Questions For A Catholic

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Selene

New Member
Apr 12, 2010
2,073
94
0
In my house
Nice bit of hair splitting Templar but if the corpse is in the ground that means that person has died.

All those who believe in Christ are alive in Christ. Their bodies are dead in the ground, but their souls are alive in Christ in Heaven. We do not speak to dead bodies on earth. We have always asked for the intercession of those living in HEAVEN. It would be a grave misconception of Heaven to think that those in Heaven are dead.
 

truthquest

Well-Known Member
May 23, 2010
846
780
93
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hello Truthquest,

No, we do not communicate with the dead. We do not bow or pray to the bodies of dead saints.

This is what we believe in. We believe that those who die in Christ will be made alive in Christ because their faith saved them (1 Corinthians 15:22). We believe that Mary and the Apostles had faith in God our Father and is now in Heaven enjoying eternal life with Jesus. The mystical body of Christ include all believers who believe in God our Father and our Lord Jesus Christ and we are all one in Christ (1 Corinthians 12:27). If a person dies, does this mean that he is no longer a member of the body of Christ. According to the Bible, the answer is no. We are all made alive in Christ (1 Corinthians 15:22) and there is no division in the body of Christ (1 Corinthians 12:25). Can death separate or break the bond between us and those of our brothers and sisters in Heaven. According to the Bible, the answer is no (Romans 8:38). Death cannot separate us from the love of Christ nor from our brothers and sisters who are alive in Christ. The bonds of love is so strong and powerful that not even death can separate us from our brothers and sisters in Heaven. Why? Because God is love (1 John 4:8). And God who is love keeps us (His family) together regardless of whether we are on earth or Heaven. And so we are called to love our neighbors including our enemies.

Mary and the Saints are in Heaven, and as for us on this earth, we were never of this world to begin with because we have been called out of this world despite that we live on this world. We imitate Christ our brother who lived on this world 2000 years ago, but was not of this world. We can speak to all the Angels and Saints in Heaven simply because we are not of this world just as Jesus said (
John 15:19 and John 17:14).

Scripture shows that Jesus spoke to Moses and Elijah during the Transfiguration (
Matthew 17:3, Luke 9:30, and Mark 9:3), and these were men who were no longer walking the earth. Jesus was not speaking to dead peope. Scripture also tells us that there are indeed people in Heaven (Hebrews 12:1 and Revelations 6:9-11). Scripture even tells us that they can see and hear us (See Luke 15:7). There will be rejoicing in Heaven if one sinner on earth repents. God allows people in Heaven to hear the repentance of one sinner so that they can rejoice. And if they can hear the repentance of one sinner, they can also hear us conversing with them and asking them to pray for us. I hope that answers your question.

In Christ,
Selene




Selene,

Thank you for your reply to my question. I guess that my understanding of the state of the dead is different than yours. First, my understanding of the state of the dead is that they are not conscious or aware of anything, so being in that state, they wouldn't be able to help anyone.

Isaiah 26:14 The dead do not live; departed spirits do not rise up. Indeed, You have visited and destroyed them;You have wiped out all memory of them. Eccl. 9: [sup]5[/sup]For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing; and they have no more reward [here], for the memory of them is forgotten. [sup]10[/sup]Whatever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might, for there is no work or device or knowledge or wisdom in Sheol (the place of the dead), where you are going. Psalm 146: [sup]3[/sup] Do not trust in nobles, in man, who cannot save. [sup]4[/sup] When his breath leaves him, he returns to the ground; on that day his plans die.
Jesus said that death was like sleep, which is an unconscious state. John 11: [sup]11[/sup] He said this, and then He told them, "Our friend Lazarus has fallen asleep, but I'm on My way to wake him up." [sup]12[/sup] Then the disciples said to Him, "Lord, if he has fallen asleep, he will get well." [sup]13[/sup] Jesus, however, was speaking about his death, but they thought He was speaking about natural sleep. [sup]14[/sup] So Jesus then told them plainly, "Lazarus has died. Acts 7: [sup]59[/sup]And while they were stoning Stephen, he prayed, Lord Jesus, receive and accept and welcome my spirit! [sup]60[/sup]And falling on his knees, he cried out loudly, Lord, fix not this sin upon them [lay it not to their charge]! And when he had said this, he fell asleep [sup][/sup][in death]. 1Cor. 15: [sup]5[/sup]And [also] that He appeared to Cephas (Peter), then to the Twelve. [sup]6[/sup]Then later He showed Himself to more than five hundred brethren at one time, the majority of whom are still alive, but some have fallen asleep [in death].

