A Question for Jehovah's Witnesses

[Jack]

Not a clue Jack

I know you don't, and no Scripture either. I have plenty!

Matthew 4
10 Then Jesus said to him, "Away with you, Satan!

 

[face2face]

I know you don't, and no Scripture either. I have plenty!

Matthew 4
10 Then Jesus said to him, "Away with you, Satan!

Yes Jack we know...I hope it comforts you

 

[Jack]

Yes Jack we know...I hope it comforts you

Scripture certainly does comfort me. Sorry you don't have the same comfort.

O look, more Scripture about Satan!

Mark 1
13 And He was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted by Satan,

 

[face2face]

Scripture certainly does comfort me. Sorry you don't have the same comfort.

O look, more Scripture about Satan!

Mark 1
13 And He was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted by Satan,

That's a long time isn't it Jack?

 

[quietthinker]

Quiet,

Did you notice the issue of death in that chapter?

For if, because of one man’s trespass, death reigned through that one man, much more will those who receive the abundance of grace and the free gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man Jesus Christ. Romans 5:17.

We know that Christ, being raised from the dead, will never die again; death no longer has dominion over him. Romans 6:9

For our sake God made Jesus to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.

Paul is bringing your mind to a fundemental point in his argument, one which many Christians shrink back from...

Can you see now how sin was represented in the body of the Lord?

Can you also see the need for God to remove it?

Few open these doors and even fewer walk through.

F2F

What I see is men projecting their heart onto Jesus. Its nature killed him because he did not resist, he absorbed everything they threw at him without retaliation and thereby nullified it....evidenced by his resurrection from death.

Paul here in Romans 5 explains how liberation from death for humanity came about. This liberation given ensures where the glory belongs, namely Jesus.

The alarming thing I find is, in spite of this unprecedented demonstration re the nature of God, men still insist on putting the attention and the focus on themselves ie, what they consider their right theology, their right organisation, how many others have it wrong, etc etc....basically their works.......and it matters little if they are right or wrong. The problem is demonstrated in where their attention and glory is (ie, in themselves) There is also the unwillingness to relinquish this self glorifying power over them.
This tells me in truth where their allegiance is.

 

[Jack]

That's a long time isn't it Jack?

Why don't you quote God? You don't seem to know anything about the Christian Bible.

Luke 22
31 And the Lord said, "Simon, Simon! Indeed, Satan has asked for you, that he may sift you as wheat.

 

[face2face]

What I see is men projecting their heart onto Jesus. Its nature killed him because he did not resist, he absorbed everything they threw at him without retaliation and thereby nullified it....evidenced by his resurrection from death.

Paul here in Romans 5 explains how liberation from death for humanity came about. This liberation given ensures where the glory belongs, namely Jesus.

The alarming thing I find is, in spite of this unprecedented demonstration re the nature of God, men still insist on putting the attention and the focus on themselves ie, what they consider their right theology, their right organisation, how many others have it wrong, etc etc....basically their works.......and it matters little if they are right or wrong. The problem is demonstrated in where their attention and glory is (ie, in themselves) There is also the unwillingness to relinquish this self glorifying power over them.
This tells me in truth where their allegiance is.

This is all true...I like this "Its nature killed him because he did not resist, he absorbed everything they threw at him without retaliation and thereby nullified it....evidenced by his resurrection from death"

If Jesus had death working in him, in his members, then he was weak like you and I...!

For Jesus was crucified in weakness, but lives by the power of God. For we also are weak in him, but in dealing with you we will live with him by the power of God. 2 Corin 13:4

We have a shared weakness, which if understood correctly should remove all that "organisational" stuff and be the ultimate leveller! Sad part is they turn him into a god, and all these lessons are lost! His fight becomes meaningless, and God's victory is over what? Himself?

It's in that shared weakness that our allegiance must be otherwise how can you do Galatians 5:24 “And those who are Christ's have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires.”

Leave it with you.

O...and the way sin was represented in the Jesus was the condemnation of death which he was under...like you he shared this also...God needed to show death whose boss! He did this in putting an obedient man to death that its power would be removed justly according to God's commandments.

If this was ever understood by you you would draw to some seriously difficult conclusions.

F2F

 

[Taken]

Indefinite moving the goal posts. Does 3 equal 1; yes or no?

Broadly Mathematically
No.
Mathematically Fractionally 1/3+1/3+1/3= 1 Yes.
Spiritually
Yes.

I am 1 body, 1 soul, 1 spirit…which is 3 that equals one WHOLE earthling called manKIND.

It is simply OBSERVING 3 Parts of a WHOLE.

The WHOLE of God…
IS: Father, Son, Holy Spirit
IS: Lord God Almighty

You SHOULD know the multiple Names and Titles God IS CALLED per Scripture and SHOULD know Certain PARTS of God DOES Certain things….

Same with men.
When your body aches, do you say, Oh my soul hurts? Or Oh my spirit hurts?

Do you NOT recognize your own parts?
Body, soul, spirit (3 different things) that is the 1 Whole of a man?

 

[quietthinker]

This is all true...I like this "Its nature killed him because he did not resist, he absorbed everything they threw at him without retaliation and thereby nullified it....evidenced by his resurrection from death"

If Jesus had death working in him, in his members, then he was weak like you and I...!

For Jesus was crucified in weakness, but lives by the power of God. For we also are weak in him, but in dealing with you we will live with him by the power of God. 2 Corin 13:4

We have a shared weakness, which if understood correctly should remove all that "organisational" stuff and be the ultimate leveller! Sad part is they turn him into a god, and all these lessons are lost! His fight becomes meaningless, and God's victory is over what? Himself?

It's in that shared weakness that our allegiance must be otherwise how can you do Galatians 5:24 “And those who are Christ's have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires.”

Leave it with you.

O...and the way sin was represented in the Jesus was the condemnation of death which he was under...like you he shared this also...God needed to show death whose boss! He did this in putting an obedient man to death that its power would be removed justly according to God's commandments.

If this was ever understood by you you would draw to some seriously difficult conclusions.

F2F

God never put anyone to death, let alone Jesus. Men murdered him. Death is not God's game. He is the giver of life not the purveyor of death. Death is an enemy.

 

[amigo de christo]

