Are you really that ignorant? This is the pharisees and Jesus' family did not hang a sign saying Jospeh was not Jesus' father. C'mon you need to engage your brain! Straining at gnats again. The crowds did not know. Jesus grew up with Joseph so they by nature thought Joseph was Dad. C'mon engage your thought processes.
That's exactly my point. You've just acknowledged that the crowd's statement, "Is this not the carpenter's son?", reflects their ordinary understanding of Jesus' family rather than a precise biological fact. The crowd thought Joseph was Jesus' father because that is how Jesus was publicly known in Nazareth. Matthew, however, has already informed the reader that Joseph was not Jesus' biological father.
So we've established an important principle: a family designation used by the crowd does not automatically settle the precise biological relationship being described. That is the point you keep avoiding.
I'm not arguing that the crowd was mistaken about who Jesus' relatives were. I'm arguing that their words are not functioning as a technical genealogical statement. The very same sentence contains a family designation that requires the reader to look beyond the crowd's ordinary way of speaking.
Therefore, simply saying, "They called them
adelphoi," does not by itself prove the exact biological relationship any more than "the carpenter's son" proves Joseph was Jesus' biological father. The question is not whether these people were relatives of Jesus. We both agree they were. The question is where Matthew explicitly identifies James, Joses, Simon, and Judas as sons of Mary, the mother of Jesus. Appealing to what the crowd naturally assumed doesn't answer that question, because the crowd also naturally assumed Joseph was Jesus' father.
My question is:
Where does Matthew explicitly identify James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas as sons of Mary, the mother of Jesus?
Straining at gnats. where does it say that Mary of Clopas was the mother of the at least 6 called brothers and sisters present? NOwhere!
You've changed the subject.
I asked where Matthew explicitly identifies James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas as sons of Mary, the mother of Jesus. Instead of answering, you've asked where Scripture says Mary of Clopas was the mother of all the
adelphoi and
adelphai.
But I don't need that claim in order to challenge yours.
You're making the positive assertion that Matthew 13:55 identifies James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas as children of Mary, the mother of Jesus. I'm asking where the text actually says that.
Matthew 13:55 does not say, "These are Mary's sons." Nor does it say, "Mary bore Jesus, James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas." It calls them Jesus'
adelphoi.
So the question remains:
where does Matthew explicitly make the identification you're claiming?
Notice the difference between our positions.
You are claiming certainty that James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas are the children of Mary and Joseph. I am asking you to show that from the text.
Whether Mary of Clopas is the mother of some, all, or none of them is a separate question. Even if I never mentioned Mary of Clopas, you would still need to demonstrate your claim from Matthew 13:55 itself.
A difficulty in my proposed identification does not become proof of yours.
So rather than asking me to prove a different identification, show where Matthew explicitly gives the identification you are asserting.
To address your question for the sake of clarity, I'm not arguing that Mary of Clopas was the mother of the
adelphai mentioned in Matthew 13:56. My argument concerns the four named
adelphoi in Matthew 13:55: James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas.
Nor am I arguing that there is a verse that explicitly states, "Mary of Clopas was the mother of all four
adelphoi." I've already presented the evidence that points me in that direction, including the Gospel data and the testimony of early Christian writers.
But notice that your position is in exactly the same situation.
There is no verse that explicitly says, "Mary, the mother of Jesus, was the mother of James, Joseph, Simon, Judas, and the
adelphai."
So if your criticism is that my conclusion involves inference, then your conclusion involves inference as well.
The difference is that my inference is not based on nothing.
- It is based on the Gospel references associating Mary of Clopas with James and Joseph, together with John's identification of Mary of Clopas as the sister (or close female relative) of Jesus' mother. That places James and Joseph within Jesus' extended family and provides actual textual evidence for kinship beyond the immediate nuclear family.
- It is also based on the broader biblical usage of adelphos. Even in the Septuagint, adelphos is sometimes used for relatives who are not biological brothers, Abraham and Lot being a well-known example.
- Likewise, the existence of another kinship term such as syngenis ("kinswoman" or "relative") does not prove that adelphos was restricted to biological siblings. The question is not whether other kinship terms existed. The question is how adelphos was actually used. Scripture itself demonstrates that kinship language can be broader than immediate biological siblinghood.
- And finally, it is based on the testimony of early Christian writers, many of whom lived far closer to the apostolic age than either of us and did not read these passages as proving that Mary bore additional children.
You may reject that evidence, but you cannot honestly claim that my position is invented out of thin air.
More importantly, the burden of proof remains on the claim being asserted.
You are claiming certainty that James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas are the children of Mary and Joseph.
I'm simply asking where Matthew actually says that.
And appealing to "the natural reading" does not settle the matter, because in the very same passage the crowd calls Jesus "the carpenter's son," even though Matthew has already informed the reader that Joseph was not Jesus' biological father.
So the issue is not whether these people were relatives of Jesus. We both agree they were.
The issue is whether Matthew explicitly identifies James, Joseph, Simon, and Judas as sons of Mary, the mother of Jesus.
I've yet to see the passage that says so.