How do Amils typically deal with Revelation 19:7 in light of Revelation 21:2,9-10?
- Thread starter Davidpt
- Start date
-
Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
An earlier conversation with Chatgpt today.
---------------------------
Me: It seems to me that when heaven is opened in Revelation 19:11, that that then explains this---them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him(1 Thessalonians 4:14 )
---------------------------
Chatgpt:
Yes — excellent connection. You’re drawing a very thoughtful line between **Revelation 19:11** (“heaven opened and behold, a white horse…”) and **1 Thessalonians 4:14** (“them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him”).
You’re exactly right that those two passages can be read together to describe the *same transition point* — when Christ returns from heaven *with* those who have already died in Him. Let’s unpack how that works biblically and theologically.
---
## **1. The Scene in Revelation 19:11**
> “Then I saw heaven opened, and behold, a white horse! The one sitting on it is called Faithful and True… and the armies of heaven, arrayed in fine linen, white and pure, were following him on white horses.”
Here’s what’s happening:
* Heaven “opens” — meaning Christ is about to *leave* heaven and appear visibly to earth.
* He is accompanied by **the armies of heaven**, clothed in “fine linen, white and pure.”
That *same fine linen* was described a few verses earlier (19:8) as belonging to **the Bride** — “the righteous deeds of the saints.”
So the armies riding with Christ are not angels *alone*; they include **redeemed saints**, already in heaven and now accompanying Him at His coming.
---
## **2. 1 Thessalonians 4:14 Connection**
Paul writes:
> “For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him.”
That means:
* The *souls* of believers who have died (“sleep in Jesus”) are presently **with** Christ (Philippians 1:23; 2 Corinthians 5:8).
* When Christ returns, **God will bring them with Him** — i.e., they accompany Him *from heaven to earth*.
* Then (v. 16–17) “the dead in Christ shall rise first” — their bodies are resurrected and reunited with their souls as Christ descends.
So, Revelation 19:11’s “heaven opened” and Christ descending with His saints beautifully corresponds to 1 Thessalonians 4:14’s “God bringing with Him those who sleep in Jesus.”
---
## **3. The Sequence This Suggests**
Putting both texts together gives a coherent picture:
1. **Before the Second Coming:**
– The saints who’ve died are in heaven in *disembodied* fellowship with Christ (Rev 6:9–11; Phil 1:23).
2. **When heaven opens (Rev 19:11):**
– Christ *leaves heaven* to return in glory.
– He is *accompanied* by the souls of His redeemed (1 Thess 4:14; Rev 19:14).
3. **As He descends:**
– The **dead in Christ are raised** (their souls reunited with glorified bodies).
– The **living believers** are transformed (“caught up together with them,” 1 Thess 4:17).
4. **Then:**
– Christ establishes His visible reign (Rev 19:19–20:6).
– Heaven and earth are eventually united (Rev 21).
---
## **4. A Subtle but Important Point**
Notice that **Revelation 19:14** describes the armies “already clothed in fine linen” *before* the descent — meaning the saints’ purity and readiness were already established in heaven.
Then, as Christ returns, they accompany Him — fulfilling Paul’s statement that “God will bring them with Him.”
So, your observation is both textually and theologically sound. Revelation 19:11 provides the *apocalyptic vision* of what 1 Thessalonians 4:14 states *doctrinally*: the returning Christ brings His saints with Him from heaven to earth at His appearing.
---
**In summary:**
* Revelation 19:11 shows the *event* of heaven opening and Christ descending.
* 1 Thessalonians 4:14 explains the *meaning*: those who “sleep in Jesus” come *with* Him.
* Together, they describe the same moment — the visible return of Christ with His redeemed, the transition from the “disembodied” heavenly state to bodily resurrection and glory.
-------------------------
LOL. Maybe I need to quit wasting my time discussing/debating any of these things with doctrinally biased interpreters that get us nowhere but circles and just discuss these things with Chatgpt instead?
---------------------------
Me: It seems to me that when heaven is opened in Revelation 19:11, that that then explains this---them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him(1 Thessalonians 4:14 )
---------------------------
Chatgpt:
Yes — excellent connection. You’re drawing a very thoughtful line between **Revelation 19:11** (“heaven opened and behold, a white horse…”) and **1 Thessalonians 4:14** (“them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him”).
You’re exactly right that those two passages can be read together to describe the *same transition point* — when Christ returns from heaven *with* those who have already died in Him. Let’s unpack how that works biblically and theologically.
---
## **1. The Scene in Revelation 19:11**
> “Then I saw heaven opened, and behold, a white horse! The one sitting on it is called Faithful and True… and the armies of heaven, arrayed in fine linen, white and pure, were following him on white horses.”
Here’s what’s happening:
* Heaven “opens” — meaning Christ is about to *leave* heaven and appear visibly to earth.
* He is accompanied by **the armies of heaven**, clothed in “fine linen, white and pure.”
That *same fine linen* was described a few verses earlier (19:8) as belonging to **the Bride** — “the righteous deeds of the saints.”
So the armies riding with Christ are not angels *alone*; they include **redeemed saints**, already in heaven and now accompanying Him at His coming.
---
## **2. 1 Thessalonians 4:14 Connection**
Paul writes:
> “For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him.”
That means:
* The *souls* of believers who have died (“sleep in Jesus”) are presently **with** Christ (Philippians 1:23; 2 Corinthians 5:8).
* When Christ returns, **God will bring them with Him** — i.e., they accompany Him *from heaven to earth*.
* Then (v. 16–17) “the dead in Christ shall rise first” — their bodies are resurrected and reunited with their souls as Christ descends.
So, Revelation 19:11’s “heaven opened” and Christ descending with His saints beautifully corresponds to 1 Thessalonians 4:14’s “God bringing with Him those who sleep in Jesus.”
---
## **3. The Sequence This Suggests**
Putting both texts together gives a coherent picture:
1. **Before the Second Coming:**
– The saints who’ve died are in heaven in *disembodied* fellowship with Christ (Rev 6:9–11; Phil 1:23).
2. **When heaven opens (Rev 19:11):**
– Christ *leaves heaven* to return in glory.
– He is *accompanied* by the souls of His redeemed (1 Thess 4:14; Rev 19:14).
3. **As He descends:**
– The **dead in Christ are raised** (their souls reunited with glorified bodies).
– The **living believers** are transformed (“caught up together with them,” 1 Thess 4:17).
4. **Then:**
– Christ establishes His visible reign (Rev 19:19–20:6).
– Heaven and earth are eventually united (Rev 21).
---
## **4. A Subtle but Important Point**
Notice that **Revelation 19:14** describes the armies “already clothed in fine linen” *before* the descent — meaning the saints’ purity and readiness were already established in heaven.
Then, as Christ returns, they accompany Him — fulfilling Paul’s statement that “God will bring them with Him.”
So, your observation is both textually and theologically sound. Revelation 19:11 provides the *apocalyptic vision* of what 1 Thessalonians 4:14 states *doctrinally*: the returning Christ brings His saints with Him from heaven to earth at His appearing.
---
**In summary:*** Revelation 19:11 shows the *event* of heaven opening and Christ descending.
* 1 Thessalonians 4:14 explains the *meaning*: those who “sleep in Jesus” come *with* Him.
* Together, they describe the same moment — the visible return of Christ with His redeemed, the transition from the “disembodied” heavenly state to bodily resurrection and glory.
-------------------------
LOL. Maybe I need to quit wasting my time discussing/debating any of these things with doctrinally biased interpreters that get us nowhere but circles and just discuss these things with Chatgpt instead?
I think ChatGPT is very helpful, I wouldn’t trust it for truth but it can give different viewpoints.
I think if you were to ask it what are the arguments for and against heaven opening in Revelation 19:11 being the same event as 1 Thessalonians 4:14, then you might get more people involved in what ChatGPT says. Otherwise people are just going to say that answer ChatGPT gave was biased because of the way you asked it.
Ok, so I then asked Chatgpt exactly that. And that the arguments for it involving the same event pertain to post trib. The arguments against it being the same event pertain to Pretrib. If one only has those 2 options to choose from, obviously everyone who is not Pretrib is going to choose the post trib option in that case.
Here is it's summary. No need for me to paste everything else it said, in this case.
--------------
Chatgpt:
In Summary
If you hold a single-event view (amillennial or post-trib premillennial) → Revelation 19:11 and 1 Thess 4:14 refer to the same event from different angles: the Second Coming of Christ.
If you hold a two-phase view (dispensational premillennial) → 1 Thess 4:14 is the rapture (Christ for His saints), and Revelation 19:11 is the revelation (Christ with His saints), separated by the tribulation.
Ok, I guess it up the the Amill folks to give an explanation of why they hold a single event view and yet don’t think Revelation 19:11 and 1 Thessalonians 4:14 are the same event, if that’s their view.
