Daniel 7 can't support Amil's Timeline Pertaining to Rev 6:9-11, Rev 20:4

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If you are suggesting that verse 22 is the angel interpreting something, then you too are mistaken like I initially was myself. The angel is not the speaker in verse 22, Daniel is.
I wasn't suggesting that. The angel doesn't speak again until verse 23. I've been clear all along about what I'm saying and what I'm asking you to show me. Daniel saw multiple visions that are recorded in Daniel 7:1-14. I would hope I don't have to convince you of that. Then it says this...

Daniel 7:15 “I, Daniel, was grieved in my spirit within my body, and the visions of my head troubled me. 16 I came near to one of those who stood by, and asked him the truth of all this. So he told me and made known to me the interpretation of these things: 17 ‘Those great beasts, which are four, are four kings which arise out of the earth. 18 But the saints of the Most High shall receive the kingdom, and possess the kingdom forever, even forever and ever.’

So, Daniel didn't know what the visions he saw meant and asked the angel to tell him the interpretation of them. That would include the vision he saw in verses 13 and 14. So, the angel started interpreting them for him. Then, as you pointed out, Daniel interrupted him and that is recorded in verses 19 to 22. Then the angel started giving his interpretation again starting in verse 23.

So, what I'm asking you is very simple. Where did the angel give the interpretation of verses 13 and 14? With Jesus being given "dominion and glory and a kingdom" at His ascension, which lines up with what Paul wrote in Ephesians 1:19-23, and with the fact that His followers are "a royal priesthood" in His kingdom right now, tell me why verse 18 could not apply to the time when Jesus received the kingdom? And why couldn't verse 22, which is very similar to verse 18, also relate to when Jesus received the kingdom upon His ascension?



The logic would then be this.

Daniel asks one of them for the truth of all he saw(verse 16). The angel gives a high level summary of the entire vision in just two sentences: four kings arise out of the earth(verse 17), and the saints of the Most high take and possess the kingdom forever(verse 18).
That's a possibility. In that case the first sentence would seem to relate to verses 1 to 12 and the second sentence would relate to verses 13 and 14.

Unsatisfied with the brief overview, Daniel asks specifically about the fourth beast, ten horns, and little horn(verses 19-20).
Yes, but that doesn't mean that the angel would have been obligated to only speak about that alone with his response. He could have still expanded on verses 13 and 14 as well since Daniel's original request was to have his visions (all of them) explained to him. It's even possible that the angel was planning to go into more detail before Daniel interrupted him, so he just continued saying what he was already planning to say even before Daniel interrupted him.

In verses 21-22, Daniel recounts the events he witnessed in his earlier vision (verses 7-11) to frame his question--citing the little horn's war against the saints(verse 21) and the intervention of the Ancient of days leading to the saints possessing the kingdom(verse 22). Daniel is summarizing his own vision(compressing verses. 9-11), not relaying a new angelic interpretation.
That's your opinion, but what is your understanding of verse 18, keeping in mind that the angel was going to give an interpretation of all the visions Daniel had, including the one recorded in verses 13 and 14? Do you acknowledge that verse 18 relates directly to verses 13 and 14? If so, why wouldn't verse 22, which is very similar to verse 18, not also relate to verses 13 and 14?

So where then does verse 13-14 fit into the scheme of things? Those verses explain how the Son of man went from a lowly servant to that of the one sitting on the throne in verses 9-11. We know a lot of this from the NT which was hidden in Daniel 7 until revealed in the NT.
Wait a minute here. Verses 9 to 11 aren't part of the angel's interpretation of the vision in verses 13 and 14. You're continuing to not address where you think the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14. Do you think the angel didn't say anything about that vision at all?

In your mind, apparently, your theology is all mapped out. Nothing else to think through.
I have thought these things through for many years. Are we supposed to never come to any conclusions about anything? Just have to have only theories are whole lives while not fully committing to anything? That's silly. I don't have it "all mapped out", but I have most of it mapped out, at least in a general sense (no one can map out all of the details) only because of many years or studying these things.

And that's what you argue from, your already mapped out theology. As if there are no more answers to pursue, that you have found all of the answers already.
Nope. I didn't say that. But, I am 100% convinced that amillennialism is true. I can't be convinced otherwise at this point. And I certainly don't find your arguments to be convincing at all. You make arguments that come from some of those most difficult passages in all of scripture that are highly debated. If you want to convince me that Premil is true, then show me clear, straightforward scripture that shows it. My Amil view is based on clear, straightforward scriptures which teach that Jesus has been reigning since His resurrection (Matt 28:18, Eph 1:19-23, Rev 1:5-6), that believers have been His priests since then (1 Peter 2:5,9; Revelation 1:5-6), that all unbelievers will be killed when Jesus returns (Matt 24:35-39, Luke 17:26-37, 1 Thess 5:2-3, 2 Thess 1:7-8, 2 Peter 3:10-12, Rev 19:17-18), that there will be one general resurrection event of all of the dead, saved and lost (Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29, Acts 24:15), and that all people will be judged at the same time (Acts 17:30-31, Matt 13:40-43, Matt 13:47-50, Matt 25:31-46). You have no such straightforward scriptures to support your Premil view.

If it wasn't for the NT, how would you or any of us be interpreting verses 9-11 in the manner we do, that it involves a 2nd coming?
What kind of question is that? We do have the NT and should use it to help us understand OT prophecies whenever possible.

But you don't want verse 22 to involve a 2nd coming also.
It's not what I want. It's what I see. I believe that Jesus was made King over His kingdom around the time of His resurrection and ascension because scripture teaches that. I believe His followers became priests ("a royal priesthood") in His kingdom at that time. So, that means the kingdom was given to the saints at that time. I'm using scripture to interpret scripture here.

And it's plainly obvious as to why. Because you fully accept that verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium.
So what?

But if you have verse 22 leading to verses 9-11 rather than verses 13-14 you have just admitted Premil and denied Amil.
LOL. Why can't you admit that the saints were given the kingdom when Jesus was given the kingdom, which was long ago?

Can you not see in verse 22 that it is the Ancient of days that comes? In verse 13, where do you see the Ancient of days coming to where?
God the Father is Spirit. It's not talking about Him literally going anywhere.

It is the Son of man that is coming from somewhere to somewhere else. And that the Ancient of days is meaning the Father in verse 13. And if the Ancient of days is meaning Jesus in verse 22, well it can't be meaning verses 13-14 then since the Father already has dibs on that title in verses 13-14.
Why would the Ancient of Days mean the Father in verse 13, but then mean Jesus in verse 22? Is that what you're trying to claim here?

Therefore, no matter which way you go, verse 22 does not fit with verses 13-14.
You say things like this after saying things that make no sense. You are always convinced in your own mind, but I cant even understand what you're saying half the time.

Because then you have to explain where the Father is coming to in verse 13.
Huh? It talks about the Son of Man, Jesus, coming to the Father in verse 13. I don't know where you come up with this stuff.

Or that you have to explain how the Ancient of days is meaning Jesus in verse 22 if the Ancient of days is meaning the Father in verse 13.
I'm not saying that. You are impossible to follow. I have no idea what you're trying to say.

There are no conflicts like this if verse 22 pertains to verses 9-11 instead. And surely you know it.
I sure do not know it. I don't even know what you're saying here at all. I can only take so much of this, so I'm not going to read the rest of your post for the sake of my sanity. I will just say one more thing. After all of my attempts to get you to tell me where the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14 you have still not answered that question. That's quite telling.
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Here is the simplest way to settle Daniel 7 without all the rabbit trails.

Verse 22 is explicitly about an intervention that puts an end to the little horn's war against the saints in verse 21(made war with the saints, and prevailed against them; until the Ancient of days came, and judgment was given to the saints).


Now look at the two passages in Daniel's vision and ask which one actually shows that intervention.


Verses 9-11 the little horn is speaking great things(verse 8)---the Ancient of days takes His judicial seat and the court sits in judgment(verses 9-10) The beast is then slain and given to the burning flame(verse 11). That is the intervention that stops the war.

Verses 13-14 there is no little horn, no war against the saints, no courtroom verdict, and no beast destroyed. It is a royal coronation in heaven where the Son of man comes to the Ancient of days to receive dominion and a kingdom.

Notice the irony in verse 22 too---the text intentionally says the Ancient of days came---even though the Son executes that judgment at His return---specifically so no one would confuse it with the Son of man came in verse 13.

So here is the bottom line---verses 13-14 are the coronation, while verses 9-11 are the intervention. Because verse 22 describes the intervention that stops verse 21's war, it belongs with verses 9-11 at the 2nd coming---never back at the ascension in verses 13-14 instead.

Let's also run a simple mirror test on how doctrinal bias works---especially since it has already been pointed out in Post #317 how Pretribbers disconnect parallel passages to protect their timeline.


Right now, we have two Amil camps on Daniel 7.

Group A (Non-mainstream Amils)---Admits verses 9–11 involve the 2nd coming, and admits verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium---but refuses to admit that verse 22 connects to verses 9-11 when verse 22 is initially meaning.

Group B (Mainstream Amils)---Admits verses 9-11 involve the 2nd coming, and admits verse 22 connects to verses 9-11 when verse 22 is initially meaning--but refuses to admit that verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium.

Now flip the labels. Suppose Group A and Group B were two camps of Pretribbers arguing over a Pretrib vs. Posttrib timeline. Suppose both camps admitted two out of three plain textual links, while each camp conveniently denied the one remaining link that would prove Posttrib if they conceded it.

Would any Amil here tell us with a straight face that neither Pretrib camp was being driven by doctrinal bias---or that one camp was totally objective while the other wasn't? Of course not. You would immediately call out both camps for protecting their system over the text.

Both Group A and Group B cannot be right---yet both mysteriously draw the line at the exact single admission that proves Premil. That isn't objective exegesis anymore than any Amil in here would claim that it = objective exegesis if 2 Pretrib camps were doing it in the exact same manner.

BTW, posts like this are for objective readers not any Amils in this thread. They don't know what 'objective' means. And my A) vs B) comparisons, for one, prove it. If 2 Pretrib camps were doing that in the same manner, not one Amil would then say doctrinal bias has nothing to do with it. Or that one of the camps is being objective the other isn't. But when Amils do it, where are there then any Amils crying foul, that both camps are being doctrinally biased? There you go then. Amils never seem to play fair--ever.
 
Last edited:

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Here is the simplest way to settle Daniel 7 without all the rabbit trails.

Verse 22 is explicitly about an intervention that puts an end to the little horn's war against the saints in verse 21(made war with the saints, and prevailed against them; until the Ancient of days came, and judgment was given to the saints).


Now look at the two passages in Daniel's vision and ask which one actually shows that intervention.


Verses 9-11 the little horn is speaking great things(verse 8)---the Ancient of days takes His judicial seat and the court sits in judgment(verses 9-10) The beast is then slain and given to the burning flame(verse 11). That is the intervention that stops the war.

Verses 13-14 there is no little horn, no war against the saints, no courtroom verdict, and no beast destroyed. It is a royal coronation in heaven where the Son of man comes to the Ancient of days to receive dominion and a kingdom.

Notice the irony in verse 22 too---the text intentionally says the Ancient of days came---even though the Son executes that judgment at His return---specifically so no one would confuse it with the Son of man came in verse 13.

So here is the bottom line---verses 13-14 are the coronation, while verses 9-11 are the intervention. Because verse 22 describes the intervention that stops verse 21's war, it belongs with verses 9-11 at the 2nd coming---never back at the ascension in verses 13-14 instead.

Let's also run a simple mirror test on how doctrinal bias works---especially since it has already been pointed out in Post #317 how Pretribbers disconnect parallel passages to protect their timeline.


Right now, we have two Amil camps on Daniel 7.

Group A (Non-mainstream Amils)---Admits verses 9–11 involve the 2nd coming, and admits verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium---but refuses to admit that verse 22 connects to verses 9-11 when verse 22 is initially meaning.

Group B (Mainstream Amils)---Admits verses 9-11 involve the 2nd coming, and admits verse 22 connects to verses 9-11 when verse 22 is initially meaning--but refuses to admit that verse 22 leads to the beginning of the millennium.

Now flip the labels. Suppose Group A and Group B were two camps of Pretribbers arguing over a Pretrib vs. Posttrib timeline. Suppose both camps admitted two out of three plain textual links, while each camp conveniently denied the one remaining link that would prove Posttrib if they conceded it.

Would any Amil here tell us with a straight face that neither Pretrib camp was being driven by doctrinal bias---or that one camp was totally objective while the other wasn't? Of course not. You would immediately call out both camps for protecting their system over the text.

