Show me in the Bible where God said that the universe was created ex nihilo (out of nothing).
Genesis 1:1 In the beginning God created heaven, and earth.
And show me where God said that "everything else was created naturally,
Most everything else. Not everything else. Our souls, for example were not created naturally.
Life,however, was. God says life was brought forth by previously-created matter.
Genesis 1:24 And God said: Let the earth bring forth the living creature in its kind, cattle and creeping things, and beasts of the earth, according to their kinds. And it was so done.
So, you believe that God made the "goo"--that primordial pool of amino acids that swirled and began to evolve....
It was more basic than that. The earth itself brought forth living things, He tells us. I believe Him. You should, too.
AND SOMEHOW, order NATURALLY resulted from disorder/chaos
There is order in chaos, but in this case, God created the earth to bring forth life as He intended. Creationists apparently think that's beyond God's capabilities, but the Bible says that's what happened. I believe Him.
over a period of millions and millions and millions of years???
So the evidence shows. He didn't say how long; doesn't seem to have mattered to His message to us.
Why not just believe what the Bible says--that the earth brought forth animals? And according to Jesus God has no body. We are like God in knowing good and evil. The likeness is in our minds and souls.