Penal Substitutionary Atonement

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
281
223
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
While this is true, who determines who is a "genuine" believer? Not the believer himself. If you go to an insane asylum and ask who's crazy...they will invariably look at others not themselves. So the false believer thinks he's genuine.

It isn't good to presume upon a judgment that only God can make.
The true believer knows that God has saved him and that he has eternal life.

1 John 5:13 (W.E.B.) These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you may continue to believe in the name of the Son of God.

Phil. 1:6 being confident of this very thing, that he who began a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ.


Those who suppress the truth are false believers.
They are unbelievers.


Our unrighteousness is the unrighteousness of believers. And God will inflict wrath on His own people.
NO! God inflicted his wrath upon the Lord Jesus Christ, so that IT DOES NOT FALL upon His own people. Jesus took our sins and their punishments upon himself, on the cross.


Protestants think that obedience is trying to be saved by works. So guess who the children of disobedience are??? OSAS
The first sentence is a lie and the second part is stupidity.

Protestants teach that obedience flows from the salvation that Christians have been given, by grace, through faith in Jesus Christ.

The children of disobedience are those who do not trust in Jesus Christ for salvation.


The Pharisees were the children of the kingdom. The ONLY person who said they were not genuine is Jesus. same thing for the judgment on the church. Many who minister in His name will be rejected as lawless. As in...go away I never knew you. Obedience is NOT optional. The very beginning of a race is not the whole race. One must begin by redemption and run by faith and faithfulness (obedience)...or else one loses the race. Works MAINTAIN salvation or else one is burying their talent.
Salvation is by grace through faith in Jesus Christ, not of works, lest anyone should boast.

Here is how Eph. 2:8,9 would read, if your doctrine were true.

Eph. 2:8,9 (altered to fit Episkopos' doctrine)
8 for by grace you have been placed on probation through faith, and that is to be maintained by yourselves;
9 it is of your works, that you may boast.

I pray that you will come to see how blasphemous and dishonouring to Jesus your false doctrine is.

Born again and baptized in the Spirit...as a very first step. My testimony only begins there....not ends there as most Protestants profess.
More lies about Protestants... Christians are supposed to tell the truth. Is this you losing your probation?


False. ALL the Israelites witnessed the many miracles God did before their very eyes. They all believed in God. They just didn't believe that THEY could do impossible things...just like modern believers don't believe they can walk without any sin in holiness. Same test, same failure of faith.
If you claim that you walk without any sin, then you are A LIAR, as God's word states; and lying is a serious sin.

The dogmatic drivel is what leads to assurance of salvation by ignoring humility and the fear of the Lord.
Assurance of salvation comes from trusting in the Lord Jesus Christ, not your own works.
 

Judge Hardcastle

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2026
488
266
63
North America
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Protestants think that obedience is trying to be saved by works. So guess who the children of disobedience are???
That's YOU that believes that, lol.
Your whole gospel is you get saved by being obedient to God's commands.

But you say some are picked to live the life of obedience by which they are saved, and others aren't. How is that not a OSAS doctrine?????
 

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,760
23,594
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
The true believer knows that God has saved him and that he has eternal life.

1 John 5:13 (W.E.B.) These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you may continue to believe in the name of the Son of God.

Phil. 1:6 being confident of this very thing, that he who began a good work in you will complete it until the day of Jesus Christ.

Again, a superficial reading of the bible with a tremendously large ego and religious certainty can basically claim to be anything. The bible exposes people. The bible interprets people. In the same way the law made religious hypocrites in Judaism...grace has made the same among modern believers.

God is indeed faithful. But those who are the Lord's are called chosen AND faithful.

This is denied in the propaganda based religion that encourages imagination.

NO! God inflicted his wrath upon the Lord Jesus Christ, so that IT DOES NOT FALL upon His own people. Jesus took our sins and their punishments upon himself, on the cross.

God was IN Christ reconciling the world to Himself. You are misrepresenting the passion of Christ. Jesus suffered for our sins. He took on Himself our evil....the way a brave man endures torture. That's not what saves us. Jesus put up with our evil. But those who would be saved with Him must also endure the same suffering. The same death.

Only real Christianity accepts the selfless quality of Jesus and actually follows Him.

The false religion is that Jesus paid the price for my sins so that I might sin without fear. Jesus dies for me so that I can throw away the fear of the Lord and replace that with a smug self-assurance that I have an immunity from prosecution for what I do...evil or not.
The first sentence is a lie and the second part is stupidity.

Protestants teach that obedience flows from the salvation that Christians have been given, by grace, through faith in Jesus Christ.

If you take a child molester and let him get away with it, he will also appreciate the gesture. So the criminal will also show gratitude.
The children of disobedience are those who do not trust in Jesus Christ for salvation.

false. Trusting Jesus for salvation is a religious delusion. We can HOPE for salvation but faith is not in OUR condition....but in God's character of justice and fairness.
Salvation is by grace through faith in Jesus Christ, not of works, lest anyone should boast.

You manipulate the verse to mean something that's not there. We are saved by God's power that makes us OBEY God just like Jesus did.
Here is how Eph. 2:8,9 would read, if your doctrine were true.

Eph. 2:8,9 (altered to fit Episkopos' doctrine)
8 for by grace you have been placed on probation through faith, and that is to be maintained by yourselves;
9 it is of your works, that you may boast.

Entering into Christ is a real salvation...no more sin. Jesus came to save us FROM our sins....not Jesus came to save us IN our sins.
I pray that you will come to see how blasphemous and dishonouring to Jesus your false doctrine is.

The opposite is true. You disobey the words of Jesus to make Him an idol that doesn't need to be obeyed.
More lies about Protestants... Christians are supposed to tell the truth. Is this you losing your probation?



If you claim that you walk without any sin, then you are A LIAR, as God's word states; and lying is a serious sin.

If you walk in a sinful Jesus then you are a reprobate. Read the bible. If we are found sinners while we claim to be redeemed from the world and its ways...is Christ then a minister of sin? Is He there to shield some sinners and not others based on a democratic process of acceptance through voting? and claiming?
Assurance of salvation comes from trusting in the Lord Jesus Christ, not your own works.
Assurance of salvation comes from religious indoctrination that ignores most of the verses in the bible to make up another gospel that champions self-interest.
 
Last edited:

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,760
23,594
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
That's YOU that believes that, lol.
Your whole gospel is you get saved by being obedient to God's commands.

The whole gospel indeed includes obedience for salvation. Without that you will be rejected as being LAWLESS. But what makes us WANT to obey Jesus? Regeneration by the Spirit. So God gets the ball rolling...and we must then engage by following Christ. Otherwise we are just burying our talent and claiming that Jesus "did it all". Such foolishness.

So you religiously indoctrinated people confuse the race with the first step and ignore running the race. That's why so many will be disqualified.
But you say some are picked to live the life of obedience by which they are saved, and others aren't. How is that not a OSAS doctrine?????
Not picked to be saved.....but faithful to run till the end. The real Jesus, who you don't think is important to listen to said...he who endures till the end will be saved.

If you were to convert to become a Christ follower that would mean something to you. But at this stage, it does not mean a thing to you.
 

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,760
23,594
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
The false gospel makes grace to be something that takes away OUR responsibility for our actions. But the very opposite is true. Grace makes us even MORE responsible for what we do. To whom much is given MORE is required. (that last statement from someone called Jesus that almost no one knows or listens to anymore).
 

One 2 question

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2023
2,458
723
113
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
S22The false gospel makes grace to be something that takes away OUR responsibility for our actions. But the very opposite is true. Grace makes us even MORE responsible for what we do. To whom much is given MORE is required. (that last statement from someone called Jesus that almost no one knows or listens to anymore).
GAL 5:16 So I say, walk by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh. 17 For the flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh. They are in conflict with each other, so that you are not to do whatever you want. 18 But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under the law.
19 The acts of the flesh are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; 20 idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions 21 and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God.

22 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. 24 Those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. 25 Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit.

Paul acknowledges it as do I. There is a dual participation happening as the Spirit and His host live out their daily life together carry out the will of the Divine Father.

Now this is good news hey.
 

Judge Hardcastle

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2026
488
266
63
North America
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You are saying works don't justify. So the epistle of James is wrong?
They don't justify so as to make you absolved of all guilt of your sin. Only the blood of Christ, received by faith can do that.

Being justified by faith, apart from works makes us legally forgiven and absolved of all guilt of unrighteousness. Without the guilt of unrighteousness we stand righteous before God.

Being justified by works shows us to have the righteousness that is by faith. Works don't make us righteous. Works, as imperfect as they are, show us to have the righteousness that is by faith, because everyone who is justified by faith in Christ receives the Holy Spirit by which they then live lives that exemplify that faith.

And so a man is justified by, both, faith and works (James 2:24).
 

Judge Hardcastle

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2026
488
266
63
North America
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Not picked to be saved.....but faithful to run till the end.
You're making a distinction without a difference. You are saying that some are picked to have the faith by which they endure to the end and are saved. And yet you slam Calvinism for believing the same thing.

The real Jesus, who you don't think is important to listen to said...he who endures till the end will be saved.
What makes you think Reformed theology says you don't have to endure to the end to be saved in the end?

Reformed theology says the person who does not endure to the end is an unsaved person who is showing by their failure that they do not have the faith by which they would otherwise be saved and through which they would have endured to the end. How did you not know this? Stop fighting an imaginary foe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David1701

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,609
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Here's one verse...

2 Cor 5:21
For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.
5:21 τὸν γὰρ μὴ γνόντα ἁμαρτίαν ὑπὲρ ἡμῶν ἁμαρτίαν ἐποίησεν ἵνα ἡμεῖς γινώμεθα δικαιοσύνη θεοῦ ἐν αὐτῷ
For our sake he made him to be more than our very sin who knew not the sin, so that in him we might begin the righteousness of God.

He became the sin of crucifying a guiltless man. I don't know if that is the BIG PSA verse. There are weaker ones though.

From "This is the Torah of the Sin Offering", Reply#2


H2403 חַטָּאָה chatta'ah and G266 ἀμαρτία hamartia.

2 Corinthians 5:21 KJV
21 For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him.

2 Corinthians 5:21 ASV
21 Him who knew no sin he made to be sin on our behalf; that we might become the righteousness of God in him.

Has the Meshiah been made to be sin for us? Do we trade places with him? Did he become sin so that we might become the righteousness of Elohim? Does this not sound just a little too much like the goat sent away for Azazel with all the sins of the congregation placed upon its (mortally wounded) head? Doesn't Paul say in another place that he speaks to those who know the Torah? Do modern translators and scholarship know the Torah all that well? (I do not mean linguistics but reasoning). If indeed they knew the Torah, and had studied the Septuagint, so as to compare the most ancient Greek translation of the Hebrew scriptures, would the above renderings be rendered as they are?

Does the sin offering become sin? Absolutely not: the sin offering is most holy, and the Kohanim are commanded to consume it. The sin offering therefore cannot "become sin" because that would mean that the Most High commanded His Kohanim to consume sin, and because of the discourse in Jhn 6:26-71 the renderings of 2Cor 5:21 quoted above are on shaky ground at best, and likely rather quite heretical. However there are some translators that do render hamartia as a sin offering. I am quoting the following translator for this passage because a commentary is given for their reasoning behind the rendering, and I will post a link to the commentary after the text, which I hope will be helpful in showing that this is not just some new idea of my own but attested by others more knowledgeable than myself, (and the understanding is surely already attested in the LXX-Septuagint).

2 Corinthians 5:21 REV
21 He made him who did not know sin to be a sin offering on our behalf, so that in union with him we would become the righteousness of God.

If you click on the verse itself, which is of course at the end of the chapter at the bottom of the page link below, you will be taken to their lengthy commentary on 2Cor 5:21.


In other instances some translators also use this rendering of hamartia, (a sin-offering), but they are few:

YLT (Young's Literal Translation) - hamartia: Heb 9:10, Heb 10:6, Heb 10:8.
LSV (Literal Standard Version) - hamartia: Heb 9:10, Heb 10:6, Heb 10:8.
HRB2012 - hamartia: Heb 10:6
ABP (Apostolic Bible Polyglot (in italics)) - hamartia Heb 5:1, (plural, hamartiown), Heb 10:8.

