The Smoke of their Torment Ascends Forever

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Phoneman777

Well-Known Member
Jan 14, 2015
7,509
2,629
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If I said, the smoke of the fire went up for a week, what would you conclude of the fire? That there was a fire sending up smoke? Or that the fire, being fully extinguished, continued to send up smoke?

OK . . . I know . . . someone, maybe you, is all poised to say, but the "flames" were out, only the embers were smoking.

OK.

The smoke from combustion went up all week. Does that help? Where there is smoke, there is . . . combustion.

The Smoke of their Torment Ascends forever. Where there is smoke, there is ____________.

A: Torment

The smoke is the smoke of their torment, not just smoke.

I realize there are some who cannot countenance such a straightforward reading, as they will say, but people are not eternal!

What if we were to set aside conclusions, doctrines, things like that, and only look at what the passage itself says? What does it say?

Revelation 14:9-12 KJV
9) And the third angel followed them, saying with a loud voice, If any man worship the beast and his image, and receive his mark in his forehead, or in his hand,
10) The same shall drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out without mixture into the cup of his indignation; and he shall be tormented with fire and brimstone in the presence of the holy angels, and in the presence of the Lamb:
11) And the smoke of their torment ascendeth up for ever and ever: and they have no rest day nor night, who worship the beast and his image, and whosoever receiveth the mark of his name.
12) Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.

Much love!
Is this saying the wicked will smolder for all eternity and the resulting smoke continuously ascends up? Not necessarily --

"The word "aionios" refers to "duration: either undefined but NOT endless; or undefined because endless". All scholars agree that when "forever" (OT "olam"/NT "aionios") refers to God, it generally means "eternity"...but when applied to the affairs of men, it means "all the days of life". That's why a freed slave who after consenting to continued servitude of his master "shall remain his slave forever" does not mean eternity, but "all his days of life".

Also, "forever" is sometime used to refer to distance, not duration...IOW, "ascendeth up forever and ever out of sight". We're all familiar with using "forever" to refer to that long hallway, road, river, etc., that "goes on forever". Therefore, it could be said the smoke ascends up "forever and ever out of sight".

John is clear that "no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him" and if he doesn't possess eternal life, how can he possess eternal suffering?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Is this saying the wicked will smolder for all eternity and the resulting smoke continuously ascends up? Not necessarily --

"The word "aionios" refers to "duration: either undefined but NOT endless; or undefined because endless". All scholars agree that when "forever" (OT "olam"/NT "aionios") refers to God, it generally means "eternity"...but when applied to the affairs of men, it means "all the days of life". That's why a freed slave who after consenting to continued servitude of his master "shall remain his slave forever" does not mean eternity, but "all his days of life".

Also, "forever" is sometime used to refer to distance, not duration...IOW, "ascendeth up forever and ever out of sight". We're all familiar with using "forever" to refer to that long hallway, road, river, etc., that "goes on forever". Therefore, it could be said the smoke ascends up "forever and ever out of sight".

John is clear that "no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him" and if he doesn't possess eternal life, how can he possess eternal suffering?

I imagine that you are aware the same words and word forms are used to describe the everlasting life of the righteous as well as the everlasting torment of the wicked?

If the suffering of the wicked doesn't endure, then why interpret the life of the righteous to endure? Right? Both actually end?

Much love!
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Feb 6, 2018
24,755
13,083
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The Smoke of their Torment Ascends Forever
OP ^

For “something” to BE TORMENTED, it must have LIFE.
Physically Dead human body’s are void of their “blood” LIFE.
Life in Souls in human body’s, is Gods Breath.
“IF” and when Gods Breath returns to God, what Torment does that soul experience?

Created “spirits” never die.

A man who has rejected becoming born again, does not possess forever spirit life.

He who is NOT WITH God, IS AGAINST God.
Then there ARE THOSE, who are not ONLY AGAINST GOD....
BUT...
1) Try to convince others to BE AGAINST God....!
2) Persecute those who ARE WITH God.....!

