Search results

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

  1. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    When not taken out of context he is correct.
  2. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Proverbs 2 Easy-to-Read Version Listen to Wisdom 2 My son, pay attention to what I say. Remember my commands. 2 Listen to wisdom, and do your best to understand. 3 Ask for good judgment. Cry out for understanding. 4 Look for wisdom like silver. Search for it like hidden treasure. 5 If you do...
  3. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    https://www.forananswer.org/Top_JW/Scholars%20and%20NWT.htm#Robertson
  4. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    2 Corinthians 4:4 Easy-to-Read Version 4 The ruler[a] of this world has blinded the minds of those who don’t believe. They cannot see the light of the Good News—the message about the divine greatness of Christ. Christ is the one who is exactly like God. EHV In the case of those people, the...
  5. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Articles The New World Translation and John 1:1: What the Scholars Really Said Robert Hommel Jesus as "a god" Alongside God: JWs and John 1:1 Sam Shamoun Theos is a Count Noun: Is the Word "God" or "a god" in John 1:1c Robert Hommel Qualitative Nouns: Emphasis or Sense? Robert...
  6. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Dixon's statistical methodology, unlike Colwells', was to begin with anarthrous PNs (as opposed to only examining those PNs that were definite), and determine the semantic force of each. His statistical analysis substantiates Harner's findings: "When the anarthrous predicate nominative...
  7. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Paul Dixon Dixon's study is the first of several to challenge the popular application of Colwell's rule. Dixon notes that Colwell's data begins with definite PNs and demonstrates that these usually lack the article. However, those using the rule to "prove" that THEOS in John 1:1c is definite...
  8. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Harner continues: Thus, Harner says that not only is John attributing the nature of THEOS to the LOGOS, but emphasizes that nature by placing THEOS at the head of the clause. The emphasis of THEOS would seem unaccountable if John intended an indefinite nuance, but is perfectly understandable...
  9. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Blass, Debrunner, and Funk The Blass and Debrunner grammar, translated and revised by Robert Funk, generally endorses Colwell's study, but notes: "[Colwell] deals only with sentences in which the verb appears and only with nouns that are unambiguously definite" (BDF, p. 143). The latter point...
  10. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Blass, Debrunner, and Funk The Blass and Debrunner grammar, translated and revised by Robert Funk, generally endorses Colwell's study, but notes: "[Colwell] deals only with sentences in which the verb appears and only with nouns that are unambiguously definite" (BDF, p. 143). The latter point...
  11. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Maximilian Zerwick Zerwick's introductory grammar first appeared in Latin in 1944. A revised and expanded edition was published in 1960, and an English translation with further additions followed three years later. Zerwick admits that Colwell has presented "not a few persuasive examples" that...
  12. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Based on his data gathered from known definite nouns, Colwell extrapolated that more or less the same statistical balance would prove true with nouns that were exegetically questionable. As we shall see below, subsequent studies have called this extrapolation into question, particularly those...
  13. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    It is important to note that these scholars did not use the term "qualitative" to describe their view of THEOS in John 1:1c. Prior to Phillip B. Harner's study of qualitative anarthrous predicate nouns (see below), "qualitative" nouns were viewed more or less as indefinite nouns. These...
  14. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    Some commentators, such as JFB, above, see PROS in this verse as shorthand for the idiomatic expression PROSÔPON PROS PROSÔPON (literally "face to face", RWP, cf., Moulton). This seems view is given weight by the context, in which the Son is said to be "in the bosom of the Father" (v. 18), and...
  15. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    "And the Word was God." Here we have what are certainly the most widely discussed five words in the Bible. Is John here declaring that the Word is God the Father? A secondary, lesser god? Or One who possesses Deity in the same measure as the Father, but is also distinct from the Father? The...
  16. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. Grammatical Analysis... Other views considered... For further reading... C o m m e n t a r y With the possible exception of Genesis 1:1, this verse is the most striking opening of any book of the Bible...
  17. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    In case you missed it, context matters.
  18. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    John 10 Easy-to-Read Version The Shepherd and His Sheep 10 Jesus said, “It is certainly true that when a man enters the sheep pen, he should use the gate. If he climbs in some other way, he is a robber. He is trying to steal the sheep. 2 But the man who takes care of the sheep enters through the...
  19. T

    There is no spiritual gift called "the gift of tongues".

    https://www.calvarychapelboston.com/Biblical%20Basis%20Trinity%20Bowman.pdf