We are warned in God's word not to ask for help from the dead. Isa. 8:
[sup]19[/sup] When they say to you, "Consult the spirits of the dead and the spiritists who chirp and mutter," [sup][/sup]shouldn't a people consult their God? [sup]][/sup] [Should they consult] the dead on behalf of the living?

But we do have hope of the resurrection when the dead will be resurrected back to life. John 5: [sup]28[/sup]
Do not be amazed at this, because a time is coming when all who are in the graves will hear His voice [sup]29[/sup] and come out—those who have done good things, to the resurrection of life, but those who have done wicked things, to the resurrection of judgment.[sup]
[/sup]Acts 24: 15 And I have a hope in God, which these men themselves also accept, that there is going to be a resurrection, both of the righteous and the unrighteous.

These are just a few scriptures that I wanted to share to explain what my understanding of the state of the dead is, and about the hope we can have in the resurrection.


truthquest
 

Anastacia

New Member
Oct 23, 2010
663
35
0
The pictures I posted previously of the church decorated with human skulls and bones was a church in Rome, Italy. I'm going to post pictures of another church that does this also, just so one doesn't think that it is an isolated incident. These pictures are of a Roman Catholic Church in Poland.

Hundreds of skulls have been put up around this alter with a crucifix. This place is a Vatican approved chapel.
poland.jpg


This picture was taken during the Pontiffs visit to the Church which has kept the bones of St. Augustine for “veneration”.
popebenedictxvibeforest-augustine1.jpg
 

Anastacia

New Member
Oct 23, 2010
663
35
0
These pictures are of a church in Milan.

This chapel of San Bernardino Church is decorated with skulls and bones.
jesus2.jpg


Look carefully, those are skulls on the walls.

The idol of the Queen of Heaven is the very center of hundreds of skulls and bones.
madonna.jpg


Inside San Bernadino Church, the failful Catholics can venerate "Holy skulls" in the hundreds.
ossa1.jpg



Catholics who visits this Church in Milan can adore skulls stored up on the walls.

skulls.jpg
 

Anastacia

New Member
Oct 23, 2010
663
35
0
Spliting the divine and human aspects of Jesus is a heresy within the early church. It is not my "nerve" that is claiming this fact - it was defined as a heresy by First Council of Ephesus in 431


Romans 1:1-3 Paul, a servant of Christ Jesus, called to be an apostle and set apart for the gospel of God— [sup]2[/sup] the gospel he promised beforehand through his prophets in the Holy Scriptures [sup]3[/sup] regarding his Son, who as to his earthly life[sup][a][/sup] was a descendant of David,

Aspen, did you read the scripture about Jesus "who as to his earthly life was a descendant of David"?

When you read that scripture it should help you to understand that Jesus, who as to his earthly life---Mary was his mother. Mary is the mother of the human/earthly Jesus. It is not correct to say Mary is the mother of God, the Father.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anastacia

aspen

“"The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few
Apr 25, 2012
14,111
4,778
113
52
West Coast
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You are a coward Anastacia

You refuse to align yourself with any church and you spend your time attacking people you disagree with

Let's be honest - you claim to be a Christian - yet you lie, personally attack, and deny your protestant roots.

You are a troll - pure and simple. You hide behind a prostestant admin and attack doctrine you know nothing about.

If you are not a teenager, I have seriously lost all respect for you.

I will pray for you, that God will soften your hard heart and bring you home - although you are Bud02 puppet - I pray for your salvation.
 

Templar81

New Member
Apr 14, 2010
854
17
0
UK
This is getting reidiculous!

If not for Anastacia's pointless hate-posts we would actually have a really good thread here.

I don't expect for one minute that everyone should just agree with the Catholics/Sacramentals on the forum because I believe God gave us different denominations of Christianity so that each could have his. I don't expect everyone here to be comfortable with all thsoe bones and bodies, but what I do expect is respect for other peoples cherished beliefs.

Also, don't think your exposing anything in fact all that is being exposed is your ignorance and lack of respect for other churches.

Selene, Aspen and I have been nothing but honest and open but you won't even tell us what chruch you belong to.
 

mcorba

Member
Aug 7, 2010
135
9
18
52
England
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
synonym doesnt mean the same, it means similar in semantic meaning.
So venerate and bow do Not mean the same as worship.

When i bow to the statue of Christ each week, I am bowing in meaning to Him - not to the material object,
you silly person! Please get this through your head.
The material object means Nothing, it is purely symbolic, representative....see?

Unless you can grasp the subtle differences between words, then its pointless trying to argue.
If you could be honest and admit that you are here to bait and antagonise Catholics, that might
be a start for your personal development and towards being really honest, Anastacia.

During this thread you have reminded me of a young child at a party who needs all the attention.
You have shown no respect for what this thread was set up for, in face you ve spent all your time
splitting hairs, derailing the subject, and posting awful pictures of skulls, as though that proves anything!

Anyone with any reasoning skills would see you for what you are, I am afraid. Our words show our true hearts.
You have no respect for Catholicism so why dont you start a new post as you have no interest in our ideas or
opinions? We know the answer to this - because you enjoy annoying people!

Look into your own heart, and stop judging and telling us what to think!!
Personally, I have One Judge - and that is Jesus Christ, thanks.
M
 

aspen

“"The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few
Apr 25, 2012
14,111
4,778
113
52
West Coast
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
[font="tahoma][size="2"]Since the Trolls have taken over and the admin has not intervened - let's call this thread what it has become - a place for people to personally attack Catholic members on this board, while parading about sacred Catholic beliefs with graphic pictures and exaggerated language, in order to put them in the worst light possible; take on the burden of answering for catholics; and rather than engage in respectful dialog - fight as much as possible for Jesus.

Since it has become obvious that a thread like this was supposed to be is impossible here, if you have any questions for a catholic (that will not be read by people who believe they know more about Catholicism than people who practice it) email me at [email protected]. I will not respond to people who are only interested in attacking - Anastacia, Bud02, marksman - do not bother. [/size][/font]
 

TexUs

New Member
Nov 18, 2010
1,197
37
0
You refuse to align yourself with any church
That is not a bad thing.
Blind and ignorant denominational loyalty is utter nonsense and I think the Apostle Paul would agree.


Anyone "aligning" themselves with a particular denomination seems to be anti-scripture.




Brothers and sisters, I could not address you as people who live by the Spirit but as people who are still worldly—mere infants in Christ. [sup]2[/sup] I gave you milk, not solid food, for you were not yet ready for it. Indeed, you are still not ready. [sup]3[/sup] You are still worldly. For since there is jealousy and quarreling among you, are you not worldly? Are you not acting like mere humans? [sup]4[/sup] For when one says, “I follow Paul,” and another, “I follow Apollos,” are you not mere human beings? [sup]5[/sup] What, after all, is Apollos? And what is Paul? Only servants, through whom you came to believe—as the Lord has assigned to each his task. [sup]6[/sup] I planted the seed, Apollos watered it, but God has been making it grow. [sup]7[/sup] So neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything, but only God, who makes things grow. [sup]8[/sup] The one who plants and the one who waters have one purpose, and they will each be rewarded according to their own labor. [sup]9[/sup]For we are co-workers in God’s service; you are God’s field, God’s building.




I'm not saying it's bad to ATTEND or be a MEMBER OF a particular denomination, but the "alignment" and "loyalty to" seems to work against Scripture. I suspect this is a bigger problem for the RCC friends who believe they alone have the "full" truth. Regardless, this applies to everyone.

