Is the Holy Spirit a "He," "She," or “It”?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
It denotes a father generating offspring...usually. But in the case of Christ we know that He has always been, that He is not a created being. In terms of the title of 'firstborn' it conveys pre-eminence in family lineage and rights of inheritance. It does not mean that Jesus was created. Indeed we also know that Jesus, as the 'Son' is not 'less' than The Father, or that The Father gave Him life...it is a signal of the order and perfection within the Trinity, of Jesus wonderful submission to the Father's will, for the glory to God.



Ahhh, because as a male He wouldn't get married to a groom? The 'marriage' of Jesus to the Church is symbolic of the covenant He has with us. I don't believe we can support in any way that in the end Jesus will actually marry the 'Church' and have the kind of relationship with us all as we do here within our marriages. The marriage is symbolic of the spiritual reality that Jesus gave His life for us...and that really has nothing to do with male or female.



Because He calls Himself The Father, and as He's promised us to be with us always, and is eternal, it will be an everlasting thing.



I agree, we cannot. And certainly these questions must be asked...with many more! But always with the understanding that what we need to know, the Bible provides for us. And in this matter, it doesn't provide us any reason or proof to designate The Spirit with the title of 'she'.


Ahh, but you have no scripture to support you theory.


A bride denotes gender. Spiritual Gender.

A Father means offspring has been begotten.

I never said Jesus was created, begotten means a birth, as in kind begets after its own kind. If I have a son then my son is human, if God begets a Son then His Son is God.


Wisdom is known by Her children.


Thanks, JLB
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
Ahh, but you have no scripture to support you theory.

I think I have more scripture to support my theory than you do yours!

A bride denotes gender. Spiritual Gender.

Okay...if we are going to side step biblical reasoning and into 'what seems rational'. You say that 'bride' denotes gender, but if we follow that rationally it doesn't make much sense. Because while the church is the 'bride' of Christ, not all the church is female to match Jesus' male. If we are talking of actual marriage, of actual gender pairing with Jesus...then that may make all the men out there in the Church a little uncomfortable! But if we, as I suggested in my previous post, regard Jesus and His 'bride' in the spiritual sense...something that doesn't need gender specifics, then it's not a problem. The Church is called the 'bride' because of the similarities in the covenant promises. Just as it should work in a biblical marriage, where the man is the head, who loves and sacrifices for the woman, and the woman follows, submits and loves her husband. Thus it is with the covenant of Jesus and His 'bride', of whom He is the head, to whom He sacrificed all for, and loves so much. It is the symbolism here that leads to the term 'bride', especially because of the fact that Jesus is male, and of course the positions...clearly we are not the head, and therefore cannot be labelled Jesus' 'groom'!

A Father means offspring has been begotten.

I'm sorry...just to clarify...are you saying that God made Jesus, as a father makes a son? That Jesus is not an equal part of the Godhead, eternal in existence, just as the Father is?

I never said Jesus was created, begotten means a birth, as in kind begets after its own kind. If I have a son then my son is human, if God begets a Son then His Son is God.

I'm sorry, I'm still confused by your understanding of 'begotten'. Granted you are saying that Jesus is God, which is accurate. But are you also saying that Jesus was still created by The Father at some point?? Jesus, being fully God, a member of the Godhead, was not created. God was not created, He has existed in eternity past, and that goes for Jesus as well. How do you regard the Trinity??

Wisdom is known by Her children.

Thanks, JLB

Yes, but by following this line of reasoning, we must regard 'wisdom' as an entity. That 'she' is a being that can be known by 'her children'. There is only God The Father, The Son and The Spirit. They have wisdom...more...wisdom is an attribute they have...it is part of them, who they are. But 'Wisdom' is not a separate entity. There is no biblical proof for this, in fact, we may argue that the bible would label that making such a thing 'alive' is idolatrous.
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
I think I have more scripture to support my theory than you do yours!

All I have given is scripture. I have written out what the bible says. Please go back and read for yourself.

