Did Jesus return around 70 AD?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Christ's audience standing in front of Him in Matthew 16:27-28 included more than just the disciples.
You need to read all 3 accounts. When He was speaking in Matthew 16:27-28 He was talking specifically to the disciples.

Read the parallel account of this entire speech in Mark 8:34 through Mark 9:1. "And when he had called THE PEOPLE unto him with his disciples ALSO, he said unto them..." Christ continued speaking to THE PEOPLE along with His disciples when He said in Mark 9:1, "Verily I say unto you, that there be some of them that stand here which shall not taste of death till they have seen the kingdom of God come with power."
No. He said that only to the disciples. He was speaking of them specifically there.

Read the account from Luke 9...

Luke 9:18 And it happened, as He was alone praying, that His disciples joined Him, and He asked them, saying, “Who do the crowds say that I am?” 19 So they answered and said, “John the Baptist, but some say Elijah; and others say that one of the old prophets has risen again.” 20 He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Peter answered and said, “The Christ of God.” 21 And He strictly warned and commanded them to tell this to no one, 22 saying, “The Son of Man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and be raised the third day.” 23 Then He said to them all, “If anyone desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow Me. 24 For whoever desires to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for My sake will save it. 25 For what profit is it to a man if he gains the whole world, and is himself destroyed or lost? 26 For whoever is ashamed of Me and My words, of him the Son of Man will be ashamed when He comes in His own glory, and in His Father’s, and of the holy angels. 27 But I tell you truly, there are some standing here who shall not taste death till they see the kingdom of God.”

Verse 18 follows the account of feeding the five thousand with the five loaves and two fish. Yes, they were still in the vicinity, but in the passage above He was talking specifically to the disciples who were gathered around Him separate from the rest of the people who were in the vicinity. Notice verse 18 says Jesus was alone praying, so He had gone away from the crowd at that point and disciples joined Him. This was in a separate place from the crowd that Jesus had fed. Keep reading from verse 18 and you can see that when Jesus said "But I tell you truly, there are some standing here who shall not taste death till they see the kingdom of God" He was talking to and about the disciples specifically there.

This is the same speech of Matthew 16:27-28, where Matthew records the added detail of Christ coming in the glory of His Father with His angels to give rewards to all according to their works when He came in His kingdom. Only some of that whole crowd of people with His disciples also would still be alive to see His return. Most would have died by then. Again, this death of the majority of the crowd of people standing in front of Jesus at that moment was NOT referring to the Mount of Transfiguration some six days later.
You are mistaken. He was only talking about the disciples there and He was not implying that some would be dead and some would be alive when He came again. That is your false assumption. He was simply saying that, despite what they may have thought, some of them (Peter, James and John) would indeed to get a glimpse of Him in power and glory before they died. And they did at His transfiguration.

See the above text of Mark 8:34 through Mark 9:1. It was a crowd of people standing in front of Christ PLUS the disciples also.
Why did you not look at the Luke 9 account which makes it clear that Jesus was talking to the disciples separately from the crowd when He said some of them would see the kingdom of God and Him in power?

The New Jerusalem's tree of life in Revelation 22:2 with its leaves intended for "the healing of the nations" is most definitely speaking of the healing of sins.
It most definitely is not. There will be no more death when the NHNE is ushered in, which implies no more sin.

Isaiah spoke of the New Jerusalem in Is. 33:24, saying, "the inhabitant shall not say, I am sick: for the people that dwell therein shall be forgiven their iniquity." Healing of the nations by the leaves of the tree of life is most definitely connected with one being forgiven of their iniquities. This means there are still sinners in need of healing in the NHNE.
You are mistaken. About many things.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Nonsense. All of scripture has to be taken into account to establish context. You have no clue of how to properly interpret scripture. None.
There’s a difference between reading one’s framework into a passage prior to deriving meaning from the passage within its own context (eisegesis) VERSUS deriving meaning from a passage within its own context and seeing how that aligns with a broader framework (exegesis)

You seem not to know the difference

We should do that AND consider the rest of scripture as well to ensure we are not causing contradictions in scripture. What is hard to understand about this?

But you are not doing that. Your external framework is first being applied in order to argue that revelation 20 is recapitulation, since you already admitted internal context can’t determine recapitulation. That’s literally classic eisesegis.

I asked Gemini: “would it be exegesis or eisegesis to apply external framework in order to argue revelation 20 is recapitulation without deriving that meaning from the text”

Answer:
“Applying a rigid external theological system to force a specific reading onto Revelation 20 is generally considered eisegesis, whereas identifying literary patterns from within the text itself is exegesis. The distinction hinges entirely on whether the framework is imposed upon the text or derived from it.

Eisegesis:
"My theological system cannot allow a literal thousand-year reign on earth after Christ returns, so I will label chapter 20 as 'recapitulation' to make the problem go away."




Of course not.

Exactly! But that’s what you are doing with revelation 20. It’s mind boggling you can’t see that.

We have to look at everything and not make assumptions just based on a few similarities. But, you say that is eisegesis. What a joke. You are actually criticizing me for saying we have to be very diligent by looking at all of scripture and you try to say, no, we just need to look at the context of verses or passages in isolation from the rest of scripture. What nonsense.
Strawman. I’m not criticizing you for looking at a broader theological context. I’m criticizing your eisegesis of claiming revelation chapter 20 is recapitulation, not from internal contextual evidence, but because your external framework demands it.