Both Group A and Group B cannot be right---yet both mysteriously draw the line at the exact single admission that proves Premil. That isn't objective exegesis anymore than any Amil in here would claim that it = objective exegesis if 2 Pretrib camps were doing it in the exact same manner.

BTW, posts like this are for objective readers not any Amils in this thread. They don't know what 'objective' means.
How are you being objective when you won't even answer my question about where the angel gave his interpretation of verses 13 and 14? Do you think the following 2 verses are directly related?

Daniel 7:18 But the saints of the Most High shall receive the kingdom, and possess the kingdom forever, even forever and ever.’

Daniel 7:22 until the Ancient of Days came, and a judgment was made in favor of the saints of the Most High, and the time came for the saints to possess the kingdom.

It seems clear that these two verses are directly related, so what is your understanding of Daniel 7:18 in terms of the timing of its fulfillment?
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
How are you being objective when you won't even answer my question about where the angel gave his interpretation of verses 13 and 14? Do you think the following 2 verses are directly related?

Daniel 7:18 But the saints of the Most High shall receive the kingdom, and possess the kingdom forever, even forever and ever.’

Daniel 7:22 until the Ancient of Days came, and a judgment was made in favor of the saints of the Most High, and the time came for the saints to possess the kingdom.

It seems clear that these two verses are directly related, so what is your understanding of Daniel 7:18 in terms of the timing of its fulfillment?

Notice you skipped every single point in Post #322---both the coronation(verses 13-14) vs. intervention(verses 9-11) comparison and the Pretrib mirror test---and pivoted to Daniel 7:18.


To answer your question directly---yes, Daniel 7:18, 7:22, and 7:27 are all describing the exact same event---the saints taking and possessing the kingdom. And there are three clear reasons why verse 18 happens at the 2nd coming----not 2,000 years ago.

1. Verse 22 gives the exact timestamp. Verse 18 states the promise(shall take the kingdom, and possess the kingdom for ever), while verse 22 tells us when that time arrives---until the Ancient of days came, and judgment was given to the saints of the most High; and the time came that the saints possessed the kingdom. Verse 27 confirms this handover happens after the court sits and strips away the little horn's dominion(verse 26).

2. Your own NOSAS doctrine refutes a church age fulfillment. Verse 18 states unconditionally that the saints shall possess the kingdom "for ever, even for ever and ever." It does not say some saints possess it temporarily and fall away while others keep it. Since both you and I agree believers can fall away during the church age(NOSAS), verse 18 cannot be fulfilled until the 2nd coming(verse 22), when the saints are glorified, resurrected, and sealed in immortality so they can never fall away(Rev. 20:6).

3. Matthew 25:34 & 1 Corinthians 15:50 put the inheritance at the 2nd coming. You already cited Matthew 25:31-46 in Post #321 as a future 2nd coming event. Look at Matthew 25:34---when the Son of Man comes in His glory(verse 31), the King says to the righteous---Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world. That is Daniel 7:18 word for word and 1 Corinthians 15:50-53 explains why it waits until Christ's return--flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. You cannot inherit and possess the kingdom 2,000 years before the King returns to grant it.

So linking verse 18 to verse 22 doesn't move verse 22 back to the ascension---it anchors verse 18 squarely at the 2nd coming.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Notice you skipped every single point in Post #322---both the coronation(verses 13-14) vs. intervention(verses 9-11) comparison and the Pretrib mirror test---and pivoted to Daniel 7:18.
Notice that you don't answer the question I've asked you multiple times of where the angel interpreted verses 13 and 14. You expect me to address every point you make while you ignore my question repeatedly. How about answering my question, which I asked first?

To answer your question directly---yes, Daniel 7:18, 7:22, and 7:27 are all describing the exact same event---the saints taking and possessing the kingdom. And there are three clear reasons why verse 18 happens at the 2nd coming----not 2,000 years ago.
So, does this mean your answer to the question I've asked you repeatedly that you think the angel did not interpret Daniel's vision of verses 13 and 14 at all?

1. Verse 22 gives the exact timestamp. Verse 18 states the promise(shall take the kingdom, and possess the kingdom for ever), while verse 22 tells us when that time arrives---until the Ancient of days came, and judgment was given to the saints of the most High; and the time came that the saints possessed the kingdom. Verse 27 confirms this handover happens after the court sits and strips away the little horn's dominion(verse 26).
So, you don't think the kingdom was given to the saints when it was given to Christ at His ascension when they were made a royal priesthood? You expect me to believe that verse 16 says the angel would tell Daniel the meaning of his visions, but somehow forgot to say anything about the vision in verses 13 and 14?

2. Your own NOSAS doctrine refutes a church age fulfillment.
Here we go again with bringing OSAS vs. NOSAS into the discussion as if it has any relevance, which it doesn't. Unbelievable.

Verse 18 states unconditionally that the saints shall possess the kingdom "for ever, even for ever and ever."
Other scripture is clear that it is conditional upon their continued faith, so you are proving nothing here. You always think you can prove something with one verse.

It does not say some saints possess it temporarily and fall away while others keep it.
It's not an exposition on how salvation works for crying out loud. There are other scriptures that go into more detail about that. If we took John 3:16 at face value we would conclude that anyone who believes in Jesus at any point will have eternal life, but you and I don't believe that is the case for those who do not continue believing until death. You can't prove things like this with just one verse. That's what cults try to do.

3. Matthew 25:34 & 1 Corinthians 15:50 put the inheritance at the 2nd coming.
There is an already, but not yet quality to the kingdom, so it can sometimes be difficult to discern whether scripture is referring to the kingdom of God as it is now or as it will be in the future. Do you deny being in the kingdom of Christ right now as part of His royal priesthood?

You already cited Matthew 25:31-46 in Post #321 as a future 2nd coming event. Look at Matthew 25:34---when the Son of Man comes in His glory(verse 31), the King says to the righteous---Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world. That is Daniel 7:18 word for word and 1 Corinthians 15:50-53 explains why it waits until Christ's return--flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. You cannot inherit and possess the kingdom 2,000 years before the King returns to grant it.
Since you brought these scriptures up, let's discuss the fact that you have people with mortal flesh and blood inheriting a supposed earthly kingdom when Jesus returns. That contradicts both Matthew 25:31-46 and 1 Corinthians 15:50-54 which say that only immortals will inherit the kingdom when Jesus comes and they will inherit eternal life at that time. You can't reconcile that with your belief that mortals will be allowed to be in Christ's supposed earthly kingdom.
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,171
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
IMO, I think a straight line works better. It has no end in either direction. But somewhere on this line there is the beginning of things and there is the end of things. Humans can only move foward on this line, even in the eternal state. God is the only one that can move both directions.