God is JUST. God forewarns.
He that IS AGAINST God, shall be destroyed, body and soul.
The Life in the soul, (Gods Breath) Shall return to God.
The spirit in the man, Shall not be quickened to forever life.
That body and soul WILL receive exactly what it wanted; Separation from God.

That body and soul shall be destroyed and be remembered no more.
A lifeless body and lifeless soul FEELS no torments.

Fallen angel spirits (that can NOT DIE) SHALL be tormented forever, forever alive and forever separated from God.

But what about MEN who were AGAINST GOD......AND tried to convince others to BE AGAINST GOD?.......OR......Persecuted men FOR Believing IN the Lord God?

What is Gods VENGEANCE? Forever darkness?
 

Phoneman777

Well-Known Member
Jan 14, 2015
7,509
2,629
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I imagine that you are aware the same words and word forms are used to describe the everlasting life of the righteous as well as the everlasting torment of the wicked?

If the suffering of the wicked doesn't endure, then why interpret the life of the righteous to endure? Right? Both actually end?

Much love!
Good question. When taken together, the Bible teaches everlasting life for the saints, but death for the wicked, which is the cessation of life, not a continuation thereof.

The entirety of the confusion traces the root back to Genesis 2:7 KJV, or rather the refusal to acknowledge it. Here, we have clearly defined what is the relationship between the Spirit, Body, and Soul:

Body + Breath of Life = Living Soul

Conversely,
Body - Breath of Life = Dead Soul (nonexistent Soul)

How do we know? Well, if the Soul comes into existence ONLY as a consequence of the union of the Body and the Breath of Life, how can the Soul continue to exist after the disunion of these two occurs? IT CAN'T. Can light from a bulb continue to shine once the electric current is removed from it?

If we can simply come to terms with this truth, the rest of Scripture falls neatly into place, and we cease to read into many verses the false idea of "innate immortality of the soul" and accept the truth that God "alone hath immortality" and that only the righteous are granted immortality, because the righteous "seek for immortality" (which reason is they don't have it yet), while the wicked who do not seek it are not granted it, and thus are unable to be alive for all eternity in torment, but will burn up and out of existence, and their smoke will travel up and up "forever" like that of the oil wells in the distance from barren highways which seem to rise forever out of sight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
but death for the wicked, which is the cessation of life,
See . . . the Bible speaks of "death" differently than people do. God says the unsaved are dead. That when Adam ate from the tree he died. That Eternal Life is knowing God, and Jesus Christ. The body is dead because of sin.

There are so many places that tell us that death is separation, physical death, when the soul separates from the body. That's what people see, and it looks like a cessation, but the thing that ceases is activity in the flesh. The person will still stand before God to be judged. What we call "life" hasn't ceased, only the appearance of life in this realm has ceased.

We have passed from death into life in Jesus Christ, not as some "flowery jargon" to show how wonderful it is, but as a point of fact. An actual truth.

I think we need a proper understanding of what life and death really are to go on to properly understand more.

Much love!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TLHKAJ

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If we can simply come to terms with this truth, the rest of Scripture falls neatly into place, and we cease to read into many verses the false idea of "innate immortality of the soul" and accept the truth that God "alone hath immortality" and that only the righteous are granted immortality, because the righteous "seek for immortality" (which reason is they don't have it yet), while the wicked who do not seek it are not granted it, and thus are unable to be alive for all eternity in torment, but will burn up and out of existence, and their smoke will travel up and up "forever" like that of the oil wells in the distance from barren highways which seem to rise forever out of sight.
And this "soul" of the wicked . . . I saw the dead, great and small . . . this soul that will stand before God and be judged, I'm sorry, just how certain are you of the properties God embued it with when He created it? How do you know exactly it extinguishes the moment the body drops? Considering the many many places in the Bible that otherwise is shown, right up to this teaching/prophecy of "eternal torment"?