Proper exegesis should be determining revelation 20 is recapitulation within its own internal context before applying it to a broader framework. But you l’ve already admitted you can’t do that.

You never indicate that you think it is important. You act as if the context can always be determined within any given verse or passage without the consideration of other scripture, but that is not always the case.

Seriously? I’m literally skeptical of 2 peter and revelation. How does that not scream evaluating passages in their own context and then seeing how that fits with a broader framework.

I have never said that it should.

You did with revelation 20 and determining whether it’s recapitulation or not

Yes, they are, if we're talking about frameworks in the sense of taking all of scripture into account to ensure there are no contradictions. You can't just interpret any given passage without taking the rest of scripture into account.

I agree that all of Scripture should inform our interpretation of individual passages. That's not what I'm disputing. The question is whether you're allowing the immediate literary and historical context to establish the meaning of a passage, or whether you're imposing a theological framework upon it beforehand and reinterpreting its language to accommodate that framework.

There's a significant difference between allowing Scripture to interpret Scripture and allowing a preconceived theological system to dictate what scripture is permitted to mean. You seem to be doing the latter, which can result in eisegesis.

Nonsense. You obviously don't believe in the concept of interpreting scripture with scripture, but that is very important. Sometimes you can't fully establish proper contextual exegesis of a given passage without bringing other scripture into consideration.

Strawman. I just don’t agree with your eisegetical method.

It's a vague reference. How would you even know if that was the case or not? We don't know what that even means for certain because no details regarding it were given. I tend to relate it to Satan's little season, but there's no real way of proving that.
Says you. That's your assumption. You like to talk about exegesis, but here you are basing an opinion on an assumption with no exegesis at all.
LOL! You can't be serious! It was Jesus Himself who made the claim! Are you saying you're skeptical of Jesus? My goodness, I cannot believe you are for real. Maybe I should just assume that you're not.

I’m skeptical of revelation, therefore I’m skeptical if Jesus made the claim.

“10Because you have kept My command to persevere, I will also keep you from the hour of testing that is about to come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth. 11I am coming soon.d”


If we try to exegete it:

dating 95 ad. Authorship: someone named John (doesn’t claim to be apostle). Audience: church of Philadelphia in Asia. Surrounding context: warnings and commands to Churches in Asia/Christ is coming soon. Content: because the church of Philadelphia’s keeping of the commandments, they will be kept from hour of trial on the entire earth.

Ok, so John writes to the church of Philadelphia in Asia, around 95 ad, that they will be kept from a world wide hour of trial that will test the whole earth.

Now Let’s apply this to a broader framework, what world wide “trial” do gospels and epistles refer to if any?

The Preterist framework fails due to the belief that any “world wide hour of trial “ such as described in the OD was related to pre 70ad leading up to 70ad.

What broader framework does a futurist Amil apply this to ?

They had no reason to be. There's nothing written in the book that contradicts anything else in scripture. There are no prophecies in it that failed to be fulfilled as you try to claim. I can't deal with you anymore. You are very annoying. I don't want to discuss these things anymore with someone who doesn't even believe that the book of Revelation and the book of 2nd Peter are canon. It's a total waste of time. Your beliefs are based on a different Bible than the one I use.


They had plenty of reason to be and There are plenty of contradictions within the book.

But I understand when faced with information that can be difficult to process or conflicts with your worldview, that you often rely on ad hominems.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
There’s a difference between reading one’s framework into a passage prior to deriving meaning from the passage within its own context (eisegesis) VERSUS deriving meaning from a passage within its own context and seeing how that aligns with a broader framework (exegesis)

You seem not to know the difference
You seem not to know how important it is to not cause contradictions in scripture. You seem to think it makes sense to interpret passages in isolation from the rest of scripture.

But you are not doing that. Your external framework is first being applied in order to argue that revelation 20 is recapitulation, since you already admitted internal context can’t determine recapitulation. That’s literally classic eisesegis.

I asked Gemini: “would it be exegesis or eisegesis to apply external framework in order to argue revelation 20 is recapitulation without deriving that meaning from the text”

Answer:
“Applying a rigid external theological system to force a specific reading onto Revelation 20 is generally considered eisegesis, whereas identifying literary patterns from within the text itself is exegesis. The distinction hinges entirely on whether the framework is imposed upon the text or derived from it.

Eisegesis:
"My theological system cannot allow a literal thousand-year reign on earth after Christ returns, so I will label chapter 20 as 'recapitulation' to make the problem go away."
Are you suggesting that it's exegesis to assume that what is written in Revelation 19 and 20 is chronological from beginning to end? If so, then you clearly have no clue about exegesis. Exegesis takes into account the genre of text within the book of Revelation and how the book is formatted. It clearly is not chronological throughout, with the clearest example of this being what is written at the end of Revelation 11 and beginning of Revelation 12. Obviously, Jesus was not born and did not ascend to heaven before the seventh trumpet sounded.

Exactly! But that’s what you are doing with revelation 20. It’s mind boggling you can’t see that.
I honestly could not care less what you find to be mind boggling. It boggles my mind that you would even take any time discussing the book of Revelation when you don't even believe it belongs in the canon.

Strawman. I’m not criticizing you for looking at a broader theological context. I’m criticizing your eisegesis of claiming revelation chapter 20 is recapitulation, not from internal contextual evidence, but because your external framework demands it.
Why is that something to be critical about? Yes, my examination and understanding of all scripture influences how I understand Revelation 20, but so what? There is no "internal contextual evidence" that prevents the possibility of recapitulation in Revelation 20.

Proper exegesis should be determining revelation 20 is recapitulation within its own internal context before applying it to a broader framework. But you l’ve already admitted you can’t do that.
No one can determine for certain what Revelation 20 means without the aid of other scripture. Why can't you understand that? It's impossible to exegete Revelation 20 in the way that you are demanding.

Seriously?
Do I come across as if I'm joking with you about this? Yes, seriously.

I’m literally skeptical of 2 peter and revelation.
You have no reason to be.

I agree that all of Scripture should inform our interpretation of individual passages. That's not what I'm disputing.
Okay, you agree with that. Good enough for me. I'm not wasting any more time debating with you about what is exegesis and what isn't. I know there is nothing wrong with the way I go about interpreting scripture and you can't change my mind about that.

The question is whether you're allowing the immediate literary and historical context to establish the meaning of a passage, or whether you're imposing a theological framework upon it beforehand and reinterpreting its language to accommodate that framework.
Is there something wrong with seeing many passages that indicate that Jesus began reigning after His resurrection and bringing that understanding into a passage like Revelation 20 that speaks about Jesus reigning in order to determine the timing of the passage? Revelation 20 itself is not specific about the timing, so why not allow other scripture to help determine that?

There's a significant difference between allowing Scripture to interpret Scripture and allowing a preconceived theological system to dictate what scripture is permitted to mean.
I don't think you even know the difference between those things.

You seem to be doing the latter, which can result in eisegesis.
You seem to not know what you're talking about, as usual.

Strawman. I just don’t agree with your eisegetical method.
That means nothing to me.

I’m skeptical of revelation, therefore I’m skeptical if Jesus made the claim.

“10Because you have kept My command to persevere, I will also keep you from the hour of testing that is about to come upon the whole world, to test those who dwell on the earth. 11I am coming soon.d”
You need to learn what the Greek word "tachy" (Strong's G5035). It means immediately. Quickly. Do you think Jesus was intending to say that He was coming immediately after He said that? Of course not. What that means is that once He does come, which He hasn't yet, He will come quickly. As quickly as lightning flashes from the east to the west (Matthew 24:27). He's coming will be unexpected as a thief in the night (1 Thess 5:2-3, 2 Peter 3:10-12, Rev 16:15). It will happen very quickly with no one even having time to react.

If we try to exegete it:

dating 95 ad. Authorship: someone named John (doesn’t claim to be apostle). Audience: church of Philadelphia in Asia. Surrounding context: warnings and commands to Churches in Asia/Christ is coming soon. Content: because the church of Philadelphia’s keeping of the commandments, they will be kept from hour of trial on the entire earth.

Ok, so John writes to the church of Philadelphia in Asia, around 95 ad, that they will be kept from a world wide hour of trial that will test the whole earth.

Now Let’s apply this to a broader framework, what world wide “trial” do gospels and epistles refer to if any?
Some translations say "hour of temptation". I believe it could be referring to Satan's little season. To the time of unrestrained wickedness that Paul wrote about in 2 Thess 2:3-12 that will occur before Jesus returns. But, we just don't know for sure because it's a vague reference with no added details given about it. To conclude that it was a false prophecy because it didn't happen is ludicrous.

They had plenty of reason to be and There are plenty of contradictions within the book.
You are clueless. There are no contradictions within the book at all. Your lack understanding of the book is not a reason to make false accusations that it contains contradictions.

But I understand when faced with information that can be difficult to process or conflicts with your worldview, that you often rely on ad hominems.
Nothing you're saying is difficult to process at all. Your way of looking at scripture is completely off base.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You seem not to know how important it is to not cause contradictions in scripture. You seem to think it makes sense to interpret passages in isolation from the rest of scripture.
Red herring. Your entire premise about contradictions is moot if it requires you to perform eisegesis.

The whole point was how you are personally determining whether revelation 20 is recapitulation. You stated external framework, as internal context cannot demonstrate it. That’s literally the definition of eisegesis.

Honestly, you should probably figure out an internal contextual argument for your position, since you don’t have one yet. This would alleviate your need for eisegesis.

Are you suggesting that it's exegesis to assume that what is written in Revelation 19 and 20 is chronological from beginning to end? If so, then you clearly have no clue about exegesis. Exegesis takes into account the genre of text within the book of Revelation and how the book is formatted. It clearly is not chronological throughout, with the clearest example of this being what is written at the end of Revelation 11 and beginning of Revelation 12. Obviously, Jesus was not born and did not ascend to heaven before the seventh trumpet sounded.

Wrong again. I’ve never said to “assume” chronological continuation. I understand Jewish apocalyptic contains recapitulations as literary elements, while also containing chronological continuations at times as well. BUT whether something is a recapitulation or not should be derived from the internal context itself and NOT external framework. Claiming something is recapitulation solely because the alternative doesn’t fit with an external framework is literally the definition of eisegesis.



