Daniel 7 can't support Amil's Timeline Pertaining to Rev 6:9-11, Rev 20:4

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
793
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Paul taught in passages like 2 Corinthians 5:6-8 and Philippians 2:21-24 that he expected to be present with Christ in heaven immediately upon his physical death. And other scriptures like 1 Peter 2:5-9 and Revelation 1:5-6 refer to the current status of believers as priests of God and Christ. So, why would that status change once a person physically dies and their soul goes to be in heaven with Christ?

Those don’t mention anything about souls reigning

I showed a list of Strong's definitions. He defined the word like this: ζάω záō, dzah'-o; a primary verb; to live (literally or figuratively):—life(-time), (a-)live(-ly), quick.

Nothing there about coming back to life from the dead. The word means to live or to be alive. It gives no indication one way or another whether the person who lives and is alive was previously dead or not.

Right because Strongs is a concordance. It’s important to know the difference.

I didn't see that at first. It's a lot of text. I was looking at the main definitions of the word that are given rather than looking at it's description of specific verses. The main definitions I saw didn't say anything about the word meaning to come to life or to be alive after previously being dead.

Ok, you then you don’t know how to use a lexicon? Lexicons demonstrate the meaning and usage of a word within a certain context. So if you were using thayer’s correctly, you would have looked for revelation 20:4 within thayer’s lexicon, not just posting any usage not related to revelation 20:5.

As far as I can tell, there are only 2 lexicons that specifically indicate how they thought the word was used in Revelation 20:4. This is not the way to discover the truth of this matter. Those are interpretations of the verse, not strict definitions of the word. There is no reason at all to think that the word specifically means to be alive after previously being dead at some point. I don't believe such a word even exists. It can be used to refer to someone who is alive after previously being dead, but the word itself gives no indication of that one way or another. So, it's a matter of interpretation.

There are more than 2. My challenge to you is to find one that agrees with what you are arguing.

What does this even mean? You think they are up there just laying around doing nothing? In Revelation 6:9-11 they are told to rest yet a little while longer while their fellow servants and brethren were killed as they were. but it's not saying they are to just lay around doing nothing while waiting for their deaths to be avenged. It's talking about them resting easy and not worrying about how long it would be until their deaths are avenged. It's not talking about them literally resting. We're not given much information at all about what things are like right now in heaven, but the idea that the souls of the dead in Christ are just up there resting while doing nothing is hilarious.

I don’t think the Bible is clear at all at what the souls of the dead are doing, but I was hoping you be able to provide something more solid.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Those don’t mention anything about souls reigning
What do you think the souls of the dead in Christ are doing in heaven? Do you understand that we (believers) are priests of God and reigning with Christ right now as a "royal priesthood", as scripture teaches (1 Peter 2:5-9, Revelation 1:5-6)? Do you think a believer's status as a priest is revoked when they die and their soul goes to heaven? I already asked you a question similar to this and you didn't answer it.

There are more than 2. My challenge to you is to find one that agrees with what you are arguing.
What other lexicons specify how the word is used in Revelation 20:4?

I don’t think the Bible is clear at all at what the souls of the dead are doing, but I was hoping you be able to provide something more solid.
I can't provide something that isn't there. We are simply not given many details about what is going on in heaven right now. It's apparently not meant for us to know. But, what we do know from scripture is that a person's soul and spirit go to be with Christ in heaven after they physically die. If someone is a priest in Christ's kingdom while they are alive, why would that change just because they physically die?
 

claninja

Active Member
Dec 11, 2022
793
158
43
the south
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Did you not read everything I said? I said that there aren't any other lexicons that I know of that even attempt to indicate how the word is used in Revelation 20:4 specifically. But, the main definition of the word that I see in the lexicons I did look at is that the word means to be alive or to live and I don't believe the word implies anything one way or another as to whether the person who is alive or living was previously dead. Do you think otherwise? If so, how do you determine when the word is being used to describe someone who is alive and wasn't previously dead or whether it's being used to described someone who is alive and previously dead?

I did, that’s why I asked - what’s the context? It means “living” but in contrast to what? The context tells us what.


My personal framework is based on my overall personal study of the entire Bible. Hello? That is being like the Bereans.

You don’t study beyond your framework?


LOL. So, you think two sources are enough to prove something. You can't be serious. Are you always that easily convinced? Small sample sizes are all you need to be convinced of something? You can't be serious. There are other Greek experts who agree with my understanding of Revelation 20:4. Just because they didn't write Greek lexicons doesn't mean they are not reliable experts. So, this proves nothing one way or another. The word itself means to be alive or to live. Whether or not the person or people who are said to be alive or living were previously dead is not something that is indicated by the word itself. Can you acknowledge that much? These interpreters decided that it refers to people being bodily alive again after being bodily dead, but that's just their interpretation. The word itself gives no indication of that one way or another.

The bdag is the golden standard.

But yes, I would be interested in your evidence that has “zao” as defined (not theologically interpreted) as spiritually life in the context of revelation 20.

My claim is backed by a good number of Greek experts who were/are amillennialists. But, if they didn't write Greek lexicons, I guess their interpretations don't mean anything to you? You talk about being like the Bereans. You're not doing that. Instead, you're letting two Greek lexicons tell you what a verse means. You're not studying it for yourself to see if what those two sources said are true or not.

Sure then what lexical arguments can they provide on revelation 20:4,5 and “zao”?
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,664
7,487
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I did, that’s why I asked - what’s the context? It means “living” but in contrast to what? The context tells us what.
Why do you think that you are the ultimate authority to decide what the context tells us? I see the context of Jesus reigning and His followers being priests as a deciding factor in the timing of Revelation 20, but you just dismiss that. Your efforts to see context are very selective. You also don't seem to consider the fact that a bodily resurrection is not required in order for the second death to not have power over someone, as written about in Revelation 20:6, so that tells us the context of the timing of Revelation 20 as well.

You don’t study beyond your framework?
LOL. I study everything and that's how I create my framework. LOL!

The bdag is the golden standard.
LOL. So, the BDAG is your replacement for the Holy Spirit? That source is all knowing and infallible?

But yes, I would be interested in your evidence that has “zao” as defined (not theologically interpreted) as spiritually life in the context of revelation 20.
That would require me to show you why I believe what I do using many different scriptures, but you have no interest in that. You think it can just be determined from Revelation 20 itself.