G266 hamartia is not just sin in the Greek Septuagint translation of the Torah: it is employed in the same manner as the Hebrew word H2403 chatta'ah, which can be either sin, the penalty for sin, or the offering for sin, hence, a sin offering all in one word. What we therefore have is a situation where the Greek Classics are just not enough because the LXX is essentially taking Greek words and assigning Hebrew meanings to them in order to render the Hebrew text into the Greek language. The Greek word hamartia in this case, (as well as many other cases if not all), is nothing more than a Greek loan word for the Hebrew word chatta'ah, carrying all the same meanings of the Hebrew equivalent into the Greek. The following LXX-Septuagint text is one example out of many where G266 hamatria is employed in the exact same manner as the Hebrew word H2403 chatta'ah:

Exodus 29:36 OG LXX
[36] και το μοσχαριον της αμαρτιας ποιησεις τη ημερα του καθαρισμου και καθαριεις το θυσιαστηριον εν τω αγιαζειν σε επ αυτω και χρισεις αυτο ωστε αγιασαι αυτο
[36] And the calf of the sin offering you shall offer for a day, (daily) for an atonement (purification), and you shall purify the altar in your consecrating upon it, and you shall anoint it, so as to sanctify it.

Here we see that G4160 ποιέω, (poieo), is rendered as to offer, and the form is ποιησεις, you shall offer, so by the context herein it is meant in the sense of doing or performing an action or task, (offering a sacrifice), rather than making something.

και το μοσχαριον της αμαρτιας ποιησεις
And the calf of the sin offering you shall offer...
And you shall offer the calf of the sin offering...


In this example αμαρτια is not the sin, but the sin offering, and such examples abound throughout the Torah in the Greek Septuagint translation of the Hebrew text. Could it be that Paul is using hamartia in this same manner in 2 Cor 5:21? Could it be that by the second occurrence of hamartia in that verse he means a sin offering instead of sin, as is so often found in the Septuagint version of the Torah? Likewise we also find G4160 ποιέω adjacent to G266 αμαρτια in this passage.

2 Corinthians 5:21 T/R / BYZ
[21] τον γαρ μη γνοντα αμαρτιαν υπερ ημων αμαρτιαν εποιησεν ινα ημεις γινωμεθα δικαιοσυνη θεου εν αυτω

2 Corinthians 5:21
[21] For the one not knowing sin offered a sin-offering on our behalf, so that in him we might come to be of a godly (or divine) righteousness.

Yes, it could very well be a sin offering instead of sin in the second occurrence of hamartia which is adjacent to poieo, and in the above statement this is surely the preferable choice. We can of course discuss my reading of the end of the statement, (so that in him we might come to be of a godly (or divine) righteousness), but it will be a lengthy post, so I am forced to exclude it herein.

So then, is it therefore possible that Paul also does the same in other instances in his epistles?
Yes, it is possible, and he does.

Leviticus 6:25 OG LXX
25 (6:18) λαλησον ααρων και τοις υιοις αυτου λεγων ουτος ο νομος της αμαρτιας εν τοπω ου σφαζουσιν το ολοκαυτωμα σφαξουσιν τα περι της αμαρτιας εναντι κυριου αγια αγιων εστιν

Leviticus 6:25 OG LXX
25 Speak to Ahron and to his sons, saying, This is the nomos [torah] of the sin offering: in the place where they slay the whole-fire-offering [Hebrew text: ascending offering] they shall slay that concerning the sin offering before YHWH: it is most holy.

ουτος ο νομος της αμαρτιας
this is the nomos-torah of the sin offering

Thus we see that, indeed, hamartia may be employed for not only sin, but also for a sin offering in the Epistles of Paul: and he does indeed employ this meaning in more places than just 2Cor 5:21, and the most blatantly evident place may be found in his lengthy discourse on the bodily members.
.
 

CrowCross

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2026
1,959
585
113
Philly
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Does the sin offering become sin? Absolutely not
2 Cor 5:21 For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

You require biblical gymnastics to explain your contradictory beliefs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David1701

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
281
223
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
I'm sorry to hear that you think that God's word is baloney.

To what religion do you adhere?

Eph. 2:8,9 (W.E.B.)
8 for by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God,
9 not of works, that no one would boast.

1 John 5:13 These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you may continue to believe in the name of the Son of God.

As everyone can see, God's word states that those who have faith in Jesus Christ have been saved; and that we should know that we have eternal life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Judge Hardcastle

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
281
223
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
You are saying works don't justify. So the epistle of James is wrong?
Perhaps you don't realise that "justified" has more than one meaning. It can mean to be declared righteous; it can also mean to be shown to be righteous.

In the case of Abraham being justified by works, he was shown to be righteous.

Justification by faith, on the other hand, is to be declared righteous through faith in Jesus Christ, the Righteous One.
 

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
281
223
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
The false gospel makes grace to be something that takes away OUR responsibility for our actions. But the very opposite is true. Grace makes us even MORE responsible for what we do. To whom much is given MORE is required. (that last statement from someone called Jesus that almost no one knows or listens to anymore).
Do you know what a straw man argument is, because it's what you present, on a regular basis?

God's grace does not take away anyone's responsibility; and I have never seen anyone teach that it does.
 

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
281
223
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
Again, a superficial reading of the bible with a tremendously large ego and religious certainty can basically claim to be anything.
It's humble of you to admit it.

The bible exposes people. The bible interprets people. In the same way the law made religious hypocrites in Judaism...grace has made the same among modern believers.
God's grace changes people for the better. I recommend that you seek God for it, then you will find out.

God is indeed faithful. But those who are the Lord's are called chosen AND faithful.
Yes, and...?

This is denied in the propaganda based religion that encourages imagination.
Tilt away, Don Quixote!


God was IN Christ reconciling the world to Himself. You are misrepresenting the passion of Christ. Jesus suffered for our sins. He took on Himself our evil....the way a brave man endures torture. That's not what saves us. Jesus put up with our evil. But those who would be saved with Him must also endure the same suffering. The same death.
Those who believe in Jesus died in him, on the cross.

Only real Christianity accepts the selfless quality of Jesus and actually follows Him.
Yes.

The false religion is that Jesus paid the price for my sins so that I might sin without fear. Jesus dies for me so that I can throw away the fear of the Lord and replace that with a smug self-assurance that I have an immunity from prosecution for what I do...evil or not.
Tilting at a gallop now, are we?


If you take a child molester and let him get away with it, he will also appreciate the gesture. So the criminal will also show gratitude.
You should tell that to the numerous R.C. priests who have engaged in such wickedness, then have quietly been moved to a different location.

false. Trusting Jesus for salvation is a religious delusion.
If you think that trusting Jesus for salvation is a religious delusion, then you are clearly not a disciple of Jesus Christ. Repent and believe in Jesus Christ, so that you will be saved!


We can HOPE for salvation but faith is not in OUR condition....but in God's character of justice and fairness.
In the N.T., hope is steadfast confidence for the future, not wishful thinking; so, yes, believers in Jesus have hope (because of the cross and resurrection of the Lord); but, no-one else does.

You manipulate the verse to mean something that's not there. We are saved by God's power that makes us OBEY God just like Jesus did.
As I have posted, here and on other fora, on numerous occasions; however, our obedience is imperfect and marred by sin. You do believe in confessing your sins to God, don't you?


Entering into Christ is a real salvation...no more sin. Jesus came to save us FROM our sins....not Jesus came to save us IN our sins.
So, do you love the LORD your God, with all your heart, soul, mind and strength, perfectly, 24/7? If you don't (and I guarantee that you don't), then you sin sometimes, just like every Christian who has ever lived.


The opposite is true. You disobey the words of Jesus to make Him an idol that doesn't need to be obeyed.
Of course we need to obey the Lord, but not in order to merit salvation by our works; rather, we obey him because we love him and want to please him.


If you walk in a sinful Jesus then you are a reprobate. Read the bible. If we are found sinners while we claim to be redeemed from the world and its ways...is Christ then a minister of sin? Is He there to shield some sinners and not others based on a democratic process of acceptance through voting? and claiming?
Okay, Don, your tilting is becoming tiresome...

Assurance of salvation comes from religious indoctrination that ignores most of the verses in the bible to make up another gospel that champions self-interest.
1 John 5:13 (W.E.B.)
These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you may continue to believe in the name of the Son of God.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,609
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
2 Cor 5:21 For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

You require biblical gymnastics to explain your contradictory beliefs.

There were no gymnastics involved. The sin offering does not become sin, it is most holy, and to be consumed by the Kohanim: (Priests), and the offering is the Testimony of the Meshiah which was not even his own, but the Word of the Father spoken through the Meshiah.

Moreover we do not "become the righteousness" of YHWH Elohim. He is our righteousness by way of His Spirit which He bestows upon us through His Word, His Son: it is your own belief system that is contradictory to the scripture for lack of Torah study, and that is no doubt because you have been taught by false doctrines of men, twisting the words of Paul, and teaching you that Paul did away with the Torah for you.