Search results

Hi DPM, GodsGrace posted the question, "Who gets to decide...."! You responded "not the magisterium of the Catholic Church that's for sure". YOU decided who doesn't get to decide. Who gave you that authority? According to you anything I need to know I should "see the Bible". I need to know...

Hi DPM, Sounds like YOU just decided who DOESN'T get to decide. Does that make you THE authority? Since you know it is NOT the magisterium of the Catholic Church then you must know who has the authority? I say The Church, which is the pillar and foundation of Truth, is the authority. Mary

Hi GG, Here is a link to an authoritative source that shows there were many "truths" based on scripture well before the Reformaiton. List of Christian heresies - Wikipedia Mary

Hi, Why did Jesus say go and baptize all nations? What did he mean by baptize? Mary

Hi KBCid, Who's "truths of Christian faith and practice" that were found from "scripture alone" do I follow? Angelican's? Baptist? Calvinist? Catholic? KBCid? Orthodox? Pentecost? They all have different "truths" they "established from scripture alone". Mary

Hi Jun2u, I look forward to their response. This could be interesting and educational for me. Using Sola Scriptura can you show me where you got your books of the Bible? Curious Mary

Hi Oz, Got it. You are now using the "sarcasm" allegation instead of the red herring or or some type of fallacy allegation to NOT answer a legitimate questions: There are no contradictions in scripture. Are there? Luther, Calvin, Zwingli, John Wesley, the men of the RCC, the men of the...

Hi GG, I find your response fascinating. Is your statement tongue in cheek? Mary

Are we getting of the PV topic now? If so, I'm ready to jump in, as long as I don't get chastised for getting off topic :( Mary

The belief is written of Joseph having children from another marriage IS written. The Proto. of James and it meshes with scripture. From just reading James "brother" can mean a step brother. It has nothing to do with salvation. It is just one example of what divides us Christians. Thanks for...

I agree. The subject at hand is PV. And that is what I am talking about. The Proto. of James backs up my assertion of PV. Is Mary being the co-redemtrix the subject? I am still trying to figure out who brought that up. ;) Mary

Both views are incorrect? You have knowledge that others don't have? Some were his brothers and others his step brothers? Is that what you are saying? I can respect that point of view(if that's what you are saying). What evidence is there to back up that view? Mary

Will do? What is the specific topic? Mary

Fair enough. I said your homework for tonight is to find the contradictions in scripture. He is alleging there are contradictions in Protoevangelium of James and those contradictions discredits it. My simple point is EVERYONE knows there are contradictions in scripture however we don't...

Hi GG, What is the subject we are supposed to be discussing? I guess I lost track. :( Mary

Hi GG, I don't understand how "relying on what the early church MIGHT have taught for 1,500 years.....is not applicable" BUT 1,000 years from now (when the Protestant churches will be 1,500 years old) their teachings will be applicable at that time. It seems to me (and I could be wrong) you...

Fair enough GG. I do not feel I was being sarcastic. I am not TRYING to be sarcastic. I am asking legitimate questions. Are you saying if they weren't sarcastic, they WOULD be legitimate? Can you please quote one question that I asked that was sarcastic so that I may re-evaluate HOW I am...

Hi, So my questions are NOT legitimate? Curious Mary

Hi GG, Your theory means that 1,500 years from now Christians that still rely on what the Protestant Churches currently teach won't be applicable anymore. That is the logical conclusion of your theory. In the year 3,000AD Protestant teachings won't be applicable. Then what teaching do we turn...

Dear Oz, A legitimate question is now SARCASIM? A detriment to our conversation? There is no conversation since you haven't answered the question. How about if you answer my questions and then I will answer yours? But of course there are no contradictions in scripture. Are there? They just...