and measured than evil must exist also else no comparison can be made. Same with love, the opposite must be true. Same with sin. God is holy, but the opposite must exist. And the latter became reality when the devil (with his free will) rebelled and became the opposite of God.

And God said to A&E, don't go there (that tree) else you also will experience the opposite of Me (the devil) and eventually you will die.

But for A&E the good (God), the love (God), the intimate direct relationship with God was not good enough for A&E, instead they listened to the devil and insisted to know the difference between good and evil and let's face it, God gave them what they wanted, out of Paradise they landed on a different place Earth, a perfect place to experience both good (God) and evil (devil).

A&E made a deal with the devil and the consequences were devastating.
By the way, based on your views, I wonder if you have read the book by Napoleon Hill, originally titled Outwitting the Devil.
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
By the way, based on your views, I wonder if you have read the book by Napoleon Hill, originally titled Outwitting the Devil.

I had a quick look, nothing to do with Christianity, only about becoming successful in wordly life.
 

Mancunian

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2026
1,222
275
83
Cheshire
Faith
Atheist
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
Thanks for the reply.

I'm not trying to give God a personality. I'm just trying to show that it's more probable that some kind of creator is responsible for all this.

If you have no problem with the watchmakers argument would you say that it's at least possible that an intelligent being created all of this?
It's a possibility yes.
So even though we only ever see life come from life, your choosing to believe that life came from non-life, totally contrary to what we are observing.
The common sense position would be to believe what we see about life.

What's the evidence that life came from non-life? Science has the primordial soup hypothesis. Google says this about it

View attachment 93607
View attachment 93608
Hypothetical. Hypothesis. These terms are very suggestive. Its just based on assumption with very little foundation.

They've been trying to replicate this primordial soup in labs and have been very unsuccessful at showing how life came from nothing. Life is very complicated and it's very unlikely that it came from random processes.

Theory of evolution says everything evolved from a single universal ancestor. But what's the evidence for that?
They've been trying to replicate this as well with no success. A type of cell, such as lizards skin cell, can only replicate itself, it cannot replicate the countless other cells required to build something else, such a dog's brain cell or a birds heart cell. A cell is extraordinarily complicated.
We know that the building blocks of life could have easily travelled here from space, the conditions on the planet millions of years ago would be extremely difficult to replicate...so no surprises that we can't exactly replicate them.
There could be life on other plantes.
Who knows.
Indeed, and that life could just be emerging in the form of single celled organisms?
To me it sounds like your agnostic.

An atheist is someone who rejects any possibility of God's existance.
An agnostic thinks there is still a possibility that God might exist.
That's my definition of it anyway.

If you think there is a possibility that some kind of God exists then would you consider youself to be more agnostic?
Atheists who deny the possibility of God and assert that they know God doesn't exist are gnostic atheists, I don't claim to know so I'm agnostic, but I don't believe with any conviction that a God does or has existed so I'm an agnostic atheist.
The issue of pain, suffering and evil is one that many if us grapple with, including myself. I haven't got the answer but the presence of evil and suffering is not a good reason to deny the possibility of an intelligent designer.
It's a good reason to deny a loving designer though.
Again, I'm just trying to show that intelligent design is more probable.
I'm talking about any kind of creator, not necessarily the Christian God.
That's fine by me.
I asked you to provide good arguments against intelligent design.
Do you think you did that? I don't.
You provided more of a criticism of the biblical God rather than an argument against intelligent design.
I provided my thoughts on why I don't think the God of the Bible is responsible for everything we see and experience.
What do you think is the probability of some kind of intelligent design?
Do you think a deist view would be closer to the truth than a Christian view?
I did at one stage
I think that a deist view would definitely be closer to the truth. If there was an intelligent designer who created everything and left the universe to it, I would be the first person in line to offer my congratulations on such a gigantic achievement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Armour of God

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
817
147
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
I was responding to @Mancunian claim that God does not care for His created.
"""I already told you about that, my 3 encounters with the Lord in one evening. Instant life changing."""

Is that your claim or someone else's ?

If yours's then the question remains :-

Mohammad, Bahai founder, Ellen G White all claimed to have had encounters/visions with the Lord
What makes your more believable than theirs ?
TIA
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
"""I already told you about that, my 3 encounters with the Lord in one evening. Instant life changing."""

Is that your claim or someone else's ?

If yours's then the question remains :-

Mohammad, Bahai founder, Ellen G White all claimed to have had encounters/visions with the Lord
What makes your more believable than theirs ?
TIA

Read the whole story, maybe you will understand then. I never had visions from the Lord. And how is it when you are born again? Is it not the good Lord deeply touches your feelings, resulting in repentance?
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
817
147
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Read the whole story, maybe you will understand then. I never had visions from the Lord. And how is it when you are born again? Is it not the good Lord deeply touches your feelings, resulting in repentance?
And how is it when you are born again?
eg ARE saved, ARE justified, ARE HS sealed, ARE forgiven of all sins ?
1 Cor 15:1-4, Eph 1:13, Col 2:13 answer that for 'today'

Whatever visons/experiences etc that you have had are/were allowed by GOD

Ellen G White, Bahai founder, Muhammad, Charles Taze Russell & so many more also TRULY believed they had visions/experiences from/with GOD.

Why do you believe yours are any more genuine than theirs ?
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
And how is it when you are born again?
eg ARE saved, ARE justified, ARE HS sealed, ARE forgiven of all sins ?
1 Cor 15:1-4, Eph 1:13, Col 2:13 answer that for 'today'

Whatever visons/experiences etc that you have had are/were allowed by GOD
Ellen G White, Bahai founder, Muhammad, Charles Taze Russell & so many more also TRULY believed they had visions/experiences from/with GOD.
Why do you believe yours are any more genuine than theirs ?

You will know them by their fruit, right ?
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
817
147
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
You will know them by their fruit, right ?
Confirming that I believe you experienced something.

You will know them by their fruit, right ?
Bahai believers are convinced
Ellen G White believers are convinced
Charles Taze Russell believers are convinced
Mohammad believers are convinced

Why do you believe your 3 encounters were more authentic than theirs ?
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
Confirming that I believe you experienced something.

You will know them by their fruit, right ?
Bahai believers are convinced
Ellen G White believers are convinced
Charles Taze Russell believers are convinced
Mohammad believers are convinced
Jesus said -

Matt 7:15 “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.
Matt 7:16 You will recognize them by their fruits. Are grapes gathered from thornbushes, or figs from thistles?

What fruit did Mohammad produce ?
What fruir did Charles Taze Russell produce ?
What fruit did Bahai produce ?

Only very bad fruit.

Beware of false prophets

Why do you believe your 3 encounters were more authentic than theirs ?

Check my fruit :Broadly:
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
817
147
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Jesus said -

Matt 7:15 “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.
Matt 7:16 You will recognize them by their fruits. Are grapes gathered from thornbushes, or figs from thistles?

What fruit did Mohammad produce ?
What fruir did Charles Taze Russell produce ?
What fruit did Bahai produce ?

Only very bad fruit.

Beware of false prophets



Check my fruit :Broadly:
The question remains :-
Why do you believe your 3 encounters were more authentic than theirs ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrangler