How does God chasten us?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Behold

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2020
24,552
9,228
113
Netanya or Pensacola
Faith
Christian
Country
Israel
Gender
Male
1 Thes 1:
[4] Knowing, brethren beloved, your election of God.


"election"... was in God's mind before Satan fell.

So, this election, in your verse, is specific to being "in Christ"........so, you have to be there first........for the election to be in process for you.

Now the lying Calvinists teach that you are pre-destined to be elected.........and you have no choice.
Whereas Paul teaches that once you are "in Christ" then the election becomes engaged.

See, everything within SALVATION is based on first becoming "in Christ", and then a lot is Pre-destined to happen to you, once you are In Christ.
For example, you are predestined to "be conformed into the image of Christ".

So, just as a person who is born again, 2 mins ago, is now as righteous as Jesus.....as they START this way......as that is how you begin your Christianity..... 'made righteous".....= .you start finished, regarding being "made righteous"......and now being righteous, you begin your daily discipleship.

And Likewise......once you are IN CHRIST>..... (born again spiritually), then that is the starting position that brings many things that are predestined to happen, ONCE you are "in Christ".
But you're not predestined to be saved......you are given the opportunity....and once you accept it.. = once God has accepted your faith, then you are put "in Christ" and that begins many things that God has pre-destined to happen to the born again believer.


The Power of God does KEEP a Converted person Saved.

You initially wrote that it keeps them BELIEVING......... so, that is what you posted previously that i was just discussing in the (see above) post to you.

And yes, God is faithful to complete our Salvation., and thank God for that, or noone would make it to Heaven.

Philippians 1:6

1 Cor 1:
[18] For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.

Yes, the Gospel is the Power of God.........and when you believe it, this power of God brings to you the new birth, and all the rest of what God does for us in an instant.
Christians who are badly taught, have a real issue with understanding what it means to become a Christian.
Most want to argue that a Christian is not made righteous, and they have to go and try to do it......which is impossible.
In fact, the righteousness that we receive from God, is "The GIFT of Righteousness".

1 John 4:
[4] Ye are of God, little children, and have overcome them: because greater is he that is in you, than he that is in the world.

Yes.
There are 2 proofs that a person is a Christian, and posting verses and arguing that you can lose your salvation, is not proving a person is saved.
In fact, it tends to prove the opposite, as, its a curious thing to realize that if you dont understand Salvation, then can you actualluy be a Christian?
"Points to ponder".........
I meet people who are saved 50 yrs and can't understand how God saved them using the BLOOD and DEATH of His only begotten Son.
All they can talk about is sinning, and repenting of sin, and confessing it, and trying to be good., and losing salvation.... and that is not Christianity.
That is a religious pretender, hell bound., worried about keeping commandments and confessing sin.... and probably water baptized on the way .

The 2 Proofs are........

Born again
&
Christ in You

John 10:
[28] And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand.

Jesus is Eternal Life, so, He knows what He's offering is "the Gift of Eternal Life".
If Jesus is in you, then you have eternal life as He is eternal life.

"I have come to give them LIFE".. Jesus said.....and that is ETERNAL., and that is one more evidence for "The Case for Eternal Security".


[29] My Father, which gave them me, is greater than all; and no man is able to pluck them out of my Father's hand.

Your verse is given before Jesus was crucified, and Its talking about the original Apostles.

However, when we receive eternal Life from Jesus, then : "you shall never go to Hell (Perish)""".


Notice WHAT a Christian “IS”…
“A Follower”, who can leave at any time.

A follower is a disciple.

A Christian is a SON-Daughter of God, born again Spiritually.....= big difference.


Notice what a “Converted Christian IS”…
A man who has Surrendered his Whole Life, unto Gods Care, Protection, Perfection, Keeping.

Every Christian should have a private talk with God and say.....>"Father, im yours.....do with me what is best for you".
Most never even consider this type of total surrender.

Disagree. You are describing a Believer, who is neither committed or saved.

Christianity is based on being born again.........its not based on behavior modification or water baptism or adoring Mary.
We have to always realize that God saved us while we were """YET SINNERS"".........not after we tried to be good.

"Jesus came into the world to save sinners".. and we all qualified long before we were saved.

(that was a struggle Paul taught was a challenge to overcome)

The Romans 7 "challange" that faces all Christians is......"when are you going to stop trying to keep the law and commandments to try to stay saved, and instead rest in God's Grace understanding you can never be lost".
Most never find that revelation and that keeps them from truly enjoying God's peace.

All these Umpteen “medical Mental “problems / Diseases”… man has identified and named….Are Conflicts between the Thoughts in the heart (spirit) and carnal mind. The mind is not yielding to the hearts thoughts.

Most mental illness is rooted in anxiety.
Anxiety is based on having no inner peace, and can't find any.
Its mostly just guilt inside them.

How to solve that?

Jesus said......."come unto me all who are heavy laden and i will give you REST". = REST from your worries and anxiety and guilt.

That REST is directly connected to God causing your conscience to stop tormenting you.....and there goes your mental illness.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,243
15,838
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
"election"... was in God's mind before Satan fell.

So, this election, in your verse, is specific to being "in Christ"........so, you have to be there first........for the election to be in process for you.

Multiple persons… One Lord God Almighty…
Each have Opportunity to Elect / Choose the other.

Now the lying Calvinists teach that you are pre-destined to be elected.........and you have no choice.
Whereas Paul teaches that once you are "in Christ" then the election becomes engaged.

I don’t know what all particular denominations teach.
God already knows who will choose what.
Men decide and then know During some point in their Natural life.

See, everything within SALVATION is based on first becoming "in Christ", and then a lot is Pre-destined to happen to you, once you are In Christ.

There is a Substantial Clause (so to speak),
Regarding … Era, A Mans Beliefs Specific, A Mans Choices, AND “WHO” does the Saving.

Some, Were Saved BY God…
Some, Shall be Saved BY God…
Some, Were Saved BY Christ…
Some, Shall be Saved By Christ…

Any man, Saved by Christ, Received his Salvation BEFORE, the man’s MORTAL Death.
Any man, Saved by God, Received his Salvation AFTER, the mans MORTAL Death.

Christ Redeems and Resurrects Those He Saved.
(Bodily having died and Living)…
Called Rapture.
Christs Redeeming Occurs, Before the Great Tribulations and Wrath, sent down from Heaven.

Gods Saving,
Applied to Those God Believers, Before Christ was Sent…
Applies to Those God Believers, After Christ Was Sent and Returned to Heaven.
Applies to Those WHO During the Great Trib. come to Belief IN God.

God Redeems and Resurrects, Those He Saved.
Called First Resurrection.

Some IN Christs Hand.
Some IN Gods Hand.

Glory To God,
Taken
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,243
15,838
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
So, just as a person who is born again, 2 mins ago, is now as righteous as Jesus.....as they START this way......as that is how you begin your Christianity..... 'made righteous".....= .you start finished, regarding being "made righteous"......and now being righteous, you begin your daily discipleship.

now as righteous as Jesus.....

I don’t believe…a human man, can ever measure Equally the Same as Jesus…/Lord God Almighty.
Similar, YES.
Same, NO.

Humans Are Not Spirits.
Humans Have Sinned.

The Lord God Almighty… is Not Human, and Never Sinned.

And Likewise......once you are IN CHRIST>..... (born again spiritually), then that is the starting position that brings many things that are predestined to happen, ONCE you are "in Christ".

Well aware of the meaning and How one Becomes “IN” Christ.

But you're not predestined to be saved......you are given the opportunity....and once you accept it.. = once God has accepted your faith, then you are put "in Christ" and that begins many things that God has pre-destined to happen to the born again believer.

I do not have ANY issues or wondering regarding “PRE-Destiny”…
God is ALL Knowing…
Whatever Applies To Whatever man…and WHEN…
God Already Knows…
God has Already Prepared a PLACE for every man.
God has Already REVEALED TO human men, HOW TO, Be WITH, or Be WITHOUT God Forever.
Every Era, Generation, of Human men during their Natural Life-Time…
Have Opportunity to Discover Their Destiny.
Some do, Some do Not.


Glory to God,
Taken
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,243
15,838
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You initially wrote that it keeps them BELIEVING......... so, that is what you posted previously that i was just discussing in the (see above) post to you.


Christians who are badly taught, have a real issue with understanding what it means to become a Christian.
Most want to argue that a Christian is not made righteous, and they have to go and try to do it......which is impossible.
In fact, the righteousness that we receive from God, is "The GIFT of Righteousness".



Yes.
There are 2 proofs that a person is a Christian, and posting verses and arguing that you can lose your salvation, is not proving a person is saved.
In fact, it tends to prove the opposite, as, its a curious thing to realize that if you dont understand Salvation, then can you actualluy be a Christian?
"Points to ponder".........
I meet people who are saved 50 yrs and can't understand how God saved them using the BLOOD and DEATH of His only begotten Son.
All they can talk about is sinning, and repenting of sin, and confessing it, and trying to be good., and losing salvation.... and that is not Christianity.
That is a religious pretender, hell bound., worried about keeping commandments and confessing sin.... and probably water baptized on the way .

The 2 Proofs are........

Born again
&
Christ in You



Jesus is Eternal Life, so, He knows what He's offering is "the Gift of Eternal Life".
If Jesus is in you, then you have eternal life as He is eternal life.

"I have come to give them LIFE".. Jesus said.....and that is ETERNAL., and that is one more evidence for "The Case for Eternal Security".




Your verse is given before Jesus was crucified, and Its talking about the original Apostles.

However, when we receive eternal Life from Jesus, then : "you shall never go to Hell (Perish)""".




A follower is a disciple.

A Christian is a SON-Daughter of God, born again Spiritually.....= big difference.




Every Christian should have a private talk with God and say.....>"Father, im yours.....do with me what is best for you".
Most never even consider this type of total surrender.



Christianity is based on being born again.........its not based on behavior modification or water baptism or adoring Mary.
We have to always realize that God saved us while we were """YET SINNERS"".........not after we tried to be good.

"Jesus came into the world to save sinners".. and we all qualified long before we were saved.



The Romans 7 "challange" that faces all Christians is......"when are you going to stop trying to keep the law and commandments to try to stay saved, and instead rest in God's Grace understanding you can never be lost".
Most never find that revelation and that keeps them from truly enjoying God's peace.

I get your points.
I get the the BROAD teaching regarding “Christianity”.

Agree, an individual actively “Following” Christ Jesus’ teaching IS a Disciple.

I place a “lower” (meaning on the Term Christian, being a “Fool-proof Condition”)

There “IS”… a caveat…
TASTING…
Or
EATING…

From The Start of Jesus’ Ministry…
* His Preaching was Pre-Announced.
* Everyone, Anyone could come to Hear Him.
* Nothing presumed ALL listeners, TASTING, would Believe, (some or all), of what Jesus Spoke.

* The Same continues to THIS Day…
A preaching to commence Announced For When…
All Individuals invited to come and Hear…
Some will believe…
maybe or not) Verify what they hear…
Follow along…
Walk away…
Continue Attending With Belief…
Continue Attending With some Doubts…
Continue Attending to please family members…
Continue Attending to impress community…
Continue Attending to take advantage of large pool of business prospects…
Continue attending and participation in (the liking of) the pious feel good Rituals.

Point Being… individuals…can Go, Be routinely Seen, Be a member of and IN a Christian Church, identify being a Christian, Be Called a Christian…
AND…
Not have Ever Heartfully Committed, Surrendered their Life unto Death For Their True Belief IN God or Christ the Lord….
And Receipt of a True Conversion

(And by the Way… THAT ^ … implying, calling oneself a Christian, (and then able to Deny, walk Away)… is Very confusing to “other religions”…and as you pointed out…
Even confusing, to People involved with Christianity.)

The Difference is Simple…
A Taster… can come be with God and Leave.
An Eater… commits, surrenders, Once and Forever is With the Lord God.

Glory to God,
Taken
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,243
15,838
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Most mental illness is rooted in anxiety.
Anxiety is based on having no inner peace, and can't find any.
Its mostly just guilt inside them.

How to solve that?

Jesus said......."come unto me all who are heavy laden and i will give you REST". = REST from your worries and anxiety and guilt.

That REST is directly connected to God causing your conscience to stop tormenting you.....and there goes your mental illness.

Anxiety is simply a “term” of a condition.

My point is:
There are “Umpteen” terms, for mans MIND / MENTAL “condition”.

God offers Changes…TO:
A mans soul… restoration.
A mans spirit…quickening rebirth.
A mans heart…new Truth, Gods Truth.
A mans body…promise of raised glorified.

But the Carnal Mind?
That CAN, think, Weigh options, logically conclude, Change thoughts, beliefs from moment to moment, lie, deceive, cheat, steal, with intent or not, trespass, be unsure…
And the puzzling Fact…
God DOES NOT CHANGE A MANS “Carnal Mind”!

God gives the Willing, the (Gifts…Tools, so to speak), TO a “CONVERTED” man…
To … Make his Own Carnal Mind, Acquiess, YEILD, to his Received Gifts, ( given per his Conversion ).