Calling those here now who do not know God, you cannot say they are alive in the Biblical sense of the word. They are dead. This is what needs to be understood.

So . . . I think we've found our point of impasse, the correct meaning of life and death.

Much love!
 

quietthinker

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2018
12,154
7,905
113
FNQ
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
See . . . the Bible speaks of "death" differently than people do. God says the unsaved are dead. That when Adam ate from the tree he died. That Eternal Life is knowing God, and Jesus Christ. The body is dead because of sin.

There are so many places that tell us that death is separation, physical death, when the soul separates from the body. That's what people see, and it looks like a cessation, but the thing that ceases is activity in the flesh. The person will still stand before God to be judged. What we call "life" hasn't ceased, only the appearance of life in this realm has ceased.

We have passed from death into life in Jesus Christ, not as some "flowery jargon" to show how wonderful it is, but as a point of fact. An actual truth.

I think we need a proper understanding of what life and death really are to go on to properly understand more.

Much love!
If one cannot understand the meanings of the words, 'life and death'; if one needs to do all manner of convoluted exercises to call death another form of life; if the straightforward pronouncement by God of 'thou shalt surely die' is given some other spin, how is it possible not to distort other parts of scripture which aren't as straight forward.
 
Last edited:

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If one cannot understand the meanings of of the words, life and death; if one needs to do all manner of convoluted exercise to call death another form of life; if the straightforward pronouncement by God of 'thou shalt surely die' is given some other spin, how is it possible to not distort other parts of scripture which are not as straight forward.
Well, that's what I'm trying to say!

:)

Life and death.

Did Adam die the day he ate from the forbidden tree, as God said he would? Or no? How do you answer that?

My answer is that Adam died that very same day, God not being a liar. Do you accept that is true?

Much love!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B. and TLHKAJ

quietthinker

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2018
12,154
7,905
113
FNQ
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Well, that's what I'm trying to say!

:)

Life and death.

Did Adam die the day he ate from the forbidden tree, as God said he would? Or no? How do you answer that?

My answer is that Adam died that very same day, God not being a liar. Do you accept that is true?

Much love!
I think Adam died emotionally and spiritually with physical death down the track. His ending resulting in Adam being dead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amadeus

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
22,617
31,850
113
80
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I think Adam died emotionally and spiritually with physical death down the track. His ending resulting in Adam being dead.
Notice that not Adam and not any other man made it to the end of a full day, if a day is equal to 1,000 years. What message, if any, is in that?
 

Phoneman777

Well-Known Member
Jan 14, 2015
7,509
2,629
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
See . . . the Bible speaks of "death" differently than people do. God says the unsaved are dead. That when Adam ate from the tree he died. That Eternal Life is knowing God, and Jesus Christ. The body is dead because of sin.
Yes, two kinds of death: physical and spiritual. Do you know that "spiritual death" is in the present tense, while physical death is always future? That's why the soul is not immortal - because "the soul that sinneth shall die", not live forever in immortal torment.
There are so many places that tell us that death is separation, physical death, when the soul separates from the body.
Genesis 2:7 KJV says the Soul exists only as a consequence of the union of the body and the breath of life. Sure, Rachel's "soul" was departing, but the word translated "soul" here refers not to "whole being", but to "life" as in "the life is in the blood". No where does the Bible say the soul is immortal...it says, "The soul that sinneth, it shall die".
That's what people see, and it looks like a cessation, but the thing that ceases is activity in the flesh.
So, when Solomon, Job, David, etc., all said the dead know nothing, hear nothing, see nothing, feel nothing, remember nothing, praise nothing, plan nothing, have nothing to do with this life or return back to this life...they just figured we were too stupid to look down at a dude with a cannonball stuck in his chest and conclude, "Yep, that dude's not thinking about anything or planning anything or praising God or can feel that cannonball" so they wrote all that, right?

