****CONTINUED FROM LAST POST****
Luke 23:43 (KJV)
“And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, Today shalt thou be with me in paradise.”
Many people, myself included, contend that the comma is in the wrong place. Instead of before the word Today, it should be placed AFTER the word Today. It should read similar to the following, as it does in some of the more accurate Bibles, such as the Rotherham Emphasized Bible, considered by some to be the most accurate Bible. The Rotherham reads as such. The || marks are one of the types of emphasis marks used throughout the Bible. It's not a "reading" Bible.
"And he said unto him--|Verily| I say into thee this day: |With me| shalt thou be in paradise."
There are 3 simple reasons that would have made it impossible for Christ and the malefactor to be in paradise that day.
(1)- The only other 2 occurrences of the word. “paradise” are in:
----- 2 Corinthians 12:2 , where it is associated with the third heaven - 2 Corinthians 12:5. This is the only place in the Bible that the third heaven in mentioned. This is the “third Heaven” in TIME. The 1st Heaven in time is in Genesis 1:1. After Satan’s rebellion, the earth became (not, “was”) without form and void, in Genesis 1:2 , when God shut it down. He then remade the heavens and the earth, Genesis 1:3-19 . This Heaven, the one we have now, is the 2nd Heaven, in time. The future Heaven, the “New Heavens”, the 3rd Heaven, in time, is the one that the person in 2 Corinthians 12:1-4 went to, in spirit.
By the way, many people, and I agree, think that Paul is not talking about himself in 2 Corinthians 12:1-5 , but, instead, is talking about John, in the spirit, at Patmos. That would make the Book of Revelation to have been written about 43AD, which makes more sense than 96AD, since there are several references in the epistles that seem to have come from Revelation. The last, 7th trump of Revelation, at the 2nd Coming, for example. Paradise doesn’t exist today and won’t exist until the New Heavens and New Earth come into existence
----- Revelation 2:7, paradise is associated with the tree of life, which is associated with the New Jerusalem, Revelation 22:2,14 , which is associated with the New Heavens and New Earth, Revelation 21:1-2
(2)- The phrase, “I say unto thee today, ............” is a common idiom that is used 42 times in Deuteronomy. We still use it today. Did you ever tell your kids, “I’m telling you right now, you’d better behave”, or something similar? Different words but the same idiom.
(3) The malefactor that talked with Christ on the cross, in Luke 23:43 , was most likely a Gentile who, at that time, had no Calling. From Gen 12 through Acts10, no Gentile EVER had a Calling. Actually, the only Calling at that time was the Land, and that was 100% for Israel. Also, from Gen 12 through the end of Acts, no one ever had a Hope of Heaven, where Christ now sits at the right hand of God - Search and See. The only people to ever have a Hope of Heaven are those Gentiles today who have been given the eyes to SEE the Hope of their Calling, Ephesians 1:17-18 , which is found ONLY in Paul’s 7 epistles written AFTER Acts. Therefore, it is impossible that the malefactor EVER would go to Heaven. Also, he couldn’t ever be admitted into Israel’s earthly Kingdom. That’s why, when he asked about being in the kingdom, Christ told him that He would be with him in paradise (instead), on the New Earth, which the malefactor would gain entrance to through the White Throne Judgment.
