I Don't Think I Can Be a Christian Anymore

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

PossibleThrowawayAccount

Active Member
Oct 1, 2022
176
120
43
33
Pittsburgh, PA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I know very well that I am probably going to be met with criticism, blame and insults for posting this but it is something I need to talk about. I am also well aware that this is mainly a Protestant board and I did post this on a Catholic site, but I felt it was worth asking this on a place that is open to everyone of all the different branches of Christianity.

Not too long ago I used to be a devote Catholic. I had a small altar in my bedroom and prayed the rosary every night while tired and standing on sore feet (I cannot kneel due to a knee injury). I always stood by God no matter what hurdles life threw at me. I have been through domestic abuse, poverty, self esteem issues, being unable to find a life partner, and seeing every single dream I ever had destroyed.

Everything continued to stack up and to add to my problems I have found myself unemployable and without work for almost two months now. One person who interviewed me outright told me that I would never find stable work because of my employment history, accusing me of job hopping. To make matters worse my closest family members got jobs at that same place and I have to be constantly reminded of it. That was it for me. I felt like God hated me and I couldn't feel comfortable being a Catholic anymore, worshiping a God who disliked me so much that He would make a total loser. If I can be completely honest, I feel like every bad thing that has happened to me and all the humiliation is because of what God thinks about me. I think He hates me so He gave me a terrible life with no chance of happiness.

So I sought shelter in Hinduism. I'm not new to Hinduism, I have loved its mythology since I was a kid and if I can be completely honest, it did wonders for me. Knowing that the body I possess is not the real me made me feel better about my situation and the hurtful things people have said about me over the years. Everyone was attacking my ego, but not my true spiritual self. Hinduism also offers me a chance to become a totally new person. I can change my name and the way I look. I didn't leave out of anger but because I genuinely don't think I can hold onto my faith anymore and no matter how hard I tried to remain Christian, the feeling that God hates me keeps pushing me away.

For the first time in my life the things that hurt me did not seem to matter, but there was one fatal flaw. There is no evidence for it while the life, crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus is an indisputable fact with evidence to back it up. There are also modern miracles and apparitions that back it up. No matter how good Hinduism makes me feel, I can't pretend that there was no resurrection of Jesus or that Mary doesn't appear on earth from time to time, especially when there are photographs and videos that record the apparitions. I also cannot deny the miracles of the Eucharist. Despite how hated God makes me feel, I kind of miss Catholicism. I felt empty when I was packing away my altar supplies and I couldn't help but feel warm when I remembered my nightly worship hours.

Right now I don't know what to do. I feel like my only options are going back to Catholicisms where I would worship a God who hates me, or becoming a Hindu and accepting things I do not believe in.
 

Sel@h

New Member
Oct 3, 2026
16
23
3
74
Louisiana
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Precious person, beloved of the Lord—I read your heart in this post, and the first thing I want to tell you is that you are not a "loser." You are a survivor. You have endured abuse, poverty, and heartbreak, and the fact that you are still searching for truth and meaning is a testament to the strength God has placed within you, even when you feel He has abandoned you. God loves you so much.
 
  • Loveit!
Reactions: GRACE ambassador

Bob

Well-Known Member
Sep 23, 2023
967
912
93
Tucson, AZ
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Thank You for sharing.

The essence of the post seems to be “O woe is me, what an awful life I’ve been subjected to.“ There is not much testimony on efforts to love your neighbor or God. Christianity is about helping others, including sacrificing personal gain and even life.

Your retreat to Hinduism, a religion all about self (and family, at best), is consistent with what appears to be your view of Catholicism (again, based on what you wrote).

God does love you, and perhaps the difficulties thrown at you were to prepare you for another important task. You have spoken to us freely, so now, pray to Him honestly, openly, fervently. Ask for guidance, especially regarding activities for loving your neighbor.

Many blessings.
 
  • Praying
Reactions: GRACE ambassador

Serve your King!

New Member
Oct 5, 2026
4
1
3
26
AZ Mountains
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I know very well that I am probably going to be met with criticism, blame and insults for posting this but it is something I need to talk about. I am also well aware that this is mainly a Protestant board and I did post this on a Catholic site, but I felt it was worth asking this on a place that is open to everyone of all the different branches of Christianity.

Not too long ago I used to be a devote Catholic. I had a small altar in my bedroom and prayed the rosary every night while tired and standing on sore feet (I cannot kneel due to a knee injury). I always stood by God no matter what hurdles life threw at me. I have been through domestic abuse, poverty, self esteem issues, being unable to find a life partner, and seeing every single dream I ever had destroyed.

Everything continued to stack up and to add to my problems I have found myself unemployable and without work for almost two months now. One person who interviewed me outright told me that I would never find stable work because of my employment history, accusing me of job hopping. To make matters worse my closest family members got jobs at that same place and I have to be constantly reminded of it. That was it for me. I felt like God hated me and I couldn't feel comfortable being a Catholic anymore, worshiping a God who disliked me so much that He would make a total loser. If I can be completely honest, I feel like every bad thing that has happened to me and all the humiliation is because of what God thinks about me. I think He hates me so He gave me a terrible life with no chance of happiness.