Or...maybe they wrote that stuff because the first lie in Scripture is "thou shalt not surely die...oh, you'll be dead alright, but not surely dead...you'll still be alive but you'll be like GOD" and every heathen religion has taught since time immemorial the very same "immortal soul" doctrine you're trying to justify as "Biblical" here, friend?
The person will still stand before God to be judged. What we call "life" hasn't ceased, only the appearance of life in this realm has ceased. We have passed from death into life in Jesus Christ, not as some "flowery jargon" to show how wonderful it is, but as a point of fact. An actual truth. I think we need a proper understanding of what life and death really are to go on to properly understand more. Much love!
There isn't a single verse in Scripture that says the soul has innate immortality, that the dead are conscious, that the wicked will be tormented forever. There are only a handful of verses that are twisted out of their context or isolated from other verses which clearly teach the soul is subject to death unless God grants it immortality.

"The Rich Man and Lazarus"?
It's a parable which interpretation has nothing to do with what happens when we die.

"Absent from the body and present with the Lord"?
Yes, Paul wanted - but knew this would not be the case - to be absent from his mortal body, skip the "naked" and "unclothed" state of lying without a body in the grave dead awaiting the resurrection, and go straight to heaven with Jesus.

"Verily, I say unto thee....... today you will be with Me in paradise"?
Wrong, it's "Verily, I say unto thee today......you will be with me in paradise."

"tormented day and night...smoke of their torment ascendeth up forever and ever"?
"Forever" - Gr. "Aionios" - "duration", either undefined but not endless or undefined because endless.

"fire is not quenched"?
Jeremiah said Jerusalem will be burned with fire "that shall not be quenched" but is the fire still burning? It means "no one will be able to put the fire out" but such fires are well able to burn themselves out.

"worm dieth not"?
Jesus and Isaiah were referring to the Valley of Gehenna, the city dump, where the fire was kept burning and the maggots fed continually on the unburned carcasses. Worms are not immortal.

The Immoral Soul crowd literally has five or six "proof" texts shown here, but prefers them over the many many other texts which flatly teach man is not mortal, the dead are not conscious, and the wicked will pass out of existence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite

Phoneman777

Well-Known Member
Jan 14, 2015
7,509
2,629
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
And this "soul" of the wicked . . . I saw the dead, great and small . . . this soul that will stand before God and be judged, I'm sorry, just how certain are you of the properties God embued it with when He created it? How do you know exactly it extinguishes the moment the body drops? Considering the many many places in the Bible that otherwise is shown, right up to this teaching/prophecy of "eternal torment"?

Calling those here now who do not know God, you cannot say they are alive in the Biblical sense of the word. They are dead. This is what needs to be understood.

So . . . I think we've found our point of impasse, the correct meaning of life and death.

Much love!
I think if we can keep things simple, we are spared from confusion. It has been my experience that those of the Immortal Soul/Eternal Torment crowd flatly refuse to allow Genesis 2:7 KJV to be the foundation of their belief when it comes to the nature of man.

It's like those who teach Jesuit Futurist eschatology: they rigidly adhere to the doctrine which involves non-stop activity on Earth from here on out --- and refuse to acknowledge the many many verses which speak of a coming period of total destruction and desolation and emptiness and silence and darkness, etc.

I certainly can't force anyone to confront themselves with the whole of Scripture, but I do what I can do in my own sphere. Genesis 2:7 KJV forms the foundation of the nature of man, of what he is comprised, and thus how death affects him, and it is simply this:

The Soul comes into existence only as consequence of the union of the Body and the Breath (Spirit) of Life, and at death the Breath returns to God as it was, the Body to the Earth as it was, the Soul passes out of existence until either the one or the other of the two resurrections.

Why the objection to this inescapable conclusion? Other texts? Let's hear them, friend :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Or...maybe they wrote that stuff because the first lie in Scripture is "thou shalt not surely die...oh, you'll be dead alright, but not surely dead...you'll still be alive but you'll be like GOD" and every heathen religion has taught since time immemorial the very same "immortal soul" doctrine you're trying to justify as "Biblical" here, friend?
I'm the guy saying that on the day God said Adam would die, the day he ate from the forbidden tree, that he actually did in fact die, just like God said, and that the Biblical use of death is separation, not cessation. We don't need all this baggage on it, we just need to accept the simple statements when we are forming our ideas.

Adam died. Death is separation.

Much love!
 
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B. and post

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Why the objection to this inescapable conclusion? Other texts? Let's hear them, friend
My only suggestion should you truly want to experience my POV would be to read all the places that speak of death - All of them - and form an understanding of what death is that is applicable in EVERY case.

But I'm not trying to convince you, only point to what the Bible says.

Much love!
 
  • Like
Reactions: post

post

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2021
1,544
601
113
_
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
There is no teaching of an immortal soul in the Hebrew scriptures

**ahem**

And he cried unto the LORD, and said,
O LORD my God, hast Thou also brought evil upon the widow with whom I sojourn, by slaying her son?
And he stretched himself upon the child three times, and cried unto the LORD, and said,
O Lord my God, I pray Thee, let this child's soul come into him again!
And the LORD heard the voice of Elijah; and the soul of the child came into him again, and he revived.

(1 Kings 17:20-22)​
 
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B. and marks

marks

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2018
33,911
21,968
113
SoCal USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
**ahem**

And he cried unto the LORD, and said,
O LORD my God, hast Thou also brought evil upon the widow with whom I sojourn, by slaying her son?
And he stretched himself upon the child three times, and cried unto the LORD, and said,
O Lord my God, I pray Thee, let this child's soul come into him again!
And the LORD heard the voice of Elijah; and the soul of the child came into him again, and he revived.

(1 Kings 17:20-22)​
If the soul of the child returned, one must ask, from where? This is a good passage for this discusson!

Much love!
 
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B. and post

post

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2021
1,544
601
113
_
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Fallen angel spirits (that can NOT DIE)

why can't created beings like angels die?
who told you that?
why did you assume that?
Whose breath is the breath of life?
how many breaths of life are there?


define death and life as God defines it:

I AM The Life
(John 14:6)​

whoever does not have the Son does not have life
(1 John 5:12)
now, does Satan have Christ?
do unbelievers exist?
or are they temporary deceptions of your imagination?
if so who is temporarily deceiving you of their existence?
 
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B.

quietthinker

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2018
12,154
7,905
113
FNQ
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
If the soul of the child returned, one must ask, from where? This is a good passage for this discusson!

Much love!
'Soul' is used in the context of reinstatement of life. It is not making a case for the soul going anywhere.
When one makes the statement, 'John returned from insanity' ...it is not saying that insanity is a place as you are suggesting in your question of 'where has the soul returned from'. To assume that it is reveals lack of understanding.
 

post

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2021
1,544
601
113
_
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If we can simply come to terms with this truth, the rest of Scripture falls neatly into place

bahahahahahahahahah!!

o rly??

O LORD, thou hast brought up my soul from the grave
(Psalm 30:3)​
 

post

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2021
1,544
601
113
_
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
'Soul' is used in the context of reinstatement of life. It is not making a case for the soul going anywhere.

pardon me, but it is explicitly speaking of the soul continuing to exist apart from the separation of the spirit from the body, being an entity distinct from the body, and 'going somewhere' not once but twice.

'insanity' is an abstract & non-specific description of a temporary state of mind. the soul is not, not as the scripture describes it. the soul is a definite & non-physical 'thing' unique to a person.

i mean, if we believe it.
but maybe some of us don't.
((some of us clearly don't))

granted this doesn't have to be a point in Euclidean space -- we should hardly expect it is, because we are talking about a non-physical object. but the soul clearly can occupy a physical object ((the body)) even though it is itself non-physical.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: L.A.M.B.