Search results

And you're lying again. I have never called anybody a "Liar" on this forum - ever. Consider yourself exposed.

Soooo, you can't answer the question?? So - WHERE does it say that Mary had "other" children?? Look - the onus is on all of YOU who say that Mary had "other" children to provide the proof for this claim. This is Debating 101 . . .

Because, my linguistically-ignorant friend - "Adelphos(oi)" has MANY meanings that are NOT restricted to uterine siblings. The Greek word "Adelphos" - like it's Hebrew counterpart "Ach" can also mean: half-brother, step-brother, cousin, uncle, nephew relation, neighbor, fellow countryman...

No, I just don't understand how anybody could reject the Authority of the Catholic Church - EXCEPT for when it comes to Sacred Scripture. How is it that the Catholic Church has the Authority to declare what is Scripture and what it not - yet has NO Authority in all other aspects of Christianity?

And, AGAIN, you won't answer the question. Protestants have a very difficult time with this question because it calls into question your rebellion against the Church. Thanks for illustrating this perfectly . . .

Ummmm, I didn't judge you regarding feasts. YOU judged ME. As for the vers from Galatians 4 that you posted - you took it OUT of context. Paul isn't chiding the Galatians for celebrations that are outside of Scripture. He is talking about celebration of PAGAN gods. And there is NO sin in...

You don't get it. I am totally fine with the fact that you reject the Church and it's Authority. What I have asked you repeatedly is - WHY do you accept the Church's Authority when it comes to declaring the Canon of Scripture, but reject that Authority everywhere else??

You have my admiration :)for your sacrifice and work ethic. And, your grandchildren's graduations are indeed a reason for celebration.

It's not the celebration of the birthdays in these passages that was bad - but the actions of those in the stories. Don't forget - Jacob was tricked into marrying Leah, Laban's older daughter - at a wedding celebration. Does that mean that ALL marriage celebrations are bad? Is it wrong to...

By the way - you never answered my question: Did you celebrate your graduation from high school or college? Is it wrong to celebrate these things?? After all - they are NOT in Scripture . . .

Read post #334 . . .

Hmmmm, I assumed you were a JW because you claim you're not a Protestant but claim to be a Christian. A Protestant by definition is a non-Catholic Christian. This coupled with the wacky ideas you have about Christmas and other celebrations led me to assume that you were a JW because these are...

Not that it's any of your business - but I knew a lot of them in Catholic high school gym class. Like I said - instead of getting angry - just don't generalize. about thing that you have no knowledge of. That's what ignorant people do.

You're a Scriptural Literalist. Peter wrote about people like you when he said: 2 Pet. 3:16 There are some things in them (Paul's letters) that are hard to understand, which the ignorant and unstable twist to their own destruction, as they do the other Scriptures.

Ahhh - so you are a Jehovah's Witness then - or some other offshoot of that sect. Did you celebrate your graduation from high school or college? The plain fact is that you erroneously said that Christmas was a replacement of Saturnalia - and I've already proven you wrong about that.

I'm not the one who is lying - YOU are. I have proven this time and time again. You may hate what I say and you may hate Christ's Church - but you've never caught me in a lie . . .

The absence of evidence that YOU should be concerned with. As an anti-Catholic - YOU are always telling us that we shouldn't recognize things that aren't in Scripture. So - WHERE does it say that Mary had "other" children. You are adding to Scripture what is NOT there . . .

My mistake - I assumed that you were a Christian. I didn't realize that you were Jewish. As for celebrating Hanukkah - no, I don't observe Jewish feasts. I'm a Christian.

You didn't actually read my post, did you? You didn't take into consideration that Hippolytus wrote about the recognition of Christmas a full 148 years BEFORE the first recorded pagan celebration of Sol Invictus in AD 354. Your problem is that you've been so polluted by anti-Catholic nonsense...

Like I keep telling you - if you don't like me exposing your lies - them don't lie any more. God frowns on lies. Opinions are fine - but lies are condemned by God.