When a converted man…does NOT Make his OWN carnal mind YEILD to his “new spirits Thoughts”… the Mental Effects become the Mans dilemma, ( and men have subscribed a name, and pill for every Mental aliment imaginable )

The cure is… the man becoming Converted, and using his Gifts to Make his own carnal mind YEILD to his hearts thoughts, which Are in Agreement with Gods Thought.

And THAT ^ being accomplished…
Is wHEN such man… HAS accomplished…
Having “a MIND, Like Christ”.

Paul preached…Regarding … the difficultly men did, and would have, in understanding this Concept and YIELDING their own Mind to their New Hearts Thoughts.

Glory to God,
Taken
 

Behold

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2020
24,552
9,228
113
Netanya or Pensacola
Faith
Christian
Country
Israel
Gender
Male
Can a person lose their Salvation?
Simple answer… Yes.

Salvation is Jesus on The Cross.

This is not something you can do for yourself........so, He is not someone you can Lose.
There are no Chrisitans in Hell, as if one went to Hell the God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit would be there also, as they are all IN The Believer.

Salvation is to be eternally joined Spiritually to God and Christ........by being BORN AGAIN into them.
And this is an eternal spiritual birth.......and is not based on how you behave.
We are not saved initially based on our behavior, and we are not kept saved based on our behavior.
Our Salvation is only based on what Jesus has finished for us, on The Cross that God accepts on our behalf.....and once we have this "Gift of Salvation".....then we have it forever.


Can a man take, receive, possess his gift of Salvation….
And THEN Lose his Gift? No

Correct, you can't lose "the Gift of Salvation"......nor can you earn it.
 

Bombastic

Member
Jun 23, 2026
92
64
18
53
Red State
isaiah.school
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
"election"... was in God's mind before Satan fell.

So, this election, in your verse, is specific to being "in Christ"........so, you have to be there first........for the election to be in process for you.

Now the lying Calvinists teach that you are pre-destined to be elected.........and you have no choice.
Whereas Paul teaches that once you are "in Christ" then the election becomes engaged.

See, everything within SALVATION is based on first becoming "in Christ", and then a lot is Pre-destined to happen to you, once you are In Christ.
For example, you are predestined to "be conformed into the image of Christ".

So, just as a person who is born again, 2 mins ago, is now as righteous as Jesus.....as they START this way......as that is how you begin your Christianity..... 'made righteous".....= .you start finished, regarding being "made righteous"......and now being righteous, you begin your daily discipleship.

And Likewise......once you are IN CHRIST>..... (born again spiritually), then that is the starting position that brings many things that are predestined to happen, ONCE you are "in Christ".
But you're not predestined to be saved......you are given the opportunity....and once you accept it.. = once God has accepted your faith, then you are put "in Christ" and that begins many things that God has pre-destined to happen to the born again believer.




You initially wrote that it keeps them BELIEVING......... so, that is what you posted previously that i was just discussing in the (see above) post to you.

And yes, God is faithful to complete our Salvation., and thank God for that, or noone would make it to Heaven.

Philippians 1:6



Yes, the Gospel is the Power of God.........and when you believe it, this power of God brings to you the new birth, and all the rest of what God does for us in an instant.
Christians who are badly taught, have a real issue with understanding what it means to become a Christian.
Most want to argue that a Christian is not made righteous, and they have to go and try to do it......which is impossible.
In fact, the righteousness that we receive from God, is "The GIFT of Righteousness".



Yes.
There are 2 proofs that a person is a Christian, and posting verses and arguing that you can lose your salvation, is not proving a person is saved.
In fact, it tends to prove the opposite, as, its a curious thing to realize that if you dont understand Salvation, then can you actualluy be a Christian?
"Points to ponder".........
I meet people who are saved 50 yrs and can't understand how God saved them using the BLOOD and DEATH of His only begotten Son.
All they can talk about is sinning, and repenting of sin, and confessing it, and trying to be good., and losing salvation.... and that is not Christianity.
That is a religious pretender, hell bound., worried about keeping commandments and confessing sin.... and probably water baptized on the way .

The 2 Proofs are........

Born again
&
Christ in You



Jesus is Eternal Life, so, He knows what He's offering is "the Gift of Eternal Life".
If Jesus is in you, then you have eternal life as He is eternal life.

"I have come to give them LIFE".. Jesus said.....and that is ETERNAL., and that is one more evidence for "The Case for Eternal Security".




Your verse is given before Jesus was crucified, and Its talking about the original Apostles.

However, when we receive eternal Life from Jesus, then : "you shall never go to Hell (Perish)""".




A follower is a disciple.

A Christian is a SON-Daughter of God, born again Spiritually.....= big difference.




Every Christian should have a private talk with God and say.....>"Father, im yours.....do with me what is best for you".
Most never even consider this type of total surrender.



Christianity is based on being born again.........its not based on behavior modification or water baptism or adoring Mary.
We have to always realize that God saved us while we were """YET SINNERS"".........not after we tried to be good.

"Jesus came into the world to save sinners".. and we all qualified long before we were saved.



The Romans 7 "challange" that faces all Christians is......"when are you going to stop trying to keep the law and commandments to try to stay saved, and instead rest in God's Grace understanding you can never be lost".
Most never find that revelation and that keeps them from truly enjoying God's peace.



Most mental illness is rooted in anxiety.
Anxiety is based on having no inner peace, and can't find any.
Its mostly just guilt inside them.

How to solve that?

Jesus said......."come unto me all who are heavy laden and i will give you REST". = REST from your worries and anxiety and guilt.

That REST is directly connected to God causing your conscience to stop tormenting you.....and there goes your mental illness.
"Hey!" @Behold, I don't believe that!
Not much of what you said is true. Obviously, you don't have a theology degree or spent the equivalent "self-learned" time in the trenches. And for those that don't, pick a fight with a 5-point Calvinist; they'll school you.
Not a bit of systematic theology in your post; congratulations on ignoring tota scriptura and the principle of sola scriptura.
The only truth from your response is for those that have ears to hear and eyes to see. You've said all we need to know "about you."
 

Behold

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2020
24,552
9,228
113
Netanya or Pensacola
Faith
Christian
Country
Israel
Gender
Male
Yes, I am aware of that false teaching that those who are born again cannot ever sin. It’s ridiculous and unbiblical.

What you can't seem to grasp is Romans 4:8 and 2nd Corin 5:19. @Anchorite

Both of these verses teach that God does not charge sin against a born again Believer.

And why not?

2 reasons....

First.........God has already charged a believers sin against Jesus on The Cross who has died for them all.

2nd, The born again are "not under the law, but under (God's) Grace"......so, "where there is no LAW, there is no Sin (Transgression)"...

Now, this does not mean that you'll never do anything carnal again.......it only means that Christ's redemptive work, has dealt with all the sin of a born again believer, and the Law has no more domimion over them.

Reader, when the law is removed by the Cross of Christ, then it can never define anything you do ever again.......nor can it define you.

"Christ has redeemed (the born again) from the CURSE of The LAW"......= and that curse was the Law's ability to define you as a sinner.
Now it can't, because the CHRISTian is not under the old covenant where the law has dominion.... The Born again are under the New Covenant, where God has eternally defined the born again, as "made righteous"... having become "the righteousness of God, in Christ".
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,243
15,838
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Salvation is Jesus on The Cross.

This is not something you can do for yourself........so, He is not someone you can Lose.
There are no Chrisitans in Hell, as if one went to Hell the God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit would be there also, as they are all IN The Believer.

Salvation is to be eternally joined Spiritually to God and Christ........by being BORN AGAIN into them.
And this is an eternal spiritual birth.......and is not based on how you behave.
We are not saved initially based on our behavior, and we are not kept saved based on our behavior.
Our Salvation is only based on what Jesus has finished for us, on The Cross that God accepts on our behalf.....and once we have this "Gift of Salvation".....then we have it forever.




Correct, you can't lose "the Gift of Salvation"......nor can you earn it.

Point is…Salvation IS A Gift…
A Gift, bought, paid for, offered to every man…
Is by default… a lost Gift, if a man Does NOT reach out his Hand and Take “his” Gift.

It is Lost to him for. NOT Taking his Gift…

Not as some falsely teach…
* that Salvation can be Received…then lost.
* that Salvation Received…must be guarded, maintained, by a man’s power.


“Working out your own Salvation”… is about the mans journey, efforts, regarding his Carnal Mind (that God gave him the tools to MAKE his own Mind YEILD to his “new” hearts thoughts) as aforementioned.

My impression is…
You and I connect in agreement on the big picture with slight variations in choice of descriptive words.

God bless you.

Glory to God,
Taken