The Mechanics of Life after Death

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Jericho

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2023
1,051
1,142
113
52
Texas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Introduction
A poster once asked, how can there be life after death? This is an attempt to provide the mechanics for life after death. It is not meant as proof, only to provide a plausible framework for a post-mortem existence. I will make the case through science, philosophy, reason, and deduction. This is not a theological argument. I purposely avoided theology to make it more accessible for the skeptic. One final note: I will often use "mind" and "consciousness" interchangeably even though consciousness is a subset of the mind.

The Hard Problem of Consciousness
Why does the brain produce subjective experience, known as qualia in philosophical terms? Consider what happens when you look at an apple. The light waves reflect off the apple, enter the eyes, and are processed and identified by the brain. Science can explain many of the physical processes involved. What it has not been able to explain is the subjective experience of seeing an apple and why it feels like something. This is known as the hard problem of consciousness.

Brain-Production Theory
The Brain-Production Theory (BPT) is the view that the brain produces consciousness. Therefore, when the brain dies, so does consciousness. This is the dominant materialist position that has been widely accepted as fact. The problem is, it has never been proven. Science has not been able to resolve the hard problem of consciousness because science deals with the material world while consciousness is immaterial. Therefore, it is unquantifiable. It can’t be tested in a lab or examined under a microscope. All science can do is to provide theories.

Brain-Receiver Theory
Where BPT falls short, an alternate hypothesis can provide a plausible explanation for the mystery of consciousness. The Brain-Receiver Theory (BRT) postulates that the brain functions as a receiver of consciousness from an external source. The radio analogy is useful in understanding how BRT works.

Imagine you had an old terrestrial radio. The radio receives an external radio signal through its antenna. The radio could become broken, and the signal might become garbled, or it might cease working completely. The radio waves, however, would continue to broadcast. It's only the ability to receive them is compromised. If the brain is analogous to the radio, consciousness is the signal.

Both BPT and BRT can explain why things such as brain damage or neurological diseases can alter a person’s memories, thoughts, personality, alertness, and awareness. But only BRT can resolve the hard problem of consciousness and account for subjective experiences. The conundrum is only resolved if consciousness was never a product of the brain but is non-local.

The Mind-Brain Connection
The mind and brain clearly have a relationship. How the immaterial mind interacts with the material brain is not fully understood. However, we can see this interaction at play in the placebo effect. The mind can affect the body and vice versa. The Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch-OR) theory posits that quantum processes inside the neurons contribute to consciousness. Orch-OR theorizes that the brain is not merely a computer and consciousness is not merely a byproduct of information processing, but some other process is involved. Orch-OR could explain how the immaterial mind and material brain interact.

If BRT is correct, then consciousness could be thought of as a field like gravity or magnetism. At the most basic level, all ordinary matter in the universe is composed of quantum fields. We are unable to detect those fields directly; we only know they exist because we can measure their interactions and effects. If consciousness acts as a field, it could explain the mechanism by which consciousness is tethered to the brain.

Origin of the Signal
If the brain produced consciousness, we should be able to detect it in the brain. However, neurological experiments are pointing in the opposite direction. Neurologist Dr. Wilder Penfield was instrumental in mapping out the brain by stimulating the brain with an electrode. When a brain is operated on, it is done with only topical anesthesia because the brain can’t feel pain. They want the patient to be alert, so they don’t cut the wrong thing.

Dr. Penfield found that he could stimulate the patient’s brain to evoke certain emotions, sensations, memories, and movements, but he couldn’t stimulate the mind. Will, reason, intellect, etc. all remained unaffected. This demonstrated that the mind can act independently of the brain. Other observations indicate that consciousness does not reside in the brain. A procedure is done where they split the brain in half to stop crippling epileptic seizures. They found that splitting the brain in half does not split the mind. People who lost parts of their brain show that if the brain is altered, the mind is not necessarily altered. The mind may generally depend upon the brain to function, but it can also function independently at times, as with terminal/paradoxical lucidity.

Where does it reside then? I would posit it exists in a higher dimension. The concept of extra dimensions is not the work of fiction but science. For string theory to work, for example, there has to be 10 or 11 dimensions. One theory is that those dimensions are so small that they are impossible for us to perceive or access. An alternate theory is that we can't access them because our entire universe is "stuck" on a three-dimensional membrane floating in higher-dimensional space. If that’s the case, some of those dimensions are large, even infinite. If consciousness exists in a higher dimensional state, it would be impossible for us to detect.

Surviving Death
There are two ways this can be addressed: philosophical and scientific. The philosophical argument is that the brain and the mind are two different substances. One is material; the other is immaterial. Something that is immaterial is not subject to death and decay. Numbers, for example, are immaterial and exist only as abstract concepts. Like numbers, the mind is intangible, abstract, with no discernible parts. If the mind is not tangible, then there is nothing to physically destroy. Physical things die; intangible things do not. And if it can't be destroyed, it leaves the possibility open to a post-mortem existence.

The scientific explanation is that information and energy are never really lost. One of the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics is that information is preserved through a process called unitary evolution. In simplified terms, it means that the complete quantum state of a closed system evolves in a way that preserves information about its previous state. If you were to burn a letter, it would be destroyed, but the particles have physical properties that carry information about their previous state. At the micro level, the information may persist in a different form. If consciousness at a fundamental level is a pattern of information, then that pattern doesn’t cease to exist even after its original form is destroyed.

According to the first law of thermodynamics, energy can neither be created nor destroyed; it can only be transferred or transformed from one form into another. Take light, for instance. When light from the sun hits your shirt, it absorbs the light photons and becomes internal energy. This makes your shirt feel warm on a hot summer’s day. Your shirt would then release that energy as heat, including radiation. That energy would escape into the surrounding environment, and the cycle continues. At death, there would be a termination of the intersection between the consciousness and the brain. Once consciousness is no longer anchored to the brain, it exists entirely in a higher-dimensional state, imperceptible to us. Death, then, is not annihilation but transformation, like a caterpillar turning into a butterfly.

Near Death Experiences
The term "near-death experience" (NDEs) was coined by author and physician Raymond Moody. In his book, Life After Life, Moody recounts the story of George G. Ritchie, who was a U.S. Army recruit in 1943 during World War II. George reportedly died of pneumonia and was declared clinically dead for about 9 minutes. During that time, he recounts leaving his body and encountering a being of light, among other things. Ritchie's story is considered one of the earliest "modern" NDEs, although NDEs are not new or novel but have been recorded in ancient texts for thousands of years. While NDEs don’t constitute proof, they do count as circumstantial evidence.

One of the most documented cases is that of Pam Reynolds. Pam had a bulging aneurysm that required radical surgery. After she was given anesthesia, her body was chilled to 60°F/15.6°C. Her heart stopped, the blood drained from her brain, and her eyes lubricated and sealed shut. Her vitals were completely monitored during this time, including her brainwaves. During the operation, she was clinically dead and had no brainwaves. That’s when the extraordinary happened. She recalled feeling pulled out the top of her head and out of her body. She was able to observe her own surgery, including the operating equipment, and the conversations in the room. She recalled being pulled through a tunnel into a place of light where she saw figures, including her deceased grandmother. After the surgery, the doctors brought her back to life.

NDEs are often dismissed as subjective and anecdotal; however, that is not always true. The Reynolds case, for instance, was later corroborated by her doctor, attending physician, and an independent investigator. Not all NDEs may be genuine, but neither can they all be easily dismissed. There is simply no logical explanation for when someone experiencing an NDE sees or hears something that is impossible for them to know, and those details are verified by others. Only BRT can account for NDEs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: soberxp