There is no more getting away with blasphemy.

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You cite 1 Corinthians 15:46, where Paul says that the natural comes first and afterward the spiritual.

But Paul is discussing the resurrection and the distinction between the natural and spiritual body. He is not establishing a chronological rule governing when blasphemy against the Holy Spirit becomes possible. That is your application of the passage, not something Paul states.
You are only assuming.

But no, what Paul said is a biblical principle established through the ages, clearly evident in one first being born of the flesh, and then "again" ("afterward") by the spirit of God.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Do you need your Pastor to tell you how to respond? Your post are very weak in scripture but very heavy in "Follw me! I have all the answers!" Are you a Pastor who sells the gospel? You are not who you present to be on this forum! Your words betray you!
If you continue with this tone I will leave you to your own trajectory.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,142
336
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You are only assuming.

But no, what Paul said is a biblical principle established through the ages, clearly evident in one first being born of the flesh, and then "again" ("afterward") by the spirit of God.
Scott,

You say I am merely assuming, yet you continue to do precisely what I have been asking you to avoid: taking a passage, extending its meaning beyond its immediate context, and presenting your interpretation as an established biblical fact.

Let's examine your argument.

In 1 Corinthians 15:44–46, Paul is discussing the resurrection of the body. He contrasts the natural body with the spiritual body, and Adam with Christ. His argument concerns the transformation from mortality to resurrection life.

You have taken Paul's statement that the natural comes first and afterward the spiritual and applied it to being born again.

Certainly, John 3 teaches that we must be born of the Spirit. I have never disputed that. But John 3 and 1 Corinthians 15 are addressing different questions.

Paul is discussing bodily resurrection. Jesus, speaking to Nicodemus, is discussing spiritual birth.

These teachings are compatible, but they are not interchangeable.

More importantly, neither passage establishes your claim that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit became possible only after Pentecost.

And here is something you continue to overlook.

Jesus explained the necessity of being born of the Spirit to Nicodemus before Pentecost (John 3:5–8).

He also warned the religious authorities about blaspheming the Holy Spirit before Pentecost.

Mark 3:30 explicitly explains the reason for that warning: they were saying that Jesus had an unclean spirit.

Matthew 12:28–32 confirms that Jesus was performing His works by the Spirit of God when He issued that warning.

These are not assumptions. These are statements found in the text.

You may believe that Pentecost fundamentally changed the application of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. But if that is your position, the responsibility is yours to demonstrate it from Scripture.

Simply repeating that the natural precedes the spiritual does not establish the distinction you are proposing.

There is a logical step missing from your argument, Scott.

Even if natural birth precedes spiritual birth, how does that prove that someone could not blaspheme the Holy Spirit before Pentecost?

One proposition does not establish the other.

And calling my interpretation an assumption does nothing to establish yours.

So I'll ask you again, as simply as possible:

Were the religious authorities Jesus addressed in Mark 3:28–30 capable of committing blasphemy against the Holy Spirit at that time, before Pentecost?

Yes or no?

If your answer is no, then explain why Jesus warned them specifically because of what they were already saying.

That is the issue we are discussing.

Please address the question rather than introduce another theological principle that does not actually answer it.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Why such a delay?
Because you apparently have a lot to unpack and relearn. Which is no criticism, but a common reality among the church.

So my question remains:

Where does Jesus say that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit was impossible before Pentecost, or that His warning applied only to people living afterward?
Jesus is the Word...and these truths reserved for these times of the end have been limited to "here a little there a little", under restraint since the beginning. This whole time people have been leaning on their own understanding to arrive at many errorred doctrines, eventualy resulting in strong delusion. That, unfortunately, is the starting point for this generation.

So stop thinking you have as much as a leg to stand on.

Meanwhile I have told you the truth, and as one among many who have been promised--not to be gifted with, but "lead unto" all truth--how did you imagine it would come? What is God's established method?

The answer to your question--Israel shown as a light unto the gentiles "precept upon precept" through suffering and by the law and the prophets; Jesus preached and lived it; and that meant a new beginning with Paul preparing the church for millennia to come, even it's own age, the finish of which was foretold since Daniel and brought forward by Paul and John--sealed until the time of the end--in a little book, that when revealed, would finish the mystery of God as He declared to His servants the prophets. This is that time, and I have been revealing its contents...because God caught me up unto the third heaven and then returned me to do so.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You say I am merely assuming, yet you continue to do precisely what I have been asking you to avoid: taking a passage, extending its meaning beyond its immediate context, and presenting your interpretation as an established biblical fact.
You don't get to define proper context. Nor do I. But God does as He wishes, even breaking what men define as context.

The question is, are you willing to follow where many will not allow? If yes, you need to drop the context rule and limit you are imposing.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You may believe that Pentecost fundamentally changed the application of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. But if that is your position, the responsibility is yours to demonstrate it from Scripture.
No...Jesus fundamentally changed things by ascending and returning in the glory of the Father.

That makes it His responsibility you are demanding--not mine.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,142
336
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Scott,

Your latest responses have taken this discussion in a rather unexpected direction, and I think we need to address what you are now claiming.

For several exchanges, I have asked you to support a specific interpretation of Scripture. Rather than demonstrate how your conclusion follows from the text, you have now explained that God personally took you into the third heaven and returned you to reveal mysteries reserved for the end times.

That is an extraordinary claim.

But claiming to have received revelation from God does not establish that your interpretation of Scripture is correct.


Throughout the New Testament, believers are encouraged to examine and test what they are taught.

The Bereans were commended for examining the Scriptures daily to determine whether Paul's teaching was true (Acts 17:11). Paul himself instructed believers to examine everything carefully and hold fast to what is good (1 Thessalonians 5:21).

Surely you would agree that your teachings should be subject to the same examination.

Now consider what you have actually said in these responses.

First, you finally answered my question about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.

I asked whether the religious authorities Jesus addressed could have committed that sin before Pentecost.

You answered, "Yes," meaning that you believe they could not.

But Mark 3:28–30 specifically connects Jesus' warning to what those authorities were already saying about Him.

Matthew 12:28–32 makes the distinction even clearer. Jesus states that He casts out demons by the Spirit of God. He then distinguishes speaking against the Son of Man from speaking against the Holy Spirit.

You respond that Jesus referred to Himself as the Son of Man rather than God.

But that actually misses the distinction Jesus was making. The issue was not simply what the authorities called Jesus. It was that they were attributing the work of God's Spirit to an unclean spirit.

How does Jesus' identification as the Son of Man establish that they could not blaspheme the Holy Spirit whose work they were witnessing?

Second, you tell me that I must abandon the rules of biblical context because God can operate beyond what men define as context.

Scott, context is not an arbitrary restriction imposed upon God.

It is how we understand what a writer is communicating.

When Paul discusses resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15, we should begin by understanding his discussion of resurrection. When Jesus addresses the Pharisees in Mark 3, we should begin by examining what prompted His warning.

Certainly, Scripture can illuminate Scripture. But that does not give us permission to disregard what individual passages actually say.

Without context, how do we distinguish what Scripture teaches from what someone wants Scripture to teach?

Third,
you now tell us that God took you into the third heaven and returned you to reveal the contents of a mystery reserved for this generation.

I cannot verify or disprove your personal experience, and I will not pretend to do either.

But I can examine your interpretation of Scripture.

Your claimed experience does not exempt your teaching from biblical examination. If anything, such an extraordinary claim makes careful examination even more important.

And finally
, you say, "I have not been arguing."

Yet you have repeatedly made theological claims, challenged my understanding, and insisted that your conclusions are correct.

That is an argument, whether you choose to call it one or not.

I have not claimed that I possess all truth. I have openly acknowledged passages that challenge my interpretations and questions that Scripture does not fully resolve.

I am asking you to demonstrate the same willingness to examine your conclusions.

There is a very important distinction between trusting God and assuming that our personal understanding of God's Word carries God's own authority.

The former is faith. The latter is a claim that requires considerable justification.

And this brings us to what I now consider the central question in our exchange:

If you believe God has personally appointed you to reveal truths concealed until the end times, and you also believe that ordinary biblical context must be set aside to receive those truths, by what objective standard can another Christian determine whether your interpretation is actually correct?

Are we to examine your teachings against Scripture, as the Bereans did?

Or are we expected to accept your interpretation because you claim God personally revealed it to you?


I am willing to examine your biblical arguments, Scott.

But I cannot accept a claim of personal revelation as a substitute for demonstrating what Scripture actually says.

You have lost touch with reality!
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You respond that Jesus referred to Himself as the Son of Man rather than God.

