Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
Thank you for your response!RANDOR said:BOTH and at the same time......as the angels in heaven are rejoicing......simplified :)
me don't understand......secret judgment call ?? standing by for futher clarification....10...9....8....7....6...5...4...3...2...........shturt678 said:Thank you for your response!
You're of a higher paygrade than I thought thus both at the same time, but is it a forensic secret judgment call from heaven or a public judgment? Agape those angels rejoicing part big time! A fact we can take to the bank and it'll clear.
Old Jack
I think Paul indirectly answers this question. Both works of God, justification and sanctification, are simultaneous events.shturt678 said:At one's 'instant of faith' one is Justified? Sanctified? Justified and Sanctified? Or?
Old Jack
Thank you for your response again!RANDOR said:me don't understand......secret judgment call ?? standing by for futher clarification....10...9....8....7....6...5...4...3...2...........
Nomad said:Thank you for your response again!I think Paul indirectly answers this question. Both works of God, justification and sanctification, are simultaneous events.
1Co 6:9 Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality,
1Co 6:10 nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.
1Co 6:11 And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
Justification = Justification is the work of God whereby the righteousness of Jesus is reckoned to the sinner, so the sinner is declared by God to be righteous under the Law.
Sanctification = Sanctification is the work of God whereby those who are justified are reckoned to be purified and dedicated to the service of God.[/Tquote]
I was curious, is "But you were washed, you were sanctiied,.." have anything to do with water baptism? I render, "..but you had yourselves washed,..." My point is one justified/sanctified per ICor.6:11 at one's instant of faith or at baptism?
In the past I usually use Mk.1:15b to eliminate any ambiguities regarding one's 'instant of faith,' not that I'm correct.
Old curious Jack
Sorry Jack..........still don't understand the two judgments....in a twinkling of the eye....is usually how it happens to born again believers...all at once...you know it, you feel it......and you know Who did it....for He lets you know.....it was I.shturt678 said:Thank you for your response again!
Good, you're at my paygrade thus can talk straight accross, amen! Scriptures speak of two judgments, ie, one that is secret that occurs now duing one's earthly life thus upon the Return of Jesus, already determined which side one will be on - left or right. This issue is one of the most difficult issues in the N.T. dealing with the "elect," ie, "secret judgment part."
Because this issue can quickly cause divisions, will only say for now, go with a public judgment where the ministers publically gets the deceased into heaven so the economics stays in the black. Would only encourage you to eyeball the "doctrine of election" again for another thread at another time my brother. I was going to let the "secret" part go, but what the heck - blood and guts my brother - lol with you,
Old Jack, no pain, no gain
Thank you for your response again!
I was curious, is "But you were washed, you were sanctiied,.." have anything to do with water baptism? I render, "..but you had yourselves washed,..." My point is one justified/sanctified per ICor.6:11 at one's instant of faith or at baptism?
In the past I usually use Mk.1:15b to eliminate any ambiguities regarding one's 'instant of faith,' not that I'm correct.
Old curious Jack
Thank you for your response again!RANDOR said:Sorry Jack..........still don't understand the two judgments....in a twinkling of the eye....is usually how it happens to born again believers...all at once...you know it, you feel it......and you know Who did it....for He lets you know.....it was I.
I'm curious though.........
God Bless ya Jack...................stay balanced :)
Romans 8:28-30shturt678 said:At one's 'instant of faith' one is Justified? Sanctified? Justified and Sanctified? Or?
Old Jack
Where's RANDOR when you need him?StanJ said:Romans 8:28-30
And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose. For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brothers and sisters. And those he predestined, he also called; those he called, he also justified; those he justified, he also glorified.
The OP posed a question regarding justification and sanctification. Where do you see the word "sanctification" anywhere in Romans 8:28-30???StanJ said:Romans 8:28-30
And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose. For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, that he might be the firstborn among many brothers and sisters. And those he predestined, he also called; those he called, he also justified; those he justified, he also glorified.
Nomad, I'm not quite sure why you have such reading problems, but I answered the OP to his total satisfaction as he commented. Apparently you didn't see the "OR?" at the end of the OP. I quoted scripture. Simple, straightforward.Nomad said:The OP posed a question regarding justification and sanctification. Where do you see the word "sanctification" anywhere in Romans 8:28-30???
Yes it's true that "washed" is in the middle voice, which probably indicates one who submits to baptism, whereas "justified" and "sanctified" are in the passive voice, which means that one receives the action of the verb apart from any action on their part. However, I don't think that the order of the verbs tells us anything regarding the order of salvation. For example, the Ethiopian eunuch was told that he may be baptized if he believes, not the other way around. I don't think that Paul intended to give us the "ordo salutis" in that verse. That wasn't his point.shturt678 said:Thank you for your response again!
Good, you're at my paygrade thus can talk straight accross, amen! Scriptures speak of two judgments, ie, one that is secret that occurs now duing one's earthly life thus upon the Return of Jesus, already determined which side one will be on - left or right. This issue is one of the most difficult issues in the N.T. dealing with the "elect," ie, "secret judgment part."
Because this issue can quickly cause divisions, will only say for now, go with a public judgment where the ministers publically gets the deceased into heaven so the economics stays in the black. Would only encourage you to eyeball the "doctrine of election" again for another thread at another time my brother. I was going to let the "secret" part go, but what the heck - blood and guts my brother - lol with you,
Old Jack, no pain, no gain
Thank you for your response again!
I was curious, is "But you were washed, you were sanctiied,.." have anything to do with water baptism? I render, "..but you had yourselves washed,..." My point is one justified/sanctified per ICor.6:11 at one's instant of faith or at baptism?
In the past I usually use Mk.1:15b to eliminate any ambiguities regarding one's 'instant of faith,' not that I'm correct.
Old curious Jack
I'm afraid that the reading problem is all yours as clearly seen in other threads. I did in fact see the word "or" in the OP. However "or" is irrelevant seeing that a passage exists that contains both of the words that the OP was seeking. In other words, the OP wanted to know if "justification" and "sanctification" were simultaneous events. I presented a passage that clearly demonstrated that they were. Your passage, on the other hand, didn't even contain the word "santification." You seem to have a penchant for firing off proof texts that have very little to do with what you're trying to prove, while at the same time twisting passages that contradict your desired point of view. Very sad.StanJ said:Nomad, I'm not quite sure why you have such reading problems, but I answered the OP to his total satisfaction as he commented. Apparently you didn't see the "OR?" at the end of the OP. I quoted scripture. Simple, straightforward.
Thank you for caring again!Nomad said:The OP posed a question regarding justification and sanctification. Where do you see the word "sanctification" anywhere in Romans 8:28-30???
Nomad said:Thank you for caring again, and responding!Yes it's true that "washed" is in the middle voice, which probably indicates one who submits to baptism, whereas "justified" and "sanctified" are in the passive voice, which means that one receives the action of the verb apart from any action on their part. However, I don't think that the order of the verbs tells us anything regarding the order of salvation. For example, the Ethiopian eunuch was told that he may be baptized if he believes, not the other way around. I don't think that Paul intended to give us the "ordo salutis" in that verse. That wasn't his point.
Acts8:26, etc. Rom.10:17, "faith" originates from something heard, ie, the eunuch heard, and even probably gave a confession of Christ as a prerequiste for water baptism, ie, following the ol' ordo salutis - First one's "instant of faith" followed with a "water baptismal rebirth."
Thank you again,
Old Jack that appreciates you and your words.
Thank you for your response sir!FHII said:It takes someone who is.... special.... To ask such a question. Why look for a difference when the Bible says, "For by grace ye are saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, it is a gift from God. Not of works, lest any man should boast".
Well, lets see... Am I saved; but not justified or sanctified? Am I saved and justified; But not sanctified? Am I sanctified and justified; but not saved? Am I saved and sanctifeid; but not justified? Or all three? Or none? Ah heck.... Give me a Pork chop and a beer.... I'll stick with by grace ye are saved! I'll let you folks argue the rest and I'll let God ignore your decision!
This kind of supercilious response indicating you know better than the OP does about his own post is what is sad.Nomad said:I'm afraid that the reading problem is all yours as clearly seen in other threads. I did in fact see the word "or" in the OP. However "or" is irrelevant seeing that a passage exists that contains both of the words that the OP was seeking. In other words, the OP wanted to know if "justification" and "sanctification" were simultaneous events. I presented a passage that clearly demonstrated that they were. Your passage, on the other hand, didn't even contain the word "santification." You seem to have a penchant for firing off proof texts that have very little to do with what you're trying to prove, while at the same time twisting passages that contradict your desired point of view. Very sad.
Ya, no, sorry Jack, Logabe had it right, it is when you are baptized with fire that you are sanctified, and THAT is the baptism of the Holy Spirit. John's baptism was to proclaim the coming of the savior. After we receive Him, Jesus baptizes us with the fire of the Holy Spirit. Luke 3:16 NIVshturt678 said:Thank you for caring again, and not really wanting the last word, ie, only a head's up.
Justification (at one's instant of faith') is distinct from, and is also prior to one's sanctification which occurs at one's water baptism.
Old Jack
Thank you for your response!StanJ said:Ya, no, sorry Jack, Logabe had it right, it is when you are baptized with fire that you are sanctified, and THAT is the baptism of the Holy Spirit. John's baptism was to proclaim the coming of the savior. After we receive Him, Jesus baptizes us with the fire of the Holy Spirit. Luke 3:16 NIV