On this line once man is formed, it is then divided into 1000 literal year segments, and that it follows the pattern 1-7. But look where Amil has the 7. Not at at the end of these things, but paralleling 5 and 6. Surely, this segment of the line doesn't end with 6, thus 6k years. It ends with 7, thus 7k years. Who ever heard of a 7 day week that has day 7 paralleling day 5 and 6 , thus not even ending with a 7th day of the week?

The 8th day following a full week is always 8 days later. Amils' timeline even contradicts that. Their timeline only has 6 days of the week on it, then on the 7th day they have that meaning the 8th day because the 5th and 6th day already has dibs on the 7th day.

If we put the Amil Timeline on a calendar as an analogy it might look like this.

Sunday--1st 1K years of human history

Monday--2nd 1K years of human history

Tuesday--3rd 1K years of human history

Wednesday--4th 1K years of human history

Thursday--5th 1K years of human history(the 7th 1k of human history paralleling this--thus the 1st 1K years of the NT church era)

Friday--6th 1K years of human history(the 7th 1k of human history paralleling this--thus the 2nd 1K years of the NT church era)

Saturday--the 8th day, a new beginning, thus 1 Cor 15:28 instead of the 7th day, since Thursday and Friday already have dibs on the 7th day.

What calendar since the beginning of time only has a 6 day week, and on the 7th day of the week it is the 8th day, and that the 7th day of the week parallels the 5th and 6th day of the week?

Timelines are Amils' worst enemies. None of them have a Timeline that contradicts nothing. Even their Daniel 7 Timeline contradicts some of Daniel 7. It certainly doesn't agree with it throughout
I probably should’ve been clearer in my post, humans definitely think of time in a linear fashion and a linear timeline makes the most sense. I’m certainly not trying to say we can time travel, other than going forward in time.

My thoughts were that when John had his visions, those visions did involve time travel to different points in time, even though physically John most likely remained on Patmos in the first century. The visions themselves don’t fit into a neat linear timeline.

For example in Revelation 4:1 John is told “I will show thee things which must be hereafter”. Then in Revelation 5:3-4 none (no man in KJV) is found worthy to open the book. (No man <3762> means none whatsoever, not just mankind). Clearly none being found worthy to open the book could only take place before the cross on a linear timeline yet Revelation 4:1 said it was things that must take place hereafter.

A circular timeline might help explain some of the anomalies in the visions that we tend to gloss over.



As far as looking at a 7,000-year timeline, I’m not opposed to that, but one thing I’ve thought about is where on the timeline does the new heaven new earth get created?
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As far as looking at a 7,000-year timeline, I’m not opposed to that, but one thing I’ve thought about is where on the timeline does the new heaven new earth get created?

If it's a process like I tend to think, where it is not in it's completed final form until after the GWTJ, it fits at the beginning of the millennium. At the beginning of whose proposed millennium? Mine, yours, Amils'? The latter is out of the question. But it might work for your view, I don't know, but if it does, obviously it doesn't mean in the same manner.

But since most Premils disagree and that Amils obviously disagree, I then posed the following for an LLM to look into and report it's findings

Me:

Are there any views from the past that argue the NHNE begin with the millennium? That's basically my view but did anyone in the past hold a view like that as well?
---------------------

This LLM:
Yes—your view has clear historical roots across both ancient and modern premillennial interpreters, primarily anchored in Isaiah 65:17–25 and Isaiah 66:22–23, where God explicitly calls the millennial era "new heavens and a new earth" even though mortal lifespans, childbirth, and occasional death still exist during it.

While most modern dispensationalists place the New Heavens and New Earth (NHNE) strictly after the Millennium (at Revelation 21:1), several notable historical figures and theological traditions have argued that the New Heavens and New Earth begin with the Millennium (often viewed in two phases: an initial renovation at Christ's return, followed by final perfection after the Great White Throne Judgment):

1. Early Church Fathers (2nd–4th Centuries)

Irenaeus of Lyons (Against Heresies, Book 5, ch. 35–36, c. 180 AD): One of the earliest Christian theologians to systematize premillennialism. Irenaeus explicitly linked Isaiah 65:17–25 ("For behold, I create new heavens and a new earth") directly to the earthly millennial kingdom of the righteous, arguing that creation is renovated at Christ's return so the righteous can reign on a renewed earth before the final consummation.

Tertullian (Against Marcion, Book 3, ch. 24, c. 208 AD) & Lactantius (Divine Institutes, Book 7, c. 310 AD): Both taught a renovated earthly creation inaugurating the 1,000-year Sabbath rest of the saints, blending Old Testament "new earth" imagery directly into the millennial reign before the final judgment.

2. Historic Premillennial & 19th-Century Expositors

George N. H. Peters (The Theocratic Kingdom, 1884): In his massive three-volume work on historic premillennialism, Peters argued extensively that the restitution of all things (Acts 3:21) and the New Heavens and New Earth of Isaiah 65 and 2 Peter 3 begin at the Second Coming—inaugurating the Millennium as the first stage of the renewed creation, which is then purged of the final rebellion at the end of the 1,000 years.

Henry Alford (The Greek Testament, 1849–1861) & J. A. Seiss (The Apocalypse, 1865): Several 19th-century historic premillennial commentators noted that 2 Peter 3:10–13 ties the fiery purging of the earth and the arrival of the "new heavens and a new earth" directly to the Day of the Lord (Christ's return), leading them to view the Millennium as the opening phase of the renewed earth rather than a separate era prior to any cosmic renewal.

3. The Two-Stage / Progressive NHNE View in Modern Scholarship

• Many modern historic premillennialists and biblical theologians (such as Wayne Grudem, Albert Mohler, and Craig Blomberg, along with various Reformed/Historic Premil expositors) resolve the tension between Isaiah 65:17–20 (which calls the Millennium "new heavens and a new earth" while death still occurs at age 100) and Revelation 21:1–4 (where death is completely abolished) by viewing the NHNE as inaugurated at the Millennium and consummated after the Great White Throne:

• Stage 1 (At Christ's Return / Millennium — Isa. 65:17; 2 Pet. 3:13): Creation is renovated and freed from the curse's bondage (Rom. 8:19–21) as Christ reigns over surviving mortal nations.

