Search results

Hey RedFan, I have thought about that also. Why doesn't Scripture OR even historical Christian writings tell us WHO replaced Peter just like it told us who replaced Judas. WHO was assigned the keys after the death of Peter is a good question. There are some writings from Ireneaus and Cyprian...

Yup, The Church is built on Christ. I have agreed with you on that already kiddo. He is the cornerstone, the foundation. But according to your premise/theory/(lack of)teaching by your men, Peter didn't do anything to build up The Church after Christ died. He and the other Apostles just sat...

Nope, not a false premise. Your men never taught you all of Scripture and how to answer those questions so it stumped you kiddo. Since you don't have an answer, you just make the accusation "False premise". And then you (in your heart) are off the hook. Sooooo let me see if I got YOUR premise...

Oh goodness Scottie...... You teach that I "may not even know the actual truth until I am in the presence of God". And, as I have shown multiple times, YOU teach opposite of Scripture: And you shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free...... a worker who does not need to be...

Oh goodness.....Sure, I will help you! As we have already established, when Jesus gave the keys to the kingdom to Peter he was talking to Peter and Peter only. Jesus said, "I will give you the keys to the kingdom...". He didn't say I AM giving you the keys right now...He was using future tense...

I'm jaded. I see NOTHING in my statement that suggests that 100% of the Catechism is a recapitulation of Scripture. Why do you ask?

Nice dodge Scottie. I know....I knew....I will never get a straight answer from you....but I baked that into our conversations already so I ain't by no ways mad kiddo.

Lol...Yup, silly ol' Marymog is showing a lack of understanding and wise ol' Scottie is going to teach me :joyful:I mean after all, those Catholic men don't know nuttin'. THEY are not guided by the Holy Spirit. But Scottie is!!! Confusion has been placed on poor lil' marymog and the truth eludes...

Uh huh.....Sure...sure!! And who do you trust to rightly divide the word of truth, Scott? Curious

Yup Scottie, only the Spirit knows what is true. Remember that when I tell you that what you wrote isn't true. Here is your dilemma, Scottie. Scripture makes it clear that the Spirit revealed and reveals the Truth to some men. Sooooo to say that "only the Spirit knows what is true" is another...

The definition of mocking is to treat one with contempt or ridicule. I don't have any contempt for you and I am not ridiculing you, Scottie. I am just flat out calling you out. I am revealing how what you teach is opposite of what Scripture teaches. I ask you questions that, if you were to...

I see NOTHING in my statement that suggests that. But you clearly have a strong desire to air your anti-Catholic grievance sooooooo let's hear it kiddo.

Huh.... :IDK:

Hold on Scottie...HOLD ON!! First off, YOU drop scripture into YOUR doctrine in YOUR posts on this website that hardly anyone in the world sees. But when the Catholic Church does it and puts it in a book (Catechism) for the entire world to see it then becomes a teaching of men? Huh....:IDK...

Nice try Scottie. I asked very specific questions of which I would like you to answer instead of acting like you are some wise sage who speaks in God inspired words. Let's try this again since you dodged me the first time: When you reveal to all of us what the Holy Spirit told YOU and what YOU...

Hold on...HOLD ON Scottie...... :jest: Partially quoting a passage from Isaiah 29 AND the context of that quote has NOTHING to do with our conversation only makes you look silly. YOU should carry on as it is written: For the Lord has poured out on you The spirit of deep sleep, And has...

:jest:

Thanks trollman

Soooo when God decides Scripture is being misused...who does he tell? Brakelite? Curious Mary

Dear Wrangler, Thank you for asking! :) First off, Marymog didn't say that God gave authority to Peter only. Jesus said he gave authority to Peter only: And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; I will give YOU the keys of the kingdom of heaven...