Penal Substitutionary Atonement

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

MonoBiblical

Well-Known Member
Apr 18, 2024
1,700
266
83
52
midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gal. 4:3-7 (W.E.B.)
3 So we also, when we were children, were held in bondage under the elemental principles of the world.
4 But when the fullness of the time came, God sent out his Son, born to a woman, born under the law,
5 that he might redeem those who were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of children.
6 And because you are children, God sent out the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!”
7 So you are no longer a bondservant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.


If you are not a son of God in this life, you will never be one. Now is the accepted time; now is the day of salvation.
Tell that to dead people, if you think you can. You are not a progeny of God because God did not start you. Adam, Eve, and Jesus were the 3 exceptions.
 

MonoBiblical

Well-Known Member
Apr 18, 2024
1,700
266
83
52
midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I already know that, but that wasn't and isn't the point: you quoted something I wrote which was taken straight from the scripture, "This is the Torah of the sin offering", and you then inserted your idea of soteria, which I responded that soteria is the peace offering, and even referenced a passage in the Torah where it is employed in that manner in the LXX. You are apparently confounding things for some private internal motive. Context matters: in the LXX version of the Torah soteria is often used for the peace offering, but never for the sin offering. All one needs to do is look in the corresponding Hebrew text to see that this is true. You are here preaching as a grown up with authority: I therefore have no need to try to wean you off your errors and treat you like the babe that you are. Study to show yourself approved and perhaps you will stop getting knocked off your high horse.
Were not the Israelites rescued on Passover? Am I the one who is dense?
 

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
291
229
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
Tell that to dead people, if you think you can. You are not a progeny of God because God did not start you. Adam, Eve, and Jesus were the 3 exceptions.
I showed you what God's word says (that believers in Jesus Christ are sons of God). As a Christian, I believe what God's word says. Why don't you?
 

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,616
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
This is interesting. This would mean that the sin offering was to deal with the problem preventing salvation (sin); and the peace offering was for salvation (restored fellowship with God, health, well-being, etc.) - two facets of Jesus' vicarious sacrifice on the cross.

I agree up until the final statement. Peace between the Father and His people comes through His Word, His Son, including the words spoken through the Meshiah in the Gospel accounts. The Testimony is the sin-offering, (if we believe/trust all of it and walk in that Testimony with him). In the same sense that Tesrtimony, (in the Gospel accounts), is also the Peace offering because walking in it with the Master is pleasing to the Father: thus the Master says to his talmidim, "Peace I leave with you: my peace I give unto you", (John 14:27). However, as for vicarious human sacrifice on a stake, they did not kill the Meshiah so that you could be saved: they killed him for his all-important Testimony which was unto them a threat, but unto us the sacrifices he made which save us because his Testimony teaches us how to walk pleasing to the Father.

A vicarious sacrifice of a human being or a perceived man-God is the result of believing the Torah according to the carnal minded way of the Chief priests, Pharisees, Sadducees, scribes, etc., who understood the Torah according to the natural mind and eyes of the natural man, (and who rejected the Meshiah). For if you understand the Torah sacrificial commands according the flesh, as flesh and blood animals, then you will surely translate all of that onto the Meshiah, and thus, you end up with a human sacrifice for your sins which is not much different from the Aztecs. The Torah is spiritual, (Rom 7:14a).

So then, yes to the first portion of your post, but I say nay to final statement: for it is his Testimony that delivers and saves us, and that is the δωρον gift-offering of Eph. 2:8, not his murder and the resulting physical blood. And that Testimony was not even his own, but was given to him from the heavens, from above, from the Father, (John 3:27 within its context, and John 12:47-50), yet he paid for that holy Testimony with his own blood. And the resurrection therefore proves and seals that Testimony; that it was sealed and approved by the Father.
 

David1701

Active Member
Oct 7, 2026
291
229
43
Peterhead
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Male
I agree up until the final statement. Peace between the Father and His people comes through His Word, His Son, including the words spoken through the Meshiah in the Gospel accounts. The Testimony is the sin-offering, (if we believe/trust all of it and walk in that Testimony with him). In the same sense that Tesrtimony, (in the Gospel accounts), is also the Peace offering because walking in it with the Master is pleasing to the Father: thus the Master says to his talmidim, "Peace I leave with you: my peace I give unto you", (John 14:27). However, as for vicarious human sacrifice on a stake, they did not kill the Meshiah so that you could be saved: they killed him for his all-important Testimony which was unto them a threat, but unto us the sacrifices he made which save us because his Testimony teaches us how to walk pleasing to the Father.

