Let's Talk About Socialism and Marxism

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Yes, mental health is a problem. But not only bipolar. Check this out:

COE - Students With Disabilities
In 2019–20, the number of students ages 3–21 who received special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) was 7.3 million, or 14 percent of all public school students. Among students receiving special education services, the most common category of disability (33 percent) was specific learning disabilities.

The Christian question I have is: is this from the fact that we're all descendants of Adam and Eve and inbred too much. LOL a little ;)

ROFL...NO...
I know that even during OT times when David was acting crazy in front of the Philistine king the King's remarks were telling. "What? We have so many crazy people that I should now import them?" or some such thing like that...but basically he was inferring that they had too many crazy people in his city as it was. So...likely crazy comes from the country and the city...basically civilization.
 

dev553344

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2020
14,528
17,216
113
USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
ROFL...NO...
I know that even during OT times when David was acting crazy in front of the Philistine king the King's remarks were telling. "What? We have so many crazy people that I should now import them?" or some such thing like that...but basically he was inferring that they had too many crazy people in his city as it was. So...likely crazy comes from the country and the city...basically civilization.
That is something I've been often wondering about trying to harmonize Genesis. I kinda think Adam and Eve had perfect genetics having been created by God. And Jesus also had perfect genetics being created by the Holy Spirit or God. But I know that in some cultures inbreeding did happen and cause some genetic mutations that were undesirable. But perhaps that's besides the point. Back to socialism.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnDB

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Yes, mental health is a problem. But not only bipolar. Check this out:

COE - Students With Disabilities
In 2019–20, the number of students ages 3–21 who received special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) was 7.3 million, or 14 percent of all public school students. Among students receiving special education services, the most common category of disability (33 percent) was specific learning disabilities.

The Christian question I have is: is this from the fact that we're all descendants of Adam and Eve and inbred too much. LOL a little ;)

As far as the "learning disabilities" go...that's a function of federal government grants...no state gets extra money for having "smart kids" for their education...but boy howdy do they get all kinds of federal dollars for identifying children who need extra learning.

BUT...if we were to have a school get extra federal dollars for the "gifted" programs...imagine the difference it would make.

On top of this...I have seen kids "coast" along warming a desk...not paying attention to anything. Until the moment comes when they decide to. Then absolutely learn at a blinding fast pace...
 

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
China is a great case study about modern day socialism and education...Not Taiwan or Hong Kong...those are different. But PRC China...where education is on a competitive level. You either learn and get smart or else you are shoveling coal or peeling garlic cloves for the rest of your life. And you don't just have to learn the materials...you have to prove yourself smarter than your peers to advance and get more education. PRC doesn't bother to educate those students who don't want to learn. Foster kids and Orphans especially have it rough as they do not get extra school supplies or tutoring the rest of the children get. Communism creates a system where the government doesn't want to afford things for the "least of these".
 
  • Like
Reactions: dev553344

dev553344

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2020
14,528
17,216
113
USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As far as the "learning disabilities" go...that's a function of federal government grants...no state gets extra money for having "smart kids" for their education...but boy howdy do they get all kinds of federal dollars for identifying children who need extra learning.

BUT...if we were to have a school get extra federal dollars for the "gifted" programs...imagine the difference it would make.

On top of this...I have seen kids "coast" along warming a desk...not paying attention to anything. Until the moment comes when they decide to. Then absolutely learn at a blinding fast pace...

Along with that I think socialism is being taught in schools. I'm a fan of capitalism since I think it's what made this country excel into what we are today, leaders in aerospace and technology. Not that there aren't other countries that accel too. But I fear socialism would lead to a depletion of talent.
 

dev553344

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2020
14,528
17,216
113
USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
China is a great case study about modern day socialism and education...Not Taiwan or Hong Kong...those are different. But PRC China...where education is on a competitive level. You either learn and get smart or else you are shoveling coal or peeling garlic cloves for the rest of your life. And you don't just have to learn the materials...you have to prove yourself smarter than your peers to advance and get more education. PRC doesn't bother to educate those students who don't want to learn. Foster kids and Orphans especially have it rough as they do not get extra school supplies or tutoring the rest of the children get. Communism creates a system where the government doesn't want to afford things for the "least of these".
You posted this just before I posted my link and I caught it afterwards. Good point, China isn't justice and rights for all people as the USA is. I wonder how they care for their disabled?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnDB

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Along with that I think socialism is being taught in schools. I'm a fan of capitalism since I think it's what made this country excel into what we are today, leaders in aerospace and technology. Not that there aren't other countries that accel too. But I fear socialism would lead to a depletion of talent.

Actually I would modify that a bit...(not really disagreeing with you)
It is "free will" cooperation and working together towards common goals that have been identified with each person getting the full rewards of their efforts that has promoted this nation to such heights.

The landing of men on the moon did a lot to spur technology that you are using today...from the computers we use to cell phones and internet. All these things were created for the space program. But these things also had real world applications...including good ball point pens. Modern golf clubs, arrows, and cars are now being built with technology developed from that era. Insulation technology also...so you can efficiently heat and cool a home. Lots of things were developed from all of that space race...

Each of the contractors developed a technology, were paid for it and then were allowed to capitalize upon the things they learned how to do...

We all worked together...city people and rural people all working together to make a society great...but each one allowed to profit or fail on their own merits as they could.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dev553344

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You posted this just before I posted my link and I caught it afterwards. Good point, China isn't justice and rights for all people as the USA is. I wonder how they care for their disabled?
Truthfully...like animals.
Lets just say it this way...
If someone was to escape North Korea and try to filter themselves into Chinese society...they are enslaved. They are treated as sub-human with no rights and subsistence food. They are caged and chained at all times. Free labor with the cheapest and least expensive room and board possible.

They have a very different viewpoint than the Judeo/Christian viewpoint about life...after all they are communist.
 

dev553344

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2020
14,528
17,216
113
USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Truthfully...like animals.
Lets just say it this way...
If someone was to escape North Korea and try to filter themselves into Chinese society...they are enslaved. They are treated as sub-human with no rights and subsistence food. They are caged and chained at all times. Free labor with the cheapest and least expensive room and board possible.

They have a very different viewpoint than the Judeo/Christian viewpoint about life...after all they are communist.
Do you have an older information base on China and disabilities? Or is there something here that is not right? I read this: Disability in China - Wikipedia

Protection. Enacted in 1982 (and later amended), the Constitution of the People's Republic of China ensured protection for individuals with disabilities: "Citizens of the People's Republic of China have the right to material assistance from the State and society when they are old, ill or disabled.
 

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Do you have an older information base on China and disabilities? Or is there something here that is not right? I read this: Disability in China - Wikipedia

Protection. Enacted in 1982 (and later amended), the Constitution of the People's Republic of China ensured protection for individuals with disabilities: "Citizens of the People's Republic of China have the right to material assistance from the State and society when they are old, ill or disabled.

OK...first off the WHO is way too political in nature to be taken that seriously.
Having a visual disability is anyone who needs glasses...you can either take the ones that the government provides or you can save your money and buy ones that you can actually see out of.
Hearing disability...similar story...but there are varying levels of education for the hearing impaired...getting them to dig silicone rich dirt doesn't require a lot of education for their eventual career.
and most of the "mental disability" programs are a dog and pony shows.

When things ease up a bit on Christianity you really need to go on one of the mission trips to see what I am talking about. Taiwan is so different it is like a different country. Hong Kong residents...their chief thing is being apathetic about anyone or anything except themselves. (they just want to be left alone)

In China every province is a bit different until you get into hard core PRC...then things get different in a hurry. Then the military is in complete control over everything. And they have a military division for everything. And depending upon the General that commands that province...you can live a somewhat decent life or not. But all of them are committed to "state run industries" and making them profitable in any way they can. Expenses like the disabled? They are going to do the minimum. Boy babies are still preferred over girls...but there has become such a shortage of women that its turning slowly.
 

NayborBear

Active Member
Jan 21, 2020
295
108
43
71
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
This has nothing to do with racism whatsoever...It hasn't been mentioned or inferred whatsoever....you are the sole person bringing this to the conversation.

It never does have anything to do with racism!
UNTIL IT DOES!
Ecclesiastes 8:
11 Because sentence against an evil work is not executed speedily, therefore the heart of the sons of men is fully set in them to do evil.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Reggie Belafonte

Reggie Belafonte

Well-Known Member
Mar 16, 2018
5,928
2,948
113
63
Brisbane
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
As far as the "learning disabilities" go...that's a function of federal government grants...no state gets extra money for having "smart kids" for their education...but boy howdy do they get all kinds of federal dollars for identifying children who need extra learning.

BUT...if we were to have a school get extra federal dollars for the "gifted" programs...imagine the difference it would make.

On top of this...I have seen kids "coast" along warming a desk...not paying attention to anything. Until the moment comes when they decide to. Then absolutely learn at a blinding fast pace...
There's that word gifted ? :rolleyes:
I first came across that nonsense with a mate of mines sisters kid, she claimed he was gifted, fact was that he was a total rude brat and then became a fruit loop.
Somewhat like say people like Sheldon Cooper on that TV show could we say ? is that a gift or a curse ? I would maybe say such a one was cursed than Gifted.

A good mate of mine who is Gay has a boy friend who is very smart but what a deranged poor bastard he truly is, boy has he some issues and boy is he nasty as they can come, he is openly strait forward in any opinions of his and I admire that of him, but for the nastiness that underlines everything he says, let alone all the filth that he wallows in, but he sees that as a positive and he just owns it that he is a whore and claims everyone else is a whore as well.

I would say that people like Cooper are queer ? as in queer not Gay but just fruit loops, maybe a claim could be said eccentric, but I think we need a better definition of such things.

I had a avid Socialist saying that his kid is autistic and this he truly believes is a more evolved progression of man :rolleyes: I said no it's not at all. it's what I see as the same key to crap deranged people who like Hitler and Stalin etc etc were totally devoid of being humane, such a disregard to others and so dull to life of others it can be so creepy. I think that Hitler and Stalin were autistic, bipolar etc for sure.

I have had to deal with people in business that have no regard to anyone at all but themselves. Creepy ! not to mention totally repulsive evil people who only cause problems and trouble at the drop of a hat not to mention their are such people everywhere that are the same, who take pride in their malice.

If I could I would set up an agenda to promote the exposing of Malice 24/7 as a main problem with our society, to hell with the childish rubbish like Racism being haled 24/7 as if such was the 1st commandment. we have gone from a society's culture that is changing it's priority's due to the whims of Cultural Marxism leading the charge. to a Godless deranged system that's plotted out for just dupes, that all must follow the narrative or else comes the malice ! so it was under Hitler and Stalin etc the same deranged powers steering a Nations into hellfire.

Attacking and demanding Racial issues is just hogwash as their is a big difference between a Racial issue and Racial prejudice as the two are totally different subjects in fact, but what does the Socialist peddle ? that they are the same thing. why is that ? well they promote a lie that all people are the same. by that what that means is that you are just a number to them and owned like your their cattle. you loose your fundamental value as a person, not to mention you rights to question such a government.
 

Mosheli

Active Member
Jul 2, 2020
133
87
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
I'm going to bed in a few minutes, but since I only have a slim idea of what these two things are about and how they're bad for America,.. I don't really know much about them and I figured it would be a good topic of conversation to have for others who are the same.

I'm surprised at how so many American christians or "christians" are so anti "Socialism". If by "socialism" you mean communism then I would agree that it is not good (because communism forces the majority into communes and only the few elite have control, and other reasons*), but the word socialism does not actually mean communism, there have been lots of other types of socialism like Owen's. Surely the only people who can be totally anti socialist are the rich and selfish. (Like do you really support there being poverty and unemployment and homelessness and slavery and sweat shops / coolie labor and slums and beggars etc?)

(* Communism = class war, Classless society, Utopian, Trade unions, forces everyone into Communes/Kibbutzim, only a few elite have control, leveling the upper & middle classes, democracy, total state ownership of everything and no private property, internationalism, egalitarianism, "united we stand divided we fall".) (Though "the USSR was collectivist not communist".) (Socialism is "community ownership/control", social justice.)

Natural world facts:
"Man is a social animal". "We all need community". "No man is an island."
Socialism is the "left wing" and Oxford dictionary says that left is the side "by the heart".
Socialism (or society) is the opposite to capitalism and individualism. We know that capitalism & (hyper-)individualism has bad things.

Biblical world facts:
Jesus and the early church in Acts could be said to be "socialists" to a certain extant.
John the Baptist said "he/she who has two coats give to him/her who has none".
Jesus said "If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me."
"Therefore I tell you, don't be anxious for your life, what you will eat, nor yet for your body, what you will wear. ... For the nations of the world seek after all of these things, but your Father knows that you need these things.
But seek God's Kingdom, and all these things will be added to you. Don't be afraid, little flock, for it is your Father's good pleasure to give you the Kingdom. Sell that which you have, and give gifts to the needy. ...."
James 2 says "Don't the rich oppress you, and personally drag you before the courts?"
Jews of the apostles times had "insulas" which were sort of like extended family compounds.
Acts 2 says "All who believed were together, and had all things in common. They sold their possessions and goods, and distributed them to all, according as anyone had need." (This seems to be where Marx got his "from each according to his ability to each according to his need" from.)
Revelation 3 letter to Laodcieans says they are rich but don't see they are poor, naked (implying there were poor and unclothed amidst the rich?)
Jesus commanded us to love one another and to be one.

Ironically even though so many say they are against socialism the current western world regime in America etc is called "Leftist" by nationalists. Right is "old", natural/traditional, socio-biological, national/racial, left is "new/revolutionary", artificial, socio-economic, globalist/multicultural. Both the two parties in our countries are really on the same side.
Fluoridation is a form of communist leveling. (So if you agree with fluoridation you are a socialist.)
This western regime is half capitalist and half communist, eg private schools for wealthy, public schools for others; unfluoridated water for wealthy/elite, fluoridated water for public; home ownership for wealthy, rental homes/flats for poor.

I'm not a socialist, and not against private property, but nor am I anti socialist. I believe in a synthesis of the left/social and the right/national (that is not the the same as "center" though, nor the same as this western regime claiming to be in between the "extreme left" and "extreme right" which is a clever lie/twisting.) Common interest not just self interests.
Atlantis Account says "They ... treated the vagaries of fortune and one another with wisdom and forbearance, as they reckoned that qualities of character were far more important than their present prosperity. So they bore the burden of their wealth and possessions lightly, and did not let their high standard of living intoxicate them or make them loose their self control, but saw soberly and clearly that all these things flourish only on a soil of common goodwill and individual character, and if pursued too eagerly and overvalued destroy themselves and morality with them. ...."
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Pathfinder7

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
4,529
2,967
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I'm surprised at how so many American christians or "christians" are so anti "Socialism". If by "socialism" you mean communism then I would agree that it is not good (because commuism forces the majority into communes and only the few elite have control) (though "the USSR was collectivist not communist"), but the words socialism does not actually mean communism, there have been lots of other types of socialism like Owen's. Surely the only people who can be totally anti socialist are the rich and selfish. (Like do you really support there being poverty and unemployment and homelessness and slavery and sweat shops / coolie labor and slums and beggars etc?)

Natural world facts:
"Man is a social animal". "We all need community". "No man is an island."
Oxford dictionary says socialism is the left wing and that left is the side "by the heart".
Socialism (or society) is the opposite to capitalism and individualism. We know that capitalism & (hyper-)individualism has bad things.

Biblical world facts:
Jesus and the early church in Acts could be said to be "socialists" to a certain extant.
John the Baptist said "he/she who has two coats give to him/her who has none".
Jesus said "Jesus said to him, "If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; and come, follow me."
"Therefore I tell you, don't be anxious for your life, what you will eat, nor yet for your body, what you will wear. ... For the nations of the world seek after all of these things, but your Father knows that you need these things.
But seek God's Kingdom, and all these things will be added to you. Don't be afraid, little flock, for it is your Father's good pleasure to give you the Kingdom. Sell that which you have, and give gifts to the needy. ...."
James 2 says "Don't the rich oppress you, and personally drag you before the courts?"
Jews of the apostles times had "insulas" which were sort of like extended family compounds.
Acts 2 says "All who believed were together, and had all things in common. They sold their possessions and goods, and distributed them to all, according as anyone had need." (This seems to be where Marx got his "from each according to his ability to each according to his need" from.)
Revelation 3 letter to Laodcieans says they are rich but don't see they are poor, naked (implying there were poor and unclothed amidst the rich?)
Jesus commanded us to love one another and to be one.

Ironically even though so many say they are against socialism the current western world regime in America etc is called "Leftist" by nationalists. Right is "old", natural/traditional, socio-biological, national/racial, left is "new/revolutionary", artificial, socio-economic, globalist/multicultural. Both the two parties in our countries are really on the same side.
Fluoridation is a form of communist leveling. (So if you agree with fluoridation you are a socialist.)
This western regime is half capitalist and half communist, eg private schools for wealthy, public schools for others; unfluoridated water for wealthy/elite, fluoridated water for public; home ownership for wealthy, rental homes/flats for poor.

I'm not a socialist, and not against private property, but nor am I anti socialist. I believe in a synthesis of the left/social and the right/national (that is not the the same as "center" though, nor the same as this western regime claiming to be in between the "extreme left" and "extreme right" which is a clever lie/twisting.) Common interest not just self interests.
Atlantis Account says "They ... treated the vagaries of fortune and one another with wisdom and forbearance, as they reckoned that qualities of character were far more important than their present prosperity. So they bore the burden of their wealth and possessions lightly, and did not let their high standard of living intoxicate them or make them loose their self control, but saw soberly and clearly that all these things flourish only on a soil of common goodwill and individual character, and if pursued too eagerly and overvalued destroy themselves and morality with them. ...."

I'm not against altruism...
But altruism at the point a gun or imprisonment is not altruism.
 

Mosheli

Active Member
Jul 2, 2020
133
87
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
I'm not against altruism...
But altruism at the point a gun or imprisonment is not altruism.

There will always be someone pointing a gun or imprisoning even in a totally anti "socialism" system. James 2 even says the rich throw you in prison. In this "anti socialist" American regime we have gun pointed at us forcing us to drink fluoridated water, forcing us to homelessness because of housing crisis, etc.
In the best regime/system only people who are doing evils would have gun pointed at them or put in prison.
I myself am forced to have faith in God.

Socialism is all about control, just like communism.
Both are evil. Both support anti and non chistian principles.
Both support abortions, just to use an example.

This western world is controlling whether it is claimed to be left/socialism or/and right/anti-socialism, control by the rich/wealthy/elite/few/masters (and alot of them are/were "christians" eg Teresa May, Angela Merkel, Bush, Bill Gates, etc).
It is true that the "left" generally support abortion. I agree that is wrong.

Also, pure freedom is not possible because humans are not all good and we can't all do anything we like without concern of effects on others, so there has to be some controls.
In the best system the best are in control and the worst under control. Not "freedom to starve".

(I'm sorry God I shouldn't have commented, all these political issues are pointless, only faith in God is going to save me.)
 
Last edited: