I don't identify as a "Christian"

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,251
31,355
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
Hmm Angelina - I think perhaps you have not fully understood my calling my "faith" Agnostic as explained already. Would you say the same as you have above, to someone who states they are a Theist? If not, then please feel free to think of me as a theist with agnostic tendencies.


In Love.

Good morning, @Eternal Entity, Thank you for your reply.
One statement in particular caught my attention: "My choice not to self identify as a Christian has nothing to do with avoiding The Christ."
I'd be interested to hear more about that. :clmSmlx

You speak of the Father, creation, and the Christ in ways that suggest these are all important parts of your understanding.
How do you understand Christ's role in relation to the Father?

I'm not asking about labels but about Christ Himself. What do you see as His place and purpose within your understanding of reality and of the Father? coffee:
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScottA

Jay Ross

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2011
9,442
3,517
113
QLD
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Yes - I have used that term myself. What other identifier recorded, did Jesus use.

A person also needs to be a "watcher" of what is happening around him so that they can see God's Glory in action.
 
Jun 12, 2026
146
15
18
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Good morning Angelina.
Thank you for your reply.
One statement in particular caught my attention: "My choice not to self identify as a Christian has nothing to do with avoiding The Christ."
I'd be interested to hear more about that. :clmSmlx
I was replying to you implying it was.
You speak of the Father, creation, and the Christ in ways that suggest these are all important parts of your understanding.
How do you understand Christ's role in relation to the Father?
"The Christ" as I understand it, is the overall process - The Source Reality. The Field of all Consciousness. The "Glue that holds it all together" et al...
The Father is the Entity representative (specific to humanity) of The Field of Consciousness Which encompasses Absolutely Everything... which could be said to being "GOD".
In that, The Father is not a particular gender and is just as suitable being referred to as The Mother.
The Son is representative of the human being who has relationship with The Father - and specific to Jesus (the common name Christianity uses) - acts both as the directing sign and the gateway to The Father - the individual humans access to relationship with.
I'm not asking about labels but about Christ Himself. What do you see as His place and purpose within your understanding of reality and of the Father? coffee:


Christ is not so much a "him" as the overall reality (as I touched on above). Jesus (the Greek name for the person) was the representation of the Field (The Christ) within a human experience, ambassadoring The Christ through said human experience - passing that data of experience on to those who followed after him - in a similar manner in which YHVH used Moses.
The overall message (contained in the Bible - and in other less known script) had to do with bringing individuals to the awareness of the possibility of direct relationship with The Father in order to circumnavigate the mediator system of Priests and prophets and even angelic encounters, all of which in their own way had proven to have evolved into a shadow of the Real and needed a "shake-up" as consequence.
The same pattern evolved after the ascension - humans are simply habitual creatures and tend toward the "need" to let "others" mediate between The Father and The Individual - It is well known and understood.

Sin = Having no relationship with The Father - as portrayed in the story of Adam.
Thus the idea "all are born into sin" is the same as saying, all are born without relationship with The Father.
The outcomes of Sin are the symptoms such as envy, pride, murdering, et al - these things are done by individuals because of their lack of relationship with The Father.

As with the story of Adam - death was promised yet it is not physical death. The death Adam experienced was the withdrawal of The Father from Adam's life experience.
The offspring were thus born into Sin - born without relationship with The Father. The Father had withdrawn - leaving humans largely to their own means. "The rest" (as the saying goes) "is history."
Part of that history involved The Son - The Son knew The Father. Was born with knowledge of a prior existence and relationship with The Father, and The Son eventually told others about that and how - through listening and understanding the words The Son shared (many of which are not recorded in the Bible) - it was possible for individual humans to wilfully connect with and through that, have relationship with The Father.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: talons
Jun 12, 2026
146
15
18
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
A person also needs to be a "watcher" of what is happening around him so that they can see God's Glory in action.
Are you therefore saying that those who call themselves "Christians" are incapable of accomplishing this? Something else?
 

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,251
31,355
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
Good morning Angelina.

I was replying to you implying it was.

"The Christ" as I understand it, is the overall process - The Source Reality. The Field of all Consciousness. The "Glue that holds it all together" et al...
The Father is the Entity representative (specific to humanity) of The Field of Consciousness Which encompasses Absolutely Everything... which could be said to being "GOD".
In that, The Father is not a particular gender and is just as suitable being referred to as The Mother.
The Son is representative of the human being who has relationship with The Father - and specific to Jesus (the common name Christianity uses) - acts both as the directing sign and the gateway to The Father - the individual humans access to relationship with.



Christ is not so much a "him" as the overall reality (as I touched on above). Jesus (the Greek name for the person) was the representation of the Field (The Christ) within a human experience, ambassadoring The Christ through said human experience - passing that data of experience on to those who followed after him - in a similar manner in which YHVH used Moses.
The overall message (contained in the Bible - and in other less known script) had to do with bringing individuals to the awareness of the possibility of direct relationship with The Father in order to circumnavigate the mediator system of Priests and prophets and even angelic encounters, all of which in their own way had proven to have evolved into a shadow of the Real and needed a "shake-up" as consequence.
The same pattern evolved after the ascension - humans are simply habitual creatures and tend toward the "need" to let "others" mediate between The Father and The Individual - It is well known and understood.

Sin = Having no relationship with The Father - as portrayed in the story of Adam.
Thus the idea "all are born into sin" is the same as saying, all are born without relationship with The Father.
The outcomes of Sin are the symptoms such as envy, pride, murdering, et al - these things are done by individuals because of their lack of relationship with The Father.

As with the story of Adam - death was promised yet it is not physical death. The death Adam experienced was the withdrawal of The Father from Adam's life experience.
The offspring were thus born into Sin - born without relationship with The Father. The Father had withdrawn - leaving humans largely to their own means. "The rest" (as the saying goes) "is history."
Part of that history involved The Son - The Son knew The Father. Was born with knowledge of a prior existence and relationship with The Father, and The Son eventually told others about that and how - through listening and understanding the words The Son shared (many of which are not recorded in the Bible) - it was possible for individual humans to wilfully connect with and through that, have relationship with The Father.

Hi @Eternal Entity. Thank you for your reply.

I’ve read through your post, but I don’t think it directly answers the questions I was asking. Basically, I was asking for a clear understanding of your view on this:

Who is Jesus in relation to the Father?
And are they two distinct persons, or the same being described in different ways?


I’m not asking for a wider explanation of reality or consciousness, just a direct answer to that specific point so I can understand your position clearly.

Be blessed, Angelina. :clmSmlx
 

PeterAndroz

Active Member
May 15, 2026
667
164
43
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Are you therefore saying that those who call themselves "Christians" are incapable of accomplishing this? Something else?
A Christian today is some who :-
Places their faith/trust/belief in only the death/burial/resurrection of Christ for the forgiveness of their sins so that they can enter Heaven.
You apparently do not so therefore rightfully "don't identify as a Christian"
 
  • Like
Reactions: talons and Angelina

Jay Ross

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2011
9,442
3,517
113
QLD
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Are you therefore saying that those who call themselves "Christians" are incapable of accomplishing this? Something else?

NO.

A Disciple and a Christian are just identification labels that people like to use. Identification labels are often useless where the labels are not matched or lived up to in the living.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eternal Entity
Jun 12, 2026
146
15
18
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
NO.

A Disciple and a Christian are just identification labels that people like to use. Identification labels are often useless where the labels are not matched or lived up to in the living.
This will be my last post in this thread.
I think what you say points out how pointless labels are. I also think that none of us have the ultimate position to make the call as to who is who because labels automatically propel judgment in relation to that observation "is not matched or lived up", as can be observed in the dynamic of this very thread with some of the posts being made and directed at targets.

Not my cup of tea.

:)
 

PeterAndroz

Active Member
May 15, 2026
667
164
43
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
This will be my last post in this thread.
I think what you say points out how pointless labels are. I also think that none of us have the ultimate position to make the call as to who is who because labels automatically propel judgment in relation to that observation "is not matched or lived up", as can be observed in the dynamic of this very thread with some of the posts being made and directed at targets.

Not my cup of tea.

:)
Because you are not a Christian
You will go to the Great White Throne Judgement if you die refusing to accept only the death/burial/resurrection of Christ for the forgiveness of your sins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anchorite

NayborBear

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2020
774
270
63
73
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Greetings Reader.

I joined this forum today. In the membership form I was asked how I identify religiously and was given a list of options, and chose the one which most closely mirrored my position - that being "Agnostic".

What I think is true:

I exist within a created thing.
I have many good reasons why I think this is true.

Since I think this is true, that would make me a "Theist" - because IF I think I exist within a created thing, THEN this implies a Creator/Creators.
Perhaps in that context, I might be an Agnostic Theist.
I do not self identify as being a "Christian" for many reasons. I have no problem with others who self identify as being Christian, for whatever reasons they chose to do so.
Truely, the "self identification" doesn't mean much to me, but I understand it means something to others, so that they may be able to better pinpoint who I am in relation to who they believe they are. Such is the nature of human interactions on that level.
To flip that, others who self identify as being "Christians" when they interact with me, the label doesn't really mean a lot to me in any significant way. This is because there are so many "types" of Christians, and many of those do not agree with one another most of the time and that is just one of the reasons why I do not self identify as being "Christian".
Are there any others hereabouts think in a similar way about this?

Peace.
EE
Greetings! Right back at ya!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Eternal Entity

Anchorite

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2026
540
476
63
68
Peoria
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
"The Christ" as I understand it, is the overall process - The Source Reality. The Field of all Consciousness. The "Glue that holds it all together" et al...
The Father is the Entity representative (specific to humanity) of The Field of Consciousness Which encompasses Absolutely Everything... which could be said to being "GOD".
In that, The Father is not a particular gender and is just as suitable being referred to as The Mother.
The Son is representative of the human being who has relationship with The Father - and specific to Jesus (the common name Christianity uses) - acts both as the directing sign and the gateway to The Father - the individual humans access to relationship with.



Christ is not so much a "him" as the overall reality (as I touched on above). Jesus (the Greek name for the person) was the representation of the Field (The Christ) within a human experience, ambassadoring The Christ through said human experience - passing that data of experience on to those who followed after him - in a similar manner in which YHVH used Moses.
Now we know why you do not identify as a Christian.

You do not know Jesus Christ.

You hold unbiblical, new age theories about who Christ and the Father are.