Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
(removed)Is there a point in publishing a link to this article?
Yes there was abuse in many religious institutions, there was also abuse and corruption in secular organisations set up to deal with the problem of " backward " indigenous people.
Society back then viewed them as both backward and in the way.
The many forced transportation of indigenous people were organised by the state.
A far greater form of abuse than that done by Christians.
An example of what could be done is seen in the example of David Brainard.
I agree !Im half native american. Im not heavily into the culture, but i see the intergenerational trauma thats been passed down all around me in my community. In my own life too, if im completely honest. Primarily, alcoholism, sexual/physical and emotional abuse. There is a "truth and reconciliation day" that is a recent statutory holiday thats been added to our calendar, after the mass graves of children were uncovered in the old residential schools properties. The first one being dicovered in Kamloops BC a couple years ago, if i remember correctly. I personally believe there were a lot of wolves in sheeps clothing that were tearing these families apart and abusing the children at the time. Children of the devil that were dressed in white. And i think we all are suffering as a result to this day. But who knows, Yahweh will have the final word.
Im half native american. Im not heavily into the culture, but i see the intergenerational trauma thats been passed down all around me in my community. In my own life too, if im completely honest. Primarily, alcoholism, sexual/physical and emotional abuse.
Many of us in the world are aware that what Europeans did to the indigenous people was disgusting and it’s still going on to this day. Many of the colonizers that came over had no respect for human life. They had little respect for their own ethnicity and race and even less for others. I don’t think I really need to go back over what we should all know about the early settlers and how they hurt the indigenous people. The doctrine of discovery was also very anti Christian. Very racist. No one really uses it now and as far as white people in America we are simply here to stay.
It’s still irrelevant to why so many people take issues with Christianity being spread by the sword and rape. I agree many are the same…. Which begs the question what’s separating Christian’s from others with the same vices?This is the same intergenerational trauma that is within the black community, and honestly, I think it has become a crutch that has held both groups back, that and government dependency. I get that there were some legitimate wrongs done in the past, but carrying around those grievances from one generation to the next is a form of self-harm. They can't move forward as long as they're always looking back.
When I was younger, I was heavy into all things Native American, so I've read a good deal about history. The natives had all the sins and vices of the Europeans and even some they didn't have, like human sacrifice and cannibalism. The natives were killing and enslaving each other long before the Europeans arrived; the Europeans were just better at it. The common denominator is that both are human, and like all humans, we all have a sin nature and are plagued by same problem.
It’s still irrelevant to why so many people take issues with Christianity being spread by the sword and rape. I agree many are the same….
Which begs the question what’s separating Christian’s from others with the same vices?
So I can’t tell if you are confused about the discussion. Part of this discussion that I was responding to was that many indigenous people take issues with Christianity. The reason why they take issue with Christianity is because the Christianity that was forced on them, by the sword and by rape, where women were bought and kidnapped and forced into a modern version of a concubine got raped by their owners and then forced to raise the kids in Christianity. Then Christians, and that’s what they called themselves and that’s what Bibles they preached, were Europeans who became Americans. These American Christians brought treaty after treaty, these American Christians hid behind the laws of discovery which meant Christians had a right to conquer , take hold of and enslave anyone or nation that was not Christian. So that’s the Christianity that was handed off to the native Americans. They stole their kids, put thousands of their kids into Christian schools where they were tortured and killed, buried in unmarked graves.Christianity wasn't spread by the sword and rape; that's Islam. Christianity is spread by the word. The Europeans were culturally Christians, but not everyone lived it. There are plenty of people who did things in the name of Christianity that were contrary to Christ's teachings.
I don't understand this question.
The reason why they take issue with Christianity is because the Christianity that was forced on them, by the sword and by rape, where women were bought and kidnapped and forced into a modern version of a concubine got raped by their owners and then forced to raise the kids in Christianity.
The Christians banned them from practicing their culture and language.
Same Christians have modern day successors. The ones who round up illegal immigrants, whose great grandparents use to own this same country, the same indigenous people. We took their land. We call them illegal. We round them up, put their kids in cages, and fire shots at them for climbing a fence.
To this day Christians try to undermine indigenous practices.
So you can’t just pull a “no true Scotsman” type of argument because it’s convenient for you. The things I’m bringing up are part of Christianity in America. Plenty of indigenous people are Christian, but that is still besides the point. Everyone Christians act like bad Christians, like Hitler, does not mean we as Christians can just say…. Well even though they did everything in the name of being Christian does not mean they are Christians. That’s besides the point too. Christians can sin and do commit horrible crimes. Sometimes a nation or political party is predominantly Christian, and they carry out their faith. Christian is a term that means someone claims to follow Christ. Does not matter if you agree or disagree with their actions or doctrines. You can say Catholics are not Christians, or that Protestants are not Christians, or that this or that is not Christian just because it does something bad. If that’s the argument you are going to keep falling on, then the discussion is pointless because as far as anyone is concerned, those actions were carried out by Christians. People who weaponized the Bible, faith and church to oppress and kill innocent people. AForced conversions are not Biblical. If anyone did that, the blame should fall on them and not Christianity. Not everyone who claims to be a Christian is a Christian.
I would also note that that was not every native's experience. Some tribes, like the Cherokee, adopted Christianity wholeheartedly, even incorporating it into their own beliefs. There were other prominent Native Americans who became Christian by their own choice, like Black Elk and Red Cloud.
A lot of what you mentioned had less to do with Christianity and more to do with government. The two shouldn't be confused. The U.S. government was the one who led the way for assimilation effort, forced them to walk the Trail of Tears, did the killing, etc.
I'm not saying there weren't injustices done; there were, but it's always one-sided. We never hear about settlers who were raped, murdered, and mutilated. They didn't care if they were women or children either. And you did not want to be taken captive. They were practically creative when it came to torture methods. So, I'm a little put off when we are constantly vilified when in reality there were atrocities on both sides.
This is conflating a whole different subject that has nothing to do with Christians or the topic at hand.
Again, governments not Christians. At this point, we're living in a post-Christian U.S.
More like the Law was used against them = so called type of Jewish intent was at foot ? Nothing truly Christian at all about such in fact !Here are some links from indigenous people of America on how Christianity was weaponized against them.
The Great Evil: Christianity, the Bible and the Native American Genocide
Chris Mato Nunpa talks about the role that the Bible played in the genocide, land theft and religious suppression of Native American people.www.pioneer.org
American Indians balance native customs with Christianity
Many misconceptions can be found of Native American spiritual practices. For America's indigenous people, late 19th century Christianity meant forced assimilation and cultural domination. And generations later, Native Americans who chose Christianity are sometimes said to have "sold out."www.mprnews.org
The Cultural Conundrum of the Indigenous Christian
The Rev. Rachel Taber Hamilton shares an intimate story about becoming Christian in a community harmed by Christianity.www.episcopalchurch.org