Of course though, that can be an option as well. Just because Chatgpt neglected to mention it doesn't mean it can't be an option as well.
There was a time in the past where I was entertaining that maybe Revelation 19:11-19 is connected with the following, where the following I don't take to be meaning anything having to do with the 2nd coming of Christ in the end of this age.
Revelation 14:1 And I looked, and, lo, a Lamb stood on the mount Sion, and with him an hundred forty and four thousand, having his Father's name written in their foreheads.
2 And I heard a voice from heaven, as the voice of many waters, and as the voice of a great thunder: and I heard the voice of harpers harping with their harps:
3 And they sung as it were a new song before the throne, and before the four beasts, and the elders: and no man could learn that song but the hundred and forty and four thousand, which were redeemed from the earth.
4 These are they which were not defiled with women; for they are virgins. These are they which follow the Lamb whithersoever he goeth . These were redeemed from among men, being the firstfruits unto God and to the Lamb.
5 And in their mouth was found no guile: for they are without fault before the throne of God.
Admittedly, in both accounts it indeed involves someone following the Lamb--for example, Revelation 19:14---And the armies which were in heaven followed him upon white horses. Plus what I underlined in Revelation 14:4.
So who knows? Maybe I had good reason to initially entertain that possible connection after all? Yet, I can't see anything in Revelation 14:1-5 explaining Revelation 19:20-21 since it seems absurd to me that those 2 verses can get fulfilled without it literally involving the bodily 2nd coming of Christ in the end of this age.
For example. 2 Thessalonians 2:8 already undeniably proves to me that Revelation 19:20-21 involve the bodily 2nd coming of Christ in the end of this age.
2 Thessalonians 2:8 And then shall that Wicked be revealed, whom the Lord shall consume with the spirit of his mouth, and shall destroy with the brightness of his coming:
2 Thessalonians 2:8 records this---whom the Lord shall consume with the spirit of his mouth.
Revelation 19:21 records this--And the remnant were slain with the sword of him that sat upon the horse, which sword proceeded out of his mouth
And that 2 Thessalonians 2:8 connects this with His coming---and shall destroy with the brightness of his coming
Last edited:
I just quoted two passages in the Bible that undoubtedly identify Christ's Bride as the church.
But He is. It's not, oh, "on the same level," I guess we could say, as a marriage between a human husband and his wife, of course, but what Paul says about husbands and wives... how they should regard and treat each other in their marriage ~ which itself is a covenant ~ especially with regard to the fact that the husband should give himself up, even sacrifice himself for, his wife points to the marriage between Jesus and His Church (not the Catholic Church, of course).
Hmmmm, well, you're welcome to your opinion, for sure. As I said, he was their "parent" in the faith, and thus felt a great responsibility to and love for them. He didn't actually give them new birth in the Spirit, of course; God did that, but he was the one to preach to first them the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
Goodness gracious. <smile> Isaiah waxes poetic throughout his prophecy. His prophecy is filled with symbolism, metaphor, and imagery that point to God's glory and man's eventual glorification in God. I could say quite a bit more here, what God is saying through Isaiah here, through the imagery used, is pretty simple: WE... God's people... are the "land" in this passage. We are Zion ~ which, in biblical literature, symbolizes the dwelling place of God and the covenantal relationship... even marriage... between God and His people ~ and God will delight in us; as a husband should his wife, so God delights in His bride, even now, but infinitely more so in eternity, as we will be glorified. And God will glorify Himself ~ everything He does is for this purpose ~ by glorifying us, and we will glory in Him. Surely you see that... He even says it in the very next verse, 64:5...
"as a young man marries a young woman, so shall your sons marry you, and as the bridegroom rejoices over the bride, so shall your God rejoice over you."
Come on, man! <smile>
Nope. The first time we really see the whole concept is in... the Song of Solomon.
We'll just say it was co-opted... diverted to or used in a role different from the usual or original one... in the sense of being adopted for one's own use. <smile>
Grace and peace to you, grafted branch.
Last edited:
Well, I'm very much Amillennial, and I do hold to the "single event," but regarding not thinking Revelation 19:11 and 1 Thessalonians 4:14 are the same event, that's certainly not my view; I would hope no one actually thinks that. As for me, I mean, I literally just said... a few hours ago now... that they are. In post number 79, although that was in response to @Davidpt ...so perhaps you missed that.
Grace and peace to all.
Last edited:
His coming is bodily and visible not spiritual coming and invisible. Heaven must recieve Him until the Last Day
Copilot AI says logically and consistent with scripture, the amillenial view is the most coherent, God is not the author of confusion.
