What happened to the 10 toes in Daniel 2?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So what's your view of Psalm 83 as the 10 toes of Dan 2,7.

I personally think Psalm 83 is a little too all-encompassing to narrow it down to one time as it could be foreshadow from history or just history or simply one psalm about something that's just going to keep happening through time.

When has Israel been in the land when the nations around her weren't antagonistic to her? Yes, Medo-Persia brought them back to the land and Greece never fully kicked them out, but those in the land when they came back from Babylon certainly didn't appreciate their return and they were constantly the punching bag during Greece's reign.

Just about all those mentioned are within the same land promised to Abraham's Seed right?

Genesis 15:18-21 – "In the same day the LORD made a covenant with Abram, saying, Unto thy seed have I given this land, from the river of Egypt unto the great river, the river Euphrates: The Kenites, and the Kenizzites, and the Kadmonites, And the Hittites, and the Perizzites, and the Rephaims, And the Amorites, and the Canaanites, and the Girgashites, and the Jebusites."

That's the same land the modern Islamic kingdoms of the Middle East are sitting. Perhaps the 10 tied to the land given to Yeshua at the beginning just have a supernatural hatred for the One on whose land they sit. The relationship between God and His chosen people Israel to whom He gave the land to dwell in with Him at His temple on His holy mountain is what ties them all together and the nations rage at it.

How many times did Israel pray that God would protect them from the enemies that surrounded them? David's psalm was a foreshadow of the enemies of Yeshua from His own people that fulfilled God's will without knowing it and bringing about the defeat of death and hell.

So I don't see the 10 toes of Daniel 2 as existing past the fall of Rome in 476 AD, whose 10 kings at that time were intermarrying to prop up the kingdom dying of 1,000 cuts. We're told in Daniel 2 that once the image was broken there was no place found for it, the end, finito.

Daniel 7's 10 horns however carry a much different vision with 10 different kingdoms in the land, not 10 kings from the same kingdom through time. This is a fundamental difference between Daniel 2 and 7. In Daniel 7 the four beasts stand before (in front of) each other at the same time while the four metals of the statue represent successive kingdoms through time.

This connection of 10 kingdoms dwelling at least partly in the land given to Yeshua at a time when 10 nations dwelt in it is an interesting parallel most people don't recognize. I was looking into something else when I learned there are 10 kingdoms mentioned in the land promise to Abraham's Seed.

But there are 11 horns, 10 similar to each other and a little one that comes up in the land after them. The time of the end is different than history in terms of this little horn.

So do I think that "let us cut them off from being a nation; that the name of Israel may be no more in remembrance" applies to the end times and that the peoples dwelling in the same lands surrounding Israel are going to be the subjects of those actions? I would have to be completely ignorant of the last almost 80 years not to see that being true. And I think that's because it's just a part of Israel being in the land. Those that live in Yeshua's land around her are threatened by her presence and want her eliminated. The Dragon has tried it throughout history by force and death, even in modern times with failure after failure.

I think that is the reason for the change in tactics. He's setup his pawns of Islam to be a threat to Israel's existence, but their impotent. They do provide a great straw man set up to strike fear in Israel's heart, yet easily defeated to set up the Dragon's king and deceiving Israel who closed their eyes to the true Messiah, Yeshua.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
410
34
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
I think of the 7th head of Revelation 13/17 as the land on which the 10 horns/kings/kingdoms sit.
Agreed, tho I consider the 10 come from Ps 83.
I personally think Psalm 83 is a little too all-encompassing to narrow it down to one time as it could be foreshadow from history or just history or simply one psalm about something that's just going to keep happening through time.

When has Israel been in the land when the nations around her weren't antagonistic to her? Yes, Medo-Persia brought them back to the land and Greece never fully kicked them out, but those in the land when they came back from Babylon certainly didn't appreciate their return and they were constantly the punching bag during Greece's reign.

Just about all those mentioned are within the same land promised to Abraham's Seed right?

Genesis 15:18-21 – "In the same day the LORD made a covenant with Abram, saying, Unto thy seed have I given this land, from the river of Egypt unto the great river, the river Euphrates: The Kenites, and the Kenizzites, and the Kadmonites, And the Hittites, and the Perizzites, and the Rephaims, And the Amorites, and the Canaanites, and the Girgashites, and the Jebusites."

That's the same land the modern Islamic kingdoms of the Middle East are sitting. Perhaps the 10 tied to the land given to Yeshua at the beginning just have a supernatural hatred for the One on whose land they sit. The relationship between God and His chosen people Israel to whom He gave the land to dwell in with Him at His temple on His holy mountain is what ties them all together and the nations rage at it.

How many times did Israel pray that God would protect them from the enemies that surrounded them? David's psalm was a foreshadow of the enemies of Yeshua from His own people that fulfilled God's will without knowing it and bringing about the defeat of death and hell.

So I don't see the 10 toes of Daniel 2 as existing past the fall of Rome in 476 AD, whose 10 kings at that time were intermarrying to prop up the kingdom dying of 1,000 cuts. We're told in Daniel 2 that once the image was broken there was no place found for it, the end, finito.

Daniel 7's 10 horns however carry a much different vision with 10 different kingdoms in the land, not 10 kings from the same kingdom through time. This is a fundamental difference between Daniel 2 and 7. In Daniel 7 the four beasts stand before (in front of) each other at the same time while the four metals of the statue represent successive kingdoms through time.

This connection of 10 kingdoms dwelling at least partly in the land given to Yeshua at a time when 10 nations dwelt in it is an interesting parallel most people don't recognize. I was looking into something else when I learned there are 10 kingdoms mentioned in the land promise to Abraham's Seed.

But there are 11 horns, 10 similar to each other and a little one that comes up in the land after them. The time of the end is different than history in terms of this little horn.

So do I think that "let us cut them off from being a nation; that the name of Israel may be no more in remembrance" applies to the end times and that the peoples dwelling in the same lands surrounding Israel are going to be the subjects of those actions? I would have to be completely ignorant of the last almost 80 years not to see that being true. And I think that's because it's just a part of Israel being in the land. Those that live in Yeshua's land around her are threatened by her presence and want her eliminated. The Dragon has tried it throughout history by force and death, even in modern times with failure after failure.

I think that is the reason for the change in tactics. He's setup his pawns of Islam to be a threat to Israel's existence, but their impotent. They do provide a great straw man set up to strike fear in Israel's heart, yet easily defeated to set up the Dragon's king and deceiving Israel who closed their eyes to the true Messiah, Yeshua.
If you refer to Deut 2, 29, it list the reasons why ONLY the three of the 10 listed in Psalm 83 were uprooted, subdued, and then delivered in Dan 11.41. Even the Psalm itself mentions it "to reinforce Lots descendants". It was land promised to Lot. Hence there being delivered.
 

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
To me its time to forget Alexander, especially as the goat. Gabriel specifically told Daniel when the vision was for. The time of the end, and specifically the time of wrath. It's mentioned 11 times from Dan 8.17,19,26 Dan 9.27, Dan 10.14, Dan 11.35,36,40, Dan 12.4,9,13.
The other difficulty is Greece was changed from Javan, where the sons of Japheth settled, ie Turkey-practically all of them, or the ones repeated in scripture, in the Septuagint, after Alexanders existence, and repeated since, I prefer to use the original, it confirms my bias better!!!
Yes, Alexander is clearly not in view with the 10 horns, I'm just saying the idea of a notable horn, Alexander, being on the head of the beast is comparable to the fourth beast with 10 horns on it's head that are defined as 10 kingdoms. Just like the ram had 2 horns on its head that were Media and Persia.

Just making the point that horns on heads is like kingdoms on land. 7 heads are 7 mountains, land, and represent 7 points in history where Israel was on the land and in Jerusalem sitting on Mount Zion when 7 kings were ruling over Israel during those times.

It explains why there isn't a head for the last 1,500 years since Rome fell, because Israel wasn't in the land anymore and that would break the symbolic representation.

I explained my reasoning in the previous posts for taking each vision on its own first for interpretation and why I see Daniel 2, 8, 9:25-26, 11:1-35 as history and Daniel 7, 9:27, 11:36-12:13, and most of Revelation as future.

Daniel 7:3-8 and Revelation 13:1-2 are particularly interesting ties to the end because Daniel 7 sees diverse, separate beasts while Revelation 13 John sees those same animal symbols joined together as parts of the Dragon, the 4th beast. It's like Daniel 7 is a view of the time leading up to the end of the first half of the week and Revelation 13 after the abomination of desolation. A transition from the 7th king at his death to the 8th at his resurrection, two different kingdoms that are still the same. Same land, same king, same people, but now the king demands worship as God and kills those who refuse.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
410
34
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
But there are 11 horns, 10 similar to each other and a little one that comes up in the land after them. The time of the end is different than history in terms of this little horn.
I treat it as prophecy. So I look at each mention as further info towards the understanding of the subject in its entirety. As with Jesus and the apostles, all their answers came from OT scripture.
I think we interpret history way too much.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,686
369
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Verse 19 does indeed increase the focus on the general statement, "for at the time of the end shall be the vision." It clarifies when the time of the end in question is by defining it at the end of the indignation, it is the appointed time of the end.

Daniel has just seen this vision and it is about to be interpreted for him. The content of the vision is Daniel 8:3-14 that starts with the ram and ends with the little horn the came up from one of the four horns that came up from the notable horn on the goat. That little horn is responsible for the transgression of the daily by the priesthood and the transgression that caused the temple to be desolate with continued unholy treading of the courts thereof. The end of the vision is the cleansing of the defiled sanctuary.

What Gabriel expounds on is that vision ending with the cleansing and re-dedication of the sanctuary, but defining the symbolic identities and expounding on the little horn that causes all of this at the latter time of their kingdom. Their kingdom is speaking of the four horns that came from the notable horn and from which one of those produced a little horn who is broken without hand.

What Daniel saw ending with the stopping of the daily and abomination of desolation being undone in 164 BC with the rededication after the Maccabbean Revolt, is the same time the little horn is broken without hand.

Both the vision and the interpretation end it at a very specific time we can see historically based on the identities interpreted for us by Gabriel, 164 BC. Indeed Media was smaller than Persia and together they made up the Achaemenid Empire, the ram. The goat defeated them and took their power, including control over Israel in the land. When the notable horn was broken, Alexander's generals split the kingdom and out of the Seleucid Empire born from that Antiochus IV commanded the Jews stop their worship of God on pain of death and many actively joined in this apostasy while those who did not were killed.

This triggered the revolt that ended the full reign over Israel in the land by the Seleucid and Ptolemaic Empires as they has semi-autonomy until Rome came and ruled over them. So not only does the vision and interpretation of it match up with what we see as history and what Daniel saw as a prophetic future, but we also see the stated end of the vision in both the vision itself and the interpretation of it because the temple was re-dedicated on 24 Kilsev (December 13, 164 BC) and Antiochus IV died in late November, early December of 164 BC.

To me this is pretty clear from the text itself that the defined end of the vision and defined end of the cause of the desolations were within a month of each other, if not much closer. The time of the end is the time appointed when the little horn meets his end while God's relationship with Israel continues leading to the Messiah bringing that relationship to all who believe.



This is where I think those who study prophecy get themselves in trouble, including myself. It's hard to not pay attention to the flashes of apparent commonalities when you've been studying for so long. But Daniel 2 was in the second year of the reign of Nebuchadnezzar, Daniel 7's vision was in the first year of Belshazzar, and Daniel 8's vision was in the third year of the reign of king Belshazzar. These are distinctly different visions at different times.

That doesn't mean there isn't a possible connection, but it means that before any attempted connection is made we must let each vision be interpreted for us by itself because that's how it was given, by itself years apart. Just because the Bible is interconnected does not mean every vision is the same time or scope. Some like Daniel 2 cover men's kingdoms from Babylon to Rome while others like Daniel 8 are focused on the two kingdoms between those bookends that both caused diaspora for Israel.

The vision and interpretation in Daniel 8 defines the start and end with the words used. Generic terms like time of the end should not be the defining factor because what end is in view? I think that is actually defined for us here by it being the latter time of their kingdom when the temple is rededicated and the man responsible for needing that dies.

Do that for Daniel 2 and 7 as well and then you can compare the three together. What I found when doing that is while Daniel 8 takes place in the scope of Daniel 2, its focus is much different. Daniel 2 is focused on the transition from the kingdoms of men to the kingdom of God, but Daniel 8 is focused on the time leading up to the foreshadow of Daniel 7's little horn that ends before Rome. Daniel 11 connects Daniel 8's little horn foreshadow with Daniel 7's future little horn in action, but not identity. They are both children of their father the devil in opposition to God and persecuting God's faithful while letting the apostate join with them in apostasy.

Daniel 7 is focused on a time after Daniel 2 and 8, joining in with Daniel 11:36-12:1 with the wars of the false messiah, the king appointed over Israel who defeats Egypt, the king of the south, and then destroys in the north and east before coming to his end in Jerusalem and starting the unparalleled time of Jacob's trouble.

These are all connected in their minor and major ways, but each vision should be understood on its own before connecting it to other visions because many of the commonly accepted expectations born of fast and loose connection are denied by the text itself if taken as stated logically. Now if one allegorizes/spiritualizes meaning over stated Biblical interpretation then it can really mean whatever one wants it to mean within reason. But when I read scripture, I see a logical and clearly stated pattern throughout. I may not fully understand it all, but symbols can still hold meaning other than the literal while actions can be taken literally to understand what those symbols will do.
well, we see Daniel very differently.... and that's okay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A Watchman

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
410
34
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
why I see Daniel 2, 8, 9:25-26, 11:1-35 as history
But each of those prophecies, start in early times and end in endtimes. All of them, Dan 2,7,8,11,12.
Dan 2.44 states in the time of those kings, He will crush all those kingdoms, surely that indicates its for the same period as the Lords coming. All those nations will collapse, Iraq, Iran, Turkey (Javan) the 10 toes of Ps 83.
All will be defeated during the battle of Armageddon, Ezek 38,39, Zech 12-14, Psalm 83.
Otherwise it makes no sense.
Every prophecy in Daniel starts the same way and ends with the Lords coming. Maybe the same applies to all.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,686
369
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
That's a key point I think. Why doesn't Daniel's vision focus on the four horns that came out of the notable horn and why focus on only one that came from one of the four in the latter time of their kingdom? Just about everything Daniel sees has some focus on Israel, the land, and Jerusalem where Israel has relationship with God at His chosen place of residence. Greece's power over that was greatly diminished at the latter time of Greece's power before Rome took their power and authority.

So what is the point of Daniel 8? Daniel 2 was the transition of kingdoms of men that ruled over Israel in the land and cast them out of it until the kingdom of God consumes them all. Daniel 8 gives us the origin of the little horn that brings the vision to a close at the latter time of what was left of Greece's power. It provides an objectively historical view from prophecy that not only builds faith in God's Word being true, but gives us actions and characteristics that those at the time of the end before Christ's return will see in another man full of pride and in opposition to God. But that doesn't make them the same person or even the same origins. The little horn in Daniel 7 and 8 have distinctly different origins because they are different visions of different times.



But again, the vision itself defines the end when it ends, at the cleansing of the sanctuary following the actions of the little horn and his influence on God's people leading them to apostasy for fear of death. It's also defined with the death of this little horn in the interpretation. I don't think we need to go beyond what the text clearly says to get the interpretation given to us in the text itself.



Chazon and Mareh don't really change anything in the interpretation imo.

You say, "Chazon — the broad, long-range prophetic vision: kingdoms, conflicts, and the movement toward the time of the end." Chazon is used 35 times in 34 verses in the Old Testament as a dream, oracle, vision, prophecy. It's focused on understanding transmitted from God to man.

You say, "Mareh — the appearance-focused vision, tied directly to the “evenings and mornings” and the sanctuary-centered turning point." Mareh is used 104 times in 84 verses in the Old Testament as sight, appearance, vision and can speak of prophecy like Chazon, but can also mean to see something, which is what happens in a Chazon. There are two examples of their use in the same verses, Mareh being used as one might expect for Daniel in a prophetic vision seeing someone that looks like a man.

Daniel 8:15 – "And it came to pass, when I, [even] I Daniel, had seen the vision[Chazon], and sought for the meaning, then, behold, there stood before me as the appearance[Mareh] of a man."

Daniel 8:26 – "And the vision[Mareh] of the evening and the morning which was told [is] true: wherefore shut thou up the vision[Chazon]; for it [shall be] for many days."

I think my reasoning for holding Daniel 8 within the context of the vision and Gabriel's interpretation of it stands whether Chazon or Mareh is used. It is a prophetic vision from God in which Daniel sees things happen. Prophecy is about more than our future, much of it has already been fulfilled. Yeshua already came and the testimony of Yeshua is the spirit of prophecy, He's all through it as the ultimate focus of it all. Some is fulfilled and some is not. I believe the plain reading and context should define each vision on its own before reading it into another vision that may or may not be connected. That's just how I approach it now though, trying to keep as much of my own personal interpretation out of the mix and put that burden on God and His faithful Word to give me understanding by taking Him at His Word.
Thanks, it is so difficult to go into details here. If I were to mention or give you a certain interpretation it may or may not make any sense to you since no interpretation stands on its own. You would not see how it ties in with the earlier verses / interpretations as well as how if must also connect and support the interpretations coming in the later verses and even the later chapters. You might say it makes sense until it is compared to the interpretations that you have established in your own earlier work.... it is just so difficult to present the entire picture. It is as though I would send you a picture of a certain slice of a 1000 puzzle piece from the middle of the puzzle. You might agree that those certain pieces to in fact fit together but if you were to take that slice and try to fit it in within your own puzzle - as you have also been working on, that slice may not fit with your existing work...

So, we are often forced to exchange interpretations on a micro level if you will and that usually never works. For example, your comment on the difference or importance of the two different visions used in Daniel 8 - the chazon and the mareh visions. In my studies, they are indeed very important and very different. The chazon vision begins in 457 BC and starts at the same time as the 70 weeks of years prophecy. Further, the 4th and final Great Jubilee also begins on this same date. And as events move toward the coming Messiah, each will have their own treatment.

So, let me ask you a question that despite the comments above. What does the Mareh vision mean to you, how do you calculate it and what is it specifically related to? Thanks.
 

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
But each of those prophecies, start in early times and end in endtimes. All of them, Dan 2,7,8,11,12.
Dan 2.44 states in the time of those kings, He will crush all those kingdoms, surely that indicates its for the same period as the Lords coming. All those nations will collapse, Iraq, Iran, Turkey (Javan) the 10 toes of Ps 83.
All will be defeated during the battle of Armageddon, Ezek 38,39, Zech 12-14, Psalm 83.
Otherwise it makes no sense.
Every prophecy in Daniel starts the same way and ends with the Lords coming. Maybe the same applies to all.

In the time of what kings? This is where context reveals some key details.

Daniel 2:41-44 – "And whereas thou sawest the feet and toes, part of potters' clay, and part of iron, the kingdom shall be divided; but there shall be in it of the strength of the iron, forasmuch as thou sawest the iron mixed with miry clay. And [as] the toes of the feet [were] part of iron, and part of clay, [so] the kingdom shall be partly strong, and partly broken. And whereas thou sawest iron mixed with miry clay, they shall mingle themselves with the seed of men: but they shall not cleave one to another, even as iron is not mixed with clay. And in the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed: and the kingdom shall not be left to other people, [but] it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand for ever."

First, there is a single kingdom in view here, the same fourth kingdom that was strong as iron in the beginning, but gets weaker with the iron and clay mixing. But there are multiple kings, suggesting a span of time within this final kingdom of men before being consumed by the kingdom of God.

Second, the stone struck the feet, suggesting it was before the time of the toes. The kingdom of God came with Yeshua's ministry, but it did not break apart and consume Rome until some time passed. The four kingdoms are sequential, one being defeated by the next, four different metals of decreasing value, but increasing strength until the end of the iron kingdom of Rome.

Third, those kings in view are tied to the ones that mingled in marriage, something tied to within the last 10 kings of Rome. It is the days of those kings that are in view in Daniel 2 when it consumes the shattered image representing those kingdoms of men that came before it.

This is not a view of the time of the end, similar to Daniel 8 it is a statement of the end defined within the vision itself. We have the benefit of history to look back on and see that there was indeed royal intermarriage in the last generation of the Western Roman Empire that cast Israel out of the land and died, never to be found again, before Israel returned to the land almost 2,000 years after being cast out.

That doesn't mean Daniel 2 is outside the scope of the end times, the mountain that fills the earth is, I believe, representative of God's kingdom being established in the earth as the sole rule over man, the completion of what the dream was about in the first place, the kingdom of God replacing the kingdoms of men. And from Zion He will reign over the whole earth, the mountain filling the earth.

It's true Daniel 11-12 starts in history, but Daniel 11:35 makes a transitional statement regarding the time after the first abomination of desolation in 167 BC.

Daniel 11:35 – "And [some] of them of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make [them] white, [even] to the time of the end: because [it is] yet for a time appointed."

But that's almost exactly what Daniel 8:19 says right? Yes, and if it weren't for the context of the rest of the vision I would be less sure. But a king is introduced with language paralleling some of the king from Daniel 11:29-32. However, this new king doesn't regard the God of his fathers, a very Hebrew way of saying YHVW. That does not match the lineage of the little horn Antiochus IV just like Daniel 7 and 8 do not match their origins.

Daniel 11:40, 45-12:1 – "And at the time of the end shall the king of the south push at him: and the king of the north shall come against him like a whirlwind, with chariots, and with horsemen, and with many ships; and he shall enter into the countries, and shall overflow and pass over. ... And he shall plant the tabernacles of his palace between the seas in the glorious holy mountain; yet he shall come to his end, and none shall help him. And at that time shall Michael stand up, the great prince which standeth for the children of thy people: and there shall be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation even to that same time: and at that time thy people shall be delivered, every one that shall be found written in the book."

This king introduced in Daniel 11:36 is attacked at the time of the end by those in verse 35 that would have been called the Ptolemaic Empire (Egypt) and Seleucid Empire (Turkey/Syria/Iran/Iraq). Egypt is specifically defeated by this new king as are those to the north and east. That's one stated nation and two directions covering the king of the south and north, modern nations in the land of the old kingdoms. It is at that time that the unparalleled time of Jacob's trouble in Judea takes place, the event Yeshua places before the sixth seal and His return at the time of the end. Matthew 24:15-22, Mark 13:14-20, Jeremiah 30:4-7, Daniel 12:1

Given all these are unparalleled in all of history and tied to Israel and they are saved out of that time, all four of these passages speak of the same event at the same time of the end. This defines for me the context of the time of the end because the end of that king in Jerusalem begins the reign of the false messiah, the Beast. And the beast has a mortal wound that is healed just before the abomination of desolation that starts the unparalleled great tribulation.

So there are certainly visions Daniel had that started in history and end in our future. There are also visions that started in Daniel's future and ended in our history. We have the benefit of God's Word and hindsight and each vision must be examined as given to determine what appears as history and what does not. They're all interconnected in some ways though, in this case as foreshadows of the Beast from history in word and deed. I certainly don't deny the relevance of that interconnection, but I think many skim the text and make connections that are not as solid as they think when you dig into the details and grammar. These things matter in understanding imo.
 

ewq1938

Mod
Staff member
Jul 11, 2015
9,395
1,931
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So when we read scripture and it names 10 entities. In a passage of scripture, ie Psalm 83, do we consider it. Especially when it contains Assyria as part of the list, and when we follow the succession of Dan 2, and Dan 7 and it shows where the little horn comes from, ie among the 10 horns, then we look at all the nations mentioned in Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel for eg. Moab, Ammon, Edom, Philistines, Ishmaelites, Byblos, Amalek, Hagrites, Tyre, and Assyria,

No horns are named in Daniel 7 or in Rev.

how do we view it, do we consider there's any relevance, I think we have to, especially when 3 heads are excluded in Dan 7.7, 20,24,

No heads are excluded. I think you are confusing heads with horns.



and those three then probably named in Dan 11.41 as Edom, Ammon, Moab - Lots land (Deut 2,29). Maybe Psalm 83 are the ten toes of Dan 7, 8, Rev 13 and 17 where they become seven heads.

Nothing becomes heads. Heads are mountains which are lands. Horns are kings that have kingdoms in the heads/lands. Example: North America is one head/mountain (think continent) and in that head are 3 horns (kingdoms or governments/countries), Canada, USA, Mexico.

In the endtimes there will be 7 lands possibly continents that will have ten new rulers/kings which will have their own kingdoms/countries. IMO the entire world will be run by ten leaders who all will serve a higher ruler we call the AC.
 

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Thanks, it is so difficult to go into details here. If I were to mention or give you a certain interpretation it may or may not make any sense to you since no interpretation stands on its own. You would not see how it ties in with the earlier verses / interpretations as well as how if must also connect and support the interpretations coming in the later verses and even the later chapters. You might say it makes sense until it is compared to the interpretations that you have established in your own earlier work.... it is just so difficult to present the entire picture. It is as though I would send you a picture of a certain slice of a 1000 puzzle piece from the middle of the puzzle. You might agree that those certain pieces to in fact fit together but if you were to take that slice and try to fit it in within your own puzzle - as you have also been working on, that slice may not fit with your existing work...

Yes and the details are important. I try to bring all the relevant scriptures that are the foundation of my understanding, but often times I'm outright told it's too long and nobody will read it. I find it helps me to have to explain from scratch and re-examine the scriptures each time to make sure I'm reading it properly and over time I get better at finding more refined ways of explaining.

I've always like the puzzle analogy to prophecy. We don't have the box to see the completed picture, but we have the edge pieces and we have the image on each piece that when placed in the right spot, expands the understanding of the whole. But at the same time, every piece is the same shape so you can't necessarily rely on the fit, but rather the image. And so much of the language that paints the picture seems like it might fit. So everyone tries to share their puzzle with pieces all over the place and different from each other, but to each person it seems right. And in your case with the chazon and mareh, you've read images that inform piece placement in your puzzle.

So, we are often forced to exchange interpretations on a micro level if you will and that usually never works. For example, your comment on the difference or importance of the two different visions used in Daniel 8 - the chazon and the mareh visions. In my studies, they are indeed very important and very different. The chazon vision begins in 457 BC and starts at the same time as the 70 weeks of years prophecy. Further, the 4th and final Great Jubilee also begins on this same date. And as events move toward the coming Messiah, each will have their own treatment.


So, let me ask you a question that despite the comments above. What does the Mareh vision mean to you, how do you calculate it and what is it specifically related to? Thanks.

I personally don't see the word mareh being used as a reason to calculate anything. It's in the foundational definition of what mareh and chazon mean to you and what I understand from the definition provided and context used elsewhere in scripture.

To you mareh is the appearance-focused vision and to me it is the act of seeing something. It is translated as vision at times, but primarily as appearance, sight, and countenance. These are actions of viewing something before you and it's not always in a prophetic way.

Daniel 8:16 is saying make this man understand what he's mareh (observing, seeing).

Daniel 8:26 speaks to both the mareh (observation) of the 2,300 evening and morning sacrifices before the cleansing of the temple and the shutting up of the chazon (prophecy). One could say these are both speaking of the vision and I would agree. A prophetic vision is also an observation of what is being shown.

Daniel 8:27 speaks to Daniel being astonished at what he saw in the prophetic vision and didn't understand it. Again the two have different meanings, a prophetic vision (chazon) and seeing something (mareh), but in this context they're almost interchangeable given we know Daniel is seeing a prophetic vision.

I agree Daniel is having a prophetic vision, chazon, and seeing, mareh, in it what God desired for him to pass on to us. But to me those word differences don't underlie a calculation of the time of the end reaching into our future.

I admit I don't fully understand the reasoning for using this difference as a calculation method. Your definition of chazon being the "long-range prophetic vision" is defining a length of time to any chazon, which the word itself does not suggest. The context around the word might suggest a period of time, and that's what I use to define the time being spoken of.

Your definition of mareh being the focused revelation, intended to define short term likewise isn't defined in the word, but in it's context. I agree that the mareh is tied to the cleansing of the temple. I just also think the prophetic vision, chazon, is exactly what the words given were, starting with the ram and goat and ending with the cleansing of the temple and death of cause of its desolation in 164 BC. That's the context of both the chazon and what Daniel saw in it, mareh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CTK

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Read it all as "one future event", Rev 13 and 17 with further detail in Dan 2, 7, 8, 11.

Yes that's what I used to do. I tied them all together and tried to fit 2,300 days into the 70th week and tie the four beasts of Daniel 2 to those of Daniel 7 and the revived Roman Empire and the whole traditional bit. But like just about everything I was taught by those who knew the Bible better than I, when I searched the scriptures to see if it was so instead of just accepting it because they knew the Bible better than me, I found little inconsistencies and big ones here a little and there a little. As I brushed away the leaves of tradition I found the stumbling blocks I kept tripping over.

If I'm really going to trust God, I have to trust His Word and not lean on my own or anyone else's understanding. So I started by taking Him at His Word and believing that every word was placed exactly where it was for a specific purpose, my understanding. When I got over some of my own interpretations taught through tradition, things started fitting together much better and it's like I had a leaf blower revealing all the stumbling blocks that kept me from understanding.

Now one might say that I'm just trying to build my own paradigm of interpretation to be different or have some new thing. But all I'm doing is taking God's Word seriously and leaving as much of my own interpretation out of it as possible. Words have meaning, the way they're ordered give context. God is not the author of confusion, but for most of my time studying His Word, I was trying to fit the traditional stumbling blocks into round holes. When I quit trying to use the stumbling blocks and just read it carefully, things made more sense.

And now I constantly find treasure troves as I search the scriptures that I don't have to figure out how to make fit, they just do because I read them as written and use the Bible to interpret the Bible. The onus is on God to not have lied in His Word and so why would I try and make it say anything other than what it does if I have faith in it?

Do I have everything right? Absolutely not. Will I find error in my conclusions because of that? Absolutely, and I will then attack my own presuppositions and conclusions with the Word of God and set the plumb line of my understanding back to where it should be, at His Word.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
410
34
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
In the time of what kings? This is where context reveals some key details.

Daniel 2:41-44 – "And whereas thou sawest the feet and toes, part of potters' clay, and part of iron, the kingdom shall be divided; but there shall be in it of the strength of the iron, forasmuch as thou sawest the iron mixed with miry clay. And [as] the toes of the feet [were] part of iron, and part of clay, [so] the kingdom shall be partly strong, and partly broken. And whereas thou sawest iron mixed with miry clay, they shall mingle themselves with the seed of men: but they shall not cleave one to another, even as iron is not mixed with clay. And in the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed: and the kingdom shall not be left to other people, [but] it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand for ever."

First, there is a single kingdom in view here, the same fourth kingdom that was strong as iron in the beginning, but gets weaker with the iron and clay mixing. But there are multiple kings, suggesting a span of time within this final kingdom of men before being consumed by the kingdom of God.

Second, the stone struck the feet, suggesting it was before the time of the toes. The kingdom of God came with Yeshua's ministry, but it did not break apart and consume Rome until some time passed. The four kingdoms are sequential, one being defeated by the next, four different metals of decreasing value, but increasing strength until the end of the iron kingdom of Rome.

Third, those kings in view are tied to the ones that mingled in marriage, something tied to within the last 10 kings of Rome. It is the days of those kings that are in view in Daniel 2 when it consumes the shattered image representing those kingdoms of men that came before it.

This is not a view of the time of the end, similar to Daniel 8 it is a statement of the end defined within the vision itself. We have the benefit of history to look back on and see that there was indeed royal intermarriage in the last generation of the Western Roman Empire that cast Israel out of the land and died, never to be found again, before Israel returned to the land almost 2,000 years after being cast out.

That doesn't mean Daniel 2 is outside the scope of the end times, the mountain that fills the earth is, I believe, representative of God's kingdom being established in the earth as the sole rule over man, the completion of what the dream was about in the first place, the kingdom of God replacing the kingdoms of men. And from Zion He will reign over the whole earth, the mountain filling the earth.

It's true Daniel 11-12 starts in history, but Daniel 11:35 makes a transitional statement regarding the time after the first abomination of desolation in 167 BC.

Daniel 11:35 – "And [some] of them of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make [them] white, [even] to the time of the end: because [it is] yet for a time appointed."

But that's almost exactly what Daniel 8:19 says right? Yes, and if it weren't for the context of the rest of the vision I would be less sure. But a king is introduced with language paralleling some of the king from Daniel 11:29-32. However, this new king doesn't regard the God of his fathers, a very Hebrew way of saying YHVW. That does not match the lineage of the little horn Antiochus IV just like Daniel 7 and 8 do not match their origins.

Daniel 11:40, 45-12:1 – "And at the time of the end shall the king of the south push at him: and the king of the north shall come against him like a whirlwind, with chariots, and with horsemen, and with many ships; and he shall enter into the countries, and shall overflow and pass over. ... And he shall plant the tabernacles of his palace between the seas in the glorious holy mountain; yet he shall come to his end, and none shall help him. And at that time shall Michael stand up, the great prince which standeth for the children of thy people: and there shall be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation even to that same time: and at that time thy people shall be delivered, every one that shall be found written in the book."

This king introduced in Daniel 11:36 is attacked at the time of the end by those in verse 35 that would have been called the Ptolemaic Empire (Egypt) and Seleucid Empire (Turkey/Syria/Iran/Iraq). Egypt is specifically defeated by this new king as are those to the north and east. That's one stated nation and two directions covering the king of the south and north, modern nations in the land of the old kingdoms. It is at that time that the unparalleled time of Jacob's trouble in Judea takes place, the event Yeshua places before the sixth seal and His return at the time of the end. Matthew 24:15-22, Mark 13:14-20, Jeremiah 30:4-7, Daniel 12:1

Given all these are unparalleled in all of history and tied to Israel and they are saved out of that time, all four of these passages speak of the same event at the same time of the end. This defines for me the context of the time of the end because the end of that king in Jerusalem begins the reign of the false messiah, the Beast. And the beast has a mortal wound that is healed just before the abomination of desolation that starts the unparalleled great tribulation.

So there are certainly visions Daniel had that started in history and end in our future. There are also visions that started in Daniel's future and ended in our history. We have the benefit of God's Word and hindsight and each vision must be examined as given to determine what appears as history and what does not. They're all interconnected in some ways though, in this case as foreshadows of the Beast from history in word and deed. I certainly don't deny the relevance of that interconnection, but I think many skim the text and make connections that are not as solid as they think when you dig into the details and grammar. These things matter in understanding imo.
Unless its written for our time. Otherwise most it is simply a history book.
 

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Nothing becomes heads. Heads are mountains which are lands. Horns are kings that have kingdoms in the heads/lands. Example: North America is one head/mountain (think continent) and in that head are 3 horns (kingdoms or governments/countries), Canada, USA, Mexico.

In the endtimes there will be 7 lands possibly continents that will have ten new rulers/kings which will have their own kingdoms/countries. IMO the entire world will be run by ten leaders who all will serve a higher ruler we call the AC.

I agree that the heads are tied to mountains and speak to the land, but I think Genesis 15:18-21 is the land in question in which Mount Zion sits.

I also agree with the idea that kings have kingdoms that reside on land owned by the king where his loyal subjects live under his protection traditionally. I think this is what the actions of the little horn will revolve around and what the ultimate victory of Yeshua will revolve around.

The land on which 10 kingdoms originally sat when given to Abraham's Seed belongs to Yeshua. The little horn will come in His name saying he is the Messiah and divide the land for gain. There is also a promise to Israel to be given lots according to their tribes and through the little horn's conquests he will be establishing his dominance over his land to give to his people that will come from around the world back to the land they believe the Messiah is establishing their kingdom in.

But he's a wolf in sheep's clothing and the true Messiah, Yeshua, will destroy the Beast's kingdom and armies at Armageddon and establish His eternal kingdom over the ashes of those that were in His land. The faithful of Israel will come out of the wilderness into the promised land once more only this time with their Messiah and their God reigning from a new Jerusalem larger than that of today.

I think the 10 kings of kingdoms in the land are in Yeshua's land, the surrounding Islamic kingdoms that are antagonistic to Israel's existence and a good enemy to defeat as part of his deception. They will give their power over to him after his defeat of three of them and his resurrection because God puts it in their heart to fulfill His will in doing so. But their hatred for Israel will ultimately lead to the destruction of Jerusalem before Armageddon, mystery, Babylon the great, mother of harlots. In the harlot city's destruction, she will never rise again because faithful Jerusalem will be established forever.

Isaiah 1:21-28 – "How is the faithful city become an harlot! it was full of judgment; righteousness lodged in it; but now murderers. Thy silver is become dross, thy wine mixed with water: Thy princes [are] rebellious, and companions of thieves: every one loveth gifts, and followeth after rewards: they judge not the fatherless, neither doth the cause of the widow come unto them. Therefore saith the Lord, the LORD of hosts, the mighty One of Israel, Ah, I will ease me of mine adversaries, and avenge me of mine enemies: And I will turn my hand upon thee, and purely purge away thy dross, and take away all thy tin: And I will restore thy judges as at the first, and thy counsellors as at the beginning: afterward thou shalt be called, The city of righteousness, the faithful city. Zion shall be redeemed with judgment, and her converts with righteousness. And the destruction of the transgressors and of the sinners [shall be] together, and they that forsake the LORD shall be consumed."
 

A Watchman

New Member
Aug 20, 2023
90
8
8
Tacoma
www.watchmanbiblestudy.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Unless its written for our time. Otherwise most it is simply a history book.

I guess I see it as a book of faith where what is fulfilled historically had a purpose for it's time to be spoken. But ultimately, at the time of the end when understanding is unsealed and knowledge increases, the history and future play off each other to provide insight to even the time of the end and faith that what God says will happen is going to happen as He said it would. We have evidence of this from historical fulfillment so we are without excuse.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
410
34
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
I guess I see it as a book of faith where what is fulfilled historically had a purpose for it's time to be spoken.
I agree, its a book of faith. And most of the issues we discuss, fit into the 'what is fulfilled historically section' where each has a view. Those are the areas we discuss and supply scripture for, to back our thoughts on a matter.
I have issues with the historical aspect, if its outside of scripture. It then becomes speculation obtained from mostly unbelievers writings of 2000 years ago. I prefer to keep to scripture, hence I struggle with the Rome, Alexander concept.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,686
369
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Yes and the details are important. I try to bring all the relevant scriptures that are the foundation of my understanding, but often times I'm outright told it's too long and nobody will read it. I find it helps me to have to explain from scratch and re-examine the scriptures each time to make sure I'm reading it properly and over time I get better at finding more refined ways of explaining.

I've always like the puzzle analogy to prophecy. We don't have the box to see the completed picture, but we have the edge pieces and we have the image on each piece that when placed in the right spot, expands the understanding of the whole. But at the same time, every piece is the same shape so you can't necessarily rely on the fit, but rather the image. And so much of the language that paints the picture seems like it might fit. So everyone tries to share their puzzle with pieces all over the place and different from each other, but to each person it seems right. And in your case with the chazon and mareh, you've read images that inform piece placement in your puzzle.



I personally don't see the word mareh being used as a reason to calculate anything. It's in the foundational definition of what mareh and chazon mean to you and what I understand from the definition provided and context used elsewhere in scripture.

To you mareh is the appearance-focused vision and to me it is the act of seeing something. It is translated as vision at times, but primarily as appearance, sight, and countenance. These are actions of viewing something before you and it's not always in a prophetic way.

Daniel 8:16 is saying make this man understand what he's mareh (observing, seeing).

Daniel 8:26 speaks to both the mareh (observation) of the 2,300 evening and morning sacrifices before the cleansing of the temple and the shutting up of the chazon (prophecy). One could say these are both speaking of the vision and I would agree. A prophetic vision is also an observation of what is being shown.

Daniel 8:27 speaks to Daniel being astonished at what he saw in the prophetic vision and didn't understand it. Again the two have different meanings, a prophetic vision (chazon) and seeing something (mareh), but in this context they're almost interchangeable given we know Daniel is seeing a prophetic vision.

I agree Daniel is having a prophetic vision, chazon, and seeing, mareh, in it what God desired for him to pass on to us. But to me those word differences don't underlie a calculation of the time of the end reaching into our future.

I admit I don't fully understand the reasoning for using this difference as a calculation method. Your definition of chazon being the "long-range prophetic vision" is defining a length of time to any chazon, which the word itself does not suggest. The context around the word might suggest a period of time, and that's what I use to define the time being spoken of.

Your definition of mareh being the focused revelation, intended to define short term likewise isn't defined in the word, but in it's context. I agree that the mareh is tied to the cleansing of the temple. I just also think the prophetic vision, chazon, is exactly what the words given were, starting with the ram and goat and ending with the cleansing of the temple and death of cause of its desolation in 164 BC. That's the context of both the chazon and what Daniel saw in it, mareh.
The Mareh vision is an "appearance focused vision" and that is important because it is directly tied to the evenings and mornings prophecy - the cleansing of the sanctuary. So, the only One who could possibly cleanse the sanctuary would be the Messiah through His perfect sacrifice. And remember, we are talking about the heavenly sanctuary. So this refers to the "appearance" of the Messiah when He arrives on the first day of the 70th week to begin His ministry. The 2300 evenings and mornings sacrifice is the Mareh vision. Daniel is giving us a "how long" in 8:14 when the sacrifice is cleansed....
 

quietthinker

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2018
16,356
9,888
113
Sunshine
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
The seven heads represent a location where the woman sits (verse 9). And also seven kings (verse 10).

Revelation 17:
9 And here is the mind which hath wisdom. The seven heads are seven mountains, on which the woman sitteth.

10 And there are seven kings: five are fallen, and one is, and the other is not yet come; and when he cometh, he must continue a short space.

five fallen: Julius Caesar,, Augustus Caesar, Tiberius Caesar, Caligula Caesar, Claudius Caesar
one is: Nero Caesar
other not yet come: end times little horn person.


Three charts below.

1. Status at the time of John, 1st century, Revelation 17:10
2. Status at the beginning of the 7 years, end times, Revelation 12:3
3. Status 42 months before Jesus returns, Revelation 13:1



View attachment 93481

View attachment 93482

View attachment 93483




I think the name of blasphemy could be "Caesar".
The connection is the misrepresentation of God. That’s where blasphemy resides.
‘Idol’ worship is none other than the misrepresentation of God and in particular, when it is presented under the umbrella of the genuine article.
 

William Barton

Well-Known Member
Apr 7, 2026
1,163
163
63
75
Lexington KY
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
IMO:
This is apocalyptic literature. "Apocalyptic" stems from Greek:
απο = οff
καλυπσις = a cover

Hence it "uncovers" the future, in such a manner that the wise will understand (Daniel 12:10).