Okay...if we are going to side step biblical reasoning and into 'what seems rational'. You say that 'bride' denotes gender, but if we follow that rationally it doesn't make much sense. Because while the church is the 'bride' of Christ, not all the church is female to match Jesus' male. If we are talking of actual marriage, of actual gender pairing with Jesus...then that may make all the men out there in the Church a little uncomfortable! But if we, as I suggested in my previous post, regard Jesus and His 'bride' in the spiritual sense...something that doesn't need gender specifics, then it's not a problem. The Church is called the 'bride' because of the similarities in the covenant promises. Just as it should work in a biblical marriage, where the man is the head, who loves and sacrifices for the woman, and the woman follows, submits and loves her husband. Thus it is with the covenant of Jesus and His 'bride', of whom He is the head, to whom He sacrificed all for, and loves so much. It is the symbolism here that leads to the term 'bride', especially because of the fact that Jesus is male, and of course the positions...clearly we are not the head, and therefore cannot be labelled Jesus' 'groom'!

Who cares if men are uncomfortable.

My whole point based on the scriptures is: Spiritual beings can have gender.



I'm sorry...just to clarify...are you saying that God made Jesus, as a father makes a son? That Jesus is not an equal part of the Godhead, eternal in existence, just as the Father is?

Jesus Christ is the only begotten Son of God - 5 For to which of the angels did He ever say: "You are My Son, Today I have begotten You"? And again: "I will be to Him a Father, And He shall be to Me a Son"? 6 But when He again brings the firstborn into the world, He says: "Let all the angels of God worship Him." Hebrews 1:5-6

Angels are referred to as sons of God. Jesus is the only begotten Son of God.

He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn over all creation. Colossians 1:15

I'm sorry, I'm still confused by your understanding of 'begotten'. Granted you are saying that Jesus is God, which is accurate. But are you also saying that Jesus was still created by The Father at some point?? Jesus, being fully God, a member of the Godhead, was not created. God was not created, He has existed in eternity past, and that goes for Jesus as well. How do you regard the Trinity??

Not created, begotten.

And Adam lived one hundred and thirty years, and begot a son in his own likeness, after his image, and named him Seth. Genesis 5:3

How else is the word begot to be understood?



Yes, but by following this line of reasoning, we must regard 'wisdom' as an entity. That 'she' is a being that can be known by 'her children'. There is only God The Father, The Son and The Spirit. They have wisdom...more...wisdom is an attribute they have...it is part of them, who they are. But 'Wisdom' is not a separate entity. There is no biblical proof for this, in fact, we may argue that the bible would label that making such a thing 'alive' is idolatrous.

The Spirit of Wisdom is The Holy Spirit. The Sevenfold Spirit of God.

The Spirit of the Lord shall rest upon Him, The Spirit of wisdom and understanding, The Spirit of counsel and might, The Spirit of knowledge and of the fear of the Lord.

This is typified by the Menorah. The sevenfold candle-stick.


Just one more point. In Isaiah 9 the scriptures teach us concerning The Son - He shall be call Everlasting Father.


Thanks, JLB
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
Ephesians 5:31-32


31 "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh." 32 This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church.
 

Sabitarian

New Member
Sep 11, 2011
198
2
0
Rach,
You are totally wrong, the Holy Spirit is not a man, thus not a trinity, but a duelality. In scripture the masculan neutered pronoun is used. The translation should be it not he. If I describe you using a masculin neutered pronoun are you alive or just a thing?
If you actually look at the word translated Holy Ghost it is the same word describing the Spirit of God.
humble servant of the Lord God Most High
 

