ScottA: Heretic, or No?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Would you call ScottA a heretic?

  • YES.

    Votes: 1 12.5%
  • No.

    Votes: 7 87.5%

  • Total voters
    8
Status
Not open for further replies.

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,634
6,992
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
No I don't think that.
What think is that you have an image of yourself as sent by God that I am not persuaded of.
What I am persuaded of is that your self reflection lacks honesty.
Typical. That is exactly how much of the truth from God was rejected down through the ages. Oh, that's so convincing--so credible, so impactful--you should be proud. Wow!

Nothing new under the sun. Go figure!
 
Last edited:

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,634
6,992
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You are “by His authority” setting before us that same choice — life and death?

You are NOT setting before us the choice of life and death. Only God can do that. You need to have a more sober, realistic view of yourself, I think.

Then you confusedly throw in something about blaspheming the Holy Spirit and not being forgiven!?

Is this supposed to frighten people?

This is a very peculiar post. It seems to be drawing attention to yourself and fishing for compliments.
Peculiar indeed. But it's not mine--you know I said that, right?

But no, I have set just what was given and commanded of me to set before this generation--by God.

To frighten people? I know better than to think that was or is at all God's intention--but rather every hidden thing and all truth is revealed--that is what is written.

Why are you so surprised? Is it because you thought the end and all that was promised with it would never come? How could anyone read the scriptures and not be struck with the reality of every promise fulfilled, as "life and death, blessing and cursing?" Were there not enough details, not enough blood, not enough miracles, not enough out-of-this-world revelations?

Don't blame me for getting real--but go and awaken those who are asleep.
 

Anchorite

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2026
418
344
63
68
Peoria
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Peculiar indeed. But it's not mine--you know I said that, right?

But no, I have set just what was given and commanded of me to set before this generation--by God.

To frighten people? I know better than to think that was or is at all God's intention--but rather every hidden thing and all truth is revealed--that is what is written.

Why are you so surprised? Is it because you thought the end would never come, and all that was promised with it? How could anyone read the scriptures and not be struck with the reality of every promise fulfilled, as "life and death, blessing and cursing? Were there not enough details, not enough blood, not enough miracles, not enough out-of-this-world revelations?

Don't blame me for getting real--but go and awaken those who are asleep.
Exactly what was given and commanded of you to set before this generation?

You sound like a self-appointed pseudo-prophet or cult leader.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amigo de christo

Jay Ross

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2011
9,372
3,491
113
QLD
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
You are interpreting in denial of Jesus coming for "the house of Israel" and then saying "It is finished."

That is enough said.

ScottA, I was quoting the Book of Ezekiel. God is not finished with the nation of Israel as you are stating. I am suggesting that God will use the nation of Israel for His purposes to gather the Gentile nations to Himself. On the other hand you have stated that the Nation of Israel is finished in God's eyes.

One of us is a heretic while the other is speaking God's truth. Why is it that God will not begin to interact with the nation of Israel, wherever they have been scattered throughout the whole earth, until after the completion of the fourth age of their existence which ends at the completion of the sixth age of mankind.

ScottA nothing that you have presented in this thread, convinces me that God is done with the nation of Israel and when the seventh age commences, from that time God will begin gathering Israel to Himself.

Based on this short interchange with you in this thread, I would be required to vote that YES, you are a heretic.

Shalom

PS: - Luke 14:25-35 speaks of the time that Israel will be told the terms of relationship with Christ.

The parable of the Minas, Luke 19:11-27, in verse 14 tells us when Israel will no longer want Satan to be their master over them, and verse 27 in that Parable tells us how Satan will react initially after he is released from the Bottomless pit.

Goodbye ScottA
 

NayborBear

Active Member
Jan 21, 2020
701
236
43
73
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I voted yes.....If what you said bothered me, or we had a run in with each other?
That's what the ignore button is for. Eh? :Laughingoutloud: And I don't really like putting people on ignore. But I have. And did! :Broadly:
Yet? Like some others that have posted I find it "kinda" odd!
If it were me feeling the the way you are projecting?
I wouldn't say nothing! I was looking for a forum to express my views, convictions, faith, witness, and testimony when I came across this one!
This ain't the only starfish in the sea yanno?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anchorite

quietthinker

Well-Known Member
May 4, 2018
15,672
9,633
113
Sunshine
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Typical. That is just how much of the truth from God was rejected down through the ages. Oh, that's so convincing--so credible, so impactful--you should be proud. Wow!

Nothing new under the sun. Go figure!
Pride is the flagship of error. Projection its means.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anchorite

Ziggy

Well-Known Member
Oct 19, 2020
10,781
9,710
113
61
Maine, USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Ecc 3:1
To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven:

I been here almost 6 years now.
It was the summer of 2020 and the riots were just getting into the starting position.
Covid was on the near horizon and the world looked bleak.

I spent the next 120 days and nights watching people burn things down, attack each other for nothing.

I found myself in a real dark place. I didn't recognize the world anymore. Things had changed.
I found this place I call my home away from home.
I don't leave my home and I have no neighbors near by.

I just hope and pray that the chaos that is outside don't find it's way inside, although I already see the signs.

And I suppose it is just another challenge or another rung on the ladder we must climb to get to the top.

Anywho..

Prayers Family
It's cold outside.
HUGS
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,634
6,992
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I voted yes.....If what you said bothered me, or we had a run in with each other?
That's what the ignore button is for. Eh? :Laughingoutloud: And I don't really like putting people on ignore. But I have. And did! :Broadly:
Yet? Like some others that have posted I find it "kinda" odd!
If it were me feeling the the way you are projecting?
I wouldn't say nothing! I was looking for a forum to express my views, convictions, faith, witness, and testimony when I came across this one!
This ain't the only starfish in the sea yanno?
Then you have not read all and have missed why I have and have not started the thread. Yet, you speak and make judgement as if you had.

Very telling...and exactly why I started the thread!
 

Jay Ross

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2011
9,372
3,491
113
QLD
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
I was not stating, but quoting--quoting what God Himself said regarding Israel, which clearly you deny here again. Your interpretation and understanding is in error.

ScottA, we both will not be around, in around 20 years' time, to confirm our present understandings of what will happen when the seventh age begins. Saying who will be right or wrong from our own perspective is fraught with embarrassment for both of us.

It seems to me that you have and axe to grind against Israel because of your biased understanding of what is to happen during the seventh age.

Let us both be patient and allow God to show us what is to come.

Shalom

PS: - waiting for another 20 or so years to pass is not difficult at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ProDeo

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
1,822
1,509
113
51
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
Let's hear it! What is the measure--the whole house, or only a few?

I am tired of being accused and called names.


I have given my testimony here on Christiany Board a half dozen times or more, published books on the details; and have been here for years not discussing, not weighing in, not giving my opinion or conjecture, but being "silent" personally allowing the Holy Spirit to speak within the parameters commanded by God regarding these times. But I don't like hanging out where I am not welcome. And I let a lot just roll off my back. But it's enough.

The Lord God sets before us all "life and death, blessing and cursing"--and today by His authority I am setting before you that same choice. I have presented the Holy Spirit, and this is that limit set by Christ of blaspheming against the Spirit that will not be forgiven (Matthew 12:31).

Your vote will determine whether I dust off my feet or not. Please vote.

Hi Scott,

I voted NO, but IMHO your are not a prophet. I have read your testimony asked some questions and it was not convincing.

Does this make you an heretic? Of course not. Because.... there is no end time theory without buts and there are a lot. I don't believe end time theories are a salvation issue. Dedication and devotion to God Almighty and Christ are.
 

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,128
31,226
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
Brother @ScottA.
I have known you since I first came online as a greenhorn using dial-up, and I joined my first online Christian forum called ProphecyTalk. Nearly 20 years ago. I know that you are a kind and caring, a man of God and a gentleman online. I do not believe you are a heretic in any way. I love you, my brother in Christ. I don't care what anyone else thinks!...:gd
 
Last edited:

Ziggy

Well-Known Member
Oct 19, 2020
10,781
9,710
113
61
Maine, USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Let us both be patient and allow God to show us what is to come.
There is this short book in the bible called Jonah.
God gave Jonah a message to send to Nineveh, warning them of pending doom.
For THREE days and nights Jonah travelled from one end of Ninevah to the other, basically yelling,
REPENT for the Kingdom of God is at hand!!
It was immanent. They had 40 days to change their ways or they would be punished big time.

After those 3 days, Jonah climbed a hill to watch and see what would happen.
And when God didn't perform the way Jonah thought He should, he got upset.

We don't know what we don't know.
And even God sometimes changes his mind.

God Bless
Hugs
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
37,105
60,836
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
ScottA, we both will not be around, in around 20 years' time, to confirm our present understandings of what will happen when the seventh age begins. Saying who will be right or wrong from our own perspective is fraught with embarrassment for both of us.

It seems to me that you have and axe to grind against Israel because of your biased understanding of what is to happen during the seventh age.

Let us both be patient and allow God to show us what is to come.

Shalom

PS: - waiting for another 20 or so years to pass is not difficult at all.
I would like to draw attention to something . You wrote we both will not be around in twenty years time .
FRIEND On that note and with that reminder i would like to remind us all of something .
THE SIGNS OF THE TIMES we presently dwell in , SHOWS ME this entire world does not have twenty years left .
The COMING of THE LORD does indeed draw nigh .
Now before one says HEY they been saying that in ever generation
Let me remind us , PETER warned men would be saying such things specially as the TIME DREW NEAR .
Not to mention i see a religoin of many antichrists being pumped out and it started within CHRISTENDOME itself
and it grows only larger and darker by the hour .
IT denies the dire need to BELEIVE ON JESUS
and gives out a lie that all religoins from buddism , islam , to taoism and any other ism
Worships the same GOD we do . AND IT beleives , as do more and more of its inclusive converts do
THIS IS WHAT WILL BRING LASTING world PEACE N SAFETY .
REALLY . lets see a peace plan that all the false religoins as well as a lot of christendom
believes Will usher in PEACE N SAFETY , HAS FLAT OUT DENIED THE DIRE NEED TO BELIEVE ON JESUS THE CHRIST .
AND they think its GODS WILL and that it wll bring PEACE N SAF ETY .
NOPE . i say r ather , as did paul , FOR WHEN they shall say PEACE N SAFETY , KABOOM its SUDDEN DESTRUCTION
upon them all and that they will not escape . OH YEAH , times running out all right .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
37,105
60,836
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Then you have not read all and have missed why I have and have not started the thread. Yet, you speak and make judgement as if you had.

Very telling...and exactly why I started the thread!
Does anyone here teach and or cliam UNBELEIF . IF SO they are in deadly danger of hell fire .
And now a word .
IF i were to ask you or anyone here , what is two plus two . would we not all say WHY ITS FOUR OF COURSE .
Now if another came along and said wait its five , or another come along and say no its not five its three
Would we not have corrected such a one and said NO it is FOUR .
And now a word .
DO we BELEIVE the gospel of JESUS CHRIST . That HE was crucified , that GOD rose HIM from the dead .
That HE is the CHRIST , THE SAVOIR . perhaps many would say , WHY YES WE DO BELIEVE THAT .
BUT what if one cometh of another religion , what if one says HEY wait are you saying that all other religoins
cannot save and that they are in darkness and must repent and BELEIVE ON JESUS .
WHAT DO WE SAY THEN . THE CORECT ANSWER OF COURSE IS < YEAH that is exactly what i am saying .
yet many all of a sudden preach UNBELIEF and act like GOD is at work in all religoins , that somehow
we all serve the same GOD differently , thus in effect THEY JUST MADE Their beleif UNBELEIF .
TWo plus two is four
AND BELEIVE ME no matter who a person is , THEY MUST ABSOLUTELY BELEIVE ON HIM TO BE SAVED .
SO its time to boot the ol whores ecumeincal broad path lies OUT . and boot this inclusive univesalism OUT
and rather PREACH JESUS CHRIST . OR its really just BELEIF IN UNBELEIF . and that IS UNBELEIF .
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,634
6,992
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
ScottA, we both will not be around, in around 20 years' time, to confirm our present understandings of what will happen when the seventh age begins. Saying who will be right or wrong from our own perspective is fraught with embarrassment for both of us.

It seems to me that you have and axe to grind against Israel because of your biased understanding of what is to happen during the seventh age.

Let us both be patient and allow God to show us what is to come.

Shalom

PS: - waiting for another 20 or so years to pass is not difficult at all.
Thanks for being calm and reasonable.

Indeed, this is our valley of decision--now--and repeating the issues has been of little or no effect.

I will say however, that I do not have "an axe to grind against Israel." On the contrary, I am grateful for their having gone before us, and glad to know that Christ has "finished" with their house with salvation as the scriptures foretold. Now being real about these times of the gentiles is also not an axe to grind, but an "other fold" Christ "must also bring", for which I am a servant.
 

lforrest

Admin
Staff member
Admin
Aug 10, 2012
6,569
7,955
113
Faith
Christian
Gender
Male
Let's hear it! What is the measure--the whole house, or only a few?

I am tired of being accused and called names.


I have given my testimony here on Christiany Board a half dozen times or more, published books on the details; and have been here for years not discussing, not weighing in, not giving my opinion or conjecture, but being "silent" personally allowing the Holy Spirit to speak within the parameters commanded by God regarding these times. But I don't like hanging out where I am not welcome. And I let a lot just roll off my back. But it's enough.

The Lord God sets before us all "life and death, blessing and cursing"--and today by His authority I am setting before you that same choice. I have presented the Holy Spirit, and this is that limit set by Christ of blaspheming against the Spirit that will not be forgiven (Matthew 12:31).

Your vote will determine whether I dust off my feet or not. Please vote.

I haven't accused you of being a heretic yet. That doesn't mean I always agree with what you say. But those disagreements have not involved doctrine as far as I remember.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScottA

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,634
6,992
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hi Scott,

I voted NO, but IMHO your are not a prophet. I have read your testimony asked some questions and it was not convincing.

Does this make you an heretic? Of course not. Because.... there is no end time theory without buts and there are a lot. I don't believe end time theories are a salvation issue. Dedication and devotion to God Almighty and Christ are.
Thank you!

I get your rationale, I do. But it is not unlike the position of many who have gone before us who simply didn't view the weakness of men sent by God was enough to be credible in spite of it being the power of God to fulfill what is written. And for what reason? Greater expectations? Greater than a woman, a shepherd boy, a babe, a simple fisherman, a persecutor of Christians?

But we all most choose.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ProDeo
Status
Not open for further replies.