But that actually misses the distinction Jesus was making. The issue was not simply what the authorities called Jesus. It was that they were attributing the work of God's Spirit to an unclean spirit.

How does Jesus' identification as the Son of Man establish that they could not blaspheme the Holy Spirit whose work they were witnessing?
What your response show is what I was saying about those of this generation having to unpack and relearn what is actually true.

The exchange between the religious leaders and Jesus was not so much about them or their claims, but about Jesus (although the did present Jesus with the opportunity). As it is with much of the gospel records, they were showing the man Jesus, son of Mary, the carpenter's son, the Son of Man, to also be God Almighty. A transition was occurring well beyond the suspensions and blasphemy of those unnamed men and their fate before God. He then went on to fulfill that transition He framed with "follow Me" "you must be born again of the spirit of God" as "firstfruits."

Incidentally, in that transition He gave His flesh body to the church, left it, and ascended into the glory of God, meaning in spirit. An act and example of the firstfruits to "follow."

All of which was and is made possible and manifest by The Holy Spirit. Thus radically changing the landscape regarding blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.

So...I am not saying that all of what you have described is not true, but rather the main reason and purposes are somewhat different, meaning consequences most have not fully understood.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Scott, context is not an arbitrary restriction imposed upon God.

It is how we understand what a writer is communicating.
Yes, and that is the problem...because the Author is God. Thus, by putting men inspired or sent by God in that frame of limitations--in that box--you do it to Him.
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
40,531
65,155
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
In 1 hour 35 minutes--YES!
and now a word .
Any who beleives NOT the testimony that GOD gave of the SON , calls GOD a liar .
This all inclusive god is satan and not GOD .
IF one recieves NOT the TRUTH they are NOT OF GOD .
Let us remember this well .
 
  • Praying
Reactions: ScottA

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
40,531
65,155
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
This is a good question .
RUN .
What i notice about the over whemling majority of folks is
THEY FAST TO RUN to anything that comes in under the guise it be of GOD and yet preaches naught but smooth things .
And bring a bible around them and the RUN from IT and from those who speak that truth
as if their heads are on fire and their rears quickly catching flame .
That is what I NOTICE .
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScottA

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
40,531
65,155
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Do you likewise run from every word from God that has come from men sent by God?

You revealed yourself as one who runs from the truth.
RUN .
What i notice about the over whemling majority of folks is
THEY FAST TO RUN to anything that comes in under the guise it be of GOD and yet preaches naught but smooth things .
And bring a bible around them and these RUN from IT and from those who speak that truth
as if their heads are on fire and their rears quickly catching flame .
That is what I NOTICE .
 

PinSeeker

Well-Known Member
Oct 4, 2021
4,665
1,117
113
Nashville
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
For the record.
Any Israelite of old (before Jesus), according to the law of Moses, would have been stoned to death for saying of themselves what you have said of yourself, Scott. We don't do that today, of course.

To the subject at hand though, yes, we are sent, for sure. Jesus commissioned us all in Matthew 28:20, and sends us... to go and make disciples of all nations. So yes, we are sent in this way. By Christ. But again, no man has or ever will be sent by the Father (John 14) in the way Jesus and the Holy Spirit were. Yes, for the record indeed.

And I'll add these little "gems" to the record:

If you continue with this tone I will leave you to your own trajectory.
If anything was ever hypocritical, this is it.

God caught me up unto the third heaven and then returned me to do so.
giphy.gif


Yes, as He Himself referred to Himself as the Son of Man, not as God.
Oh. my.

I have not been arguing.
giphy.gif


I mean yeah, again, for the record indeed. Wow.

Grace and peace to you. And mercy.
 
Last edited:

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,080
7,393
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Third, you now tell us that God took you into the third heaven and returned you to reveal the contents of a mystery reserved for this generation.

I cannot verify or disprove your personal experience, and I will not pretend to do either.

But I can examine your interpretation of Scripture.

Your claimed experience does not exempt your teaching from biblical examination. If anything, such an extraordinary claim makes careful examination even more important
If you are hearing this for the first, it is not that I haven't said it here many times, because I have. But with all that is written, the warnings, promises, and prophecies...and the former accounts of discerning the times, if Christians were not falling into the foretold delusion, they/we should have expected correction...or to be given over to our own doctinal errors and devices. At the very least we should have expected God to do what He's always done. "Extraordinarily."

But the real test is spiritual.
 
Last edited: