Sherrill collected accounts of speaking in tongues, including claims associated with recognizable human languages.
what is not established numerous cases were independently verified as genuine foreign languages spoken by people who had never learned them.
Four sources worth examining
1. William J. Samarin — Linguist, University of Toronto (1972)
His book,
Tongues of Men and Angels, is one of the best-known scientific studies.
Samarin examined recordings of glossolalia and compared them with natural languages.
He found that the speech resembled language in rhythm and pronunciation but lacked the consistent grammar and vocabulary characteristic of genuine languages.
His conclusion was that the samples he studied were not identifiable human languages.
You can read a
detailed review of his findings.
2. Felicitas D. Goodman — Linguist and anthropologist (1969–1972)
Goodman conducted cross-cultural research involving speakers of English, Spanish, and Mayan languages.
Her research found that glossolalia displayed recognizable sound patterns, but these did not establish that the speech was an actual foreign language.
Her work also considered how religious and psychological states affected speaking in tongues.
EBSCO OpenURL+1
Study:
Speaking in Tongues: A Cross-Cultural Study of Glossolalia.
3. Michael T. Motley — Linguistic analysis (1982)
Motley examined how closely glossolalia resembled normal speech and how much it depended on the speaker's native language.
His study found distinctive speech patterns that warranted psycholinguistic investigation, rather than establishing that the utterances were previously unknown foreign languages.
Taylor & Francis Online
A Linguistic Analysis of Glossolalia: Evidence of Unique Psycholinguistic Processing.
4. Phonetic Descriptions of Glossolalia — George Mason University (2013)
This research involved recording people speaking in tongues and examining the actual speech sounds.
The study concluded that the sounds speakers used were drawn from the sound inventories of their native languages.
.
What do these studies tell us?
They provide substantial evidence that
ordinary modern glossolalia is generally not a recognizable foreign language.