2 Cor 5:8, “We are confident, I say, and willing rather to be absent from the body, and to be present with the Lord.”
Unfortunately, I don’t exactly know the meaning of this verse and, over 30 years, I've had at least 5 different theories on what it meant. I do know that it’s much, much more complicated than people think it is. The context includes all of chapter 5 and some authors include chapters 4 and 6. So, verse 8 certainly doesn’t stand alone and, alone, it is totally meaningless. I used to think that Paul was saying, “If I had my druthers, I’d druther be present with the Lord than be at home in the body”. In vs 3, what is this naked state? Does that mean that Paul hopes he will still be alive at the rapture and not in the grave, naked, without a body? I just downloaded a 42 page tome that I haven’t read yet, that’s only giving an explanation of that one verse. I really don't think anyone really knows its exact meaning
Anyway, it makes no difference what it means, as far as anyone alive during the last 1955 years is concerned. One thing I am positive about is that it is impossible that Paul ever thought, at that time, that he would ever go to the uncreated Highest Heaven, where Christ sits at the right hand of God. He had no knowledge that anyone would go there until, after Acts, when he received a revelation directly from Christ, telling him about the brand new church contained in a mystery (secret) that had been hid in God since the world began, Ephesians 3:9 , Colossians 1:26 , Ephesians 1:20 (Christ), Ephesians 2:6 (Us = those who have the eyes to SEE this Hope in Eph and Col – Everyone on the planet today is Called to this Hope of Heaven, but only those that SEE it, believe it, and claim it are chosen). Only in Paul's 7 post-Acts books does anyone have a chance of going to Heaven. No one in the other 59 books ever had a chance of going to Heaven - Search and See. Paul's 7 post-Acts books are the only books in the Bible that will tell anyone living today what their future can hold. During Acts, Paul’s Hope was the New Jerusalem, which isn’t Heaven. It comes down out of the created starry New Heavens and attaches to the New Earth.
Maybe the best is John 3:13 , which is proof, according to 56 out of 62 Bibles, that ONLY Jesus Christ has ever gone to Heaven. A 3rd grader could read it and tell you what it means. So far as the truth goes, it runs rings around everything else you said, combined
NOTE: I'm adding this note Charity made on this subject, which I feel is the true meaning of 2Cor 5:8. Excellent, Charity! Thanks. Much simpler than the 42 page explanation I have by Otis Sellers.
"Paul had no desire to be 'unclothed' by death, but to be 'present' with the Lord; and that could not be achieved except by the return of the risen Christ, which was the expectation of believers during that period. He desired that his body to be clothed upon by life, resurrection life: immortality instead of mortality, incorruption instead of corruption (1 Cor.15). It has nothing to do with dying and going to be with the Lord immediately: but about passing from the mortal state into immortality by the change that will be brought about by resurrection power, 'in the twinkling of an eye' (1 Cor.15:52)."
**************************************************
Where does it say that Moses and Elijah were alive at the transfiguration? In Matthew 17:9 , it says that seeing them was a VISION. In Strong's, the Greek word translated "vision" in that verse means "a spectacle -- especially a supernatural one".
I, a living soul, Genesis 2:7, practice soul sleep, because I sleep every night. The unBiblical idea that man HAS a soul, like the unBiblical idea of hell, where our loving God tortures those that don’t believe, in fire, 24/7, forever, is a pagan doctrine. No scripture proves the existence of Hell or a separate thing from man, called a soul. The Christian concept of hell is not in the Bible. The word “hell” has been erroneously used to replace 4 totally unrelated words. The usage of the word "hell" in any Bible can only be considered a translation error. Why? Because the concept that "hell" denotes is not found in any Bible Text. I have read that the word "hel", meaning a covered place, was used in the 1611 KJV AV for "grave". Today, it should be gone, but "Hell" sells Bibles.
Actually, all the churches not believing in soul sleep are correct, but only because man does not HAVE a soul. There are about 50, or more, instances, in the Bible, where a dead Saint is referred to as being asleep or in a state of sleep. This is basically a figure of speech that is used because, even though the person is dead, he will rise again at the resurrection, as though he had always been asleep. I know of no dead unbeliever in the Bible that is said to be asleep. The graves are full of dead souls, some asleep and some permanently dead.
Your “proof” that soul sleep doesn’t exist because most all churches don't teach it made me laugh. From what I’ve seen, the more people that believe something, the better the odds are that that “something” is untrue. Just look around you. There is Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Catholicism, Talmudic Judaism, and the entire mainstream Denominational Church System (only with salvation do they know anything) that proves me right. Tons and tons of people, but none in those groups have a clue about truth..
I have zero interest in what any commentary says. I prefer to get my information from scripture.
Looking for that blessed hope, and the glorious appearing of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ; - when we, who can see the Hope of Christ's Calling (Ephesians 1:17-18 ), will appear (be manifested) with Him when He appears (is manifested) in Glory – Colossians 3:4 . The location of Glory is above the Heavens, Psalms 8:1, in the KJV.