A vicarious sacrifice of a human being or a perceived man-God is the result of believing the Torah according to the carnal minded way of the Chief priests, Pharisees, Sadducees, scribes, etc., who understood the Torah according to the natural mind and eyes of the natural man, (and who rejected the Meshiah). For if you understand the Torah sacrificial commands according the flesh, as flesh and blood animals, then you will surely translate all of that onto the Meshiah, and thus, you end up with a human sacrifice for your sins which is not much different from the Aztecs. The Torah is spiritual, (Rom 7:14a).

So then, yes to the first portion of your post, but I say nay to final statement: for it is his Testimony that delivers and saves us, and that is the δωρον gift-offering of Eph. 2:8, not his murder and the resulting physical blood. And that Testimony was not even his own, but was given to him from the heavens, from above, from the Father, (John 3:27 within its context, and John 12:47-50), yet he paid for that holy Testimony with his own blood. And the resurrection therefore proves and seals that Testimony; that it was sealed and approved by the Father.
This is clearly not Christian doctrine; so, what religion are you? Some kind of Gnostic?
 

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,616
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
This is clearly not Christian doctrine; so, what religion are you? Some kind of Gnostic?

It's no secret that I am an Adoptionist, having spoken about it plenty of times and places on this particular board where I most often post, (I have no posting privileges in the Christian-only boards). Adoptionism is not Gnosticism, and, just so you know, my form of Adoptionism is not of the Arian type, (I am not an Arian).

However, all of my understanding is derived from the scripture, and is provable with the scripture: but this is not true of your own private version of what you call Christian. Your version of Christianity is so far removed from the teachings of the Meshiah and his Apostles that you have no clue what original first century Christianity was about: and it was originally Adoptionism, until your so-called church fathers got hold of the scriptures.

How does any of this have anything to do with the thread topic?
 

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,772
23,612
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
I agree up until the final statement. Peace between the Father and His people comes through His Word, His Son, including the words spoken through the Meshiah in the Gospel accounts. The Testimony is the sin-offering, (if we believe/trust all of it and walk in that Testimony with him). In the same sense that Tesrtimony, (in the Gospel accounts), is also the Peace offering because walking in it with the Master is pleasing to the Father: thus the Master says to his talmidim, "Peace I leave with you: my peace I give unto you", (John 14:27). However, as for vicarious human sacrifice on a stake, they did not kill the Meshiah so that you could be saved: they killed him for his all-important Testimony which was unto them a threat, but unto us the sacrifices he made which save us because his Testimony teaches us how to walk pleasing to the Father.

A vicarious sacrifice of a human being or a perceived man-God is the result of believing the Torah according to the carnal minded way of the Chief priests, Pharisees, Sadducees, scribes, etc., who understood the Torah according to the natural mind and eyes of the natural man, (and who rejected the Meshiah). For if you understand the Torah sacrificial commands according the flesh, as flesh and blood animals, then you will surely translate all of that onto the Meshiah, and thus, you end up with a human sacrifice for your sins which is not much different from the Aztecs. The Torah is spiritual, (Rom 7:14a).

So then, yes to the first portion of your post, but I say nay to final statement: for it is his Testimony that delivers and saves us, and that is the δωρον gift-offering of Eph. 2:8, not his murder and the resulting physical blood. And that Testimony was not even his own, but was given to him from the heavens, from above, from the Father, (John 3:27 within its context, and John 12:47-50), yet he paid for that holy Testimony with his own blood. And the resurrection therefore proves and seals that Testimony; that it was sealed and approved by the Father.
The purpose of Messiah's death was to defeat sin and death through the power of His resurrection. The law says that the soul that sins it shall die. But Jesus was without sin, therefore the very institution or curse of death was lifted or taken away for all who walk in His life. He was raised for our justification....or all who die with Him and are raised with Him....participate in His victory over the the devil and evil men who follow after the devil. The process of salvation involves dying or losing one's life in order to be resurrected with Christ and walk in His victory over sin, the devil and the world.

All who abide in Christ walk in His resurrection life and power...and don't sin...since there is no sin in Christ. In Him is no sin.

A dead religion claims the sacrifice of Christ for sins even as sin still remains master over the claimant. Such are false believers.
 
Last edited:

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,772
23,612
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
It's no secret that I am an Adoptionist, having spoken about it plenty of times and places on this particular board where I most often post, (I have no posting privileges in the Christian-only boards). Adoptionism is not Gnosticism, and, just so you know, my form of Adoptionism is not of the Arian type, (I am not an Arian).

However, all of my understanding is derived from the scripture, and is provable with the scripture: but this is not true of your own private version of what you call Christian. Your version of Christianity is so far removed from the teachings of the Meshiah and his Apostles that you have no clue what original first century Christianity was about: and it was originally Adoptionism, until your so-called church fathers got hold of the scriptures.

How does any of this have anything to do with the thread topic?
We are just human after all. It's true that many of the early Jewish believers were adoptionist. They saw Jesus as being glorified because He was faithful. And there is biblical evidence to support that.

But just like Protestantism has done, you can take one idea too far so as to negate other truth.

The irony in all this is that modern believers negate the words of Jesus...since they deny He is human and spoke the truth. They ignore Jesus' words and treat Jesus as an idol. The early church did the very opposite....even selling all to have all things in common. The Ebionites OBEYED Jesus' words. To counter that, the believers in Jesus eternal divinity chose to NOT obey Jesus but rather to follow a follower of Christ, Paul. Paul said...follow me as I follow Christ. And since most modern believers don't know Jesus at all...they have chosen a second-hand approach that fully ignores Jesus since they don't understand Paul.

So we have a conundrum....those who are in error actually seek to obey Jesus. And those who see Jesus as eternal ignore Him.

Such is the ridiculous state of the church.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dak

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,616
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The purpose of Messiah's death was to defeat sin and death through the power of His resurrection.

Amen.

The law says that the soul that sins it shall die.

How do you understand this? I see it as a commandment to cut off sin: part yourself into members and count them as soul(s), for there is a war in the bodily members. Put to death the soul, (member), that sins, (Paul). Cut off the hand or foot that causes you to stumble, (Meshiah). These are the same explanation for the commandment to put to death the soul that sins: it's just that people do not believe the Testimony of the Meshiah interprets the Torah for us.

But Jesus was without sin, therefore the very institution or curse of death was lifted or taken away for all who walk in His life.

Amen, taking up our own stake and following him: die now instead of waiting until the carcass is dead, for when the whole carcass is dead the old man who was never converted will die with his old carcass.

It is appointed unto men once to die, then the judgment: and every one will die for his or her own iniquities in the new-renewed covenant, (Jer 31:29-30), therefore it is much better to die now than to put it off until the whole carcass dies. Thus the Testimony of the Meshiah even teaches us how to die in such a manner that is pleasing to the Father, by taking up or own stake and following in the manner which the Master has laid out for us in his all-important Testimony in the Gospel accounts.

He was raised for our justification....or all who die with Him and are raised with Him....participate in His victory over the the devil and evil men who follow after the devil. The process of salvation involves dying or losing one's life in order to be resurrected with Christ and walk in His victory over sin, the devil and the world.

All who abide in Christ walk in His resurrection life and power...and don't sin...since there is no sin in Christ. In Him is no sin.

Amen just as in my comments directly above.

A dead religion claims the sacrifice Christ for sins even as sin still remains master over the claimant. Such are false believers.

Not sure about the statement "A dead religion claims the sacrifice Christ for sins", it seems incomplete or as if something is missing or misspelled. I therefore cannot answer.
 

dak

Well-Known Member
Feb 9, 2013
1,616
223
63
Chrestianos
sites.google.com
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
We are just human after all. It's true that many of the early Jewish believers were adoptionist. They saw Jesus as being glorified because He was faithful. And there is biblical evidence to support that.

But just like Protestantism has done, you can take one idea too far so as to negate other truth.

The irony in all this is that modern believers negate the words of Jesus...since they deny He is human and spoke the truth. They ignore Jesus' words and treat Jesus as an idol. The early church did the very opposite....even selling all to have all things in common. The Ebionites OBEYED Jesus' words. To counter that, the believers in Jesus eternal divinity chose to NOT obey Jesus but rather to follow a follower of Christ, Paul. Paul said...follow me as I follow Christ. And since most modern believers don't know Jesus at all...they have chosen a second-hand approach that fully ignores Jesus since they don't understand Paul.

So we have a conundrum....those who are in error actually seek to obey Jesus. And those who see Jesus as eternal ignore Him.

Such is the ridiculous state of the church.

No doubt.
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands

Valentinus​

Valentinus: Annihilation of the Realm of Death​

The following text is excerpted from Bentley Layton in The Gnostic Scriptures (Doubleday 1987), p. 241. The text comes from Clement of Alexandria, Stromateis 4.89.1-3. Please refer to Layton for background, bibliography, and notes.

Fragment F

From the beginning you (plur.) have been immortal, and you are children of eternal life.
And you wanted death to be allocated to yourselves so that you might spend it and use it up, and that death might die in you and through you. For when you nullify the world and are not yourselves annihilated, you are lord over creation and all corruption.

This is very proto-orthodox.

abracadabra to me.
 

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
2,397
1,978
113
52
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
Resist the lies of the Babylonian church....there is no PSA. It is a major deviation from the truth.

In the simplest possible terms, the biblical doctrine of penal substitution holds that Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross takes the place of the punishment we ought to suffer for our sins. As a result, God’s justice is satisfied, and those who accept Christ can be forgiven and reconciled to God.


As long as the word "wrath" is not used in PSA it is a correct doctrine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,772
23,612
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Amen.



How do you understand this? I see it as a commandment to cut off sin: part yourself into members and count them as soul(s), for there is a war in the bodily members. Put to death the soul, (member), that sins, (Paul). Cut off the hand or foot that causes you to stumble, (Meshiah). These are the same explanation for the commandment to put to death the soul that sins: it's just that people do not believe the Testimony of the Meshiah interprets the Torah for us.



Amen, taking up our own stake and following him: die now instead of waiting until the carcass is dead, for when the whole carcass is dead the old man who was never converted will die with his old carcass.

It is appointed unto men once to die, then the judgment: and every one will die for his or her own iniquities in the new-renewed covenant, (Jer 31:29-30), therefore it is much better to die now than to put it off until the whole carcass dies. Thus the Testimony of the Meshiah even teaches us how to die in such a manner that is pleasing to the Father, by taking up or own stake and following in the manner which the Master has laid out for us in his all-important Testimony in the Gospel accounts.



Amen just as in my comments directly above.



Not sure about the statement "A dead religion claims the sacrifice Christ for sins", it seems incomplete or as if something is missing or misspelled. I therefore cannot answer.
I forgot the word "for" as in "the sacrifice of Christ for sins... as in...my personal protection from prosecution for sins. There is no such guarantee in the bible.
 

CrowCross

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2026
1,983
597
113
Philly
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Good question I like what this says: [Rev 21:7 NKJV] – 7 "He who overcomes shall inherit all things, and I will be his God and he shall be My son.
OK, you shifted the definition of inheritance to overcoming....what is "overcoming"?
 

CrowCross

Well-Known Member
Jun 25, 2026
1,983
597
113
Philly
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Gal. 4:3-7 (W.E.B.)
3 So we also, when we were children, were held in bondage under the elemental principles of the world.
4 But when the fullness of the time came, God sent out his Son, born to a woman, born under the law,
5 that he might redeem those who were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of children.
6 And because you are children, God sent out the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!”
7 So you are no longer a bondservant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ.


If you are not a son of God in this life, you will never be one. Now is the accepted time; now is the day of salvation.
I thought the question...."You claim to be a son of God but you aren't even dead yet."...was a strange question.
 

Episkopos

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2011
15,772
23,612
113
68
Montreal
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
In the simplest possible terms, the biblical doctrine of penal substitution holds that Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross takes the place of the punishment we ought to suffer for our sins. As a result, God’s justice is satisfied, and those who accept Christ can be forgiven and reconciled to God.


As long as the word "wrath" is not used in PSA it is a correct doctrine.
Forgiveness is based on God's mercy, not His sacrifice. And you are confusing God's justice with His holiness. Sin destroys holiness not righteousness. God is holy. And we are to be holy because He is...IF we want to be in relationship with Him.