Matthew 25:31- the sheep and the goats.

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Yeah, I didn't really cover that point. But it should be easy enough if you take the time to go over those Revelation 20 Scriptures again while keeping in mind what Jesus said in John 5:28-29 about those spiritually dead of the "resurrection of damnation," and what Apostle Paul taught about the Salvation requirement of one's mortal soul must put on immortality.

That "resurrection of damnation" is a 'resurrection' too you know. So those will already be in their spirit bodies, their souls just not having putting on "immortality" through Faith on Jesus Christ. And how does one's soul put on immortality? Our soul is our person, the real 'you'. It has to make a decision by 'what' and on Whom to be saved? By FAITH on Jesus Christ. That is what some of those unsaved will do when they stand at God's Great White Throne Judgement after the Millennium. That is why the Book of Life will be opened one final time to see if any more names are written there unto Christ. We already know those of the 1st resurrection will have had their names already written in that Book of Life, even from the foundation of the world as written in Revelation 13 and 17, and Ephesians. But at the Great White Throne Judgment, that will be a 'final' check. And for the unsaved that convert to Lord Jesus during... that "thousand years" period? They will be joined with those of the 1st resurrection unto Christ Jesus and be saved. That is what the so-called second resurrection will be about. It is not really a second resurrection of flesh dead like how Church tradition treats it, but instead about their conversion by Faith on Jesus Christ unto Eternal Life.




Yes Paul actually does... say that in those 1 Corinthians 15:53-54 verses, but in the GREEK. How many brethren do you know that bother to look that up in the Greek to find 4 different Greek words involving that change?

1 Cor 15:54
54 So when this
corruptible shall have put on incorruption, and this mortal shall have put on immortality, then shall be brought to pass the saying that is written, "Death is swallowed up in victory."
KJV


"corruptible" = Greek phthartos, definition - 'decayed, perishable', (our flesh body).
"incorruption" = Greek aphthrasia, - 'unending existence', (the "spiritual body").
AND
"this mortal" = Greek thnetos, - 'liable to die' (i.e., perish at the lake of fire, the soul).
"immortality" = Greek athanasia, - 'deathlessness', (Eternal Life through Faith on Jesus Christ.)
(All definitions are from Strong's Exhaustive Concordance)

That's two... changes, not just one. And Paul refers to Isaiah 25 with that quote... which I will leave to you to look up for yourself.




No, not just to believers on Christ only, because Paul quoted from Isaiah 25 which points to death being swallowed up for ALL peoples. Have you read it yet?



Church tradition made you already forget what Jesus said about the "resurrection of damnation" in John 5:28-29 that will also happen on the day of His future coming?


That's OK, put the idea on a shelf and stick with Church tradition. It won't affect your Faith in our Lord Jesus Christ.
Thank you for explaining your understanding further. I think I now have a clearer picture of how you distinguish between the resurrection of the body, the condition of the soul, and the eventual reception of immortality.

I also appreciate your reference to Isaiah 25. The promise that God will swallow up death is a remarkable one, particularly because the passage speaks of all peoples and nations.

But I still have some difficulty finding your proposed sequence in Paul's actual words.

Let's look more carefully at the Greek in 1 Corinthians 15:53–54.

You are correct that Paul uses four different Greek terms:

  • Phtharton — perishable or corruptible.
  • Aphtharsia — imperishability or incorruption.
  • Thnēton — mortal, or subject to death.
  • Athanasia — immortality or deathlessness.
I agree that these distinctions are meaningful.

But how do those four words establish that Paul is describing two different groups of people undergoing two separate transformations?

Paul does not identify thnēton as the soul. Nor does he say that aphtharsia is given to everyone while athanasia is reserved for believers.

Rather, he appears to be describing the transformation of our present mortal condition from two closely related perspectives: what is perishable becomes imperishable, and what is mortal receives immortality.

The fact that Paul uses different words does not necessarily mean he is identifying different subjects.

In fact, the immediate context begins with his question in verse 35: How are the dead raised, and with what kind of body do they come?

His discussion proceeds to answer that question.

Now consider John 5:25–29.

I certainly agree that Jesus teaches a resurrection of both the righteous and the unrighteous.

But notice something interesting.

In verse 25, Jesus speaks of an hour that is coming and already is, when the dead will hear His voice and live.

In verses 28–29, He speaks of a coming hour when all who are in the tombs will hear His voice and come out.

Could Jesus be distinguishing between the spiritual life available through Him in the present and the future resurrection of those who have physically died?

And while He describes two resurrection outcomes, where does He specifically say that both occur at the same moment at His return?

That timing seems to be something you are supplying through your interpretation rather than something Jesus explicitly states.

Then there is Revelation 20:4–5.

John says one group comes to life and reigns with Christ for a thousand years, while the rest of the dead do not come to life until those thousand years are completed.

I still don't see why we should understand the second group as having already come to life in spiritual bodies when John specifically tells us they do not come to life until afterward.

You suggest that they remain spiritually dead, but what in the immediate passage establishes that John has changed the meaning of coming to life?

Finally, your understanding of the book of life raises another question.

You suggest that some people will come to faith during the millennium and that the book of life will be opened at the great white throne judgment to determine whether more names have been added.

I am not dismissing the possibility that God's mercy may reach further than we presently understand.

But Revelation 20:12 tells us that the book of life is opened. It does not tell us that names are being added during the millennium or at the final judgment.

That distinction matters.

I find considerable reason in Scripture to hope for the breadth of God's ultimate redemptive purpose. Romans 11:32, Colossians 1:20, and 1 Corinthians 15:22–28 are passages I take very seriously.

But I also recognize that there are unanswered questions concerning the nature, timing, and final outcome of judgment.

My hesitation is not with the possibility of restoration. It is with treating a particular explanation of how restoration occurs as though Scripture has explicitly revealed it.

I am willing to consider your interpretation, but I would appreciate understanding how the passages themselves establish these distinctions without assuming them in advance.

And regarding your suggestion that I should simply remain with church tradition, I would point out that questioning inherited interpretations is precisely why I am examining these passages so carefully.

My concern is not defending tradition. It is understanding what the biblical authors actually wrote.

I appreciate your willingness to continue the discussion.