Catholic miracle claims

[CoreIssue]

Sooooo you didn't watch the video you posted

Palms can't support the weight of the body....that's your evidence

Stick model is supposed to mimic the crucifixion.

If the blood is in the hand that is not mimicking the crucifixion.

It is deceiving people.

 

[Marymog]

Stick model is supposed to mimic the crucifixion.

If the blood is in the hand that is not mimicking the crucifixion.

It is deceiving people.

Are there any documented miracles you accept as authentic? (2nd time asking)

 

[aspen]

Are there any documented miracles you accept as authentic? (2nd time asking)

Conspiracy theorists love to make outlandish charges without concern for presenting reasonable critiques - they live to flame! Listening to other just gets in the way....

 

[Nondenom40]

Apparitions, stigmata, etc.

Or the bleeding eucharist, mary on toast, the flying house of Loreto. Catholicism is full of this nonsense and many others.

 

[CoreIssue]

Or the bleeding eucharist, mary on toast, the flying house of Loreto. Catholicism is full of this nonsense and many others.

Agree

 

[aspen]

Or the Virgin Birth, or the resurrection, or the deity of Christ!?

Silly Catholics

 

[Marymog]

Or the bleeding eucharist, mary on toast, the flying house of Loreto. Catholicism is full of this nonsense and many others.

The "bleeding Eucharist" have been studied by scientist. They say it contains blood sooooo not just a claim by The Church. It is also claimed by men who tested it. Are you a science denier?

Mary on toast has nothing to do with The Church and the "flying house of Loreto" is not accepted as fact by The Church.

Any others you would like to throw out there to discuss? What miracle would you accept as authentic?

Mary

 

[Enoch111]

What miracle would you accept as authentic?

It is a miracle that Pope Francis is still holding on to his office.

 

[CoreIssue]

‘Bleeding host’ was mold, not miracle, according to diocese

 

[Nondenom40]

Or the Virgin Birth, or the resurrection, or the deity of Christ!?

Silly Catholics

Those are all biblical doctrines. No problem with those at all.

 

[Nondenom40]

The "bleeding Eucharist" have been studied by scientist. They say it contains blood sooooo not just a claim by The Church. It is also claimed by men who tested it. Are you a science denier?

Its a hoax. All meant to stir the faithful.

Mary on toast has nothing to do with The Church and the "flying house of Loreto" is not accepted as fact by The Church.

Ah, but the $$ is pretty good huh? Just like mary having two tombs one in Jerusalem and one in Ephesus per new advent catholic encyclopedia.

Any others you would like to throw out there to discuss? What miracle would you accept as authentic?

Mary

There are tons of whacky catholic sayings, beliefs, traditions that i know you don't have to believe. But they are out there and no one condemns them. I guarantee if i went around my church saying mary was omnipotent i'd be called in by someone saying stop it or leave. Catholics just say 'we don't have to believe it. And yes its been said; Ligouri- The glories of mary, multiple times says mary is omnipotent. Thats an attribute of God btw.

 

[Marymog]

‘Bleeding host’ was mold, not miracle, according to diocese

The Diocese investigated and determined it was not a miracle.

Stay focused....this discussion is about "bleeding host" not host with mold.

Mary

 

[CoreIssue]

The Diocese investigated and determined it was not a miracle.

Stay focused....this discussion is about "bleeding host" not host with mold.

Mary

Only in Catholicism.

 

[Marymog]

It is a miracle that Pope Francis is still holding on to his office.

Thanks for chiming in with your disparaging joke that makes zero sense.

Do you have an answer or is it more important to you to try and be funny?

 

[Marymog]

Only in Catholicism.

I don't have a clue what you mean by that statement.

 

[CoreIssue]

Thanks for chiming in with your disparaging joke that makes zero sense.

Do you have an answer or is it more important to you to try and be funny?

Only Catholics believe what to said.

 

[Marymog]

Only Catholics believe what to said.

???????

 

[Enoch111]

Do you have an answer or is it more important to you to try and be funny?

I was hoping you'd get a good laugh out of that. Pope Francis is a joke, no matter which way you look at.

As to Catholic miracles, you should read the book by Benjamin Breckenridge Warfield titled Counterfeit Miracles. He did a thorough study of Catholic miracles and concluded that they were not really genuine.
The book is available from Amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/Counterfeit-Miracles-Benjamin-B-Warfield/dp/085151166X

 

[Marymog]

I was hoping you'd get a good laugh out of that. Pope Francis is a joke, no matter which way you look at.

As to Catholic miracles, you should read the book by Benjamin Breckenridge Warfield titled Counterfeit Miracles. He did a thorough study of Catholic miracles and concluded that they were not really genuine.
The book is available from Amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/Counterfeit-Miracles-Benjamin-B-Warfield/dp/085151166X

Thank you Enoch.

IMO Pope Francis, as of now, has not proven to be the best choice to lead The Church but I wouldn't call him a joke. In your opinion was there any Pope that was not a joke?

For every book you present that debunks miracles I could present two that affirms them thru sworn statements and scientific study.

https://www.amazon.com/God-Miracles...les&qid=1559055269&s=books&sr=1-1-spons&psc=1

https://www.amazon.com/Exploring-Mi...1559055571&s=gateway&sr=8-7#reader_1612787797

So for us to go back and forth on if those miracles are credible by using books would be a waste of both of our time. You believe your guy, I believe mine.

Are there any documented non-biblical miracles from history that you do accept as real?

I appreciate the serious conversation....Mary