Once Saved....always Saved - Results of Questionnaire.

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

B

brakelite

Guest
@Bread of Life
I said.....
19th century new enough for you? Or how about pre Vatican 2? I am sure I could find some evidence of Rome calling one such as I a heretic if I dug deep enough. Why, I think if I ventured onto a Catholic operated forum and spoke openly of my beliefs the charge of heresy would be very quick in coming.
Your response was....
WRONG
.
Your lack of homework keeps digging you into a deeper hole.

the definition of a "heretic" is a CATHOLIC who espouses heresy - NOT a Protestant who espouses heresy.
I short - you have to be a Catholic to be considered a heretic by the Catholic Church.

Your Protestant Fathers were all CATHOLICS, and were therefore, considered to he heretics.
Do your homework . . .
I was a Catholic...the old saying 'once a Catholic always a Catholic" is a Catholic tradition. If I ventured into a Catholic forum, I would be branded a heretic. Period. Thing is though BOL, it wasn't just heretics that Catholics were warring against was it. The Albigenses, the Waldenses, The Celtic church in Britain, the Hugenoets, the Hussites, the Lollards, the Goths, Vandals, and Heruli, all groups of people who were Christian, but different. That difference, and their refusal to bow and submit to a pagan emperor posing as a bishop, brought war.

Sure. The Way
No, Brakelite - you don't get to pass the buck.

I asked YOU to show me where the BIBLE says to come out of the Catholic Church.
If YOU can't show me that - then, you're just another angry little anti-Catholic with ZERO evidence . . .

BOL, stop presuming. First you assume I was not Catholic, then you presume I am giving you a lead to someone elses writing. The link 'The Way' is to my blog. My article, original. In that article you will find an exegetical study that clearly and profoundly points an unerring finger at the Papacy, the RCC, as being the prime stake-holder (pun not intended) of Babylon the Great Inc. Minor shareholders are the Lutherans, the Anglicans, with others being added daily as your church's daughters/separated brethren (how appropriate) return to mother.
A woman in prophecy is the a symbol of God's people. A pure woman such as that in Revelation 12, a pure church, such as those remnant true believers at the time of Christ's birth, a harlot woman an apostate church, such as the woman in Revelation 17. This woman in Revelation 17, Babylon the Great, is an apostate church riding a beast, which in prophecy designates a nation/civil power/ or state. The church is holding the reins, the state is subservient to her wishes, going where she directs. The state is used as her puppet in legislating church dogma, and her proxy in putting to death those who don't submit to those laws. This woman is a persecuting woman. Drunk with the blood of the saints. So she persecutes Christians. Her cup is full of abominations and filth of her fornication...her practices and false teachings. Her adultery is in joining with the kings of the earth instead of her former husband, Christ. She is dressed in purple and scarlet colour. She is greatly wealthy. And she blasphemes. There are two definitive descriptions of blasphemy in scripture...both charges being laid at the feet of Jesus by the Pharisees. One was that He forgave sin. "Who can forgive sin but God alone?". The answer was obvious, no-one, but Jesus is God right? The second was the charge of claiming to be God. Of claiming to have the prerogatives and authority that belong only to God. It may have passed your notice, because I sense you are not one to look honestly in the mirror, but the above description of that whore is an apt description of Rome. So, God calls His people to come out, because He is going to judge her. Soon. There is NO-ONE, not an indiviidual, not a religion, not a government, that is so well presented in scripture as that final and ultimate expression of the Antichrist. Growing up from being the little horn in Daniel 7, to being the composite beast in Revelation 13, and now the fully matured whore of Revelation 17. Come out of her BOL, lest you be judged along with her.

Associated with that article if you scroll to the bottom you will find similar articles showing different perspectives, but drawing the same conclusion.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Many are called to elect to choose God;

Few elect to choose God;

Those who do elect to choose God;

God chooses them Forever;

That Simple and that Permanent.

Matt 22:14
1 Thes 1:4
2 John 1:2

God Bless,
Taken
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Oct 22, 2011
15,476
21,157
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
With BOL;
No one accused him of not loving the Lord.
No one said they did not love Catholics.

Hi, thanks for yours.

As for the above...do you want to bet on that? :D
Wrong on both counts...if you'd been on this Site longer you would be amazed at who has said what!!!

He..... and takes disagreement with Catholic practices, to mean not loving Catholics, because of their practices...

That I can agree upon, he does tend to lump all Protestants in together.
He has tarred us all with the same brush.

I do think he is very brave...he is here every day doing what he feels he must do...and that is defend the Catholic faith against misunderstandings. I would have given up long ago.
I don't agree with some of it...but on the other hand I have no idea why it bothers so many people!!
If we know what we do not believe, then why on earth not let it drop and roll.
Every now and again someone joins the Site and starts posting stupid anti-Catholic threads. :rolleyes:
It drives me nuts..heaven knows what it must be like to be a Catholic!!
We don't see it against the JW's...occasionally there is a Muslim rant...but the favourite kicking horse is always the Catholics.

Catholics seem to imply; ALL Catholics believe the exact same things. They don't, just as ALL people who are called Protestants do not believe the exact same things.

Yes I agree with that..and I am sure @aspen would agree also.
I have known many Catholics all are not the same for sure. BOL just seems very passionate about "his" Church.
I am confident that God sees the hearts... we will all get a big surprise I am sure, when we see who is "in" and " who is "out".
When the Scales are before each one of us...I firmly believe that God will NOT be measuring our doctrine ....but He will be measuring our hearts.

You will have noticed now you have been on here longer...that I won't get into arguments, I side step. I see no point in contention or proving a point.
A good discussion I like, but arguments just so someone can come out as top dog, bore me...and get no one any where.
It is all about the flesh.
Arguments divide.
There are some caring hearts on the Site...
Some days it is hard to recognize The Master Voice in the hubbub and noise of people 'spouting off'...but once in a while a gem is posted.
That is why I am am here. Listening :)

"My sheep hear My Voice and a Stranger they will not follow."

Further seems Catholics teach, ONCE a man IS Forgiven, Saved, Sanctified, Born Again....
It is the man, WHO has to KEEP his own soul saved, and if the man doesn't; the man loses his salvation.

Again..as I often say...that is NOT only with Catholics...even our friend bbyrd009 and many others I know believe that works save us!!
Catholics do not own the corner on that one.
I would say more believers than not see no difference between our salvation and our works.... Our position in Christ and our walk in Christ.
They lump them both together ...no wonder there is so much confusion and discussions about " Faith v Works"...when all the time it is BOTH, not either/ or. One is a gift, one will be measured, weighed and tested by fire.

Bless you...H
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
20,939
3,389
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
In observance of the swinging door....

More sentiments from another angry little anti-Protestant...

God Bless,
Taken
Actually - anti-lies.

I don't have anything against honest Protestants.
It's only the ones that resort to lying to get their point across that I have a problem with.

Most of my siblings are Protestants and I love them dearly.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hi, thanks for yours.

As for the above...do you want to bet on that? :D
Wrong on both counts...if you'd been on this Site longer you would be amazed at who has said what!!!

Just was going by the evidence of the current discussion.

That I can agree upon, he does tend to lump all Protestants in together.
He has tarred us all with the same brush.

I agree with that. The point is I don't believe Protestants lump "them" selves all together, but do believe the Catholics promote lumping "them" selves all together.

God Bless,
Taken
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Actually - anti-lies.

Being anti-lies, does not mean being anti-Catholic, nor anti-people who are Catholic.

I don't have anything against honest Protestants.

And? What does honesty have to do with a person who is Protestant or Catholic?

It's only the ones that resort to lying to get their point across that I have a problem with.

Having different perspectives does not equal lying.

Most of my siblings are Protestants and I love them dearly.

What does Loving a person have to do with if the person is Protestant or Catholic?

God Bless,
Taken
 

aspen

“"The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few
Apr 25, 2012
14,111
4,778
113
52
West Coast
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Honest means agreement with BOL
 

Dcopymope

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2016
2,650
800
113
36
Motor City
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Honest means agreement with BOL

Well that's obvious, it makes me wonder why people waste their precious time having lengthy discussion's with him about anything, much less the catholic church. I just say my piece and move on in life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aspen

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
20,939
3,389
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Being anti-lies, does not mean being anti-Catholic, nor anti-people who are Catholic.
And? What does honesty have to do with a person who is Protestant or Catholic?

Having different perspectives does not equal lying.

What does Loving a person have to do with if the person is Protestant or Catholic?

God Bless,
Taken
Having a "different perspective" and telling outright lies are NOT the same thing.

I respect a Protestant's different perspective.
I respect the fact that a Protestant may disagree with me.

However - I have absolutely NO tolerance for the anti-Catholic, who invents or revises history and spews falsehoods about the Church and what we teach. BIG difference . . .
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
20,939
3,389
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Well that's obvious, it makes me wonder why people waste their precious time having lengthy discussion's with him about anything, much less the catholic church. I just say my piece and move on in life.
You mean, you plant your angry little anti-Catholic lies and move on.
That''s okay - that's what I'm here to expose.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Having a "different perspective" and telling outright lies are NOT the same thing.

I highly doubt you are having a conversation on this thread with anyone whose Intent is to tell "outright lies", and ARE rather expressing their perspective, that you disagree with.

I respect a Protestant's different perspective.
I respect the fact that a Protestant may disagree with me.

That is questionable. Even something was said about Catholics who disagree with Catholics, was not painted as respectible, but rather as heretical.
IOW ~ disrespectful and namecalling.

However - I have absolutely NO tolerance for the anti-Catholic, who invents or revises history and spews falsehoods about the Church and what we teach. BIG difference . . .

The point is; EVERY group, is made up of INDIVIDUALS, who do not all agree 100%.

And EVERY long-time established group, (Religious groups, Governmental groups, Freemasons groups, Sports groups, etc,.)have shady skeletons in their closets.

And individuals, still electing to be part of the group, many or may not AGREE with ALL that has transpired within their groups or leadership; but the historical tarnish of the group; doesn't disappear; even if an individual member of the group, doesn't practice or teach portions of the things that HAS been shady.

Protestants don't particularly LUMP themselves all together as ONE Church. They openly identify their disagreements, and form umpteen denominations.

The Catholic Church on the other hand Promote the Catholic Church as ONE Church, and when a Shady thing happens, they intently try to hide it and make excuses for it if publically found out. That doesn't make the Catholic Church unique; other exclusive groups, do the same thing; and individual members (who may not be individually shady); often times appear to DEFEND the shady behavior, to save face, and integrity of the group as a whole.

Many Governments do that, Many Politicians do that, Many Catholics do that, Many Freemasons do that, Many Jews do that, Many Muslims do that, and pretty much Many Protestants break away and join up with a different denomination.

And the fact is; People who break away from some Governments, Political groups, the Catholic Church, the Freemasons, AND any person claiming they FORMERLY Believed in God and now they don't, etc. are ridiculed, (which goes beyond Disagreement), by remaining members;

The one who Breaks away, reveals THEIR own experience and knowledge and understanding; and a remaining member, without having the SAME experience and knowledge and understanding.....DOES, what is going on here....hurls out Accusations of Lies and Deceit.

Being a member of ANY group, doesn't require one to DEFEND shady things that historically occurred within the group, or to pretend they Didn't occur.

A member merely needs to stand by their own convictions and satisfaction within the group.

You attempted to do that with your expression of "holy father", as your view of expression of love and admiration of your Pope and your Dad.

I fully get that. And I believe that APPLIES to you, but not every Catholic. Because just as you can speak for yourself, so also do other Catholics, who do not ONLY see the Pope as a "holy godly man"; but AS their infallible Lord God ON Earth.

You can say that is not taught in the Church, but it does not relinquish the fact; that many members OF the Catholic Church conclude by their Catholic teaching the Pope is to them, to be revered infallible, sinless, holy, and their Lord God on earth.

As much as the Catholic Church attempts to promote THEY are thee ONLY ONE True Christian Church, and ALL Catholic Church Members ARE in agreement; they aren't.

God Bless,
Taken
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dcopymope

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Back to the OP ...

Facts and Misconceptions ~

Fact:
Salvation IS a Gift provided By the Lord.
The Gift of Salvation is Everyone's.

Misconception:
The Gift of Salvation is NOT Everyone's, until they Receive the Gift.

False. The Gift is For the Life of the Whole World. John 6:51

Fact:
An individual person, must TAKE the Gift, to possess Salvation.

Misconception:
An individual "POSSESSES" the Gift, BEFORE he TAKES the Gift.

False. Taking, Receiving, Possessing, Having the Gift of Salvation, IS expressly accomplished THROUGH "Confession".
Rom 10:10

Fact:
Individuals, make all kinds of Confessions.
Individuals ROUTINELY make Confessions out of their mouths and through the THOUGHTS OF THEIR MINDS.
They CONFESS to believe one thing, and Routinely CHANGE THEIR MINDS.

Misconception:
Men confessing with their Mind, can RECEIVE the Gift, THEN LOSE the GIFT.

False. God KNOWS ALL THINGS. He is not fooled or tricked BY men, To "Giving a man Possession of Salvation" and then "making Himself a LIAR", by Taking it Back.
Rom 8:27
Rev 2:28

Fact:
A Confession PERTAINING TO BELIEF in God and His Word; are ONLY Acceptable TO the Lord, that the Confession BE, THROUGH the Thoughts of a MANS HEART!
Rom 8:27
Rev 2:23

Fact:
A Confession PERTAINING TO BELIEF in God and His Word; THROUGH the Thoughts of a Mans HEART....is the ONE AND ONLY Confession the Lord REQUIRES, FOR the man TO RECEIVE "HIS" Gift of SALVATION.
Rom 10:9

Fact:
ONCE a man HAS RECEIVED "HIS" Gift of Salvation; it is a Permanent Gift and "HIS" to possess FOREVER.
John 6:58

Misconception:
"MEN" can "RECEIVE" the Gift of Salvation, and then "STOP" Believing In God.

False.
Men WHO heartfully CONFESS and accept, take, receive, the Lords Gift of Salvation; HAVE EXPRESSLY given the Lord AUTHORITY over the mans SALVATION. (MEN DO NOT GET TO RENIG OR REVOKE their Autority)

Fact:
The Lord does not PLAY GAMES with a mans Salvation or what a man Heartfully Confesses. The Lord has given mankind the FREEWILL to make his OWN decisions, to make his OWN choices, to make his OWN confession, to his OWN make commitments.....

And Scripture INFORMS a man IT'S a PERMANENT Decision.
And Scripture WARNS a man, TO BE SURE, BEFORE He COMMITS.
2 Pet 1:10

The Lord REQUIRES a HEARTFELT CONFESSION of BELIEF IN HIM, IN HIS WORD; and ONCE a man CHOOSES to make that confession; It's a DONE DEAL!
Matt 5:37

Misconception:
Men can Believe, Heartfully Commit, then CHANGE to disbelief; AND LOSE their Salvation.

False.
Men HAVE NOT THE POWER,
to Receive, to Keep, or to Lose SALVATION.

The Lord Gives, thus a man receives.
BY THE Lords POWER!
The Lord Keeps, the man Saved;
BY THE Lords POWER!
John 14:16

The Lord MAKES INTERNAL CHANGES WITHIN a man; that FOREVER THE MAN IS SAVED, BORN AGAIN, AND CAN NEVER AGAIN...
NOT BELIEVE IN GOD and HIS WORD.
Ezekiel 18:31
Ezekiel 36:36

Misconception:
Men who do not do "WORKS" to Glorify God;
Put their SALVATION in Jeopardy of Becoming Lost.

False;
A man WHO HAS RECEIVED SALVATION;
Confession ONCE to the Lord;
And ONCE receives his SALVATION.
It is Permanent.
The Lord is NOT wondering or fooled or guessing "IF" the man WILL DO WORKS to Glorify Him. The Lord KNOWS ALL THINGS.

Facts:
"WORKS" are Service unto the Lord.
The Lord REQUIRES "ONE REASONABLE SERVICE" of the man.
Rom 12:1

ONLY a man WHO IS internally changed can DO ANY WORKS that GLORIFY GOD.

The Lord Requires the Converted man TO obey and follow ONE Commanding Preceipt;
Love the Lord, with all the mans might;
Body, Soul, Spirit, Mind. And love all other men.

Fact:
A natural man CANNOT accomplish his ONE reasonable Service; his command to the Love the Lord; his command to Love all men; or any other Precept of Works that glorifies God; or to Gain Gods Wisdom or Gain Gods Understanding.......
WITHOUT THE POWER OF GODS SPIRIT WITHIN THE MAN.

Fact:
A man WHO has received the Lords Gift of Salvation~ ALSO forever receives the Power of the Lord Forever Indwelling Holy Spirit.
John 14:16

Misconception and False teaching:
Men CAN receive Salvation, then Lose Salvation.
Men CAN receive the Indwelling Holy Spirit, then Lose having the Indwelling Holy Spirit.

God Bless,
Taken
 

Grams

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2017
1,509
1,080
113
88
brown city
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Eph. 2:
8
For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:

9
Not of works, lest any man should boast
 
  • Like
Reactions: Taken

Grams

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2017
1,509
1,080
113
88
brown city
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
BELIEF !!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! UNDERSTANDING !!!!!!!!!! FAITH !!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
20,939
3,389
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I highly doubt you are having a conversation on this thread with anyone whose Intent is to tell "outright lies", and ARE rather expressing their perspective, that you disagree with.
WRONG.

I have actually exposed lies with documented evidence - only to have the person continue to hold their dishonest position.
Lies defended by more lies. Don't tell me what a lie is or isn't. It has nothing to do with "opinion".
It has everything to do with dishonesty . . .
That is questionable. Even something was said about Catholics who disagree with Catholics, was not painted as respectible, but rather as heretical.
IOW ~ disrespectful and namecalling.
WRONG again.

Doesn't matter to me ONE bit if a person simply "disagrees" with the Catholic position. However , that is not the case.
It's when they resort to telling LIES that

Secondly - I've never engaged in "name calling" on this forum.
Pointing out that a person is ignorant of Catholic teaching is an observation based on their remarks. Calling them an "ignoramus" is name-calling. Get your facts straight before you accuse people of something - otherwise, you're just bearing FALSE witness.

Try being honest, for a change.
The point is; EVERY group, is made up of INDIVIDUALS, who do not all agree 100%.

And EVERY long-time established group, (Religious groups, Governmental groups, Freemasons groups, Sports groups, etc,.)have shady skeletons in their closets.

And individuals, still electing to be part of the group, many or may not AGREE with ALL that has transpired within their groups or leadership; but the historical tarnish of the group; doesn't disappear; even if an individual member of the group, doesn't practice or teach portions of the things that HAS been shady.

Protestants don't particularly LUMP themselves all together as ONE Church. They openly identify their disagreements, and form umpteen denominations.

The Catholic Church on the other hand Promote the Catholic Church as ONE Church, and when a Shady thing happens, they intently try to hide it and make excuses for it if publically found out. That doesn't make the Catholic Church unique; other exclusive groups, do the same thing; and individual members (who may not be individually shady); often times appear to DEFEND the shady behavior, to save face, and integrity of the group as a whole.

Many Governments do that, Many Politicians do that, Many Catholics do that, Many Freemasons do that, Many Jews do that, Many Muslims do that, and pretty much Many Protestants break away and join up with a different denomination.

And the fact is; People who break away from some Governments, Political groups, the Catholic Church, the Freemasons, AND any person claiming they FORMERLY Believed in God and now they don't, etc. are ridiculed, (which goes beyond Disagreement), by remaining members;

The one who Breaks away, reveals THEIR own experience and knowledge and understanding; and a remaining member, without having the SAME experience and knowledge and understanding.....DOES, what is going on here....hurls out Accusations of Lies and Deceit.

Being a member of ANY group, doesn't require one to DEFEND shady things that historically occurred within the group, or to pretend they Didn't occur.
A member merely needs to stand by their own convictions and satisfaction within the group.

You attempted to do that with your expression of "holy father", as your view of expression of love and admiration of your Pope and your Dad.

I fully get that. And I believe that APPLIES to you, but not every Catholic. Because just as you can speak for yourself, so also do other Catholics, who do not ONLY see the Pope as a "holy godly man"; but AS their infallible Lord God ON Earth.

You can say that is not taught in the Church, but it does not relinquish the fact; that many members OF the Catholic Church conclude by their Catholic teaching the Pope is to them, to be revered infallible, sinless, holy, and their Lord God on earth.

As much as the Catholic Church attempts to promote THEY are thee ONLY ONE True Christian Church, and ALL Catholic Church Members ARE in agreement; they aren't.

God Bless,
Taken
Rubbish.

First of all - your insistence that I attack people for their "opinions" is completely unsubstantiated.
I only attack lies and falsehoods.

Finally - whether or not 100% of Catholics adhere to Catholic teaching doesn't diminish the fact that the Catholic Church is monolithic in its teachings. It doesn't make the Catholic Church "splintered". It simply means that there are faithful Catholics and dissident Catholics. When these people officially break away to start their own "versions" of the Catholic Church (i.e., The Old Catholic Church, The SSPX, the SSPV, et al) - they are schismatic, NON-Catholic sects who have divorced themselves from the Catholic Church.

In other words - they are Protestant sects, not Catholic.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,560
12,976
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
their dishonest

Lies defended by more lies

Secondly - I've never engaged in "name calling" on this forum.

Try being honest, for a change.

Are you so politically correct, and indoctrinated you actually separate a PERSONS OWN TRUTH from the PERSON?

You seriously think you are not calling the PERSON a liar, dishonest?

Get real!!
 

aspen

“"The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few
Apr 25, 2012
14,111
4,778
113
52
West Coast
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You cant argue with a delusional person, Taken.

Yes, he believes his opinions are fact and everyone elses opinions are lies.
Yes, he name calls constantly, but claims to be simply naming behavior he disagrees with
Yes, he assigns negative intentions to everyone who calls him out on his bs and who points out problems with Catholicism because in his world, there are no problems with Catholicism.

And yes, there is pretty much a consensus here that BOL calls people liars who disagree with him

Overidentification with your religion is not a pretty state to be in, but here it is.....
 
Last edited:

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
"his opinion is fact and everyone elses opinion are lies"

"He opposes and exalts himself above every so-called god or object of worship, so that he sits in God's sanctuary, publicizing that he himself is God."
 
  • Like
Reactions: mjrhealth and aspen