Wait, so now it's ok to use other passages to support the meaning of a text? So why is it so crucial that I only use Matthew 1:25 and the text contained within?
Those aren't parallel situations.
In this Matthew 13:55 discussion, I'm making a cumulative historical argument. The question is which identification best accounts for all the available evidence. That's why it is appropriate to bring in other passages, family relationships, and early historical testimony.
In the Matthew 1:25 discussion, however, you made a different claim. You said:
"If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it... the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex."
That's a claim about what Matthew 1:25 itself implies.
So when I asked what in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication, I wasn't asking you to prove your entire position from Matthew 1:25 alone. I was asking you to support the specific claim that the implication is present in Matthew 1:25 itself.
Those are two different questions.
In this Matthew 13:55 discussion, I'm saying:
"Here is a cumulative case. Let's examine all the evidence together."
In the Matthew 1:25 discussion, you were saying:
"Matthew 1:25 itself naturally implies later marital relations."
If a verse itself is said to imply something, then it's reasonable to ask what word, phrase, or feature of that verse creates the implication.
So there's no inconsistency here. I'm perfectly happy to use cumulative arguments when the claim is a cumulative argument. I only asked you to identify something in Matthew 1:25 itself because you claimed the implication was present in Matthew 1:25 itself.
Back to this discussion, you still haven't addressed the specific questions I asked:
- Do you think the James and Joseph of Matthew 27:56 are different people from the James and Joseph of Matthew 13:55? If so, what evidence demonstrates that?
- Do you think the early Christian writers who identify the Lord's brothers with the family of Clopas/Alphaeus were mistaken? If so, where specifically do they go wrong?
My opening post lays out that cumulative case. If you think the case fails, then identify the specific link in the chain that breaks.
Are James and Joseph in Matthew 27:56 different people from the James and Joseph of Matthew 13:55? If so, what evidence demonstrates that?
Or are the early Christian writers who identify the Lord's brothers with the family of Clopas/Alphaeus mistaken? If so, where specifically do they go wrong?
So far, you've raised a general objection, but you still haven't identified a specific mistake in the argument itself.