Finally, a doctrine Superjag and I agree on.I actually agree, but I may not interpret the specifics as he has. However, Justin Martyr also argued that the soul dies in Hell, and it's obvious, he argues, that God who is described in the scriptures, made the "death of the soul", rather than infinite torture. He was a clever philosopher.To understand this difference, I think it's important to understand the difference between "Eternal" and "Infinite". I've explained it many times before, so I won't divulge yet again. However, I think that, even considering it philosophically, it makes much more sense for the second death, to be the death of the soul, rather than some immaterial and yet material torture for an infinite amount of time.I think Scripture is clear on this;"And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell."~ Matthew 5:28The soul will be Eternally destroyed, not infinitely tortured. I agree that God is a wrathful God. However, to even for a moment begin to suggest that an infinite torture is a justified punishment for any crime, seems to me to be philosophically incoherent. For, if certain crimes deserve various punishments, each having been deemed "appropriate" by the measure of itself, in accordance with the crime, then punishments are proportionally variable. If, however, this is true, then certain punishments are out of place, or not proportional to the crimes. If this is true at all, then unless there is any unforgivable crime which can rightly and obviously be called such, which additionally deserves punishment unending, then an infinite torture of tremendous proportions is surely very out of place, and does not line up philosophically with the God of the Bible.I understand why the church has gotten confused over this issue. However, I think, perhaps, a re-examination of the terms such as "Eternal" and "Infinite" are very much in order.About a year ago, I would not have accepted this. I was invited to a Bible study, given by a man in a friends church who I already knew to be wise. He proposed a study on "Hell", and hinted towards these things. I prepared myself with a few pages of notes with passages from the Bible, from the Dead Sea Scrolls, and everything else I could find/think of, which supported the "hard" belief that Hell was infinite torture. He was so wise, and well prepared, I didn't even have to take any of those notes out. I recognized the superiority of his points immediately. Not one person there, even the friend whose church this man was from, agreed with him at the beginning, and we had all prepared ourselves in our own ways to really test him and see if he knew what he was talking about. By the end of the night, I think every single one of us left, intellectually satisfied, and recognizing his points.That's the power of Truth and Reason.