The ceremonial or written ordinances/rite ritual and ceremony laws could faultlessly be obeyed, even by the worst of sinners(Phil3:6) Law you can faultlessly obey never would be described as the letter that kills, the ministry of death and condemnation. Indeed, if only that law had been given at Sanai, man could have been justified by the law, for law you can faultlessly obey you can indeed be justified by obeying.
Paul said the law engraved in stone was the letter that kills, the ministry of death and condemnation NOT the law written on parchments. The only law engraved in stone was the TC. You are wrong
The problem in your argument is this: you assume that because something was “engraved in stone,” it automatically means that the phrase “the letter that kills” must refer to the Ten Commandments. But this ignores both the Old Testament background and the way the Bible itself uses the word “letter” and “ordinance.” It also ignores Jesus’ clear defense of the commandments.
First, if Paul had truly meant that the Ten Commandments are “death” or “condemnation,” then he would be contradicting Jesus. Jesus said, “Do not think that I came to destroy the law… not to destroy, but to fulfill” (ASV, Matthew 5:17). Jesus also said, “If you would enter into life, keep the commandments” (ASV, Matthew 19:17). Jesus never spoke of the Ten Commandments as death or condemnation. He lifted them up, explained them, purified them and commanded obedience to them.
Second, the Old Testament itself uses the word “ordinances” for
ceremonial laws, never for the Ten Commandments. These are laws connected to sacrifices, ritual cleansing, feast days, and priestly requirements. They were written in a
book, not on stone (Deuteronomy 31:24–26). God even told Moses to place that written book
beside the ark, not inside, because it was not the eternal covenant. Only the Ten Commandments were placed inside the ark.
Here are the exact types of laws the Old Testament calls
ordinances, the same type Paul is referring to:
•
Sacrifice requirements – Leviticus 1–7
Burnt offerings, sin offerings, grain offerings, peace offerings. These were required to deal with sin and guilt. These laws “kill” in the sense that failure meant death or atonement by blood.
•
Purity and cleansing rules – Leviticus 12–15
Touching a dead body, childbirth cleansing, leprosy laws, blood purification. These laws constantly declared people “unclean,” unable to enter God’s presence. They condemned by their very design.
•
Festival regulations – Leviticus 23
Passover, Unleavened Bread, Trumpets, Day of Atonement, Tabernacles. Each feast required specific sacrifices “by ordinance forever.” These were shadows pointing to Christ.
•
Priestly regulations – Exodus 28–29
Special garments, anointing oil, washing rituals, blood placed on ear/thumb/toe. These were heavy, detailed rules that symbolized access to God. Failure meant death.
•
Sin-transfer rituals – Leviticus 16
The scapegoat, incense requirements, blood sprinkled in the Most Holy Place. These laws directly symbolized sin, death, guilt, and separation.
These are the laws that constantly declared death, impurity, guilt and separation.
This is why they are called a ministry of death and condemnation in contrast to the life and cleansing brought by Christ.
Third, the idea that these ceremonial laws could be obeyed “faultlessly” misunderstands the whole purpose of the system. The entire sacrificial system existed because sin
cannot be faultlessly overcome. The blood, the rituals, the washings, the yearly atonement all existed because people were not faultless. This is why Hebrews says these rituals were repeated “year by year” and that they “could never take away sins.”
Jesus is the true sacrifice. The animal sacrifices were the “letter,” the shadow, the symbol. By their very nature they proclaimed death, not life. Every animal killed represented the reality that sin leads to death.
The Ten Commandments are never called a shadow. They are called “the covenant” and “the words of life.”
Finally, the phrase “engraved in stone” does not change the Old Testament meaning of “ordinance.” A phrase can refer to an entire system. For example, when the prophets spoke of “Zion,” they often meant all of Israel. When they spoke of “Jerusalem,” they often meant the whole nation. In the same way, “engraved in stone” can refer to the covenant package given at Sinai, which included the Ten Commandments as the heart, but also the larger system of ordinances that dealt with sin, sacrifice and cleansing.
If the Ten Commandments were death, Jesus would never have commanded obedience to them. But He did. The laws that killed were the ritual laws that required blood, cleansing and death symbols, because they pointed to the need for a Savior.
This is why the early Christians understood that the "moral" Ten Commandments remain, while the sacrificial and ceremonial system pointed to Christ and found fulfillment in Him.