 

WhiteKnuckle

New Member
Mar 29, 2009
866
42
0
47
WhiteKnuckle, whatever you were taught and believed and practiced about bowing---you then read in the Bible not to make statues, nor to bow to images, nor to bow to men and angels. When we read do not make statues, nor bow to any images.....does that mean for a church to go make statues and pictures and command the people to venerate them with bowing? No, that would be going against the Word of God. But, it is what the Catholic religion does.

You really can't read the word of God clearly and plainly about that? You really don't take seriously the word of God, and obey when God says not to make a statue and bow to it?

Some of you here can't seem to keep all the information together. Here, I'll recap: The Catholic religion makes statues and pictures; they also keep and display remains of the dead; they call the statues and remains "holy." The Catholics command that these things be bowed to, venerated, prayed to, and even kissed.

Now go read what the Word of God says, and believe and obey.

As I said, I completely understand someone not agreeing with me on this. What exactly is the difference to you? If I were in Japan and I bow to another person, am I worshiping them? They also bow before they enter Church. Are they worshiping the Church?

Do you put flowers on graves of loved ones? What about all the groveling at the feet of kings in times past?

As far as macabre, well, different cultures treat the dead in different ways. To most in the "west" it's a disgrace to be creamated or to have a corpse exposed after burrial. In many Asian countries specifically India corpses are dug up regularly. They pay rent on the grave, if the family can't pay rent the corpse is dug up and the remains are sold. Yes, sold, I worked for a place that bought them and resold them.

Churches made out of skulls,,, that may seem evil to some. It looks spooky and is very macabre. But what's the difference? If you die and rot and become dust and someone years later uses that dust to build a brick, is it truely any different than if they built a door jam out of your arms and legs directly?

What about viewing of loved ones in a funeral home? Don't we dress them in fine clothes, and construct fine coffins with silk and metals. Burry them with all thier araignments, gold earings, wedding rings, watches, necklaces, eye glasses? Don't we all sit around a gawk at them? Then one by one stand up and walk past them for a final viewing? With tears and a broken heart don't some even kiss the body, or hold their hand?

Do you know anyone who has an urn in their house? They're usually highly decorated and put in a place of honor. The ashes themselves are placed in high regard and the memories are honored by all those who look at the urn. Wouldn't it be an offense if you just grabbed the urn and threw the ashes into the yard? What about people spreading ashes?

Are we worshiping soldiers by draping the flag over their coffin? What about the 21 gun salute?

I think different cultures deal with death in different ways and have different ways of honoring the memory of the deceased. Many of them seem apaulling to us, and completely absurd, sick, or disgusting, even unsanitary.

The western culture isn't the only culture in the world. What seems insulting to us, or seems like worship to us, is normal and has nothing to do with worship to others of different cultures.
I think that's a huge part of Catholicism, in that there's many different cultures rituals combined with them, and they've added their own as well. I do believe that many of the reasons for the rituals have been lost through the centuries, same as with any other culture.

Many of us in the west don't understand other cultures, Catholics are a culture unto themselves, and those of us who are not a part of it don't understand sometimes. Not understanding brings a fearfull heart. A fearfull heart is the breeding ground for hatred and ignorance. Ignorance and Hate demand those around us to conform completely to our views and ideas in order for us to feel comfortable within our own understanding. These also give us confirmation that we are right and that there is nothing wrong with us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Selene

aspen

“"The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few
Apr 25, 2012
14,111
4,778
113
52
West Coast
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As I said, I completely understand someone not agreeing with me on this. What exactly is the difference to you? If I were in Japan and I bow to another person, am I worshiping them? They also bow before they enter Church. Are they worshiping the Church?

Do you put flowers on graves of loved ones? What about all the groveling at the feet of kings in times past?

As far as macabre, well, different cultures treat the dead in different ways. To most in the "west" it's a disgrace to be creamated or to have a corpse exposed after burrial. In many Asian countries specifically India corpses are dug up regularly. They pay rent on the grave, if the family can't pay rent the corpse is dug up and the remains are sold. Yes, sold, I worked for a place that bought them and resold them.

Churches made out of skulls,,, that may seem evil to some. It looks spooky and is very macabre. But what's the difference? If you die and rot and become dust and someone years later uses that dust to build a brick, is it truely any different than if they built a door jam out of your arms and legs directly?

What about viewing of loved ones in a funeral home? Don't we dress them in fine clothes, and construct fine coffins with silk and metals. Burry them with all thier araignments, gold earings, wedding rings, watches, necklaces, eye glasses? Don't we all sit around a gawk at them? Then one by one stand up and walk past them for a final viewing? With tears and a broken heart don't some even kiss the body, or hold their hand?

Do you know anyone who has an urn in their house? They're usually highly decorated and put in a place of honor. The ashes themselves are placed in high regard and the memories are honored by all those who look at the urn. Wouldn't it be an offense if you just grabbed the urn and threw the ashes into the yard? What about people spreading ashes?

Are we worshiping soldiers by draping the flag over their coffin? What about the 21 gun salute?

I think different cultures deal with death in different ways and have different ways of honoring the memory of the deceased. Many of them seem apaulling to us, and completely absurd, sick, or disgusting, even unsanitary.

The western culture isn't the only culture in the world. What seems insulting to us, or seems like worship to us, is normal and has nothing to do with worship to others of different cultures.
I think that's a huge part of Catholicism, in that there's many different cultures rituals combined with them, and they've added their own as well. I do believe that many of the reasons for the rituals have been lost through the centuries, same as with any other culture.

Many of us in the west don't understand other cultures, Catholics are a culture unto themselves, and those of us who are not a part of it don't understand sometimes. Not understanding brings a fearfull heart. A fearfull heart is the breeding ground for hatred and ignorance. Ignorance and Hate demand those around us to conform completely to our views and ideas in order for us to feel comfortable within our own understanding. These also give us confirmation that we are right and that there is nothing wrong with us.

All I am saying is that we all follow a tradition - denying it is deceitful and presents the false position of being pure "christian", while labeling others as being wrong for admitting allegiance to a particular tradition.
 

WhiteKnuckle

New Member
Mar 29, 2009
866
42
0
47
All I am saying is that we all follow a tradition - denying it is deceitful and presents the false position of being pure "christian", while labeling others as being wrong for admitting allegiance to a particular tradition.

LOL, Just what I said, but with fewer words. Well done.
 

Selene

New Member
Apr 12, 2010
2,073
94
0
In my house
Selene,

Thank you for your reply to my question. I guess that my understanding of the state of the dead is different than yours. First, my understanding of the state of the dead is that they are not conscious or aware of anything, so being in that state, they wouldn't be able to help anyone.

Isaiah 26:14 The dead do not live; departed spirits do not rise up. Indeed, You have visited and destroyed them;You have wiped out all memory of them. Eccl. 9: [sup]5[/sup]For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing; and they have no more reward [here], for the memory of them is forgotten. [sup]10[/sup]Whatever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might, for there is no work or device or knowledge or wisdom in Sheol (the place of the dead), where you are going. Psalm 146: [sup]3[/sup] Do not trust in nobles, in man, who cannot save. [sup]4[/sup] When his breath leaves him, he returns to the ground; on that day his plans die.
Jesus said that death was like sleep, which is an unconscious state. John 11: [sup]11[/sup] He said this, and then He told them, "Our friend Lazarus has fallen asleep, but I'm on My way to wake him up." [sup]12[/sup] Then the disciples said to Him, "Lord, if he has fallen asleep, he will get well." [sup]13[/sup] Jesus, however, was speaking about his death, but they thought He was speaking about natural sleep. [sup]14[/sup] So Jesus then told them plainly, "Lazarus has died. Acts 7: [sup]59[/sup]And while they were stoning Stephen, he prayed, Lord Jesus, receive and accept and welcome my spirit! [sup]60[/sup]And falling on his knees, he cried out loudly, Lord, fix not this sin upon them [lay it not to their charge]! And when he had said this, he fell asleep [sup][/sup][in death]. 1Cor. 15: [sup]5[/sup]And [also] that He appeared to Cephas (Peter), then to the Twelve. [sup]6[/sup]Then later He showed Himself to more than five hundred brethren at one time, the majority of whom are still alive, but some have fallen asleep [in death].

We are warned in God's word not to ask for help from the dead. Isa. 8:
[sup]19[/sup] When they say to you, "Consult the spirits of the dead and the spiritists who chirp and mutter," [sup][/sup]shouldn't a people consult their God? [sup]][/sup] [Should they consult] the dead on behalf of the living?

But we do have hope of the resurrection when the dead will be resurrected back to life. John 5: [sup]28[/sup]
Do not be amazed at this, because a time is coming when all who are in the graves will hear His voice [sup]29[/sup] and come out—those who have done good things, to the resurrection of life, but those who have done wicked things, to the resurrection of judgment.[sup]
[/sup]Acts 24: 15 And I have a hope in God, which these men themselves also accept, that there is going to be a resurrection, both of the righteous and the unrighteous.

These are just a few scriptures that I wanted to share to explain what my understanding of the state of the dead is, and about the hope we can have in the resurrection.


truthquest

Hello Truthquest,

Your understanding of the dead is exactly the same as mine. This is why we do not ask intercession from the dead on the earth. When we ask intercession, it is only from the LIVING IN HEAVEN. My understanding of Heaven is that there are no dead people in Heaven.

When Christ spoke to Moses and Elijah during the Transfiguration, he was not speaking to the dead. When we speak to the Saints in Heaven, we also are not speaking to the dead because there are no dead spirits in Heaven. Heaven is a place of eternal life, and there are people in Heaven (Hebrews 12:1 and Rev. 7:9). Now, that Christ has risen from the dead, the gates of Heaven has been opened to mankind and those who believe in our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ can have eternal life in Heaven.

In Christ,
Selene


Romans 1:1-3 Paul, a servant of Christ Jesus, called to be an apostle and set apart for the gospel of God— [sup]2[/sup] the gospel he promised beforehand through his prophets in the Holy Scriptures [sup]3[/sup] regarding his Son, who as to his earthly life[sup][a][/sup] was a descendant of David,

Aspen, did you read the scripture about Jesus "who as to his earthly life was a descendant of David"?

When you read that scripture it should help you to understand that Jesus, who as to his earthly life---Mary was his mother. Mary is the mother of the human/earthly Jesus. It is not correct to say Mary is the mother of God, the Father.

We have never said that Mary was the mother of God the Father. We have always said that Mary is the mother of God the Son. The human/earthly Jesus is God.
 

Anastacia

New Member
Oct 23, 2010
663
35
0

That is not a bad thing.
Blind and ignorant denominational loyalty is utter nonsense and I think the Apostle Paul would agree.

Anyone "aligning" themselves with a particular denomination seems to be anti-scripture.

Brothers and sisters, I could not address you as people who live by the Spirit but as people who are still worldly—mere infants in Christ. [sup]2[/sup] I gave you milk, not solid food, for you were not yet ready for it. Indeed, you are still not ready. [sup]3[/sup] You are still worldly. For since there is jealousy and quarreling among you, are you not worldly? Are you not acting like mere humans? [sup]4[/sup] For when one says, “I follow Paul,” and another, “I follow Apollos,” are you not mere human beings? [sup]5[/sup] What, after all, is Apollos? And what is Paul? Only servants, through whom you came to believe—as the Lord has assigned to each his task. [sup]6[/sup] I planted the seed, Apollos watered it, but God has been making it grow. [sup]7[/sup] So neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything, but only God, who makes things grow. [sup]8[/sup] The one who plants and the one who waters have one purpose, and they will each be rewarded according to their own labor. [sup]9[/sup]For we are co-workers in God’s service; you are God’s field, God’s building.

I'm not saying it's bad to ATTEND or be a MEMBER OF a particular denomination, but the "alignment" and "loyalty to" seems to work against Scripture. I suspect this is a bigger problem for the RCC friends who believe they alone have the "full" truth. Regardless, this applies to everyone.



Thanks, TexUs. So glad to find someone like minded in this, and with scripture.


I still would like to say a few things here.....that the "Church" is not a building or a denomination, it is the body of Christ, and true believers are part of the body, which Jesus is the head. When believers get together, the Bible calls it the church, and also is called the household of God, and that can even be in someone's house. The first Christians did not have denominations, when they got together, the people who gathered ,"the church," would be identified by the name of the city where the church gathered.
In the past, I have joined different denominations, and when I would grow in the Lord, I would find that they had beliefs that I found to be false. I will not claim any denomination again. A denomination did not die for me, Jesus did.

We have never said that Mary was the mother of God the Father. We have always said that Mary is the mother of God the Son. The human/earthly Jesus is God.

Selene, your Catholic brother, aspen, says the Catholic church calls Mary the Mother of God, the Father. See aspen's post below:


Spliting the divine and human aspects of Jesus is a heresy within the early church. It is not my "nerve" that is claiming this fact - it was defined as a heresy by First Council of Ephesus in 431
 

Selene

New Member
Apr 12, 2010
2,073
94
0
In my house
Selene, your Catholic brother, aspen, says the Catholic church calls Mary the Mother of God, the Father. See aspen's post below:

Really? Where did it say that in his quote below? According to his quote, I don't even see the name "Mary" in it.

Spliting the divine and human aspects of Jesus is a heresy within the early church. It is not my "nerve" that is claiming this fact - it was defined as a heresy by First Council of Ephesus in 431

Mary is called the "mother of God" because she gave birth to Jesus who is also God. Of course, we also know that God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit are all one and the same. They are not separate because God is really three persons in one. Perhaps, you only see Jesus as a human being, but to us, Jesus is God. Jesus was never created because He existed even before Mary. But the truth is that Mary did give birth to Jesus despite the fact that Jesus already existed. Jesus is God incarnate who was never created and is also God the Father and God the Holy Spirit for all are one and the same.

This is why Mary is called the "mother of God" because she carried Jesus (who is God) in her womb. If you say that Mary did not carry God in her womb, but only carried Christ’s human nature, this is a heresy from the fifth century known as Nestorianism. A mother does not merely carry the human nature of her child in her womb. Rather, she carries the person of her child. Women do not give birth to human natures; they give birth to persons. Thus, Mary carried and gave birth to the person of Jesus Christ, and the person she gave birth to was God because Jesus is God.
 

Templar81

New Member
Apr 14, 2010
854
17
0
UK
That's got me thinking about eh Ave. All it does is greet Mary and ask her to pray for us. Ora pro nobis pecatoribus nunc et in hora mortis nostrae: Pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death. We are all sinners and we all need praying for.
 

marksman

My eldest granddaughter showing the result of her
Feb 27, 2008
5,578
2,446
113
82
Melbourne Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
When Christ spoke to Moses and Elijah during the Transfiguration, he was not speaking to the dead. When we speak to the Saints in Heaven, we also are not speaking to the dead because there are no dead spirits in Heaven. Heaven is a place of eternal life, and there are people in Heaven (Hebrews 12:1 and Rev. 7:9). Now, that Christ has risen from the dead, the gates of Heaven has been opened to mankind and those who believe in our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ can have eternal life in Heaven.

Dear me Selene, truth is not high on your agenda is it. Hebrews 12:1 is a follow on from the previous chapter about all the witnesses tha are held up as examples to us. You have to draw a very long bow to suggest that chapter 11 talks about them all being in heaven. In fact you will find that there are verses which say they are not.

As for Rev 7:9 a perfect example of proof texting, ignoring the rest of the chapter which asks the question "who are all these" and the reply is "those that have come out of the tribulation." Obviously you don't know that the tribulation hasn't happened yet, so these people probably haven't been born yet.

I don't know if you realise but your method of bible study seems to be a case of what is the end result I want to achieve so lets find something that will support my hypothesis.


All I am saying is that we all follow a tradition - denying it is deceitful and presents the false position of being pure "christian", while labeling others as being wrong for admitting allegiance to a particular tradition.

And my tradition is to avoid all tradition.

This thread was started by Aspen, and the purpose of this thread was to have an honest dialogue with non-Catholics. If you want to speak your truth, so go start your own thread. How difficult can that be? If Aspen is able to start a thread, then why is it so difficult for you to do the same thing?

In case you had not noticed Selene, this is now an anti catholic thread not asking catholics questions, which is probably a good idea as you answered very few of the questions you were asked so the thread became a bit pointless.

I pity you, and you are in my prayers.

That is totally condescending Selene, and certainly indicative of the fact that all your talk about love for others is nothing more than smoke and mirrors.

Though his body is no longer alive and has been consumed by a special type of soil that allowed his bones to disolve extremely fast, he shows us that he is alive by aid ing in miracoulous works and is a very important figure for both Anglicans and Catholics, possibly a force for reunification but that is a long way off. I look forard to the day when he is given full canonization.

Wo hoo!!! I have been looking for new fairy stories to tell my grandchildren.

Nice bit of hair splitting Templar but if the corpse is in the ground that means that person has died.Thankful, I am sure your wife was visited by something, but the Mother of Jesus it wasn't.

Quite right Foreigner. It is an occult experience when a spirit mimicks another person. It is no different to occultist mediums who use evil spirits to mimic the voice of someone who is dead.

When I asked st George to intercede for me I wasn't communciating with the dead but simply talking to a fellow Christian who is alive in the church triamphna twhile I still belong to the church militant. St George like all the others is very much alive in the body of Chrsit. St George used to be my patron but now I have St James of Compostella, though George is still important to me.

Try using the "edit" button after posting. Is St. James the patron saint of compost heaps?

havn't you read the posts where I explained that saints remains aren't just any old bones, they are holy and worthy of our veneration, don't you get it?

And don't you get it that NOWHERE, and I MEAN NOWHERE in scripture are you told to do this!!!!!!
 

marksman

My eldest granddaughter showing the result of her
Feb 27, 2008
5,578
2,446
113
82
Melbourne Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
"Venerate," "bow," and "worship" are not identical in either connotation or denotation. If you can show me precisely identical dictionary entries, I could be convinced that they are equivalent, but I have heard all used quite distinctly, and they are different words with different meanings.

No they are not. The word "worship" in Greek does not mean singing songs. It means bowing down before the one who has captured you in battle and acknowledging your surrender to him and you becoming a slave to him.

When I worship God, I am surrendering to him as he has captured me by his love so I give myself over to his Lordship in my life. I don't need any so called "saint" to enable me to do it and I certainly don't need no dead statue to achieve that aim apart from the fact that you will not find ANYWHERE in scripture you are to bow before man made images of dead persons.

What you are doing is no different to what happens in pagan religions who worship and bow down before bits of wood and stone in the hope that they can keep the peace with non existent gods that they have invented for themselves.


All those who believe in Christ are alive in Christ. Their bodies are dead in the ground, but their souls are alive in Christ in Heaven. We do not speak to dead bodies on earth. We have always asked for the intercession of those living in HEAVEN. It would be a grave misconception of Heaven to think that those in Heaven are dead.

Chapter and verse please for what you are claiming here?
 

Templar81

New Member
Apr 14, 2010
854
17
0
UK
Cahter and verse: Revelations 8:4

And the smoke of the incense, [which came] with the prayers of the saints, ascended up before God out of the angel's hand.

That is proof that they interceed for us.

Don't belittle me Marksman and don't make fun of St James, he's a better man than you. Compostela is Galicia in Northern Spain and has nothign to do with compost.

No they are not. The word "worship" in Greek does not mean singing songs. It means bowing down before the one who has captured you in battle and acknowledging your surrender to him and you becoming a slave to him.

When I worship God, I am surrendering to him as he has captured me by his love so I give myself over to his Lordship in my life. I don't need any so called "saint" to enable me to do it and I certainly don't need no dead statue to achieve that aim apart from the fact that you will not find ANYWHERE in scripture you are to bow before man made images of dead persons.

What you are doing is no different to what happens in pagan religions who worship and bow down before bits of wood and stone in the hope that they can keep the peace with non existent gods that they have invented for themselves

Well in case you havn't noticed we speak English here not first century Greek so no! veneration and bowing do not have to be synonymously bound up with worship.

Oh yes! it might appear pagan to the ignorant but that is because the devil created pagan religions to look similar to what is good and true as a means of decieving people. and Marskman has fallen for it hook, line and sinker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.