Demographic collapse. Capitalism Dies of Childlessness

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
Again, stop thinking as a man.

"It is given once for men to die." -- But did you miss the teachings of being born again--out of this world? Did you think we were here to lay up treasures for future generations--here in this world--that they may die too after living a good and fair life? That is not what God is doing at all. How is it that you do not know this?

On the contrary, God is dividing the light from the darkness--daily, and the sheep from the goats. No picnic. Then comes the end.

Meanwhile, we are here to subdue and multiply--but not to populate the world with a good balance of worldly resources. That is not the abundance promised by God--but by Satan. To the contrary, we are to lay up treasure in heaven, while walking through this shadow of death--sentenced to walk out what and who we are at our core--and were since before the foundation of the world.

As for society and government--we are not to live fair, but free, free to do what we are appointed to by God. Let that be your test and rationale of what is good--anything less is against God.
I’d totally get your tone if we were both tonsured monks who’d taken vows of poverty and were living in a cave on Mount Athos right now. In that case, yeah, go ahead and drop the “Did you forget we’re supposed to be born again and lay up treasure in heaven?” line. I’d even nod along.

But here’s the thing: I’m not a monk. I live in the world. I have a wife, kids, bills, taxes, and a mortgage. That means I can’t just shrug and say “let the world burn, I’m just passing through.” What happens in politics, economics, housing policy, schools, and culture directly affects me, my children, and everyone I love. So no, I’m not going to pretend it doesn’t matter.

A few quick points:

1. “Laying up treasures for future generations” — right now we’re just trying not to leave our kids drowning in debt. If we manage to hand them a paid-off house and no student loans, that already feels like winning the lottery. We’re not talking yachts and Forbes lists here.

2. You wrote: “Did you think we were here to… let them live a good and fair life and then die?”
Honestly? Yeah, I’d be pretty happy if my kids got to live a decent, relatively peaceful life, raise their own families, and die old and surrounded by grandchildren. Is that somehow evil in your book? Should I be praying they live miserable, unjust lives instead? What exactly do you think parents ought to want for their children?

3. You’re drawing this super-sharp line: either “store up treasure in heaven” or “care about this world,” like those two things cancel each other out. That feels like a false dichotomy. Wanting your kids to be able to afford a home and have three children without going bankrupt isn’t the same as chasing Mammon. It’s literally the bare minimum for a normal family life.

So tell me straight: are you actually saying Christians should just give up on marriage, kids, and society altogether and go full monastic? Because that’s what it sounds like. If not, then what exactly are you proposing we do—just sit back, watch birth rates collapse, housing become unaffordable, and culture rot, all while repeating “this world is not my home”?
 

Mink57

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2020
1,446
632
113
68
Las Vegas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
speaking of natural diseases
IF folks would have heeded GOD and not been a fornicating around .....................well then .
And speaking of disease , the number one killer
that quickly spread from man to man and man with woman
WELL how did that spread so fast . drugs , and etc .
SEEMS TO ME , rather than folks hating on the bible
and the good ol fashoined patraicharcal system ,
THEY NEEDS TO DO AN FORGIVE ME LORD FOR I HAVE SINNED moment
COME to JESUS
and get IN THE BIBLE to learn for themselves . Thank you for your reminder as well .
The biggest most leading cause of ALL 'disease' isn't physical, but SPIRITUAL. And as it turns out, the "good of fashioned" patriarchal system isn't so "good" at all. Maybe good for men, but not for women.

A new world order is needed. And it has nothing to do with patriarchy or feminism.

But in my own head, it begins with "Doing Unto Others." THIS IS THE LAW AND THE PROPHETS.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: amigo de christo

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
37,025
60,721
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The biggest most leading cause of ALL 'disease' isn't physical, but SPIRITUAL. And as it turns out, the "good of fashioned" patriarchal system isn't so "good" at all. Maybe good for men, but not for women.

A new world order is needed. And it has nothing to do with patriarchy or feminism.

But in my own head, it begins with "Doing Unto Others." THIS IS THE LAW AND THE PROPHETS.
Well you are correct when ya said the most leading cause of all disease SURE IS SPIRITUAL .
As far as the rest , omit it and start afresh in the bible to actually learn for you my dear friend .
AND believe me , THIS SO CALLED NEW WORLD ORDER
OH ITS GONNA be the end of this world . I wouldnt run to man if i were you .
I would not trust in man if i were you .
Satan is highly clever and he knows how to twist t ruth .
I highly suggest a mass return to the bible and let us be refreshed and reminded of the Words of T RUTH .
Cause JESUS , THE JESUS , THE ACTUAL CHRIST OF GOD
yeah , HE DONT PANDER TO SIN , nor is he a minstir of ANY and i mean ANY SIN .
We better watch out and stop focusing on what WE THINK we entitled too
and rather LEARN OF GOD and BE THANKFUL TO HIM FOR HIS Great work and salvation
GIVEN US IN CHRIST JESUS . but remember another jesus cannot save.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

Mink57

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2020
1,446
632
113
68
Las Vegas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Well you are correct when ya said the most leading cause of all disease SURE IS SPIRITUAL .
As far as the rest , omit it and start afresh in the bible to actually learn for you my dear friend .
AND believe me , THIS SO CALLED NEW WORLD ORDER
OH ITS GONNA be the end of this world . I wouldnt run to man if i were you .
I would not trust in man if i were you .
I don't.
Satan is highly clever and he knows how to twist t ruth .
I highly suggest a mass return to the bible and let us be refreshed and reminded of the Words of T RUTH .
Cause JESUS , THE JESUS , THE ACTUAL CHRIST OF GOD
yeah , HE DONT PANDER TO SIN , nor is he a minstir of ANY and i mean ANY SIN .
We better watch out and stop focusing on what WE THINK we entitled too
and rather LEARN OF GOD and BE THANKFUL TO HIM FOR HIS Great work and salvation
GIVEN US IN CHRIST JESUS . but remember another jesus cannot save.
I don't think this is good enough advice. After all, the Bible can be twisted...

Let me rephrase that. The bible HAS been twisted. And misinterpreted....and butchered....
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
37,025
60,721
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don't.

I don't think this is good enough advice. After all, the Bible can be twisted...

Let me rephrase that. The bible HAS been twisted. And misinterpreted....and butchered....
of men . oh yes many men and women sure do twist the bible .
ITS WHY i say READ IT FOR YOURSELVES daily .
Always remember , however , what one loves can easily been seen
in where they spend their time . Many no likey the bible .
though not all those who no likey it will all say they no likey it .
But whether its the one who tries to plant doubt about the bible
To even the one who stands and says THIS IS THE BIBLE , I BELEIVE i can do what it says
EVEN THOUGH ITS DARN CLEAR they dont actually read it , let alone teach it .
SO my advice stands firm and in love , GET IN THE B IBLE FOR YOURSELF .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
I think that's a good question. And it's a question that we SHOULD ask ourselves AND be honest with ourselves.

And I've asked a similar question on other forums: Why do you want a woman? The answers ranged anywhere from "To get steady unpaid for sex" or "To have someone to cook and clean the house" to "To share the joys and trials of life with a partner" or "To raise a family with a partner because I believe that having two parents is the best model to raising healthy well-adjusted children."

As for the value and purpose of marriage, like I point out in the paragraph above, SOME people (men) might even admit those reasons to themselves (at least), and see 'value and purpose' in them. But are those valid reasons for wanting a wife?
You listed three main reasons guys say they want a wife.

1. Regular sex
Marriage is literally the most expensive, risky, and paperwork-heavy way on planet Earth to get sex. Scientists still haven’t found conclusive proof that sex continues to exist after the wedding night (half-joking, but only half).

2. Cooking & cleaning
Bro, it’s 2025. Robot vacuums, dishwashers, washing machines, and delivery apps have solved 95 % of that. Five minutes from my house there’s a supermarket hot-food counter where I can buy a full dinner for roughly the same price (and zero time) it would take to cook it myself. Housework is no longer a valid selling point.

3. Raising kids together
You’re jumping ahead — we haven’t even established why a man needs a wife yet. Yes, kids usually come with a wife, but that’s a separate question. Even if we grant that a wife is needed for kids, having kids is insanely expensive, stressful, dangerous, and a lifelong anchor. That’s not only a motivation — it’s also a massive demotivator.
Plus, the desire for children is at least as strong (probably stronger) in women as in men, so it’s not a uniquely male incentive. Before you can sell marriage with “think of the children,” you first have to sell men on wanting children at all.
And so far I haven’t heard a single compelling reason from you why a man today should actually want kids in the first place.

So yeah, still waiting for an actual positive motivation that survives contact with 2025 reality.
“it depends on the lifestyle” — seriously?
What lifestyle are we even talking about here?

- Even a tiny 1-bedroom apartment for a childless couple is insane money now. Add one kid → need 2 bedrooms. Two kids of different sexes → need 3 bedrooms. A 3-bedroom apartment today is oligarch territory. A real house? Might as well be Mars.

Boomers and most Millennials caught the last train where a normal salary + mortgage could still buy something. Zoomers aren’t even in the same universe.