I honestly could not care less what you find to be mind boggling. It boggles my mind that you would even take any time discussing the book of Revelation when you don't even believe it belongs in the canon.
Red herring. This doesn’t address your double standard on when things are only similar and when things are fulfillment of a broader theological framework.

Why is that something to be critical about? Yes, my examination and understanding of all scripture influences how I understand Revelation 20, but so what? There is no "internal contextual evidence" that prevents the possibility of recapitulation in Revelation 20.

because it’s eisegesis, which is an improper interpretation method.

And now your argument is “No evidence that prevents possibility”? A formal fallacy known as argument from ignorance.

Don’t be surprised that I don’t agree with you interpretation method, since it has been relying on eisegesis, strawmans, red herrings, and now arguments from ignorance. What a house of cards.

But to counter, there is internal contextual evidence that revelation 20 is not likely recapitulation: revelation 20:10. The beast and false prophet are already in the lake of fire. When were they thrown in? Chapter 19. In other words, the chronology of chapter 19 and 20:

1.) Christ comes on his horse to defeat beast and false prophet and throws them into the LOF
2.) the dragon is bound for 1000 years.
3.) the souls of martyred saints who were killed by the beast are RESURRECTED to reign with Christ
4.) after 1000 years the dragon is loosed to make war in the saints
5.) the dragon is defeated and thrown into the LOF, WHERE THE BEAST AND FALSE PROPHETS ALREADY ARE.

Do I come across as if I'm joking with you about this? Yes, seriously.

You often do, with all the “lols” and ad hominems.

Okay, you agree with that. Good enough for me. I'm not wasting any more time debating with you about what is exegesis and what isn't. I know there is nothing wrong with the way I go about interpreting scripture and you can't change my mind about that.

Good to know you prefer eisegesis in order to uphold your framework.

Is there something wrong with seeing many passages that indicate that Jesus began reigning after His resurrection and bringing that understanding into a passage like Revelation 20 that speaks about Jesus reigning in order to determine the timing of the passage? Revelation 20 itself is not specific about the timing, so why not allow other scripture to help determine that?

Revelation 20 does NOT say that it’s the beginning of Christs reign. That’s another of your imposing framework assumptions.

Additionally, Revelation 20 states the dead souls and martyrs are resurrected to live and reign with Christ. Lexically, the BDAG and thayer’s lexicon define “they lived” as resurrection from physical death to physical life.

But I know, I know, you don’t care about evidence that directly contradicts your eisegetical method.

don't think you even know the difference between those things.

Ok good, so you recognize imposing a theological framework over a text prior to understanding it in its internal context is literally the definition of eisegesis?

I plugged that question into google ai:

Gemini:
“Spot on. By definition, eisegesis (from the Greek eis- "into" + hēgeisthai "to lead") is the practice of reading one's own presuppositions, biases, or external theological systems into a text, rather than drawing meaning out of it (exegesis).

When an external framework acts as a filter before the text is allowed to speak on its own terms—accounting for its grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context—the text stops being an independent voice and becomes a mirror for whatever system the reader already holds.”

You seem to not know what you're talking about, as usual.

nice generic statement. It’s clear you are unfamiliar with what eisegesis vs exegesis means.

Here’s gemeni’s response again:

“Spot on. By definition, eisegesis (from the Greek eis- "into" + hēgeisthai "to lead") is the practice of reading one's own presuppositions, biases, or external theological systems into a text, rather than drawing meaning out of it (exegesis).

When an external framework acts as a filter before the text is allowed to speak on its own terms—accounting for its grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context—the text stops being an independent voice and becomes a mirror for whatever system the reader already holds.”

You need to learn what the Greek word "tachy" (Strong's G5035). It means immediately. Quickly. Do you think Jesus was intending to say that He was coming immediately after He said that? Of course not. What that means is that once He does come, which He hasn't yet, He will come quickly. As quickly as lightning flashes from the east to the west (Matthew 24:27). He's coming will be unexpected as a thief in the night (1 Thess 5:2-3, 2 Peter 3:10-12, Rev 16:15). It will happen very quickly with no one even having time to react.

Red herring. The point wasn’t about soon vs quickly. I simply had the ESV translation open which has “soon”. Quickly is also a possible translation. But I understand you’re grasping at anything to try to counter.

Some translations say "hour of temptation". I believe it could be referring to Satan's little season. To the time of unrestrained wickedness that Paul wrote about in 2 Thess 2:3-12 that will occur before Jesus returns. But, we just don't know for sure because it's a vague reference with no added details given about it. To conclude that it was a false prophecy because it didn't happen is ludicrous.
So you believe Satan’s little season occurred around 95ad, which the church of Philadelphia was kept from for keeping God commands?

You are clueless. There are no contradictions within the book at all. Your lack understanding of the book is not a reason to make false accusations that it contains contradictions

Says the guy who prefers eisegesis to keep his framework afloat.

Nothing you're saying is difficult to process at all. Your way of looking at scripture is completely off base.

“Or conflicts with your worldview”.