So I sought shelter in Hinduism. I'm not new to Hinduism, I have loved its mythology since I was a kid and if I can be completely honest, it did wonders for me. Knowing that the body I possess is not the real me made me feel better about my situation and the hurtful things people have said about me over the years. Everyone was attacking my ego, but not my true spiritual self. Hinduism also offers me a chance to become a totally new person. I can change my name and the way I look. I didn't leave out of anger but because I genuinely don't think I can hold onto my faith anymore and no matter how hard I tried to remain Christian, the feeling that God hates me keeps pushing me away.

For the first time in my life the things that hurt me did not seem to matter, but there was one fatal flaw. There is no evidence for it while the life, crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus is an indisputable fact with evidence to back it up. There are also modern miracles and apparitions that back it up. No matter how good Hinduism makes me feel, I can't pretend that there was no resurrection of Jesus or that Mary doesn't appear on earth from time to time, especially when there are photographs and videos that record the apparitions. I also cannot deny the miracles of the Eucharist. Despite how hated God makes me feel, I kind of miss Catholicism. I felt empty when I was packing away my altar supplies and I couldn't help but feel warm when I remembered my nightly worship hours.

Right now I don't know what to do. I feel like my only options are going back to Catholicisms where I would worship a God who hates me, or becoming a Hindu and accepting things I do not believe in.
Good news! You never were a Christian! Catholics are fine folks (I was one for 65 years), but not Christians!
The only Christians are those who have committed to a life following Jesus. The only path to the Father is through the Son. You want to run away from "religions" into Jesus' arms and ask him for salvation: NOT some failed human in a black robe hidden in a dark room.
For starters, throw away all the idols you had worshiped and begin reading and following the Bible. God has always loved you! When you ask the Lord for salvation your life will change in an instant, and you will find the Agape love you have missed in your explorations. If you end up in a church, only go to Bible centric Christian churches. Calvary churches are a fine place to start, but first listen to Bible loving Pastors like Jack Hibbs. May you be blessed!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sel@h

Sel@h

New Member
Oct 3, 2026
16
23
3
74
Louisiana
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
@PossibleThrowawayAccount

The greatest evidence that God does not hate you is the Cross. God loved you so much that He took on human flesh, experienced betrayal, felt the crushing weight of loneliness, and endured physical torture and death—all for you.

Romans 5:8 tells us, "But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us." Jesus didn't wait for you to have a perfect life to love you. He came so that in Him, you would have Life.

In John 3:16-17, we are reminded: “For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved.”
 
  • Loveit!
Reactions: GRACE ambassador

SavedInHim

Well-Known Member
Jan 10, 2023
711
686
93
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I know very well that I am probably going to be met with criticism, blame and insults for posting this but it is something I need to talk about. I am also well aware that this is mainly a Protestant board and I did post this on a Catholic site, but I felt it was worth asking this on a place that is open to everyone of all the different branches of Christianity.

Not too long ago I used to be a devote Catholic. I had a small altar in my bedroom and prayed the rosary every night while tired and standing on sore feet (I cannot kneel due to a knee injury). I always stood by God no matter what hurdles life threw at me. I have been through domestic abuse, poverty, self esteem issues, being unable to find a life partner, and seeing every single dream I ever had destroyed.

Everything continued to stack up and to add to my problems I have found myself unemployable and without work for almost two months now. One person who interviewed me outright told me that I would never find stable work because of my employment history, accusing me of job hopping. To make matters worse my closest family members got jobs at that same place and I have to be constantly reminded of it. That was it for me. I felt like God hated me and I couldn't feel comfortable being a Catholic anymore, worshiping a God who disliked me so much that He would make a total loser. If I can be completely honest, I feel like every bad thing that has happened to me and all the humiliation is because of what God thinks about me. I think He hates me so He gave me a terrible life with no chance of happiness.

So I sought shelter in Hinduism. I'm not new to Hinduism, I have loved its mythology since I was a kid and if I can be completely honest, it did wonders for me. Knowing that the body I possess is not the real me made me feel better about my situation and the hurtful things people have said about me over the years. Everyone was attacking my ego, but not my true spiritual self. Hinduism also offers me a chance to become a totally new person. I can change my name and the way I look. I didn't leave out of anger but because I genuinely don't think I can hold onto my faith anymore and no matter how hard I tried to remain Christian, the feeling that God hates me keeps pushing me away.

For the first time in my life the things that hurt me did not seem to matter, but there was one fatal flaw. There is no evidence for it while the life, crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus is an indisputable fact with evidence to back it up. There are also modern miracles and apparitions that back it up. No matter how good Hinduism makes me feel, I can't pretend that there was no resurrection of Jesus or that Mary doesn't appear on earth from time to time, especially when there are photographs and videos that record the apparitions. I also cannot deny the miracles of the Eucharist. Despite how hated God makes me feel, I kind of miss Catholicism. I felt empty when I was packing away my altar supplies and I couldn't help but feel warm when I remembered my nightly worship hours.

Right now I don't know what to do. I feel like my only options are going back to Catholicisms where I would worship a God who hates me, or becoming a Hindu and accepting things I do not believe in.
You need to forget about religion and work on a close relationship with God and His Son. You can do this best by His word and prayer.

"Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you." Matthew 7:7

God is the one who gives peace, not religion.