Healthcare?
When I was a kid, a dentist came to school with his chair — free check-ups, free treatment. I could walk to any doctor alone, get tests, procedures — zero cost. Parents only bought the meds. (During the Soviet era)
Now? You can’t send a school-age kid to the dentist without a fat stack of cash. Every cough, every fever instantly triggers “how big will this hospital bill be?” panic. Nothing is free anymore.

Children's summer camp? My parents got a free voucher from the union. Today you basically have to win the lottery or sell a kidney.

So please tell me — what “simple life” are you talking about?
Because right now even the rock-bottom, no-frills version of raising kids is completely out of reach for the average guy.

That may be in the Ukraine. Not quite the same here in the USA, despite what you may have heard from angry men who claim that they were 'raked over the coals' by their ex's (financially). Statistically, it is women with children who come out worse off financially than their ex-husband's.
You’re talking about the USA, I’m talking about Ukraine. The reality here is completely different:

Divorce rate is higher than in the US.
Joint custody basically doesn’t exist; in 95 % of cases the mother gets the kids and the father becomes legally powerless.
She alone decides whether you see your children or not. Court visitation orders are just paper; she can ignore them and nothing happens to her.
In practice, whoever gets the kids also gets the apartment/house. That means she gets everything.
So after divorce a man usually ends up with no home, no kids, and a big chunk of his salary taken for child support.
And 86 % of divorces here are initiated by women.

Tell me honestly: is this risk worth it? Where exactly is the motivation for a man to sign up for that?

By the way, this is also the answer to the question “why do I even need a wife?”
If you look at marriage as a way to have kids, in Ukraine it actually turns out (in ~70–80 % of cases) that a wife is just the person who gets child support paid to her while making sure you never see those kids again.
Maybe start by actually listening to why more and more women don't want to marry and have children.
Seriously?
How is hearing a woman explain why she doesn’t want marriage or kids supposed to convince a man to marry her?
If anything, it just gives him one more reason to stay single.
Any man today can already list fifty reasons why he himself doesn’t want this.
Sending him to listen to her fifty reasons isn’t motivation; it’s just doubling the list of red flags.
So again: what exactly is the positive incentive for a man here?
Still waiting for an actual answer.
Men and women BOTH face serious financial risks if they get divorced.
But women face more emotional and physical risks of getting married in the first place.
No. Just no.
A man faces catastrophic financial AND total loss-of-children risk the moment he signs the marriage papers.
The woman faces almost zero risk: she keeps the kids, keeps the home, keeps the cash flow (alimony), and can block the father from the children with zero consequences = zero.

Emotional and physical risks for her?
But for a man the risk is: lose everything you’ve worked for your entire life + become a stranger to your own kids forever. That’s not “serious financial risk,” that’s financial and existential annihilation, and it happens in the majority of divorces here.

Still waiting for the part where this becomes motivating.
 

Mink57

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2020
1,446
632
113
68
Las Vegas
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
of men . oh yes many men and women sure do twist the bible .
ITS WHY i say READ IT FOR YOURSELVES daily .
No. Has to be more than that. Can't read it for ourselves because THAT'S where we've gotten into trouble.
So many interpretations.

See? THESE verses say THIS!
But SEE? These OTHER verses say THIS!
Always remember , however , what one loves can easily been seen
in where they spend their time . Many no likey the bible .
though not all those who no likey it will all say they no likey it .
But whether its the one who tries to plant doubt about the bible
To even the one who stands and says THIS IS THE BIBLE , I BELEIVE i can do what it says
EVEN THOUGH ITS DARN CLEAR they dont actually read it , let alone teach it .
SO my advice stands firm and in love , GET IN THE B IBLE FOR YOURSELF .
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
37,025
60,721
113
54
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
No. Has to be more than that. Can't read it for ourselves because THAT'S where we've gotten into trouble.
So many interpretations.

See? THESE verses say THIS!
But SEE? These OTHER verses say THIS!
Nope . the reason they got into trouble is they were the problem , their heart was .
Many can read the bible but do so through their own lustful hearts desires .
Rather than enjoying the TRUTH and allowing the SPIRIT to mold and shape them
THEY rather mold and shape the scrips INTO their own T RUTH .
But this the sheep DO NOT DO .
SO for me to tell you all to READ that bible for yourselves IS dire necessary .
DONT let the bad seeds be your examples .
In fact i bet the real reason you dont really do so
IS the bible has things IN IT that you DO not LIKE . lets be honest , I AM RIGHT about that my friend .
But it does not have to be that way for you . YOU can start fresh anew again in those pages
and just pray to GOD to lead and guide you .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
The Red-pill, MGTOW and Tate followers aren't "opting out" of relationships. A good chunk of those "manosphere" groups may despise women (and their perceived notions about women) and yet...still seek out women to have sex with....

...while the 4b movement says, "NO SEX WITH MEN." (which doesn't imply that women should have sex with women instead of men). To the women who have opted out of intimate relationships with men altogether, those men cannot claim that those women are seeking men as "disposable providers, workhorses, cannon fodders and walking ATM's". Most women these days have no need for a man's money. They earn their own. So the whole idea of a woman looking for an ATM with a penis is pretty much out the window. And since MOST women DO work outside the home AND bring in a decent income, can't say that men are disposable "providers"...especially if SHE'S doing much and/or MOST of the 'providing'.
Bro, let me translate that feminist word-salad into plain English for you:
The 4B chicks aren’t “opting out” of relationships…
They’re opting out of giving you pussy while still expecting you to pay for everything, protect them, and die for them if war comes.
That’s not independence; that’s the ultimate parasite play: all the benefits of men, zero of the responsibilities.
MGTOW and Red-pill guys?
Yeah, a lot still smash, but they do it on their terms: pump-and-dump, passport bros, sugar-daddy game, whatever.
They’re not begging, simping, or signing their life away on a marriage contract that’ll get weaponized the moment she gets bored.
They took the power back.
4B women proudly announce “no sex, no kids, no marriage” like it’s some revolutionary strike.
Cool. Enjoy your cats and your wine and dying alone.
The wall is undefeated, and in ten years those same women will be crying on TikTok about “where have all the good men gone?”
Men built everything.
If we all collectively say “fine, keep it,” civilization ends in one generation.

So yeah, keep coping.
I agree! But I DON'T agree that both sides are dropping out in equal measures.

...and, it seems that a LOT more men are ticked off because women are quietly dropping out...including the sex game.
Women “quietly dropping out” of the sex game?
That’s not power, that’s suicide by boredom.
They think withholding pussy is some nuclear weapon?
LMAO. Pussy is the most over-supplied resource on planet Earth in 2025.
OnlyFans, Instagram, Dubai porta-potties, Eastern Europe, Latin America, Southeast Asia… supply is literally infinite for any man with a passport and a couple grand.

Real players? We’re laughing. We upgraded the menu and never looked back.
Women can 4B all they want.
In five years they’ll be 35+, dried up, hitting the wall at 300 km/h, begging for attention from the same men they ignored at 25.
Men dropping out isn’t “equal measures.”
It’s a total checkmate.
Men still get sex whenever we want, zero commitment, zero risk, zero drama.
They get cats, wine, and therapy.
Who really lost the game, bro?
Exactly.
 

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
I would tell them not to fear . But they must raise those children up in the way they should Go .
And be prepared to home school .
Cause from pre to kinder to elementary to jr high and high sch ool
A NASTY delusion is already taken them captive to a real long list of genders and same sex marriage
as well as other things .
DONT feed the children to the den of lions .
Do not give them to the ecumenical harlot , SO be on gaurd cause that HO
done infected many a church too .
Be prepared , i would say , TO NOT be loved and to be persecuted . Forgive those who do persecute
but never conform .
You’re out here in every thread screaming about the Great Whore, ecumenism, lions’ dens, and how the entire world is one giant satanic indoctrination machine…
and then in the same breath you tell people “just don’t fear, have kids, and raise them right.”
Bro, do you even hear yourself?
If literally everything (pre-school, kindergarten, public school, peers, Disney, TikTok, YouTube, pop stars, and now even most churches) is already captured and brainwashing kids into 72 genders and sodomy from age 4… then parents today aren’t raising their children anymore.
The system is raising them.
The algorithm is raising them.
The rainbow-flag teacher with purple hair is raising them.
And guys like you on forums are raising them with nonstop apocalyptic fear porn.
So why exactly would any sane man look at that battlefield, where he’s outgunned 100-to-1 from the moment the kid is born, and say “yeah, sign me up for this war I’m guaranteed to lose”?
You’re not motivating anyone to have kids.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: amigo de christo

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,580
6,968
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I’d totally get your tone if we were both tonsured monks who’d taken vows of poverty and were living in a cave on Mount Athos right now. In that case, yeah, go ahead and drop the “Did you forget we’re supposed to be born again and lay up treasure in heaven?” line. I’d even nod along.

But here’s the thing: I’m not a monk. I live in the world. I have a wife, kids, bills, taxes, and a mortgage. That means I can’t just shrug and say “let the world burn, I’m just passing through.” What happens in politics, economics, housing policy, schools, and culture directly affects me, my children, and everyone I love. So no, I’m not going to pretend it doesn’t matter.

A few quick points:

1. “Laying up treasures for future generations” — right now we’re just trying not to leave our kids drowning in debt. If we manage to hand them a paid-off house and no student loans, that already feels like winning the lottery. We’re not talking yachts and Forbes lists here.

2. You wrote: “Did you think we were here to… let them live a good and fair life and then die?”
Honestly? Yeah, I’d be pretty happy if my kids got to live a decent, relatively peaceful life, raise their own families, and die old and surrounded by grandchildren. Is that somehow evil in your book? Should I be praying they live miserable, unjust lives instead? What exactly do you think parents ought to want for their children?

3. You’re drawing this super-sharp line: either “store up treasure in heaven” or “care about this world,” like those two things cancel each other out. That feels like a false dichotomy. Wanting your kids to be able to afford a home and have three children without going bankrupt isn’t the same as chasing Mammon. It’s literally the bare minimum for a normal family life.

So tell me straight: are you actually saying Christians should just give up on marriage, kids, and society altogether and go full monastic? Because that’s what it sounds like. If not, then what exactly are you proposing we do—just sit back, watch birth rates collapse, housing become unaffordable, and culture rot, all while repeating “this world is not my home”?
Your sentiments are well placed for this life--yes, see to those things--but biblically that is not the object. On the contrary, Jesus gave counsel not to worry about such things. Don't be overly concerned or troubled. Read again the book of Ecclesiastes.

But yes--go to work--do your best for your wife and family. But just as you face the world by day and go home to your family--that is to be our relationship also with God. We are to go out into the world from Him, with Him, and return not having lost focus that He has not set this path before us to see us fail, but to succeed. But the profit is not a better tomorrow in this world--though we should attempt to do so--the intended profit rather...is not of this world.

I know what you are saying and are faced with--I struggle too, we all do in our own way. But we are to take a lesson from Job--in spite of what may appear--we are not defeated.
 

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
Your sentiments are well placed for this life--yes, see to those things--but biblically that is not the object. On the contrary, Jesus gave counsel not to worry about such things. Don't be overly concerned or troubled. Read again the book of Ecclesiastes.

But yes--go to work--do your best for your wife and family. But just as you face the world by day and go home to your family--that is to be our relationship also with God. We are to go out into the world from Him, with Him, and return not having lost focus that He has not set this path before us to see us fail, but to succeed. But the profit is not a better tomorrow in this world--though we should attempt to do so--the intended profit rather...is not of this world.

I know what you are saying and are faced with--I struggle too, we all do in our own way. But we are to take a lesson from Job--in spite of what may appear--we are not defeated.
My question wasn't about what I should do. I was wondering if you had any substantive input on the matter.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,580
6,968
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
My question wasn't about what I should do. I was wondering if you had any substantive input on the matter.
I do. But you were not ready. Correction--focus was in order...but so far things are not looking good for you. You seem determined to rant rather than listen. You know how the world is, and you know the end that shall be, and you know what is expected. Did you just want to groan and be told you are correct about the world?
 

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
I do. But you were not ready. Correction--focus was in order...but so far things are not looking good for you. You seem determined to rant rather than listen. You know how the world is, and you know the end that shall be, and you know what is expected. Did you just want to groan and be told you are correct about the world?
If I just wanted to whine and hear “yeah, you’re totally right,” I’d call my mom.

But are YOU ready to say something interesting?
Honestly, I was hoping you’d bring something original to the table on the actual issue.
So far… not looking great on your end.
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
15,580
6,968
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If I just wanted to whine and hear “yeah, you’re totally right,” I’d call my mom.

But are YOU ready to say something interesting?
Honestly, I was hoping you’d bring something original to the table on the actual issue.
So far… not looking great on your end.
Ha...you were grinding your axe.

You want to bash capitalism, go for it. You've been ranting. Your doing, not mine. I simply pointed out that the areas of possible solution that you posted, are not where the solution lies, nor are any of those issues the actual issue. That is not the reason God created the world. There is a parable at work here, and as it is with all parables, the object of the parable is not the subject.

But if you want to break it down, we can, just name one part to begin. The bigger picture will only come into focus when we have properly defined each of the components. Pick one.
 
Last edited:

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
Ha...you were grinding your axe.

You want to bash capitalism, go for it. You've been ranting. Your doing, not mine. I simply pointed out that the areas of possible solution that you posted, are not where the solution lies, nor are any of those issues the actual issue. That is not the reason God created the world. There is a parable at work here, and as it is with all parables, the object of the parable is not the subject.

But if you want to break it down, we can, just name one part to begin. The bigger picture will only come into focus when we have properly defined each of the components. Pick one.
1. Right after creating the world, God gave mankind the very first command:
“Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth” (Gen 1:28).
That’s not my opinion; that’s literally the first thing He told us to do.
And you come along saying “God didn’t create the world for that”?
Then what exactly did He create it for?
So the top 1 % can vacuum up every resource while the other 99 % go extinct?
Because that’s what’s actually happening right now.

God already had something to say about that too:

“Woe to those who join house to house,
who add field to field,
until there is no place left
and you live alone in the land.” (Isaiah 5:8)

Every time you open your mouth “on behalf of God and the Bible,” it’s just nonsense.
It has zero connection to Scripture, to Christianity, or to real life.

2. You’re boring.
You only have two gears:
- spout mystical gibberish about “parables” and “stop thinking like a man,”
- or go personal with “you’re just whining,” “you’re not ready,” etc.

That’s your entire arsenal.
I bring facts, numbers, stats, and 2025 reality.
You bring “you’re whining” and mangled Bible verses.
Guess who’s actually doing the whining here.

So either step up with real arguments,
or keep chanting your little mantras.
Just stop hiding behind God.
He’s not the one saying this stuff; you are.
 

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
5,879
3,759
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The fact that the modern financial system is essentially a giant Ponzi scheme is obvious. Nobody is even seriously trying to hide it anymore. It’s just as obvious that this system will collapse in the foreseeable future.

Modern capitalism is a machine that only runs on constant growth. More people = more workers, more consumers, more tax revenue. GDP goes up, companies make money, debts get serviced, pensions get paid. But once fertility drops below the replacement level of 2.1, the growth stops. South Korea’s population is projected to fall from 51 million today to about 20 million by 2100; Europe from roughly 750 million to around 400 million. This isn’t a “soft decline” — it’s a collapse: every new generation will be 25–50 % smaller than the previous one.

For those of us alive right now, this means that in 20–30 years there simply won’t be enough working-age people. The economy will shrink, factories will shut down, tax revenues will plummet. And my pension? There won’t be one — there’ll be nobody left to pay it. Japan already has 28 % of its population over 65 and fewer and fewer young people; the system is creaking at the seams.

War (like what’s happening in Ukraine and Russia) only accelerates the drop: millions of young people die, birth rates crash even further. In 10–20 years we’ll see empty cities, shuttered hospitals, and weakened armies. Thanks to medicine, the elderly are living longer, but the young are becoming an endangered species.

By 2050 every third person in Europe will be over 65. Who’s going to feed and care for them? In South Korea in thirty years there will be two retirees for every single working person — that’s mathematically impossible to sustain.
View attachment 73952
Governments will either have to jack up taxes to insane levels (which will kill what’s left of the economy) or simply abandon the elderly. And that’s us — we’re the ones who will become those pensionless, uncared-for old people.

The scariest part?
Nobody is preparing. There is no plan, no alternative model. Countries throw money at the problem (South Korea has already spent $270 billion since 2006 on pro-natal policies), but fertility still doesn’t budge — cash can’t fix the lack of time, the stress, or the cultural shift.

We’re sliding toward a cliff, and we’re the generation that will feel it — not some distant descendants. In 20–30 years the current system will be dead, and nothing has been built to replace it.

Developed societies suffer from extreme short-term thinking: politicians care about the next election (4–5 years), corporations care about the next quarter, capitalism rarely looks beyond quarterly reports. Demography operates on a 20–50-year horizon, and nobody wants to deal with timeframes that long.
We’re in a dead end.
There is no alternative model, no contingency plan. In 20–30 years we’ll be asking, “Where’s my pension? Where’s my safety net?” — and there will be no answer.
The situation is worse in South Korea than you have stated.

In 20 years they will be completely dysfunctional as an ethnic group or nation.

People work too much, recreation is non-existent and nobody is having children. Their population demographics looks like an inverted trapezoid.
Japan's isn't much better and China's population numbers also are in steep decline as well. (China's population numbers are completely phoney)

The only countries on an incline or in stasis are India and certain areas of Africa. And these areas are not the areas that we really want to be growing. These are the areas with the highest incidences of incest and superstitions of witchcraft. Very little formal educations and one step above cannibalism.
The war in Russia and Ukraine has affected population as well. Both nations will be greatly affected for decades. North Korea offering up troops is a mistake that they could little afford either. Same with Cuba.

They have destroyed their economies and populations for decades to come if they actually can rectify their birth rates by having children.

The USA and areas of Europe have overcome some of this by immigration. And it fixes the problem of insufficient low skill labor somewhat....and if the H1-B visa situation is actually fixed to not be slimy....maybe we could feel good about it.
 

JohnDB

Well-Known Member
Feb 7, 2010
5,879
3,759
113
TN
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Population in these nations can increase.

It's not like the solutions are a huge mystery or unknown. There has been leadership in history that has tried various things that has worked. A LOT that has not. The outrageous always got noticed and press but the truly effective mostly ignored.

However, the biggest problem is and has been the same thing as the Blair Mountain War was fought over. (You likely have never heard of this early 1900's American Civil War either)

But essentially Big Business and our Governments are hand in glove with DELIBERATELY AND SYSTEMATICALLY economically oppressing the working class citizens while enriching themselves to the point of ridiculousness.
People literally cannot afford to live full lives anymore.

Proof that I'm not just being alarmist or conspiracy theorist?
Henry Ford.
He paid $5/day-8hrs 6 day work week for low skill labor to make cars. He wanted to pay more so he could fill labor shortfalls but the investors sued and stopped him from doing so and Federal Courts agreed with investors.
But here's the rub.
A $30/week job using the standard of Gold price as a measure of true equivalency across the years....
Those jobs paid roughly a tad over $200,000/yr.....for a LOW SKILL job. The vehicles sold for $800-$1200. Executives and engineers made a little more than the low skill labor....but the educations were not very expensive and required no loans.

Currently your average Master's Degree from a State University will leave a student with over $100,000 in debt to have sufficient qualifications to get a $45,000/yr job.

THIS is not even fudged numbers. Today at any of the Big Three Automakers who actually make vehicles in the USA the wages and benefit packages for American workers who actually work for the automakers and not a labor supply firm is around $100k/yr. The labor supply firms? Half that at maximum but usually around a third.

It's fixable....but our government does not want to. They are profiting off of this situation way too much.
 

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
The USA and areas of Europe have overcome some of this by immigration. And it fixes the problem of insufficient low skill labor somewhat....and if the H1-B visa situation is actually fixed to not be slimy....maybe we could feel good about it.
I pretty much agree with you. The only thing I’d push back on is the line “Europe has overcome some of this through immigration.”
I know this one from the inside—I’m an immigrant in Europe myself.

Why do migrants in the EU often prefer welfare over work? Here’s the view from the trenches (Muslim and Ukrainian migrants in Germany and Poland).

1. Cultural shock for Muslims Muslims who come to the EU to work face a massive problem from day one—cultural shock. On factory floors at places like Volkswagen or BMW, the overwhelming majority of line supervisors (the people directly in charge of the workers) are women. In assembly or packing halls, up to 60 % of middle-management foremen can be female. Higher up, at the plant-manager level, you see more men, but the immediate day-to-day boss is usually a woman.


For a Muslim man raised in a traditional culture, submitting to a woman in the workplace is already a huge shock. If that woman is harsh or arrogant, it feels like a direct violation of religious and cultural norms.

2. Inhuman working conditions
Capitalists in the EU (Germany, Poland, doesn’t matter) demand absolute maximum output every single second. Workers are driven to exhaustion with deliberately unrealistic quotas.
Example from a Polish factory: you’re told to process 500 parts per shift; the moment you hit 500, tomorrow the norm becomes 600. Miss it → sanctions.
The (usually female) line supervisor has a direct financial incentive: she gets a bonus of up to 20 % of her salary (500–700 € extra) if the line meets the plan. Result: brutal, rude, dehumanizing treatment of workers. In Poland you’ll hear shouts like “Po co, kurwa, przyjechałeś do Polski? Pracować? No to pracuj szybciej!” (“Why the fuck did you come to Poland? To work? Then work faster!”). In Germany it’s more polite, but the threat is the same: “No quota today → we’ll be saying goodbye.”
In practice, they transfer you to the worst, most toxic, coldest section until you quit on your own. If you still don’t leave, after the three-month probation period (the usual initial contract), they simply don’t renew it. You’re out looking for the next hellhole where the cycle repeats.
Werkvertrag contracts make it even easier to fire you on the spot. Werkvertrag is a civil-law contract that gives almost none of the protections of a regular employment contract (Arbeitsvertrag). The dismissal protection law barely applies, and the subcontractor can terminate you without giving any reason.

Combine the two factors for a Muslim man: He’s being screamed at, humiliated, and threatened by a woman boss—something many consider haram and an unbearable assault on male dignity and honor. And all of this for what? So the female supervisor gets her bonus and the capitalist can buy another yacht with a pool and helipad (the kind the owners of Siemens, ThyssenKrupp, or VW actually own). VW alone posted €22.5 billion profit in 2023.

The math is simple:​

Bürgergeld in Germany (2024) = €563/month, zero humiliation.
A full-time minimum-wage job (12.82 €/h in 2025) = ~€2,051 gross → ~€1,435 net after taxes and contributions. Subtract rent, transport, etc., and you’re left with maybe €500–700 more than welfare, often less.
Why endure daily humiliation for pocket money?

Ukrainians Germans love to complain that Ukrainian refugees “don’t want to work” either. As of July 2024, Germany has over 1.2 million Ukrainian refugees; about 700,000 are of working age. According to the Federal Employment Agency, in early 2024 only ~170,000 out of 840,000 working-age Ukrainians had jobs. By October 2024 the number rose to ~266,000—still just 38 %. That leaves roughly 434,000 (62 %) on benefits.

So immigration is not “solving” Europe’s demographic problem.
It’s just showing people from less cushioned systems that sitting on welfare is often less degrading than selling your soul to European capitalism.

And what if we just cut the benefits?​

Some will say: “Stop paying migrants welfare and they’ll be forced to work.”
Okay, but will they suddenly line up to work in those same inhuman, soul-crushing, dignity-destroying conditions?
Of course not.
Scrapping benefits won’t magically speed up “integration” into capitalism; it will only make migrants’ lives worse.
With no money to live on, they end up homeless → crime spikes or they mass-exodus the country entirely.
Tell me how exploding street crime and half the migrants leaving overnight is supposed to “help integration.”
It doesn’t.
It just turns the problem from “people on welfare” into “people robbing you for food or catching the next bus back to wherever they came from.”
Same collapse, different flavor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnDB

Chrysostomos

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2025
864
309
63
Kiev
Faith
Christian
Country
Ukraine
Population in these nations can increase.

It's not like the solutions are a huge mystery or unknown. There has been leadership in history that has tried various things that has worked. A LOT that has not. The outrageous always got noticed and press but the truly effective mostly ignored.

However, the biggest problem is and has been the same thing as the Blair Mountain War was fought over. (You likely have never heard of this early 1900's American Civil War either)

But essentially Big Business and our Governments are hand in glove with DELIBERATELY AND SYSTEMATICALLY economically oppressing the working class citizens while enriching themselves to the point of ridiculousness.
People literally cannot afford to live full lives anymore.

Proof that I'm not just being alarmist or conspiracy theorist?
Henry Ford.
He paid $5/day-8hrs 6 day work week for low skill labor to make cars. He wanted to pay more so he could fill labor shortfalls but the investors sued and stopped him from doing so and Federal Courts agreed with investors.
But here's the rub.
A $30/week job using the standard of Gold price as a measure of true equivalency across the years....
Those jobs paid roughly a tad over $200,000/yr.....for a LOW SKILL job. The vehicles sold for $800-$1200. Executives and engineers made a little more than the low skill labor....but the educations were not very expensive and required no loans.

Currently your average Master's Degree from a State University will leave a student with over $100,000 in debt to have sufficient qualifications to get a $45,000/yr job.

THIS is not even fudged numbers. Today at any of the Big Three Automakers who actually make vehicles in the USA the wages and benefit packages for American workers who actually work for the automakers and not a labor supply firm is around $100k/yr. The labor supply firms? Half that at maximum but usually around a third.

It's fixable....but our government does not want to. They are profiting off of this situation way too much.
The truth is that under the capitalist system, a worker is effectively a powerless slave.
To the capitalist, a worker isn’t a human being; he’s a resource, a tool for generating profit.
The atmosphere in factories is horrific, demoralizing, and profoundly unjust. The capitalist couldn’t care less about migrants integrating into society; his only goal is to maximize profit. To achieve that, he deliberately creates working conditions where people are forced to endure humiliation, work themselves to the bone, and live in constant fear of being fired.

And here’s the kicker: isn’t it exactly these same conditions that are causing the native population to die out in the first place, creating the “need” for migrant labor?
In Germany in 2024, the total fertility rate was 1.35 children per woman—well below the replacement level of 2.1. Young Germans aren’t having kids in a world where work swallows every ounce of time and energy and the social system offers zero certainty about the future.
Who’s going to bring children into a reality where capitalism turns human beings into disposable, powerless resources?

Migrants in the EU aren’t refusing to work because they’re lazy.
They refuse because of the inhuman conditions: cultural shock, daily humiliation, impossible quotas, zero job protection, and a pathetic gap between take-home pay and welfare.
The capitalist system—by putting profit above people—is the very thing pushing migrants away from integration.
Instead of blaming the migrants, maybe it’s time to ask the real question:
isn’t it long past time to change a system that reduces workers to powerless slaves?