mjrhealth said:
Aspen, what has religion got to do with having a relationship with God.
Ok, this kind of statement really make me wonder if it is possible for you to understand what I am writing.......
I thought I was being clear about the relationship between religion and a relationship with God. One more time; the relationship between religion and a relationship with God is similar to a relationship between language and communication. Religion is simply the language we use to communicate with God. Without language (a shared lexicon) we could not communicate with each other - without religion we cannot communicate with God.
religion told me there is a God, God Himself taught me about Himself without the religion.
By your very words, you learned that there is a God from religion - without religion, you would still be in the dark. Also, God spoke to you about Himself through the language of religion. Because religion is the language you speak, God used it to teach you about Himself.
Do you really thing God needs.
Religion to save anyone,
a clergy, hierarchy to save anyone,
even the bible to reach out to and save anyone,
It is not a matter of 'what God needs', it is a bout what God chooses to use. He uses our language, which is religion to speak to us. Makes sense, because Jesus meets us where we are at. If you are going to ask why God uses religion to communicate with us, you need to ask the same thing about everything God uses.
Religion puts chains around His feet,it puts shackles upon His hands, it puts a gag across His mouth,and says only we can talk to God, you want Him you go though us.
Make no mistake, religion didn't kill Jesus, we did.
Also, you are describing an abusive church, not religion. And finally, in my experience, many people who reject religion provide the same sort of negativity as you - a litany of misunderstanding about religion.
I have learned more about my Father and Jesus than I was ever taught whilst a religious person, I received the Holy Spirit before I even knew there was such a thing.
Sounds like the definition of private interpretation to me.
Religion will always keep you a slave to it, Jesus came so we could have Life in Him, to set us free, but we must choose whom we serve, Him or religion, which will it be.
Here is an example of a false dichotomy - setting Jesus up against religion. Jesus spoke against the restrictions of the law, not religion. You have adopted this false dichotomy from your Protestant Fathers, who create the notion that religion is bad and spirituality is good. See, they had to do this in order to justify breaking away from Catholicism. So in essence, your anti-religion mindset is actually adopted from doctrine, which is in fact, religion, itself.
And as far as confusing my works with God - not going to happen. My works have been redeemed along with my faith - they are inseparable. Jesus and Paul spoke against works in the context of Temple worship and Generational Redemption (belief that as long as I am a Jew, I am chosen). Luther and Calvin were the people who over interpreted those ideas and generalized them to Catholic teachings. Fact is, the Reformers had to equate the Vatican with the Temple in order to justify rebelling against it.