Paul Christensen
Well-Known Member
- Mar 2, 2020
- 3,068
- 1,619
- 113
- 77
- Faith
- Christian
- Country
- New Zealand
I read enough of the article to determine that these respected scholars are trying to explain with human wisdom, what was a straight miracle. There were 120 people who got filled with the Spirit on the Day of Pentecost, and there is nothing to say that the crowd heard just 12 people speaking in tongues. Whether the 120 actually spoke the languages, or the people from different regions heard their own language is not conclusive.If you have the maturity to read something all the way through, carefully and slowly, without judging, you might like this article.
If you lack that ability, don't bother opening this. (It isn't being placed here to listen to arguments about how you "know" what is correct. It's probably too long for you, anyway. LOL)
A New Look At Tongues
Also it is quite true that the pilgrims were either Jews from other regions or gentile "God-fearers" who had converted to Judaism. So the Jewish ones would understand Hebrew and Aramaic, and the gentile ones would understand Greek, as well as their own regional dialects which did not disappear when Alexander the Great introduced Koine Greek to those regions. It is the same in New Zealand where English was introduced by the first British colonists, but the indigenous NZ Maori language is still widely spoken as an official NZ language alongside English. Similarly, English and Spanish are side by side languages in California and other states bordering Mexico. Canada has English and French spoken side by side in certain provinces. Switzerland has people speaking English, French, and German, with some children speaking a mixture of these languages without knowing! Nothing out of the ordinary there. Therefore it is quite possible that in the regions listed by Luke, Latin, Greek and regional dialects would be spoken.
So it is quite possible that when the 120 were heard speaking in tongues, persons from each of the listed regions could well have heard their own dialects spoken and not Hebrew or Greek, and it is significant that these ones were amazed because they knew that the 120 were "uneducated Galilieans". The pilgrims from the regions knew that these Galileans could never have known their regional dialects, and that is what amazed them. If the 120 were speaking just Hebrew or Greek, then the crowd would not have been amazed at all.