The biblical principle is "the spirit is not first but the natural, and afterward the spiritual." "The first Adam" (and all born of his flesh and lineage) was/is "natural", "and the second Adam, a life-giving spirit."
Jesus was the change point, who then asked the Father to send the Holy Spirit. During which time He encountered blasphemy, and addressed what would be different regarding blasphemy going forward.
In other words, no, what Jesus came to do was not just so many events limited to the local time and setting, but extended to involve and effect all of history in a before and after way as a line of dividing...everything.
Do you understand?
Scott,
I'm happy to address one point at a time. In fact, that may help us distinguish what Scripture actually says from what we infer from it.
You cite 1 Corinthians 15:46, where Paul says that the natural comes first and afterward the spiritual.
But Paul is discussing the resurrection and the distinction between the natural and spiritual body.
He is not establishing a chronological rule governing when blasphemy against the Holy Spirit becomes possible. That is your application of the passage, not something Paul states.
You are certainly correct that Christ's coming marks a decisive turning point in redemptive history. I have never disputed that. But acknowledging that truth does not establish your particular conclusion about blasphemy.
Let's return to Mark 3:28–30.
Jesus warned the religious authorities about blaspheming the Holy Spirit, and Mark explicitly tells us why He issued the warning:
because they were attributing His works to an unclean spirit.
This occurred before Pentecost.
The Holy Spirit was already active before Pentecost. Pentecost marked a new outpouring of the Spirit, not the beginning of the Spirit's existence or activity.
So my question remains:
Where does Jesus say that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit was impossible before Pentecost, or that His warning applied only to people living afterward?
You have explained your theological framework. You have not demonstrated that conclusion from the passage.
I'm not asking you to explain the entirety of redemptive history. I'm asking you to establish one specific claim from Scripture.
Why such a delay? Do you need your Pastor to tell you how to respond? Your post are very weak in scripture but very heavy in "Follw me! I have all the answers!" Are you a Pastor who sells the gospel? You are not who you present to be on this forum! Your words betray you!