There is that pesky word "until" in Rom. 11:25 which makes a big change in the narrative. One has to look at the whole of prophecy to see where a particular prophecy might have it's place.
The King James Version renders Romans 11:25:
“blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.”
It means that a remnant of Israel is saved and the rest are blinded while the fulness of the Gentiles comes in. When is the fulness of the Gentiles come in? When Christ returns. Manifestly, they are not all blinded; a remnant will continue to believe (as they always have). The engrafting isn't restricted to an end-time mass repentance by the whole nation (prior to the Lord's coming) as Dispensationalists seem to imagine (although a sizeable company of Jews may be saved at the end). This reading makes no such suggestion along that line. It is simply speaking of that portion or part of Israel that is not blinded but has been saved by the precious blood of Jesus. They will continue to come to Christ “while” the Gentiles also come through.
All Israel shall be saved once all the saved Gentiles and once all the saved Jews have come through, having entered into the kingdom of God through being born from above.
Dispensationalists interpret Romans 11:25 as if the engrafting of Israelis
must occur after the in-coming of the Gentiles. However, the original doesn't say that. It declares,
“For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until [Gr.
achris hou or
while wherein]
the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.”
The Greek word
achris literally means up to, as far as, until, or while. Palmer Robertson explains: “The phrase rendered ‘until’ (
achris hou) is essentially terminative. More particularly, it indicates the
terminus ad quem [ending point] … The phrase brings matters ‘up to’ a certain point or ‘until’ a certain goal is reached. It does not itself determine the state of affairs after the termination. The subsequent circumstances can be learned only from the context” (The Israel of God: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow).
This text is telling us that not all Israelis are going to be saved. A notable portion of natural ethnic Israel will remain blind while the Gentiles come in, right up until Christ comes. That does not mean that God will not continue to move and save amongst the Jewish people. Romans 9-11 makes clear that there are 2 types of Israeli – the blinded and the elect remnant. That will remain up until Jesus comes. The same applies in every nation.
The same sense is found in Luke 21:24 (a passage that Dispensationalists present as a proof-text for their beliefs), which says,
“Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the Gentiles, until [Gr.
achris hou or
while wherein]
the times of the Gentiles be fulfilled.”
Is there a time coming when Jesus will stop reaching out to the Gentiles as He is today? Only when He comes to rescue us and destroy the wicked and usher in eternity.
This text is simply telling us that ancient Jerusalem has lost her favored place of preeminence as the center-point of worship to the Almighty globally as it once was in the golden years of the Old Testament. Their theocracy was been removed from them. It has been given to the New Testament Church. That will remain so throughout this new covenant period as the nations are brought to Christ. What is more, Jerusalem will never again be free of Gentiles influence. There is no more damning a testimony of that than the prominent and provocative standing of Islam’s Al-Aqsa Mosque that sits on the former site of the Jewish temple.