IanLC

Active Member
Encounter Team
Mar 22, 2011
862
80
28
North Carolina
The Holy Spirit- He is the eternal and perfect Spirit of God the Father and Jesus the Son. He is the third person of the Holy Trinity. He is of the same substance, equal to power and glory with the Father and the Son. He is to be believed in, obeyed, and worshipped along with the Father and the Son. He breathed life into man in the beginning. The Holy Spirit was actively involved in the Old Testament by prophecy, musical talents, and the work of the priests, judges, elders, and leaders of Israel. The Holy Spirit convicts and converts mankind of sin and dwells in the believer and keeps the believer from the power of sin. The Holy Spirit anoints, ordains, appoints, calls, and consecrates believers to their God given ministry. The Holy Spirit is given by God for the equipping of the saints with gifts and power to witness, preach, teach, live, and minister of the gospel of Jesus Christ. He teaches and guides believers into all truth! The Holy Spirit regenerates, sanctifies, and leads the believer into holiness, love, and the fullness of Christ. The Holy Spirit develops and grows the fruit of the Spirit in the believer which are love, joy, peace, gentleness, meekness, faithfulness, long suffering (patience), temperance (self-control). The Holy Spirit bestows gifts upon the believer which are prophecy, diverse tongues, interpretation, gifts of healing, miracles, discernment, administration, teaching, preaching, and among others stated in the Holy writ. (Acts 1:8, 8:39, John 16:13, 1 Corinthians 2:10-16, 1 Corinthians 12:1-11, 1 Corinthians Chapter 13, 1 Corinthians 14:1-25, Ephesians 4:1-13, Ephesians 4:30, Romans 8:12-17, Romans 8:9, John 15:5-12)
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
The Holy Spirit- He is the eternal and perfect Spirit of God the Father and Jesus the Son. He is the third person of the Holy Trinity. He is of the same substance, equal to power and glory with the Father and the Son. He is to be believed in, obeyed, and worshipped along with the Father and the Son. He breathed life into man in the beginning. The Holy Spirit was actively involved in the Old Testament by prophecy, musical talents, and the work of the priests, judges, elders, and leaders of Israel. The Holy Spirit convicts and converts mankind of sin and dwells in the believer and keeps the believer from the power of sin. The Holy Spirit anoints, ordains, appoints, calls, and consecrates believers to their God given ministry. The Holy Spirit is given by God for the equipping of the saints with gifts and power to witness, preach, teach, live, and minister of the gospel of Jesus Christ. He teaches and guides believers into all truth! The Holy Spirit regenerates, sanctifies, and leads the believer into holiness, love, and the fullness of Christ. The Holy Spirit develops and grows the fruit of the Spirit in the believer which are love, joy, peace, gentleness, meekness, faithfulness, long suffering (patience), temperance (self-control). The Holy Spirit bestows gifts upon the believer which are prophecy, diverse tongues, interpretation, gifts of healing, miracles, discernment, administration, teaching, preaching, and among others stated in the Holy writ. (Acts 1:8, 8:39, John 16:13, 1 Corinthians 2:10-16, 1 Corinthians 12:1-11, 1 Corinthians Chapter 13, 1 Corinthians 14:1-25, Ephesians 4:1-13, Ephesians 4:30, Romans 8:12-17, Romans 8:9, John 15:5-12)


What does this scripture mean to you.

Ephesians 5:31-32


31 "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh." 32 This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church.

Why did Paul use this scripture and call it a great mystery?


Thanks, JLB
 

IanLC

Active Member
Encounter Team
Mar 22, 2011
862
80
28
North Carolina
What does this scripture mean to you.

Ephesians 5:31-32


31 "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh." 32 This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church.

Why did Paul use this scripture and call it a great mystery?


Thanks, JLB
It means we as the church have left our old parents of Adam & Eve and our old sinful nature and have joined with our husband Jesus who produces in us our new nature which is Christ like and we became like in Him and joined with Him in oneness! ULTIMATELY it is a great mystery and our finite minds can not understand it! Really I don't know what it means! "Now our knowledge is partial and incomplete, and even the gift of prophecy reveals only part of the whole picture!" (NLT) (1 Cor 13:9)
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
It means we as the church have left our old parents of Adam & Eve and our old sinful nature and have joined with our husband Jesus who produces in us our new nature which is Christ like and we became like in Him and joined with Him in oneness! ULTIMATELY it is a great mystery and our finite minds can not understand it! Really I don't know what it means! "Now our knowledge is partial and incomplete, and even the gift of prophecy reveals only part of the whole picture!" (NLT) (1 Cor 13:9)

How many persons does this scripture involve?

Ephesians 5:31-32

31 "For this reason a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh." 32 This is a great mystery, but I speak concerning Christ and the church.
 

Sabitarian

New Member
Sep 11, 2011
198
2
0
Rach,
If the words clearly are neutered masculin pronouns, how can you get him out of that? It is the same word used to identify the Spirit of God the Father and if it is just one of the Spirits of God how can it be a separate entity? The Spirits of God belong to Him. It was translated Holy Ghost by the Catholic Church as a lot of doctrine comes from Papal doctrine, which they used to control people through the ages and that is what it is all about. Luther went part way with his thesis as did all major leaders of the Churches, but they knew and understood what the truth was.
humble servant of the Lord God Most High
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
I've never tried to claim the the HS is an actual HE! I know Him to be spirit, which means no physical form, which means no sex! If it really comes down to it, I would be happy to refer to The Spirit as an 'it', just for peace! My whole point in this thread was that some people were calling The Spirit a 'She'. If there is no support for labelling The Spirit a "He"....there is even less for calling it a 'She'.
I still believe its not biblically wrong to refer to The Spirit as a 'he'. After all, God the Father is spirit as well, but He still wants us to call Him Father. We know Jesus to be male. To then suggest that the Spirit is female...well, to me, it smacks of unbiblical reasons...and just a little bit blasphemous...suggesting a relationship between the Godhead that most certainly is not true.
If we were supposed to refer to the Spirit as 'she', the bible would have made that clear to us, just as it does with "The Father". We know, linguistically, that we call things 'he', if we are vague on the sex of someone. We ONLY call someone 'she' if we know, beyond a doubt that they are a female.

As far as how I 'reached the conclusion' I did, there is the bible, of course:

John 14:16-17-"And I will ask the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may be with you forever; [that is] the Spirit of the truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it does not behold Him or know Him, [but] you know Him because He abides with you, and will be in you."

And the translations that support this interpretation: NIV, NLT, ESV, NASB, KJB, ISV, ASV, ERV, Aramaic Bible in Plain English, God's Word Translation, Darby Bible Translation, Douary-Rheims Translation, Websters Bible Translation.......so, pretty much all of them. One wonder how that many biblical/linguistic scholars could be wrong, how that many learned and Christian...in other words, in dwelt by the very Spirit we are talking about...could get it wrong. So basically, I'm trusting the very Spirit who inspired the scriptures to be written in the first place, to guide those who are translating the words and intent about Him. The bible says 'him'....so I call Him a Him.
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
I've never tried to claim the the HS is an actual HE! I know Him to be spirit, which means no physical form, which means no sex! If it really comes down to it, I would be happy to refer to The Spirit as an 'it', just for peace! My whole point in this thread was that some people were calling The Spirit a 'She'. If there is no support for labelling The Spirit a "He"....there is even less for calling it a 'She'.
I still believe its not biblically wrong to refer to The Spirit as a 'he'. After all, God the Father is spirit as well, but He still wants us to call Him Father. We know Jesus to be male. To then suggest that the Spirit is female...well, to me, it smacks of unbiblical reasons...and just a little bit blasphemous...suggesting a relationship between the Godhead that most certainly is not true.
If we were supposed to refer to the Spirit as 'she', the bible would have made that clear to us, just as it does with "The Father". We know, linguistically, that we call things 'he', if we are vague on the sex of someone. We ONLY call someone 'she' if we know, beyond a doubt that they are a female.

As far as how I 'reached the conclusion' I did, there is the bible, of course:

John 14:16-17-"And I will ask the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may be with you forever; [that is] the Spirit of the truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it does not behold Him or know Him, [but] you know Him because He abides with you, and will be in you."

And the translations that support this interpretation: NIV, NLT, ESV, NASB, KJB, ISV, ASV, ERV, Aramaic Bible in Plain English, God's Word Translation, Darby Bible Translation, Douary-Rheims Translation, Websters Bible Translation.......so, pretty much all of them. One wonder how that many biblical/linguistic scholars could be wrong, how that many learned and Christian...in other words, in dwelt by the very Spirit we are talking about...could get it wrong. So basically, I'm trusting the very Spirit who inspired the scriptures to be written in the first place, to guide those who are translating the words and intent about Him. The bible says 'him'....so I call Him a Him.


I know Him to be spirit, which means no physical form, which means no sex (gender)!

After all, God the Father is spirit as well, but He still wants us to call Him Father. We know Jesus to be male.


Which is it, no physical form of male? You sound very confused!


Is the bride that Jesus will be married to male or female?




Thanks, JLB
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
I know Him to be spirit, which means no physical form, which means no sex (gender)!

After all, God the Father is spirit as well, but He still wants us to call Him Father. We know Jesus to be male.


Which is it, no physical form of male? You sound very confused!


Is the bride that Jesus will be married to male or female?




Thanks, JLB

Ok...you seem to be missing, so I'll break it down very simply.

Does the Bible reveal God to us as "The Father"?....well yes, it does. - And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of His Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!" Galatians 4:6

Does the Bible also tell us that God is a spirit being?....actually, yes it does. -"God is spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth.” John 4:24

So I fail to see how I am the confused one, just because I've repeated what scripture clearly reveals to us.

As far as the 'bride' of Christ....man, we've been over that before. My answers aren't going to change, so if you can't remember, just go back and have a look.
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
Ok...you seem to be missing, so I'll break it down very simply.

Does the Bible reveal God to us as "The Father"?....well yes, it does. - And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of His Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!" Galatians 4:6

Does the Bible also tell us that God is a spirit being?....actually, yes it does. -"God is spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth.” John 4:24

So I fail to see how I am the confused one, just because I've repeated what scripture clearly reveals to us.

As far as the 'bride' of Christ....man, we've been over that before. My answers aren't going to change, so if you can't remember, just go back and have a look.


What scripture clearly says! You have completely ignored every scripture that I have given you!

You dare to use that line!

You have NOT answered any of my scriptures because you don't like what the bible says!

You hypocrite!

Stay out of this discussion if you are not going to clearly answer my scriptures!!!


Answer this scripture -

Genesis 1:26-28

26 Then God said, "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over the cattle, over all the earth and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth." 27 So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them. 28 Then God blessed them, and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth."


Was female created in the image of God? Yes or no!

Is God singular or plural?
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
What scripture clearly says! You have completely ignored every scripture that I have given you!

You dare to use that line!

You have NOT answered any of my scriptures because you don't like what the bible says!

You hypocrite!

Calm down, or leave.

I have, in fact, addressed your questions, just not to your desired answers. Some things I have refused to go back over, as I already had touched on them earlier in this thread. So if you want my answers, go back and read, but stop flinging absurd accusations that have no basis but your own need to be right. This is a forum for godly discussion about biblical issues. I have, repeatedly on this thread given sound, biblical reasons for why I call the HS a 'him'. If those answers do not please you, say so and then leave. There is no call, at all, to have a tantrum.

Stay out of this discussion if you are not going to clearly answer my scriptures!!

Dude...this is my thread. I started it...it's my discussion! And as you didn't write the bible, it isn't your scriptures that I need answer. I answer to and form my opinion from all of scripture.
And as you have not answered any of my posted verses either, but only attacked, I can only wonder at the label hypocrite you try and pin on me. Plank...speck.

Answer this scripture -

Genesis 1:26-28

26 Then God said, "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over the cattle, over all the earth and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth." 27 So God created man in His own image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them. 28 Then God blessed them, and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on the earth."

Sigh. This is one of the topics that I've already been over in this thread. I'm sorry if that conversation wasn't with you, but as it's there for all to read, I'm not going to repost it again and again.

Was female created in the image of God? Yes or no!

We are told mankind is made in the imagine of God. But then making a huge leap into assuming that The Spirit must be female is ridiculous. God is one. God is perfect in and off Himself. Even though the Trinity exist in perfect harmony together, they are all equally God, and therefore all equally perfect and whole within themselves. So assuming it must take a 'ying/yang' thing for God to be complete, that God must be male and female, just like He created us, lesser beings who needed each other as helpers...well, that speaks to God in ways He has never deemed us fit to know. You are assuming...that is all. For all you know, the "image and likeness" of God could refer only to us having a soul and a conscience...etc...something that separated us from the animals. That is an assumption as well...just like yours. I don't like dealing in assumptions when it comes to God...only what He tells us through His word.