• Stage 2 (After the Little Season & Great White Throne — Rev. 21:1–4): The last vestiges of sin, rebellion, and death are permanently cast into the lake of fire, bringing the New Heavens and New Earth into its final, eternal state.
 

grafted branch

Well-Known Member
Dec 11, 2023
2,171
374
83
49
Arizona
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If it's a process like I tend to think, where it is not in it's completed final form until after the GWTJ, it fits at the beginning of the millennium. At the beginning of whose proposed millennium? Mine, yours, Amils'? The latter is out of the question. But it might work for your view, I don't know, but if it does, obviously it doesn't mean in the same manner.

But since most Premils disagree and that Amils obviously disagree, I then posed the following for an LLM to look into and report it's findings

Me:

Are there any views from the past that argue the NHNE begin with the millennium? That's basically my view but did anyone in the past hold a view like that as well?
---------------------

This LLM:
Yes—your view has clear historical roots across both ancient and modern premillennial interpreters, primarily anchored in Isaiah 65:17–25 and Isaiah 66:22–23, where God explicitly calls the millennial era "new heavens and a new earth" even though mortal lifespans, childbirth, and occasional death still exist during it.

While most modern dispensationalists place the New Heavens and New Earth (NHNE) strictly after the Millennium (at Revelation 21:1), several notable historical figures and theological traditions have argued that the New Heavens and New Earth begin with the Millennium (often viewed in two phases: an initial renovation at Christ's return, followed by final perfection after the Great White Throne Judgment):

1. Early Church Fathers (2nd–4th Centuries)

Irenaeus of Lyons (Against Heresies, Book 5, ch. 35–36, c. 180 AD): One of the earliest Christian theologians to systematize premillennialism. Irenaeus explicitly linked Isaiah 65:17–25 ("For behold, I create new heavens and a new earth") directly to the earthly millennial kingdom of the righteous, arguing that creation is renovated at Christ's return so the righteous can reign on a renewed earth before the final consummation.

Tertullian (Against Marcion, Book 3, ch. 24, c. 208 AD) & Lactantius (Divine Institutes, Book 7, c. 310 AD): Both taught a renovated earthly creation inaugurating the 1,000-year Sabbath rest of the saints, blending Old Testament "new earth" imagery directly into the millennial reign before the final judgment.

2. Historic Premillennial & 19th-Century Expositors

George N. H. Peters (The Theocratic Kingdom, 1884): In his massive three-volume work on historic premillennialism, Peters argued extensively that the restitution of all things (Acts 3:21) and the New Heavens and New Earth of Isaiah 65 and 2 Peter 3 begin at the Second Coming—inaugurating the Millennium as the first stage of the renewed creation, which is then purged of the final rebellion at the end of the 1,000 years.

Henry Alford (The Greek Testament, 1849–1861) & J. A. Seiss (The Apocalypse, 1865): Several 19th-century historic premillennial commentators noted that 2 Peter 3:10–13 ties the fiery purging of the earth and the arrival of the "new heavens and a new earth" directly to the Day of the Lord (Christ's return), leading them to view the Millennium as the opening phase of the renewed earth rather than a separate era prior to any cosmic renewal.

3. The Two-Stage / Progressive NHNE View in Modern Scholarship

• Many modern historic premillennialists and biblical theologians (such as Wayne Grudem, Albert Mohler, and Craig Blomberg, along with various Reformed/Historic Premil expositors) resolve the tension between Isaiah 65:17–20 (which calls the Millennium "new heavens and a new earth" while death still occurs at age 100) and Revelation 21:1–4 (where death is completely abolished) by viewing the NHNE as inaugurated at the Millennium and consummated after the Great White Throne:

• Stage 1 (At Christ's Return / Millennium — Isa. 65:17; 2 Pet. 3:13): Creation is renovated and freed from the curse's bondage (Rom. 8:19–21) as Christ reigns over surviving mortal nations.

• Stage 2 (After the Little Season & Great White Throne — Rev. 21:1–4): The last vestiges of sin, rebellion, and death are permanently cast into the lake of fire, bringing the New Heavens and New Earth into its final, eternal state.
The process of creating the heavens and earth in Genesis took seven days (six days of work and a day of rest). You have the millennium taking place in the 7,000th year of human history and the creation of the new heaven new earth also taking during that time span, which correlates to the sabbath day of rest.

I see how the LLM gives an explanation for how we can derive that view from the Bible but it didn’t give an explanation for why the creation of NHNE would take place on a sabbath. Do you see a reason for the NHNE being created on a sabbath?
 

Davidpt

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2023
3,153
980
113
68
East Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The process of creating the heavens and earth in Genesis took seven days (six days of work and a day of rest). You have the millennium taking place in the 7,000th year of human history and the creation of the new heaven new earth also taking during that time span, which correlates to the sabbath day of rest.

I see how the LLM gives an explanation for how we can derive that view from the Bible but it didn’t give an explanation for why the creation of NHNE would take place on a sabbath. Do you see a reason for the NHNE being created on a sabbath?

This same LLM:

In post #328, the user grafted branch asks why the creation of the New Heavens and New Earth (NHNE) would take place during the Millennium—which corresponds to the seventh "day" (or 7,000th year) of human history—when the Sabbath is meant to be a day of rest rather than a day of creative work.

In Christian theology and biblical typology, there are a few key reasons why interpreters who hold to a 7,000-year "cosmic week" view see no contradiction between the Sabbath rest and the inauguration of the New Heavens and New Earth:

1. Renovation vs. Ex Nihilo Creation

• Restoring existing creation: In Genesis 1, God created the universe from nothing (ex nihilo) over six days and rested on the seventh. In this view, the Millennium is not a brand-new ex nihilo creation, but rather the redemption and restoration of the existing earth (Romans 8:19–21; Acts 3:21).

• Sabbath healing: Throughout the Gospels, Jesus repeatedly performed acts of healing and restoration on the Sabbath, explicitly arguing that restoring what is broken is the true purpose of the Sabbath (e.g., Luke 13:10–17; John 5:16–17). Therefore, lifting the curse from the earth at the start of the 7th millennium is seen as an act of Sabbath restoration rather than six-day "labor."

2. The Jubilee and Sabbath-Year Typology

• Levitical rest for the land: Under the Mosaic Law, the Sabbath wasn't just about humans stopping work; it was about giving the land itself rest and returning property to its rightful state every seventh year and every fiftieth year (the Year of Jubilee in Leviticus 25).

• Creation entering its rest: During the first 6,000 years of human history, creation is described as "groaning" under the bondage of corruption (Romans 8:22). Inaugurating the New Heavens and New Earth at the start of the 7th millennium is the exact moment the earth finally enters its promised Sabbath rest from the curse.

3. The "Work" Happens Before the Seventh Day Begins

• Judgment precedes the rest: In the two-stage NHNE model mentioned in post #327, the fiery purging and judgment that clears away the old corrupt order (2 Peter 3:10–13; Revelation 19) takes place at the end of the 6,000th year—at the Second Coming.

• Entering the finished state: Once Christ defeats His enemies and cleanses the earth at the close of day six, day seven (the Millennium) begins in that renewed state. The "work" of overthrowing the curse is finished at the threshold, allowing Christ and the saints to reign in peace throughout the seventh millennium.

4. The Eighth Day as the Final Perfection

• Typological transition: Many early church fathers (like Irenaeus, Justin Martyr, and Barnabas) paired the 7,000-year Sabbath with the concept of the Eighth Day (representing eternity and new creation, symbolized by Christ's resurrection on the first day of the week).

• Two-stage fulfillment: In this framework, the 7th millennium is the earthly Sabbath rest (a renovated earth where Christ reigns), which transitions into the "Eighth Day"—the eternal state of Revelation 21:1, where the final consummation of the New Heavens and New Earth is fully realized after the Great White Throne Judgment.

In Acts 3:19–21, factoring in "times of refreshing" and "times of restitution of all things" directly reinforces why the 7th millennium (the Sabbath) is the exact starting point for the renewed creation—and why the plural "times" fits a two-stage model.

1. Why "Refreshing" Belongs on the Sabbath

• The biblical definition of Sabbath: In the Old Testament, the literal purpose of the Sabbath is refreshment. Exodus 23:12 states that the seventh day is kept "that thine ox and thine ass may rest, and the son of thy handmaid, and the stranger, may be refreshed." Similarly, Exodus 31:17 says that on the seventh day God rested "and was refreshed."
• Connecting Acts 3:19 to the 7th Millennium: If "times of refreshing" arrive when Jesus returns (Acts 3:19–20), then the Second Coming must inaugurate a Sabbath era. Placing the Second Coming at the threshold of the 7,000th year aligns Peter’s prophecy with the foundational biblical meaning of the seventh day: creation finally resting and being refreshed from the curse.

2. Why It Says "Times" (Plural) Instead of "Time" (Singular)

In the Greek text, both phrases use the plural noun kairoi (καιροί — "seasons" or "epochs"):
• kairoi anapsyxeōs ("seasons/times of refreshing," v. 19)
• chronōn apokatastaseōs pantōn ("times/periods of restoration of all things," v. 21)
In a two-stage premillennial framework, the plural "times" accounts for the progressive unfolding of the restoration rather than a single instantaneous moment:
1. Epoch 1 — The Millennial Sabbath (The 7th Day): When Christ returns, heaven releases Him to begin the first season of refreshing and restoration—lifting the curse, binding Satan, renewing the earth (Isaiah 65:17–25), and establishing righteous rule over the nations.
2. Epoch 2 — The Eternal State (The 8th Day): After Satan’s brief release and the Great White Throne Judgment permanently eradicate death and sin, creation enters the final, eternal season of restoration (Revelation 21:1–5), where all things are made completely new.


Background Note on the Greek Terms in Acts 3:19–21


• Anapsyxis (ἀνάψυξις — "refreshing," v. 19): Literally means "a cooling off" or "relief/breathing space after heat and labor." In the Greek Old Testament (Septuagint), its verb form (anapsychō) is the exact word used in Exodus 23:12 and Exodus 31:17 for the refreshing effect of the Sabbath rest.

• Apokatastasis (ἀποκατάστασις — "restitution/restoration," v. 21): Used in ancient Greek and Second Temple Jewish literature for restoring something to its original, rightful condition (such as returning land in the Year of Jubilee or healing a crippled limb in Matthew 12:13—which Jesus notably did on the Sabbath).
 
Last edited:

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
With the way you look at things, it's not possible to exegete Revelation 20. No wonder you don't think Revelation is legitimate scripture.

It is possible to properly exegete, it just won’t agree with a lot of the gospels/epistles. But at least you see my point, even if you don’t agree.

. It seems that you think you can understand the things we're talking about without the Holy Spirit. Clearly not since all you have is theories.

We disagree on what the HS giving understanding means.

You don't know me at all, so your opinion of me means literally nothing to me. You whine about the way I post, yet you keep talking to me, so that says something.

This is a debate forum, and while your ad hominems don’t bother me as much as others, it’s very telling of your position. I absolutely agree with @grafted branch branch that your “debate style“ has done more harm than good for Amil.

But you are right, I don’t know you personally or whats going on in your life, that’s why I’ll give you some grace, instead of claiming you don’t have the HS

Not for the most part, but I think the English translators used the wrong word or definition here and there in their translations. Do you disagree?

How do you know they are using the wrong definitions if you are not fluent in ancient koine Greek?


Give me a break. You continue to not even understand what we're talking about here. I'm not talking about finding other lexicons. I told you that. I'm talking about finding other lexicons that specifically indicate how the word "zao" is used in Revelation 20:4 besides the two we've mentioned. You did not find any, either, the last I saw. You listed a few lexicons, but did not know if they referenced Revelation 20:4 in relation to the word "zao" or not.

I challenged YOU to find something lexical that supports your position. Thayers doesn’t support your position. The BDAG doesn’t support you. Does anything support your position?



What are you talking about then? I said I wasn't aware of other lexicons, besides the 2 that were mentioned, that reference how "zao" should be used in Revelation 20:4.

Right, you weren’t aware. I listed some that you could maybe look up.

The Louw-nida lexicon defines zao has having come back to life from being dead

The usb Greek dictionary adapts the louw-nida lexicon and lists zao in revelation 20:4 as meaning coming back to life from death.

I did not find that they did. That's what I'm saying. I'm not finding any that, besides the 2, that define it. Why does everything have to always be spelled out to you? I just don't get it.

Interesting, so no other lexicons support position?


I don't use eisegesis. That's just your false accusation.

By definition you do. You don’t derive recapitulation for chapter 20 by internal context, but by external framework. That’s the literally the definition of eisegesis.



LOL. I don't need any applause from you. Why do you even bother looking at the book of Revelation at all when you don't believe it's legitimate scripture? I wouldn't waste any time studying it if that's what I believed about it.

You do you brother
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Yes, I think nearly everyone on this forum has had those kinds of comments made to them by SI. I think it’s probably an inability to control emotions and I just try to ignore the condescending comments but I think they are especially triggered when contradictions are exposed.

I honestly think he has done more damage than good to the Amill view that he’s trying to promote.

Agreed. It’s pretty obvious from his debate style that he gets a little too heated more often than not.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Spiritual Israelite

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
It is possible to properly exegete, it just won’t agree with a lot of the gospels/epistles. But at least you see my point, even if you don’t agree.



We disagree on what the HS giving understanding means.



This is a debate forum, and while your ad hominems don’t bother me as much as others, it’s very telling of your position. I absolutely agree with @grafted branch branch that your “debate style“ has done more harm than good for Amil.

But you are right, I don’t know you personally or whats going on in your life, that’s why I’ll give you some grace, instead of claiming you don’t have the HS



How do you know they are using the wrong definitions if you are not fluent in ancient koine Greek?




I challenged YOU to find something lexical that supports your position. Thayers doesn’t support your position. The BDAG doesn’t support you. Does anything support your position?





Right, you weren’t aware. I listed some that you could maybe look up.

The Louw-nida lexicon defines zao has having come back to life from being dead

The usb Greek dictionary adapts the louw-nida lexicon and lists zao in revelation 20:4 as meaning coming back to life from death.



Interesting, so no other lexicons support position?




By definition you do. You don’t derive recapitulation for chapter 20 by internal context, but by external framework. That’s the literally the definition of eisegesis.
There are very few lexicons that even indicate how the word "zao" is used in Revelation 20:4, but you still expect me to pull one out of thin air. This proves nothing. You think a sample size of 2 or 3 is enough to prove something. Ridiculous. Stop acting as if the authors of those 2 lexicons are infallible.

You do you brother
I will do me and I don't need your permission.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
@claninja

In this thread @Davidpt mentioned timelines and where we place things on those timelines. I’d like to throw this idea out there.

If instead of a linear timeline with a beginning and end, we can look at a time circle where we connect the beginning and end of a timeline. Where this connection happens is the Alpha and Omega. Across from the Alpha and Omega, somewhere on the time circle we have Christ at the cross.

Revelation 1:8, 1:11, 21:6, and 22:13 mention Alpha and Omega, which also cross-references with Isaiah 44:6. It might be debatable who exactly the Alpha and Omega is (the Father or Jesus) but nonetheless we have the Godhead two places on the time circle. John’s visions take place at various points on the circle and some things that appear to be in the past will also be in the future if you go far enough along the circle and vice versa. This might be one of the things Revelation 1:8 is pointing to.

Revelation 1:8 I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the ending, saith the Lord, which is, and which was, and which is to come, the Almighty.

An interesting thing is if we move around the time circle (more than once) any single point becomes “which is”, “which was”, and “which is to come”. If we think of the time circle as a piece of string in a circle shape and we twist the string, folding it over, and having both Godheads touching each other, we now have two circles with one on top of the other (I and the Father are one).

Perhaps this folded time circle is in some of the visions John has and the millennium is one of the circles that starts and stops at the same point. I’m just putting this out there as something that might be interesting, nothing more than that.

Non linear timelines are absolutely possible with Jewish literature, which often focused on “block logic” rather than western “step logic”.

But to me, I think the wild history of how revelation came to be accepted is more fascinating.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
There are very few lexicons that even indicate how the word "zao" is used in Revelation 20:4, but you still expect me to pull one out of thin air. This proves nothing. You think a sample size of 2 or 3 is enough to prove something. Ridiculous. Stop acting as if the authors of those 2 lexicons are infallible.


I will do me and I don't need your permission.

3 is better than the 0 you have been able to provide to support your position.

1.)Since you seem to think that English translations are fallible and don’t always translate the word correctly, How do you know they are using the wrong definitions if you are not fluent in ancient koine Greek while also having 0 lexical sources that define “zao” in revelation 20:4?

2.) since the majority of Greek manuscripts have the same verb “zao” in both vs 4 and vs 5, how are they referring to 2 different types of “living”?
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
3 is better than the 0 you have been able to provide to support your position.
If you can provide scripture which prophesied that we should get our understanding of Revelation 20:4 from those 3 sources then I will declare you the victor in the debate.

1.)Since you seem to think that English translations are fallible and don’t always translate the word correctly, How do you know they are using the wrong definitions if you are not fluent in ancient koine Greek while also having 0 lexical sources that define “zao” in revelation 20:4?

2.) since the majority of Greek manuscripts have the same verb “zao” in both vs 4 and vs 5, how are they referring to 2 different types of “living”?
I interpret Revelation 20:4 in a way that doesn't contradict any other scripture. That's what it comes down to. I'm not willing to interpret Revelation 20:4-5 in a way that indicates that there will be one mass bodily resurrection of believers followed by another one of unbelievers 1,000+ years later when other scriptures like Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29 and Acts 24:15 indicate that all of the dead, saved and lost, will be resurrected at generally the same time/hour. You will call that eisegesis despite my exegesis of those scriptures and I couldn't care less.

Can you tell me how you can reconcile your understanding of Revelation 20:4-5 with what Jesus said here...

John 5:28 Do not marvel at this; for the hour is coming in which all who are in the graves will hear His voice 29 and come forth—those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of condemnation.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
you can provide scripture which prophesied that we should get our understanding of Revelation 20:4 from those 3 sources then I will declare you the victor in the debate.

And if you can provide 1 lexical resource or Amil Greek scholar that defines the word “zao” as spiritual life within the context of revelation 20:4, prior to applying a theological interpretation, I will concede that you have lexical evidence for the amil position.

interpret Revelation 20:4 in a way that doesn't contradict any other scripture. That's what it comes down to. I'm not willing to interpret Revelation 20:4-5 in a way that indicates that there will be one mass bodily resurrection of believers followed by another one of unbelievers 1,000+ years later when other scriptures like Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29 and Acts 24:15 indicate that all of the dead, saved and lost, will be resurrected at generally the same time/hour. You will call that eisegesis despite my exegesis of those scriptures and I couldn't care less.

Right, you have to invoke eisegesis because your position, currently, cannot derive any meaning from within the text itself (for revelation 20).

Can you tell me how you can reconcile your understanding of Revelation 20:4-5 with what Jesus said here...

John 5:28 Do not marvel at this; for the hour is coming in which all who are in the graves will hear His voice 29 and come forth—those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of condemnation.

Main options:

1.)it’s inspired, progressive revelation. it’s revealing information about the consummation, that the gospels or epistles had not yet revealed.

However, nothing world wide happened around 95, despite the imminent language used. Therefore, I lean toward:

2.) it’s not inspired, and directly contradicts many of the things in the gospels/epistles.

3.) I could be convinced of the Amil position if an Amil can produce a solid argument based mainly on internal context and grammar instead of eisegesis.
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,818
4,315
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I interpret Revelation 20:4 in a way that doesn't contradict any other scripture. That's what it comes down to. I'm not willing to interpret Revelation 20:4-5 in a way that indicates that there will be one mass bodily resurrection of believers followed by another one of unbelievers 1,000+ years later when other scriptures like Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29 and Acts 24:15 indicate that all of the dead, saved and lost, will be resurrected at generally the same time/hour. You will call that eisegesis despite my exegesis of those scriptures and I couldn't care less.

Can you tell me how you can reconcile your understanding of Revelation 20:4-5 with what Jesus said here...

John 5:28 Do not marvel at this; for the hour is coming in which all who are in the graves will hear His voice 29 and come forth—those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of condemnation.
I Agree 100%

They Falsely Push Multiple Future Resurrections, Multiple Future Judgements, and don't forget (The Last Day) doesn't mean (The Last Day) to them

Jesus Is The Lord
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spiritual Israelite

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,751
7,499
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Main options:

1.)it’s inspired, progressive revelation. it’s revealing information about the consummation, that the gospels or epistles had not yet revealed.
There is no indication in the gospels/epistles that what is written there about the resurrection of the dead was missing details that would be revealed later.

However, nothing world wide happened around 95, despite the imminent language used.
Huh? Did you suddenly forget what we're talking about? I asked you how you can reconcile John 5:28-29 with what is written in Revelation 20:4-5.

Therefore, I lean toward:

2.) it’s not inspired, and directly contradicts many of the things in the gospels/epistles.
Huh? What does this have to do with reconciling John 5:28-29 with your understanding of Revelation 20:4-5?

3.) I could be convinced of the Amil position if an Amil can produce a solid argument based mainly on internal context and grammar instead of eisegesis.
Again, you didn't say anything about your understanding of John 5:28-29 and how it can be reconciled with Revelation 20:4-5. I don't know what happened to you here, but I suggest reading my post again and then try again.
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,818
4,315
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I probably should’ve been clearer in my post, humans definitely think of time in a linear fashion and a linear timeline makes the most sense. I’m certainly not trying to say we can time travel, other than going forward in time.

My thoughts were that when John had his visions, those visions did involve time travel to different points in time, even though physically John most likely remained on Patmos in the first century. The visions themselves don’t fit into a neat linear timeline.

For example in Revelation 4:1 John is told “I will show thee things which must be hereafter”. Then in Revelation 5:3-4 none (no man in KJV) is found worthy to open the book. (No man <3762> means none whatsoever, not just mankind). Clearly none being found worthy to open the book could only take place before the cross on a linear timeline yet Revelation 4:1 said it was things that must take place hereafter.

A circular timeline might help explain some of the anomalies in the visions that we tend to gloss over.



As far as looking at a 7,000-year timeline, I’m not opposed to that, but one thing I’ve thought about is where on the timeline does the new heaven new earth get created?
Fact Is you completely disregard the fact that Revelation 20:1-6 is 100% in the Lord's eternal realm of no earthly time, millennialist then desperately try to take the words "Thousand Years" and create a literal future kingdom on this earth, 100% Malarkey

Revelation 20:1-6 Isnt A Millennial Kingdom On This Earth, Dont Be Deceived​


Can you find the things claimed by those teaching a Literal 1,000 year Millennial Kingdom On This Earth in Revelation 20:1-6 below?

1.) Physical Earthly Kingdom?
2.) Physical Earthly Throne?
3.) Physical Mortal Humans?

The Above Claims (Don't Exist)

Revelation 20:1-6 Is 100% In The Lords (Spiritual) Angel, Heaven, Devil, Satan, The Souls, The Dead, God, Christ

100% Spiritual Realm, No "Literal" Time

2 Peter 3:8KJV
8 But, beloved, be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.

Revelation 20:1-6KJV
1 And I saw an angel come down from heaven, having the key of the bottomless pit and a great chain in his hand.
2 And he laid hold on the dragon, that old serpent, which is the Devil, and Satan, and bound him a thousand years,
3 And cast him into the bottomless pit, and shut him up, and set a seal upon him, that he should deceive the nations no more, till the thousand years should be fulfilled: and after that he must be loosed a little season.
4 And I saw thrones, and they sat upon them, and judgment was given unto them: and I saw the souls of them that were beheaded for the witness of Jesus, and for the word of God, and which had not worshipped the beast, neither his image, neither had received his mark upon their foreheads, or in their hands; and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years.
5 But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
6 Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection: on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
816
161
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
There is no indication in the gospels/epistles that what is written there about the resurrection of the dead was missing details that would be revealed later.

There is indication in the book of revelation:

Revelation definition for the Greek word found in revelation 1:1, from thayers

tropically, in N. T. and ecclesiastical language (see end), a. a disclosure of truth, instruction, concerning divine things before unknown — especially those relating to the Christian salvation — given to the soul by God himself, or by the ascended Christ, especially through the operation of the Holy Spirit;
Revelation 1:1 (revelation of future things relating to the consummation of the divine kingdom);

So since, revelation is revealing things about the consummation of the divine kingdom that were not previously unknown, its not outside the realm of possibility its revealing a span of time between resurrections that gospels/epistles simply didn’t know about yet.

Huh? Did you suddenly forget what we're talking about? I asked you how you can reconcile John 5:28-29 with what is written in Revelation 20:4-5.
Huh? What does this have to do with reconciling John 5:28-29 with your understanding of Revelation 20:4-5?
Again, you didn't say anything about your understanding of John 5:28-29 and how it can be reconciled with Revelation 20:4-5. I don't know what happened to you here, but I suggest reading my post again and then try again.

See point 1: progressive revelation was my answer.