How do we know we are HIS . How does one know they truly love HIM .
I take us back to a time long , long ago .
When JESUS walked the earth . There was a huge crowd following HIM .
JESUS then says No man can be my desciple lest he ........................................
If we have this love of the world that puts ANYTHING before JESUS CHRIST , WE ARE NOT HIS .
IF one hates not his mother , father , own life , wife etc .
IN other words , IF we have this love of the world , LIKE THE ONE I SEE GETTING TAUGHT IN THE CHURCHES TODAY
which elvates the OPINIONS OF MAN ABOVE THE WORD OF GOD .
WHICH puts man , puts humanity FIRST and omits the truth of GOD and of CHRIST . I GOT SERIOUS BAD NEWS
THE POPE and this all inclusive lovey do HAS YOU ALL FOOLED . SEE WE OUGHT TO LOVE CHRIST ABOVE ALL .
NO COMPARISON . WE are not to put our gay childs desires BEFORE THE WORD of GOD .
WE are not to honor the sins of others and simply PUT MAN , PUT HUMANITY BEFORE GOD .
WE SHOULD have LOVED GOD , CHRIST ABOVE ALL . THERE IS NO COMPARISON to GOD .
OUR HEARTS should have EXALTED HIM , HIS CHRIST , HIS TRUTH . PUT HIM FIRST .
See lambs know this . We should not have done what the seeker friendly suggested
we should not have done what the all inclusive false love suggested .
FOR ANY LOVE that puts man , puts anything BEFORE GOD , BEFORE CHRIST . IS A FLAT OUT LOVE OF THE WORLD .
Yeah , try reading the bible folks .
YE CANNOT BE MY DESICPLE . THAT IS WHAT JESUS TOLD ALL those who FOLLOWED HIM .
HE TURNED around and told THEM THAT . JESUS FIRST , GOD FIRST . But that aint what i am seeing
In this all inclusive pile o stink dung love . IT PUTS EVIL FIRST , it honors SINS , IT HONORS the OPINIONS OF MEN
WE SHOULD have LOVED GOD ABOVE EVERYTHING , CHRIST ABOVE EVERYTHING .
Lambs do . AND its high time the lambs REMIND ALL about that . MANY gonna hear I NEVER KNEW YOU .
Cause they put HUMANITY BEFORE GOD . THEY LOVED Money or etc MORE THAN GOD
IF A MAN LOVETH GOD HE WOULD HAVE LOVED CHRIST . IF A MAN LOVETH CHRIST , HE WOULD HAVE KEPT HIS TEACHINGS .
TIME is running out . WHOSE WE ARE TRULY MATTERS . IS it another jesus we belong too or is it JESUS THE CHRIST WE BELONG TOO .For the answer to that , I INVITE US TO OPEN THEM BIBLES and find out JUST what jesus ya been following .
Cause if ya jesus honors sins , IT AINT JESUS CHRIST . IF ya jesus says all religons serve the same GOD we do
IT AINT JESUS CHRIST . We bess get in them bibles and super duper fast . CAUSE JESUS
and later the apostels all warned and said this , TAKE HEED THAT NO MAN DECIEVE YOU . and many are DECIEVING THE HECK
out of the churches . But lambs , the lambs HEED not the voice of strangers . Lambs HEED THE VOICE OF THE GREAT SHEPARD
of THE SHEEP CHRIST JESUS .

 

[quietthinker]

How do we know we are HIS . How does one know they truly love HIM .
I take us back to a time long , long ago .
When JESUS walked the earth . There was a huge crowd following HIM .
JESUS then says No man can be my desciple lest he ........................................
If we have this love of the world that puts ANYTHING before JESUS CHRIST , WE ARE NOT HIS .
IF one hates not his mother , father , own life , wife etc .
IN other words , IF we have this love of the world , LIKE THE ONE I SEE GETTING TAUGHT IN THE CHURCHES TODAY
which elvates the OPINIONS OF MAN ABOVE THE WORD OF GOD .
WHICH puts man , puts humanity FIRST and omits the truth of GOD and of CHRIST . I GOT SERIOUS BAD NEWS
THE POPE and this all inclusive lovey do HAS YOU ALL FOOLED . SEE WE OUGHT TO LOVE CHRIST ABOVE ALL .
NO COMPARISON . WE are not to put our gay childs desires BEFORE THE WORD of GOD .
WE are not to honor the sins of others and simply PUT MAN , PUT HUMANITY BEFORE GOD .
WE SHOULD have LOVED GOD , CHRIST ABOVE ALL . THERE IS NO COMPARISON to GOD .
OUR HEARTS should have EXALTED HIM , HIS CHRIST , HIS TRUTH . PUT HIM FIRST .
See lambs know this . We should not have done what the seeker friendly suggested
we should not have done what the all inclusive false love suggested .
FOR ANY LOVE that puts man , puts anything BEFORE GOD , BEFORE CHRIST . IS A FLAT OUT LOVE OF THE WORLD .
Yeah , try reading the bible folks .
YE CANNOT BE MY DESICPLE . THAT IS WHAT JESUS TOLD ALL those who FOLLOWED HIM .
HE TURNED around and told THEM THAT . JESUS FIRST , GOD FIRST . But that aint what i am seeing
In this all inclusive pile o stink dung love . IT PUTS EVIL FIRST , it honors SINS , IT HONORS the OPINIONS OF MEN
WE SHOULD have LOVED GOD ABOVE EVERYTHING , CHRIST ABOVE EVERYTHING .
Lambs do . AND its high time the lambs REMIND ALL about that . MANY gonna hear I NEVER KNEW YOU .
Cause they put HUMANITY BEFORE GOD . THEY LOVED Money or etc MORE THAN GOD
IF A MAN LOVETH GOD HE WOULD HAVE LOVED CHRIST . IF A MAN LOVETH CHRIST , HE WOULD HAVE KEPT HIS TEACHINGS .
TIME is running out . WHOSE WE ARE TRULY MATTERS . IS it another jesus we belong too or is it JESUS THE CHRIST WE BELONG TOO .For the answer to that , I INVITE US TO OPEN THEM BIBLES and find out JUST what jesus ya been following .
Cause if ya jesus honors sins , IT AINT JESUS CHRIST . IF ya jesus says all religons serve the same GOD we do
IT AINT JESUS CHRIST . We bess get in them bibles and super duper fast . CAUSE JESUS
and later the apostels all warned and said this , TAKE HEED THAT NO MAN DECIEVE YOU . and many are DECIEVING THE HECK
out of the churches . But lambs , the lambs HEED not the voice of strangers . Lambs HEED THE VOICE OF THE GREAT SHEPARD
of THE SHEEP CHRIST JESUS .