Oh Well, at least you’re not denying the ad hominems.
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
What broader framework does a futurist Amil apply this to ?
I would be considered myse an Amil futurist, here's my take on the hour of the earth's temptation

God's plagues upon the wicked world will passover the Church on earth, those that have been sealed by God the Holy Spirit won't be harmed, Eph 1:13, 4:30

The future 42 month great tribulation in plagues brought by the (Two Witnesses) will be a complete remake of Moses/Aaron against Pharaoh of Egypt, and God's Church on earth will be protected

Exodus 12:12-13KJV
12 For I will pass through the land of Egypt this night, and will smite all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, both man and beast; and against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgment: I am the Lord.
13 And the blood shall be to you for a token upon the houses where ye are: and when I see the blood, I will pass over you, and the plague shall not be upon you to destroy you, when I smite the land of Egypt.

Revelation 9:4KJV
4 And it was commanded them that they should not hurt the grass of the earth, neither any green thing, neither any tree; but only those men which have not the seal of God in their foreheads.

Revelation 22:4KJV
4 And they shall see his face; and his name shall be in their foreheads.

Gods Divine protection of the Church on earth during the tribulation, the hour of earths temptation

The Church on earth is instructed to enter their dwelling, until the Lords indignation is past, just like the passover in Egypt

Isaiah 26:20-21KJV
20 Come, my people, enter thou into thy chambers, and shut thy doors about thee: hide thyself as it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast.
21 For, behold, the Lord cometh out of his place to punish the inhabitants of the earth for their iniquity: the earth also shall disclose her blood, and shall no more cover her slain.

Revelation 3:10KJV
10 Because thou hast kept the word of my patience, I also will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.
 
Last edited:

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
1.) Christ comes on his horse to defeat beast and false prophet and throws them into the LOF
Agree, the second coming and final judgement of all
2.) the dragon is bound for 1000 years.
Satan is bound from deceiving the nations to battle and nothing more, thousand years shows its in the Lord's spiritual having no literal earthly time

3.) the souls of martyred saints who were killed by the beast are RESURRECTED to reign with Christ
False, there is one future resurrection of all and it takes place on (The Last Day)
4.) after 1000 years the dragon is loosed to make war in the saints
False, no literal 1,000 year Kingdom will take place on this earth, it's a fabricated fairy tale of man found no place in scripture
5.) the dragon is defeated and thrown into the LOF, WHERE THE BEAST AND FALSE PROPHETS ALREADY ARE.
Yes this takes place at the second coming and final judgement, Satan is the last mentioned because he's death, the last enemy to be destroyed
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I would be considered myse an Amil futurist, here's my take on the hour of the earth's temptation

God's plagues upon the wicked world will passover the Church on earth, those that have been sealed by God the Holy Spirit won't be harmed, Eph 1:13, 4:30

The future 42 month great tribulation in plagues brought by the (Two Witnesses) will be a complete remake of Moses/Aaron against Pharaoh of Egypt, and God's Church on earth will be protected

Exodus 12:12-13KJV
12 For I will pass through the land of Egypt this night, and will smite all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, both man and beast; and against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgment: I am the Lord.
13 And the blood shall be to you for a token upon the houses where ye are: and when I see the blood, I will pass over you, and the plague shall not be upon you to destroy you, when I smite the land of Egypt.

Revelation 9:4KJV
4 And it was commanded them that they should not hurt the grass of the earth, neither any green thing, neither any tree; but only those men which have not the seal of God in their foreheads.

Revelation 22:4KJV
4 And they shall see his face; and his name shall be in their foreheads.

Gods Divine protection of the Church on earth during the tribulation, the hour of earths temptation

The Church on earth is instructed to enter their dwelling, until the Lords indignation is past, just like the passover in Egypt

Isaiah 26:20-21KJV
20 Come, my people, enter thou into thy chambers, and shut thy doors about thee: hide thyself as it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast.
21 For, behold, the Lord cometh out of his place to punish the inhabitants of the earth for their iniquity: the earth also shall disclose her blood, and shall no more cover her slain.

Revelation 3:10KJV
10 Because thou hast kept the word of my patience, I also will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.

Ok, so you believe the church in Philadelphia was kept from this around 95ad?
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Agree, the second coming and final judgement of all

Satan is bound from deceiving the nations to battle and nothing more, thousand years shows its in the Lord's spiritual having no literal earthly time


False, there is one future resurrection of all and it takes place on (The Last Day)

False, no literal 1,000 year Kingdom will take place on this earth, it's a fabricated fairy tale of man found no place in scripture

Yes this takes place at the second coming and final judgement, Satan is the last mentioned because he's death, the last enemy to be destroyed

You incorrectly understood my point. I’m talking about the chronology of the narrative PRIOR to theological interpretation.

It’s not false that martyred and beheaded souls of the saints are resurrected to life from death in narrative of revelation 20.

It’s not false that these resurrected saints reign for 1000 years in the narrative of revelation 20.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Red herring. Your entire premise about contradictions is moot if it requires you to perform eisegesis.

The whole point was how you are personally determining whether revelation 20 is recapitulation. You stated external framework, as internal context cannot demonstrate it. That’s literally the definition of eisegesis.

Honestly, you should probably figure out an internal contextual argument for your position, since you don’t have one yet. This would alleviate your need for eisegesis.



Wrong again. I’ve never said to “assume” chronological continuation. I understand Jewish apocalyptic contains recapitulations as literary elements, while also containing chronological continuations at times as well. BUT whether something is a recapitulation or not should be derived from the internal context itself and NOT external framework. Claiming something is recapitulation solely because the alternative doesn’t fit with an external framework is literally the definition of eisegesis.




Red herring. This doesn’t address your double standard on when things are only similar and when things are fulfillment of a broader theological framework.



because it’s eisegesis, which is an improper interpretation method.

And now your argument is “No evidence that prevents possibility”? A formal fallacy known as argument from ignorance.

Don’t be surprised that I don’t agree with you interpretation method, since it has been relying on eisegesis, strawmans, red herrings, and now arguments from ignorance. What a house of cards.

But to counter, there is internal contextual evidence that revelation 20 is not likely recapitulation: revelation 20:10. The beast and false prophet are already in the lake of fire. When were they thrown in? Chapter 19. In other words, the chronology of chapter 19 and 20:

1.) Christ comes on his horse to defeat beast and false prophet and throws them into the LOF
2.) the dragon is bound for 1000 years.
3.) the souls of martyred saints who were killed by the beast are RESURRECTED to reign with Christ
4.) after 1000 years the dragon is loosed to make war in the saints
5.) the dragon is defeated and thrown into the LOF, WHERE THE BEAST AND FALSE PROPHETS ALREADY ARE.



You often do, with all the “lols” and ad hominems.



Good to know you prefer eisegesis in order to uphold your framework.



Revelation 20 does NOT say that it’s the beginning of Christs reign. That’s another of your imposing framework assumptions.

Additionally, Revelation 20 states the dead souls and martyrs are resurrected to live and reign with Christ. Lexically, the BDAG and thayer’s lexicon define “they lived” as resurrection from physical death to physical life.

But I know, I know, you don’t care about evidence that directly contradicts your eisegetical method.



Ok good, so you recognize imposing a theological framework over a text prior to understanding it in its internal context is literally the definition of eisegesis?

I plugged that question into google ai:

Gemini:
“Spot on. By definition, eisegesis (from the Greek eis- "into" + hēgeisthai "to lead") is the practice of reading one's own presuppositions, biases, or external theological systems into a text, rather than drawing meaning out of it (exegesis).

When an external framework acts as a filter before the text is allowed to speak on its own terms—accounting for its grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context—the text stops being an independent voice and becomes a mirror for whatever system the reader already holds.”



nice generic statement. It’s clear you are unfamiliar with what eisegesis vs exegesis means.

Here’s gemeni’s response again:

“Spot on. By definition, eisegesis (from the Greek eis- "into" + hēgeisthai "to lead") is the practice of reading one's own presuppositions, biases, or external theological systems into a text, rather than drawing meaning out of it (exegesis).

When an external framework acts as a filter before the text is allowed to speak on its own terms—accounting for its grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context—the text stops being an independent voice and becomes a mirror for whatever system the reader already holds.”



Red herring. The point wasn’t about soon vs quickly. I simply had the ESV translation open which has “soon”. Quickly is also a possible translation. But I understand you’re grasping at anything to try to counter.


So you believe Satan’s little season occurred around 95ad, which the church of Philadelphia was kept from for keeping God commands?



Says the guy who prefers eisegesis to keep his framework afloat.



“Or conflicts with your worldview”.

Oh Well, at least you’re not denying the ad hominems.
With all the supposed exegesis that you think you are doing, you still don't understand scripture at all. How does that happen? When scripture contradicts your beliefs then you resort to claiming that it's not legitimate scripture like in the case of the book of 2nd Peter and the book of Revelation. I've never said that a text's "grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context" should not be taken into account, but at the same time our interpretations of any given text should not contradict any other text in scripture. My approach is to allow clear, straightforward scriptures to form the foundation of our doctrine that helps us understand more difficult scriptures like we find in the book of Revelation.

Scripture is very clear that Jesus began reigning after His resurrection (Matthew 28:16-18, Ephesians 1:19-23, Revelation 1:5-6) with His followers being made His priests (1 Peter 2:5-9, Revelation 1:5-6). Scripture talks about the tremendous affect that Christ's ministry, death and resurrection and the preaching of the gospel of Christ has had on Satan (Hebrews 2:14-15, 1 John 3:8, Acts 26:18, etc.). Scripture is clear that all of the dead will be resurrected at generally the same hour/time (Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29, Acts 24:15). Scripture is clear that all people will be judged at the same time (Matt 13:40-43, Matt 13:47-50, Matt 25:31-46). So, if you want to say that I'm using eisegesis to bring that information into my study of the highly symbolic book of Revelation, so be it. I couldn't care less. Meanwhile, you will continue believing all of the falsehood that you believe because interpreting scripture with scripture, spiritual discernment from the Holy Spirit and the consideration of ALL scripture while being careful to avoid contradictions is not part of your interpretive approach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Truth7t7

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
With all the supposed exegesis that you think you are doing, you still don't understand scripture at all. How does that happen? When scripture contradicts your beliefs then you resort to claiming that it's not legitimate scripture like in the case of the book of 2nd Peter and the book of Revelation. I've never said that a text's "grammar, literary genre, historical setting, and immediate context" should not be taken into account, but at the same time our interpretations of any given text should not contradict any other text in scripture. My approach is to allow clear, straightforward scriptures to form the foundation of our doctrine that helps us understand more difficult scriptures like we find in the book of Revelation.
So, if you want to say that I'm using eisegesis to bring that information into my study of the highly symbolic book of Revelation, so be it. I couldn't care less. Meanwhile, you will continue believing all of the falsehood that you believe because interpreting scripture with scripture, spiritual discernment from the Holy Spirit and the consideration of ALL scripture while being careful to avoid contradictions is not part of your interpretive approach.

If your framework is correct about recapitulating revelation 20, you shouldn’t need to rely on eisegesis, especially if you are trying to debate premils on it.

Scripture is very clear that Jesus began reigning after His resurrection (Matthew 28:16-18, Ephesians 1:19-23, Revelation 1:5-6) with His followers being made His priests (1 Peter 2:5-9, Revelation 1:5-6). Scripture talks about the tremendous affect that Christ's ministry, death and resurrection and the preaching of the gospel of Christ has had on Satan (Hebrews 2:14-15, 1 John 3:8, Acts 26:18, etc.). Scripture is clear that all of the dead will be resurrected at generally the same hour/time (Daniel 12:1-2, John 5:28-29, Acts 24:15). Scripture is clear that all people will be judged at the same time (Matt 13:40-43, Matt 13:47-50, Matt 25:31-46)
Agreed
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Ok, so you believe the church in Philadelphia was kept from this around 95ad?
No I believe that the hour of earth's temptation is future, and it takes place close to the Lord's second coming (The End) future unfulfilled
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
No I believe that the hour of earth's temptation is future, and it takes place close to the Lord's second coming (The End) future unfulfilled

How can it be still future, if it is was described as “about to be” and that the church of Philadelphia was promised to be kept from it for obeying God’s commands
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
It’s not false that martyred and beheaded souls of the saints are resurrected to life from death in narrative of revelation 20.

It’s not false that these resurrected saints reign for 1000 years in the narrative of revelation 20.

Revelation 20:1-6 Isnt A Millennial Kingdom On This Earth, Dont Be Deceived​


Can you find the things claimed by those teaching a Literal 1,000 year Millennial Kingdom On This Earth in Revelation 20:1-6 below?

1.) Physical Earthly Kingdom?
2.) Physical Earthly Throne?
3.) Physical Mortal Humans?

The Above Claims (Don't Exist)

Revelation 20:1-6 Is 100% In The Lords (Spiritual) Angel, Heaven, Devil, Satan, The Souls, The Dead, God, Christ

100% Spiritual Realm, No "Literal" Time

2 Peter 3:8KJV
8 But, beloved, be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.

Revelation 20:1-6KJV
1 And I saw an angel come down from heaven, having the key of the bottomless pit and a great chain in his hand.
2 And he laid hold on the dragon, that old serpent, which is the Devil, and Satan, and bound him a thousand years,
3 And cast him into the bottomless pit, and shut him up, and set a seal upon him, that he should deceive the nations no more, till the thousand years should be fulfilled: and after that he must be loosed a little season.
4 And I saw thrones, and they sat upon them, and judgment was given unto them: and I saw the souls of them that were beheaded for the witness of Jesus, and for the word of God, and which had not worshipped the beast, neither his image, neither had received his mark upon their foreheads, or in their hands; and they lived and reigned with Christ a thousand years.
5 But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
6 Blessed and holy is he that hath part in the first resurrection: on such the second death hath no power, but they shall be priests of God and of Christ, and shall reign with him a thousand years.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If your framework is correct about recapitulating revelation 20, you shouldn’t need to rely on eisegesis, especially if you are trying to debate premils on it.
I rely on showing what scripture as a whole teaches, which you call eisegesis. Even though that's the only real way to determine what Revelation 20 is about since it is highly symbolic and not just clear, straightforward, literal scripture. If you can't rely on clear scripture to help understand more difficult scripture, then no one can prove anything in relation to Revelation 20.

claninja said:
So, why can't you take what is taught in those other scriptures, which you agree teach that Jesus began reigning after His resurrection, etc. to help in understanding what Revelation 20 is about?
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
It’s not false that martyred and beheaded souls of the saints are resurrected to life from death in narrative of revelation 20.

It’s not false that these resurrected saints reign for 1000 years in the narrative of revelation 20.
Revelation 20:1-6 is seen in the Lord's eternal spiritual realm where no literal earthly time exist, many in "Error" want to take this eternal spiritual "Thousand Years" and apply it to a Literal Kingdom on this earth "False"

As seen below In 2 Peter 3:8 is it one literal earthly day with the Lord, or 1,000 literal earthly years?

It's neither, it's doing nothing more than explaining to the reader that literal earthly time doesn't exist in the Lord's eternal realm, it's that simple

Yes the Lord's eternal could be expressed to the human mind that "One Day" is a "Trillion Years" expressing "Eternal"

2 Peter 3:8KJV
8 But, beloved, be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,788
4,305
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
How can it be still future, if it is was described as “about to be” and that the church of Philadelphia was promised to be kept from it for obeying God’s commands
The seven churches are representative of the churches today, Philadelphia is faithful and true, inside buildings that call themselves "Church" can be found all the types of the seven churches and their spiritual conditions, not everybody in the megachurch buildings belongs to the Philadelphian church type

The scripture is straight forward in explanation, the church of Philadelphia today and in the future is walking pleasing to the Lord, he has promised them protection from the future hour of earths temptation

You completely ignored the timing as given in verse 11, and it takes place close to the Lord's second coming thats seen (Behold I Come Quickly) "Future"

Revelation 3:10-11KJN
10 Because thou hast kept the word of my patience, I also will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.
11 Behold, I come quickly: hold that fast which thou hast, that no man take thy crown.

Revelation 22:12KJV
12 And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.

Gods Divine protection of the Church on earth during the tribulation, the hour of earths temptation

The Church on earth is instructed to enter their dwelling, until the Lords indignation is past, just like the passover in Egypt

Isaiah 26:20-21KJV
20 Come, my people, enter thou into thy chambers, and shut thy doors about thee: hide thyself as it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast.
21 For, behold, the Lord cometh out of his place to punish the inhabitants of the earth for their iniquity: the earth also shall disclose her blood, and shall no more cover her slain.
 
Last edited:

nathanjohnson

New Member
Nov 16, 2026
2
1
1
36
Hartford
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
On Revelation 3:10, the phrase rendered “shall come” has an impending sense, which fits the first-century churches better than a still-future tribulation. Also, “keep thee from” can mean preserve through the trial rather than remove beforehand, so it does not by itself settle the timing. Treating Philadelphia as a type of faithful churches today is possible, but using that to override the stated imminence seems strained. That point is separate from whether Revelation 20 is recapitulation or a future millennium.
 
  • Like
Reactions: claninja

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
On Revelation 3:10, the phrase rendered “shall come” has an impending sense, which fits the first-century churches better than a still-future tribulation.
What are you basing that claim on exactly? What hour of trial/temptation occurred in the fist century?

Also, “keep thee from” can mean preserve through the trial rather than remove beforehand, so it does not by itself settle the timing.
That's exactly what that phrase ('tereo ek" in Greek) means in John 17:15 which refutes the pre-trib idea that it's talking about being taken out of the world before a future hour of trial/temptation.

Treating Philadelphia as a type of faithful churches today is possible, but using that to override the stated imminence seems strained.
What stated imminence are you talking about? I don't see where Jesus indicated that the hour of trial was imminent and going to happen soon. I know some assume it had to happen in the lifetimes of the people of the church in Philadelpha since He was talking to them, but He also was talking in relation to His second coming, as verse 11 shows. And his message was not just for them but for "the churches", as can be seen in verse 13. It's not as if Jesus was promising to protect only that first century church from trial/temptation and not any others in that time period and in the future. I think Jesus was promising to protect anyone from that hour of trial, whenever it would occur, if they kept His command to persevere like those in the church in Philadelphia did.

That point is separate from whether Revelation 20 is recapitulation or a future millennium.
Right.

By the way, welcome to the forum. It looks like this was your first post.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,651
7,486
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The seven churches are representative of the churches today, Philadelphia is faithful and true, inside buildings that call themselves "Church" can be found all the types of the seven churches and their spiritual conditions, not everybody in the megachurch buildings belongs to the Philadelphian church type

The scripture is straight forward in explanation, the church of Philadelphia today and in the future is walking pleasing to the Lord, he has promised them protection from the future hour of earths temptation

You completely ignored the timing as given in verse 11, and it takes place close to the Lord's second coming thats seen (Behold I Come Quickly) "Future"

Revelation 3:10-11KJN
10 Because thou hast kept the word of my patience, I also will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.
11 Behold, I come quickly: hold that fast which thou hast, that no man take thy crown.
Yep. This is an important point. Whatever the hour of trial/temptation is, it's something that Jesus related to His return, implying that it's something that would occur leading up to His return. And Jesus obviously hasn't returned yet. And it would be worldwide. That reminds me personally of Satan's little season that affects the whole world before Jesus returns. And Christ's promise of protection was not just for the first century church in Philadelphia as if He had no interest in protecting anyone else. He would protect any believers alive during that time and who had "kept the word of my patience" from the hour of temptation. That's not a promise of physical protection since there's no reason to think that He would prevent any believers from being physically persecuted and killed, but rather a promise of protection from being deceived. It's the hour of temptation, not the hour of physical tribulation.
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
790
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The seven churches are representative of the churches today, Philadelphia is faithful and true, inside buildings that call themselves "Church" can be found all the types of the seven churches and their spiritual conditions, not everybody in the megachurch buildings belongs to the Philadelphian church type

The scripture is straight forward in explanation, the church of Philadelphia today and in the future is walking pleasing to the Lord, he has promised them protection from the future hour of earths temptation

You completely ignored the timing as given in verse 11, and it takes place close to the Lord's second coming thats seen (Behold I Come Quickly) "Future"

Revelation 3:10-11KJN
10 Because thou hast kept the word of my patience, I also will keep thee from the hour of temptation, which shall come upon all the world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.
11 Behold, I come quickly: hold that fast which thou hast, that no man take thy crown.

Revelation 22:12KJV
12 And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.

Gods Divine protection of the Church on earth during the tribulation, the hour of earths temptation

The Church on earth is instructed to enter their dwelling, until the Lords indignation is past, just like the passover in Egypt

Isaiah 26:20-21KJV
20 Come, my people, enter thou into thy chambers, and shut thy doors about thee: hide thyself as it were for a little moment, until the indignation be overpast.
21 For, behold, the Lord cometh out of his place to punish the inhabitants of the earth for their iniquity: the earth also shall disclose her blood, and shall no more cover her slain.

Where does revelation say the 7 churches are representative?