Spiritual Israelite
Well-Known Member
I wasn't suggesting that. The angel doesn't speak again until verse 23. I've been clear all along about what I'm saying and what I'm asking you to show me. Daniel saw multiple visions that are recorded in Daniel 7:1-14. I would hope I don't have to convince you of that. Then it says this...If you are suggesting that verse 22 is the angel interpreting something, then you too are mistaken like I initially was myself. The angel is not the speaker in verse 22, Daniel is.
Daniel 7:15 “I, Daniel, was grieved in my spirit within my body, and the visions of my head troubled me. 16 I came near to one of those who stood by, and asked him the truth of all this. So he told me and made known to me the interpretation of these things: 17 ‘Those great beasts, which are four, are four kings which arise out of the earth. 18 But the saints of the Most High shall receive the kingdom, and possess the kingdom forever, even forever and ever.’
So, Daniel didn't know what the visions he saw meant and asked the angel to tell him the interpretation of them. That would include the vision he saw in verses 13 and 14. So, the angel started interpreting them for him. Then, as you pointed out, Daniel interrupted him and that is recorded in verses 19 to 22. Then the angel started giving his interpretation again starting in verse 23.
So, what I'm asking you is very simple. Where did the angel give the interpretation of verses 13 and 14? With Jesus being given "dominion and glory and a kingdom" at His ascension, which lines up with what Paul wrote in Ephesians 1:19-23, and with the fact that His followers are "a royal priesthood" in His kingdom right now, tell me why verse 18 could not apply to the time when Jesus received the kingdom? And why couldn't verse 22, which is very similar to verse 18, also relate to when Jesus received the kingdom upon His ascension?
That's a possibility. In that case the first sentence would seem to relate to verses 1 to 12 and the second sentence would relate to verses 13 and 14.The logic would then be this.
Daniel asks one of them for the truth of all he saw(verse 16). The angel gives a high level summary of the entire vision in just two sentences: four kings arise out of the earth(verse 17), and the saints of the Most high take and possess the kingdom forever(verse 18).
Yes, but that doesn't mean that the angel would have been obligated to only speak about that alone with his response. He could have still expanded on verses 13 and 14 as well since Daniel's original request was to have his visions (all of them) explained to him. It's even possible that the angel was planning to go into more detail before Daniel interrupted him, so he just continued saying what he was already planning to say even before Daniel interrupted him.Unsatisfied with the brief overview, Daniel asks specifically about the fourth beast, ten horns, and little horn(verses 19-20).
That's your opinion, but what is your understanding of verse 18, keeping in mind that the angel was going to give an interpretation of all the visions Daniel had, including the one recorded in verses 13 and 14? Do you acknowledge that verse 18 relates directly to verses 13 and 14? If so, why wouldn't verse 22, which is very similar to verse 18, not also relate to verses 13 and 14?In verses 21-22, Daniel recounts the events he witnessed in his earlier vision (verses 7-11) to frame his question--citing the little horn's war against the saints(verse 21) and the intervention of the Ancient of days leading to the saints possessing the kingdom(verse 22). Daniel is summarizing his own vision(compressing verses. 9-11), not relaying a new angelic interpretation.
Wait a minute here. Verses 9 to 11 aren't part of the angel's interpretation of the vision in verses 13 and 14. You're continuing to not address where you think the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14. Do you think the angel didn't say anything about that vision at all?So where then does verse 13-14 fit into the scheme of things? Those verses explain how the Son of man went from a lowly servant to that of the one sitting on the throne in verses 9-11. We know a lot of this from the NT which was hidden in Daniel 7 until revealed in the NT.
I have thought these things through for many years. Are we supposed to never come to any conclusions about anything? Just have to have only theories are whole lives while not fully committing to anything? That's silly. I don't have it "all mapped out", but I have most of it mapped out, at least in a general sense (no one can map out all of the details) only because of many years or studying these things.In your mind, apparently, your theology is all mapped out. Nothing else to think through.
Nope. I didn't say that. But, I am 100% convinced that amillennialism is true. I can't be convinced otherwise at this point. And I certainly don't find your arguments to be convincing at all. You make arguments that come from some of those most difficult passages in all of scripture that are highly debated. If you want to convince me that Premil is true, then show me clear, straightforward scripture that shows it. My Amil view is based on clear, straightforward scriptures which teach that Jesus has been reigning since His resurrection (Matt 28:18, Eph 1:19-23, Rev 1:5-6), that believers have been His priests since then (1 Peter 2:5,9; Revelation 1:5-6), that all unbelievers will be killed when Jesus returns (Matt 24:35-39, Luke 17:26-37, 1 Thess 5:2-3, 2 Thess 1:7-8, 2 Peter 3:10-12, Rev 19:17-18), that there will be one general resurrection event of all of the dead, saved and lost (Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29, Acts 24:15), and that all people will be judged at the same time (Acts 17:30-31, Matt 13:40-43, Matt 13:47-50, Matt 25:31-46). You have no such straightforward scriptures to support your Premil view.And that's what you argue from, your already mapped out theology. As if there are no more answers to pursue, that you have found all of the answers already.
What kind of question is that? We do have the NT and should use it to help us understand OT prophecies whenever possible.If it wasn't for the NT, how would you or any of us be interpreting verses 9-11 in the manner we do, that it involves a 2nd coming?
It's not what I want. It's what I see. I believe that Jesus was made King over His kingdom around the time of His resurrection and ascension because scripture teaches that. I believe His followers became priests ("a royal priesthood") in His kingdom at that time. So, that means the kingdom was given to the saints at that time. I'm using scripture to interpret scripture here.But you don't want verse 22 to involve a 2nd coming also.
So what?And it's plainly obvious as to why. Because you fully accept that verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium.
LOL. Why can't you admit that the saints were given the kingdom when Jesus was given the kingdom, which was long ago?But if you have verse 22 leading to verses 9-11 rather than verses 13-14 you have just admitted Premil and denied Amil.
God the Father is Spirit. It's not talking about Him literally going anywhere.Can you not see in verse 22 that it is the Ancient of days that comes? In verse 13, where do you see the Ancient of days coming to where?
Why would the Ancient of Days mean the Father in verse 13, but then mean Jesus in verse 22? Is that what you're trying to claim here?It is the Son of man that is coming from somewhere to somewhere else. And that the Ancient of days is meaning the Father in verse 13. And if the Ancient of days is meaning Jesus in verse 22, well it can't be meaning verses 13-14 then since the Father already has dibs on that title in verses 13-14.
You say things like this after saying things that make no sense. You are always convinced in your own mind, but I cant even understand what you're saying half the time.Therefore, no matter which way you go, verse 22 does not fit with verses 13-14.
Huh? It talks about the Son of Man, Jesus, coming to the Father in verse 13. I don't know where you come up with this stuff.Because then you have to explain where the Father is coming to in verse 13.
I'm not saying that. You are impossible to follow. I have no idea what you're trying to say.Or that you have to explain how the Ancient of days is meaning Jesus in verse 22 if the Ancient of days is meaning the Father in verse 13.
I sure do not know it. I don't even know what you're saying here at all. I can only take so much of this, so I'm not going to read the rest of your post for the sake of my sanity. I will just say one more thing. After all of my attempts to get you to tell me where the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14 you have still not answered that question. That's quite telling.There are no conflicts like this if verse 22 pertains to verses 9-11 instead. And surely you know it.