Is God singular or plural?

The Godhead is made up of three persons.

Now, as I've answered your questions...again, and very deliberately so you can't accuse me, I will now ask you to answer mine.
You seemed to have difficulty with the idea that God is Father, and also Spirit. I provided verses to support my statement.

Does the Bible reveal God to us as "The Father"?....well yes, it does. - And because you are sons, God has sent the Spirit of His Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba, Father!" Galatians 4:6

Does the Bible also tell us that God is a spirit being?....actually, yes it does. -"God is spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth.” John 4:24

My point was that God specifically calls us to name Him Father. But we also know Him to be spirit...without gender, just like The Spirit. The bible clearly leads us to call God Father, we know that Jesus was male, and again, centuries of scholars have translated passages calling The Spirit 'him'. And nothing in the bible gives us leave to assume we should call The Spirit 'she'...so logically, we are back at 'him', or 'it'. Linguistically we land there as well, although calling The Spirit 'it' seems to be rendering it an object, rather than an actual person.
 

JLB

Member
Mar 25, 2012
334
9
18
My question -

Was female created in the image of God?

Your opinion -

We are told mankind is made in the imagine of God. But then making a huge leap into assuming that The Spirit must be female is ridiculous. God is one. God is perfect in and off Himself. Even though the Trinity exist in perfect harmony together, they are all equally God, and therefore all equally perfect and whole within themselves. So assuming it must take a 'ying/yang' thing for God to be complete, that God must be male and female, just like He created us, lesser beings who needed each other as helpers...well, that speaks to God in ways He has never deemed us fit to know. You are assuming...that is all. For all you know, the "image and likeness" of God could refer only to us having a soul and a conscience...etc...something that separated us from the animals. That is an assumption as well...just like yours. I don't like dealing in assumptions when it comes to God...only what He tells us through His word.

What you are saying is your opinion! With no scriptural basis. In my opinion, your are being a hypocrite! As a deacon and part of the staff, you are to be held to a higher standard!


Let's try it again -

Was Eve, female, woman made in the image of God? Yes or no?


Thanks, JLB
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
My question -

Was female created in the image of God?

Your opinion -

We are told mankind is made in the imagine of God. But then making a huge leap into assuming that The Spirit must be female is ridiculous. God is one. God is perfect in and off Himself. Even though the Trinity exist in perfect harmony together, they are all equally God, and therefore all equally perfect and whole within themselves. So assuming it must take a 'ying/yang' thing for God to be complete, that God must be male and female, just like He created us, lesser beings who needed each other as helpers...well, that speaks to God in ways He has never deemed us fit to know. You are assuming...that is all. For all you know, the "image and likeness" of God could refer only to us having a soul and a conscience...etc...something that separated us from the animals. That is an assumption as well...just like yours. I don't like dealing in assumptions when it comes to God...only what He tells us through His word.

What you are saying is your opinion! With no scriptural basis. In my opinion, your are being a hypocrite! As a deacon and part of the staff, you are to be held to a higher standard!

Here's one of the big problems as I see it. You seem unable to believe that a spirit can also have a gender...as shown when I pointed out the biblical perspective of God the Father (your post #33 shows your denial of God being both Father and spirit). And yet you still claim that 'one of the Trinity' must be 'female', since women were made by God. Your logic is not adding up.

And as far as my standing as a deacon...yes, I suppose it does hold me to a higher standard. But it is God who is holding it, and it is God I will answer to, not you. I am doing my best to follow God and His word...that is what I am doing here. Just because I disagree with you, does not mean I'm a hypocrite.
In fact, I would say that I have more scriptural basis for my argument than you do. Your big idea is that God made us in his 'image and likeness'...which you follow with opinion and assumption, not biblical fact. You cannot make an argument from what the bible does not say. Just because the bible doesn't tell us that the Spirit is female, doesn't mean we get to freely assume that he is. The bible also doesn't tell us not to eat a lawnmower either, but I'm guessing most people won't use that as an excuse to prove that its a good idea.