Ahhhh, buckets of what you deem good advice ie, telling people what to do. This is your real focus. I see it as a decoy; a distraction from good news in spite of your rhetoric. It offers nobody hope but plenty of judgement all the while elevating yourself as one who knows. .....all twisted up in religious language.

 

[face2face]

God never put anyone to death, let alone Jesus. Men murdered him. Death is not God's game. He is the giver of life not the purveyor of death. Death is an enemy.

"not my will, but thine be done"...Jesus was the lamb slain from before the world was...this is a teaching which is hard to process, harder for some to accept.

Yet it was the will of the LORD to crush him (Jesus); he has put him to grief; when his soul makes an offering for guilt, he shall see his offspring; he shall prolong his days; the will of the LORD shall prosper in his hand.

Boy quiet...there is so many beautiful lessons I could show you but somehow, I don’t think the soil in you has been tilled sufficiently to receive them.

Take care!

F2F

 

[quietthinker]

"not my will, but thine be done"...Jesus was the lamb slain from before the world was...this is a teaching which is hard to process, harder for some to accept.

Yet it was the will of the LORD to crush him (Jesus); he has put him to grief; when his soul makes an offering for guilt, he shall see his offspring; he shall prolong his days; the will of the LORD shall prosper in his hand.

Boy quiet...there is so many beautiful lessons I could show you but somehow, I don’t think the soil in you has been tilled sufficiently to receive them.

Take care!

F2F

I guess my untilled soil just wont party with your tilled soil ....isn't that the implication? that I am just blind to your wonderful insights?

 

[Wrangler]

Broadly Mathematically
No.
Mathematically Fractionally 1/3+1/3+1/3= 1 Yes.

Broadly Mathematically? Now, you've moved the goal post to assert parts are the whole, which works for any number, not just 3. Point is, 3 is not 1 and 3-in-1 is not 1.

A philosopher pointed out that 100 pennies are not $1. To prove this, he presented this context. If 100 pennies is $1, then 100,000 pennies is $1K and if you swim across a river with this you'll drown with the weight of the pennies but won't with the weight of a $1K bill or check. Therefore, parts lead to death and the whole leads to live. Opposites are not the same.

 

[Jack]

ONLY God / Jesus are called "Mighty God" and "the first and the last"! NOBODY else. The JW bible says so!

Thank you Kingdom Hall for admitting that Jesus is God!!!

 

[Taken]

Broadly Mathematically? Now, you've moved the goal post to assert parts are the whole, which works for any number, not just 3. Point is, 3 is not 1 and 3-in-1 is not 1.

A philosopher pointed out that 100 pennies are not $1. To prove this, he presented this context. If 100 pennies is $1, then 100,000 pennies is $1K and if you swim across a river with this you'll drown with the weight of the pennies but won't with the weight of a $1K bill or check. Therefore, parts lead to death and the whole leads to live. Opposites are not the same.

You want to argue your Understanding of Spiritual things with a Secular argument per mathematics and sports.

ManKIND was Created and Made NATURAL, BY, THROUGH, OF a WHOLLY Spiritual God.

* Man =
a BODILY Creation from Dust, BY God;
with that body’s own life: Blood
With that body’s own seed: Sperm, Ovum
With that body’s own spirit: Heartful Truth

That BODY is MADE a LIVING MAN;
THROUGH Receiving, GODS BREATH:
Called a SOUL.
That Born ALIVE Body WITH A Natural spirit, WITH a LIVING SOUL;
IS CALLED: A ManKIND Person.

If you can not Understand it is THREE things that MAKEUP the WHOLE of a NATURAL PERSON…

You become suspect, of ALSO Not Understanding WHAT IS the WHOLE of God.

Further lacking the Understanding, the WHOLE of a Natural ManKIND of thing CALLED: A Person…
IS a LIVING BODY….(BLOOD, it’s LIFE)
HAS a SOUL…(Gods BREATH, it’s LIFE)
HAS a SPIRIT….(IT’s OWN Truth, in it’s Heart)

You are suspect of NOT also Understanding,
BY, THROUGH….OF God…
IS an OFFERING FROM God;
THAT IF….
That ManKIND of Person SHALL FREELY CHOOSE TO:
* BE sorry FOR NOT Believing IN God.
* BE a BELIEVER IN the Lord God Almighty.
* CONFESS his HEARTFUL (natural spirits TRUTH) OF his BELIEF IN the Lord Gods Almighty.
* Freely GIVE his BODY unto DEATH FOR his Belief IN the Lord God Almighty.

The Lord God Almighty, Creator AND Maker;
SHALL “MAKE” that persons;
1 - BODY….anew WITHOUT BLOOD.
2 - SOUL….RESTORED to Good and KEPT ALIVE.
3 - SPIRIT…BORN AGAIN WITH Gods SEED.

WITH those THREE THINGS, MADE, By, Through, Of the Lord God Almighty (according to HIS WAY)…
THAT ManKIND of PERSON…IS: by, through, of God……MADE SPIRITUALLY WHOLE.

SPIRITUAL WHOLENESS:
Body…WITHOUT BLOOD
Soul….RESTORED and KEEPS Gods BREATH
Spirit…Born of Gods SEED, With Gods Truth IN his Heart.


NATURAL WHOLENESS:
Body…WITH BLOOD
Soul….Corrupted YET alive WITH Gods Breath
Spirit…With his own Natural Truth in his Heart.

The MAKING of A WHOLE natural PERSON, is by, through, of God….WITHOUT the Persons FREEWILL or CONSENT.

The MAKING of a WHOLE spiritual PERSON, is by, through, of God….EXPRESSLY WITH the Persons FREEWILL AND CONSENT.

Yes…THREE IS the WHOLE of ONE God.
Yes…THREE IS the WHOLE of ONE Person.

Mans Mathematical conclusions and Sports goal posts are Irrelevant in Understanding Spiritual things.

If you can NOT Understand the Application of THREE regarding ONE WHOLE person….
How Can You Expect to Understand the Application of THREE regarding the WHOLE of God?

 

[Ritajanice]

Scripture certainly does comfort me. Sorry you don't have the same comfort.

O look, more Scripture about Satan!

Mark 1
13 And He was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted by Satan,

That’s the Living word of God comforting you Jack, as he speaks to your heart!...Praise God!

 

[Wrangler]

You want to argue your Understanding of Spiritual things with a Secular argument per mathematics and sports.

And what do you want to argue based on?

If you can NOT Understand the Application of THREE regarding ONE WHOLE person….
How Can You Expect to Understand the Application of THREE regarding the WHOLE of God?

The issue is not my lack of understanding; nonsense is not supposed to be understood. The issue is how to you limit parts to the magic number of 3 while also calling these parts a whole? That is inherently contradictory in any language, in any context (math, sports, etc).

Consider Christianities end game @ 1 Corinthians 15:27
For the Scriptures say, “God has put all things under his authority.”[a] (Of course, when it says “all things are under his authority,” that does not include God himself, who gave Christ his authority.)

Notice how this passage speaks of 2 and not 3. Odd huh?

 

[Taken]

And what do you want to argue based on?


The issue is not my lack of understanding;

Sure it is.

nonsense is not supposed to be understood. The issue is how to you limit parts to the magic number of 3 while also calling these parts a whole?

“I” LIMITED nothing. “I” understand WHAT God Established.

God Himself Established the NATURAL whole of 1 Man THREE THINGS…
1 BODY…1 SOUL…1 SPIRIT

God OFFERS the Natural whole of 1 MAN’S THREE THINGS … TO BECOME “RE-MADE SPIRITUALLY”; OF, BY, THROUGH the POWER OF God…
* 1 man’s BODY … given IN Death to God ….
RAISED UP without Blood Life, without Sin.
* 1 man’s SOUL …
RESTORED to GOOD, without Sin.
* 1 man’s SPIRIT … BORN Again of Gods Seed, without corruption, without Sin.
One man’s BODY, SOUL, SPIRIT…MADE “ANew” By, Through, Of the POWER of God…
IS THOSE THREE THINGS, of that ONE man being MADE “SPIRITUALLY” WHOLE…
ONCE and FOREVER!

1 Thes 5:
[23] And the very God of peace sanctify you wholly; and I pray God your whole spirit and soul and body be preserved blameless unto the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.

God Sanctifies…MAKES Blameless, (Sinless), MAKES Anew (Sinless)…the WHOLE of man..
WHOLE body
WHOLE soul
WHOLE spirit

That is inherently contradictory in any language, in any context (math, sports, etc).

No contradiction in Spiritual Understanding.

Consider Christianities end game @ 1 Corinthians 15:27
For the Scriptures say, “God has put all things under his authority.”[a] (Of course, when it says “all things are under his authority,” that does not include God himself, who gave Christ his authority.)

Notice how this passage speaks of 2 and not 3. Odd huh?

Ever NOTICE how GOD Himself …
Gave “HIS WORD” that IS His, and comes forth out FROM His Mouth….
A NAME…?? Jesus
TITLES…..?? Lord, Son of God
DESCRIPTIONS…?? Truth, Life, Way, Teacher

Ever NOTICE how GOD Himself …
Gave “HIS POWER” that IS His, and comes forth out FROM HIM at His Pleasure…
A TITLE…..?? Almighty, Messiah, Christ
A NAME….?? Jesus
DESCRIPTIONS….?? ALL-Knowing, ALL-Powerful, Maker, Savior, KING

God IS His own Word, His own Power and inasmuch as GOD sends His own Word, His own Power Forth OUT FROM HIM He KEEPS His WORD, His POWER IN HIMSELF…

God FREELY gives His WORD to mankind.
God FREELY gives His LIMITED Power to mankind.
God withholds and gives to NO ONE the WHOLE of His POWER, which IS “HIS” Glory.

Jesus IS the NAME of Gods WORD, Gods TRUTH, Gods LIFE, Gods Way.
Christ IS the TITLE of Gods POWER, and the TITLE of Jesus.

God didn’t HAVE a baby…He SENT His Word forth out of His Mouth…..He SENT His Word to Earth, without His POWER’ TITLE being revealed TO mankind…..
THEN REVEALED JESUS IS THE CHRIST, The POWER OF GOD.

Don’t you KNOW God is omnipresent, omniscient, omnipotent ?

While God was IN Heaven IN His Kingdom, He was ALSO ON EARTH Serving His OWN WILL…in a FASHION men on Earth could SEE.

 

[Wrangler]

Ever NOTICE how GOD Himself …
Gave “HIS WORD” that IS His, and comes forth out FROM His Mouth….

Language Usage. You do know that "Him/His" are singular pronouns, right? They do not refer to 3 is one.