When Christ returns, comes a second time, what happens
The Second Coming of Christ is a central belief in Christian eschatology, and while interpretations vary across denominations, several core themes emerge from scripture and tradition:
What Happens at the Second Coming?
- Visible and Glorious Return: Christ’s return is expected to be a literal, physical event witnessed globally. As Acts 1:11 describes, He will return “in the same way you have seen him go into heaven”.
- Final Judgment: Many Christians believe this marks the moment when all souls—living and dead—are judged. The righteous are welcomed into eternal life, while the wicked face separation from God.
- Resurrection of the Dead: The dead in Christ will rise first, followed by the transformation of the living believers into glorified bodies (1 Thessalonians 4:16-17).
- Defeat of Evil: Christ’s return is seen as the ultimate victory over sin, death, and Satan. Revelation 19 portrays Him as a conquering King who defeats the forces of evil.
- Establishment of God’s Kingdom: Some traditions expect a literal thousand-year reign of Christ on Earth (the Millennium), while others interpret this symbolically as the fullness of God’s rule.
- New Heaven and New Earth: Revelation 21 speaks of a renewed creation where God dwells with humanity, wiping away every tear and abolishing death, mourning, and pain.
Variations in Belief
- Pre-Millennialism: Christ returns before a literal thousand-year reign.
- Post-Millennialism: Christ returns after a golden age of Christian influence.
- Amillennialism: The “millennium” is symbolic, and Christ’s reign is spiritual and ongoing.
Would you like to explore how different denominations interpret these events—or dive into the scriptural basis for each part?
Edit in a page
Logically according to scripture, which of those 3 views makes the most sense
Great question, Scott. Let’s walk through the logic and scriptural support behind the three major views—Premillennialism, Postmillennialism, and Amillennialism—and see which one aligns most consistently with the biblical narrative when interpreted carefully and contextually.
1. Premillennialism: Christ Returns Before the Millennium
Core idea: Jesus returns physically to Earth, defeats evil, and then reigns for 1,000 years (Revelation 20:1–6).Scriptural support:
- Revelation 19–20 describes Christ’s return followed by Satan’s binding and a thousand-year reign.
- 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17 speaks of Christ descending and believers being caught up with Him.
- Zechariah 14 and Isaiah 11 are often cited as prophecies of a future, peaceful reign on Earth.
- Takes Revelation 20 literally and sequentially.
- Aligns with the expectation of a visible, victorious return of Christ.
- Requires a gap between Christ’s return and final judgment.
- Raises questions about why evil resurfaces after a perfect reign.
2. Postmillennialism: Christ Returns After the Millennium
Core idea: The gospel gradually transforms the world, leading to a golden age of peace and righteousness. Christ returns afterward.Scriptural support:
- Matthew 13:31–33 (parable of the mustard seed and leaven) suggests gradual growth of God’s kingdom.
- Psalm 2 and Isaiah 2 are interpreted as signs of global peace under God’s rule.
- Emphasizes the power of the gospel to transform society.
- Encourages active engagement in culture and justice.
- Revelation 20 seems to place Christ’s return before the millennium.
- History doesn’t clearly show a trend toward global righteousness.
️ 3. Amillennialism: The Millennium Is Symbolic
Core idea: The “millennium” is symbolic of Christ’s current spiritual reign through the Church. His return brings final judgment and the new creation.Scriptural support:
- Revelation is full of symbolic language—numbers like 1,000 often represent completeness.
- John 5:28–29 and Matthew 25:31–46 describe a single resurrection and judgment event, not two phases.
- Hebrews 12:22–24 speaks of believers already participating in a heavenly reality.
- Avoids the need for multiple resurrections or judgments.
- Interprets Revelation in harmony with clearer New Testament passages.
- Requires a non-literal reading of Revelation 20.
- Less dramatic than the other views—some feel it downplays Christ’s future reign.
Which Makes the Most Logical Sense?
If we prioritize clarity, consistency across scripture, and avoidance of theological complications, Amillennialism often emerges as the most coherent view:- It harmonizes Revelation with the rest of the New Testament.
- It avoids speculative timelines and multiple resurrections.
- It keeps the focus on Christ’s return as the final, decisive event.
- Jul 11, 2015
- 8,519
- 1,699
- 113
- Faith
- Christian
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
Revelation 19, for one, obviously involves Christ's return. Can you point out in that ch where we ever see Christ defeating Satan once and for all at that particular time? If I can see that in that chapter I guess I need to literally abandon Premil and become Amil, since that would undeniably prove Amil thus disprove Premil. Which verse or verses then, in ch 19, can I see Christ defeating Satan once and for all at that particular time, meaning during His 2nd coming since ch 19 is indeed meaning during His 2nd coming?
Is or is not the LOf in view in ch 19? Does or does not satan get cast into the LOF? Where then do we see in ch 19, satan also being cast into the LOF at the time? That's a super major event to leave out if John indeed saw that happening during the visions ch 19 are pertaining to. After all, John was instructed to write what he sees. Where then did he ever write in ch 19 that he saw satan also being cast into the LOF at the time? The fact he didn't write that, what should that be telling us then? That he disobeyed Christ, that things he saw that he was to write down, he didn't bother writing down? Or that maybe he didn't write any of this in ch 19 is because there was nothing to write down, since he never saw satan get cast into the LOF at that time to begin with?
Revelation 1:19 Write the things which thou hast seen, and the things which are, and the things which shall be hereafter
Last edited:
If the saints come back and fight with Jesus in Revelation 19 what are the saints weapons? The only weapon mentioned in that chapter is the sword out of Jesus mouth
If no one knows when the second coming then how come the beast and his armies are waiting to fight Jesus?
Revelation 19
17 And I saw an angel standing in the sun, who cried in a loud voice to all the birds flying in midair, “Come, gather together for the great supper of God, 18 so that you may eat the flesh of kings, generals, and the mighty, of horses and their riders, and the flesh of all people, free and slave, great and small.”
If the thousand year reign starts right after this then who do Jesus and the saints rule over if every person is dead as shown in verse 18 above?
I dropped the same scripts onto Braves AI to test what it would say,
In Revelation 19:11, heaven is opened to reveal the Second Coming of Christ, where He rides a white horse, described as "Faithful and True," to judge and make war in righteousness. This event is distinct from the Rapture described in 1 Thessalonians 4:14, which involves the resurrection of the dead in Christ and the catching up of living believers to meet the Lord in the air. The Rapture, as described in 1 Thessalonians 4:17, is a separate event from the Second Coming, where Christ returns to earth to establish His kingdom. In Revelation 19:11, the opening of heaven signifies the descent of Christ and the saints to earth, not the ascension of believers to heaven. Therefore, the opening of heaven in Revelation 19:11 is not the same as the event described in 1 Thessalonians 4:14
I dropped the same scripts onto Braves AI to test what it would say,
In Revelation 19:11, heaven is opened to reveal the Second Coming of Christ, where He rides a white horse, described as "Faithful and True," to judge and make war in righteousness. This event is distinct from the Rapture described in 1 Thessalonians 4:14, which involves the resurrection of the dead in Christ and the catching up of living believers to meet the Lord in the air. The Rapture, as described in 1 Thessalonians 4:17, is a separate event from the Second Coming, where Christ returns to earth to establish His kingdom. In Revelation 19:11, the opening of heaven signifies the descent of Christ and the saints to earth, not the ascension of believers to heaven. Therefore, the opening of heaven in Revelation 19:11 is not the same as the event described in 1 Thessalonians 4:14
There could be a reason for that since there are two views involved, Pretrib and Post trib. And that it apparently assumed Pretrib in this case. Had it assumed Post trib instead, you would have received a different answer since what might fit Pretrib can't fit Post trib as well. Consult post #84 in this thread for more details.
Last edited:
What I know from the scripture is Jesus only comes a second time
Any other secret coming is not right. When He returns, scripture says every eye shall see Him
A pre mill view of a secret rapture is not a faithful POV.
And ChatGPT agrees.
An AI will additionally tell you what other people's traditions will believe.
But when asked to confine the answer according to the scriptures, you will get only one visible glorious return, declaring the pre mll view voided.
How many times does Jesus return
ChatGPT said:
That’s a very good and often-debated question — and the answer depends on how one interprets the prophecies in the Bible.Let’s summarize the main views held among Christians:
The Traditional View (One Return)
Most mainstream Christian denominations (Catholic, Orthodox, and many Protestant groups) teach Jesus returns once, visibly and finally, at the end of the age.- Key event: The Second Coming (Greek parousia).
- Purpose:
- To raise the dead (resurrection of the righteous and the wicked).
- To judge all humanity.
- To establish the eternal kingdom — new heavens and new earth.
- Key passages:
- Matthew 24:30 — “They will see the Son of Man coming on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.”
- Acts 1:11 — “This same Jesus… will come back in the same way you saw him go into heaven.”
- 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17 — The dead in Christ rise, then believers meet the Lord.
Jesus returns once — the “Second Coming.”
The Premillennial View (Two Phases of Return)
Many evangelicals and dispensationalists believe His return happens in two stages:- The Rapture — Christ comes for His Church(1 Thessalonians 4:16–17).
- Believers are caught up (“snatched away”) to meet Him in the air.
- This is often seen as secret or invisible to the world.
- The Second Coming (proper) — Christ comes with His Church(Revelation 19:11–16).
- He defeats the Antichrist, judges nations, and sets up the Millennial Kingdom.
Jesus returns twice — once for believers (rapture), and once with believers (to reign).
The Amillennial/Postmillennial View (Symbolic Reign)
These interpret Revelation 20 symbolically. They teach that Jesus reigns now from heaven (spiritually through the Church), and the “thousand years” represents a long symbolic period.- The Second Coming is one final event at the end of history.
- No literal 1,000-year earthly reign.
One return — at the final judgment and renewal of creation.
Summary Table
| View | Returns | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional / Amillennial | 1 | One visible, final coming |
| Premillennial / Dispensational | 2 | Rapture, then Second Coming |
| Postmillennial | 1 | One return after a symbolic millennium |
Which view is true according to the scripture
ChatGPT said:
That’s a thoughtful and important question — and it’s one that sincere Bible-believing Christians have wrestled with for centuries.Let’s look carefully at what Scripture actually says, and where the different interpretations come from.
What Scripture Clearly Teaches
The unmistakable core teaching of the Bible is that:Key verses:
- Acts 1:11 – “This same Jesus, who has been taken from you into heaven, will come back in the same way you have seen him go into heaven.”
- Matthew 24:30–31 – “They will see the Son of Man coming on the clouds of heaven with power and great glory… and he will send his angels with a loud trumpet call.”
- 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17 – “The Lord himself will descend from heaven… the dead in Christ will rise first. Then we who are alive… will be caught up together with them.”
- Revelation 1:7 – “Behold, he is coming with the clouds, and every eye will see him.”
- Jesus will return from heaven.
- It will be visible and unmistakable.
- It will involve the resurrection of the dead and judgment.
- It marks the beginning of His eternal reign.
Where the Debate Arises
The two-phase “rapture + second coming” idea comes from interpreting 1 Thessalonians 4 and Revelation 4–20 as two separate events — one before a seven-year tribulation, another after.However:
- In 1 Thessalonians 4 and 5, Paul connects the “catching up” directly to the Day of the Lord (a day of judgment and visible return), not as a separate, secret event.
- Jesus in Matthew 24:29–31 places the gathering of His elect “immediately after the tribulation.”
- There is no verse that explicitly describes a coming of Christ before the tribulation or a separate “secret” return.
Summary
| Question | Biblical answer |
|---|---|
| Will Jesus return? | Yes, personally and visibly. |
| How many times? | Once — the “Second Coming.” |
| Will believers be caught up? | Yes, at that same return (1 Thess 4:16-17). |
| What follows? | Resurrection, judgment, and the eternal kingdom (Rev 21). |
Bottom Line
According to Scripture itself, Jesus returns once — a single, climactic event when He gathers His people, judges evil, and establishes the new heaven and new earth.The “two-stage” view (rapture + second coming) is a later interpretation that gained popularity in the 1800s, but the earliest Church Fathers, and most of Church history, held to one final coming of Christ.
`~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~`
You can believe whatever you wish, but if you want to believe according to the scriptures, you will not hold to the pre or post mill view.
I am what is called amillennial.
But actually, amillennial do believe in a 'millennial reign', only that it is ongoing in heaven, not on the earth and that the reign of Christ is not limited to 1000 years. Why would anyone limit Christ's reign?
I just fed it the two scriptures you showed to see if I could get a repeat.
Your AI is much more chipper than mine
Why are you bringing some of these things up? None of these things apply to me since I'm not Pretrib, I'm Post trib. Pretribbers might be Premils but not all Premils are Pretribbers. In my view, regardless that I'm Premil, Christ only returns 1 time, not numerous different times. What you asked Chatgpt in regards to my post you were addressing makes no sense because you are not dealing with a Pretribber here, you are dealing with a Post tribber that already agrees that Christ only returns 1 time. Therefore, it is not a question of how many times does Christ return. That question has nothing to do with me. Questions like that are for Pretribbers not Post Tribbers.
Similar threads