Let's try it again -

Was Eve, female, woman made in the image of God? Yes or no?


Thanks, JLB

You want me to say yes...and indeed, the answer is yes...Eve was most certainly made in the image and likeness of God. But before you pounce on that, we must consider, in regards to exegetical understanding, what it means to bear the 'image and likeness of God'.

One author says this: "To be made in the image and likeness of God means you are designed to represent God, to make him known, to reflect his glory like a mirror, to look like him. God has made every human being in such a way that simply being human could make his presence know."

Another author says this: "Unlike the animals who were made according to their 'own kind', we are made in the 'image of God.' This makes human life distinct from and superior to all other created things. We are altogether unique and bestowed with particular dignity, value and worth. God gives commands to us because he made us as moral image bearers. We can know right and wrong, and we can respond to God with moral obedience as an act of faith and love."

Yet another author suggests that after God created our first parents in his image and likeness, they were able to relate to God in a unique way. He goes on to say that this interaction is evidence that the image and likeness we bear enables humans to act as revelation receivers, interpreters and worshipers.

We know the word 'image' is often translated as 'idol'. Now, we know 'idolatry' to be a sin, but that is not what the bible speaks of here. Here 'idol' means something that makes the invisible God visible. To image the real Trinitarian God of the Bible is to make him visible to the world. We are to 'mirror' His invisible attributes to the world, somewhat like Moses, who radiated the glory of God after being in God's presence.

I could go on, with more and more sources. But the point is this...we are indeed made in God's image and likeness, but that does not mean that one of the Trinity must be female. The bible in no way gives us leave to assume this, in fact, given deep study on the meaning of 'image and likeness', we may in fact come to the opposite conclusion. Consider what this author has to say:

"While God is not engendered, he does reveal himself as Father and comes to us as the God-man Jesus Christ. Nonetheless he makes both men and women in his image. Practically, this means that thought they are in some ways different, the man and woman are equal in dignity, value and worth by virtue of the fact that they are equally God's image bearers."

This summation fits in with what the rest of the bible teaches about the roles of men and women.

So, is Eve made in God's image and likeness? Yes. Does this mean the Holy Spirit is female? Nope. Does it give us leave to make the wild assumption that maybe the Spirit could be a female...nope.
 

HammerStone

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Feb 12, 2006
5,113
279
83
36
South Carolina
prayerforums.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hey, when you call out my deacons I stand in support of what he or she is saying when Biblical. Particularly when the hypocrite term is being thrown out there.

Like Rach said, Eve is made in the image of God. Imago Dei. However, I can be said to be in the image of my mother. In fact, I get told I look like her, particularly in the eyes. Now, I am my mother's child obviously, but does that make me female or her male? Obviously it doesn't. It's rather clear from any look at the general population that sons possess traits that make them look like their mothers and daughters can look a lot like their fathers. I hear often that the little girl has her daddy's eyes, for instance. I would submit that you're the one stretching the image - it would be very reasonable that God Almighty can derive two forms from one - IE: both men and women have noses, 2 eyes, 2 legs, etc. It's a bit of a leap to say "Well, God said they were made in his image...so God musta had a female around." (Note the whole his image part.)

The problem I have with the whole thing is that forcing a female consort to God merely resurrects the old false religions of the world. I'm not accusing you of being a fertility cult worshiper or anything of the sort, but numerous cultures attempted to place God with a consort/wife. It's not a good thing because it creates this mystique of the sacred and feminine.

We must understand that God transcends a number of our limited notions. It's very obvious in many books that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit have what we would call feminine traits attributed to them. Jesus did a number of "feminine" things in the culture he was born into, but that doesn't make him a woman. God gives birth in Job and speaks of himself as a mother in Isaiah, for instance.
 

Rach1370

New Member
Apr 17, 2010
1,801
107
0
44
Australia
Wow, HS...thanks. You very eloquently said in 3 paragraphs what I've been trying to say in 2 pages!
Don't know if I'm being heard though...it might be time to let it drop, I'm thinking!