I’d totally get your tone if we were both tonsured monks who’d taken vows of poverty and were living in a cave on Mount Athos right now. In that case, yeah, go ahead and drop the “Did you forget we’re supposed to be born again and lay up treasure in heaven?” line. I’d even nod along.Again, stop thinking as a man.
"It is given once for men to die." -- But did you miss the teachings of being born again--out of this world? Did you think we were here to lay up treasures for future generations--here in this world--that they may die too after living a good and fair life? That is not what God is doing at all. How is it that you do not know this?
On the contrary, God is dividing the light from the darkness--daily, and the sheep from the goats. No picnic. Then comes the end.
Meanwhile, we are here to subdue and multiply--but not to populate the world with a good balance of worldly resources. That is not the abundance promised by God--but by Satan. To the contrary, we are to lay up treasure in heaven, while walking through this shadow of death--sentenced to walk out what and who we are at our core--and were since before the foundation of the world.
As for society and government--we are not to live fair, but free, free to do what we are appointed to by God. Let that be your test and rationale of what is good--anything less is against God.
But here’s the thing: I’m not a monk. I live in the world. I have a wife, kids, bills, taxes, and a mortgage. That means I can’t just shrug and say “let the world burn, I’m just passing through.” What happens in politics, economics, housing policy, schools, and culture directly affects me, my children, and everyone I love. So no, I’m not going to pretend it doesn’t matter.
A few quick points:
1. “Laying up treasures for future generations” — right now we’re just trying not to leave our kids drowning in debt. If we manage to hand them a paid-off house and no student loans, that already feels like winning the lottery. We’re not talking yachts and Forbes lists here.
2. You wrote: “Did you think we were here to… let them live a good and fair life and then die?”
Honestly? Yeah, I’d be pretty happy if my kids got to live a decent, relatively peaceful life, raise their own families, and die old and surrounded by grandchildren. Is that somehow evil in your book? Should I be praying they live miserable, unjust lives instead? What exactly do you think parents ought to want for their children?
3. You’re drawing this super-sharp line: either “store up treasure in heaven” or “care about this world,” like those two things cancel each other out. That feels like a false dichotomy. Wanting your kids to be able to afford a home and have three children without going bankrupt isn’t the same as chasing Mammon. It’s literally the bare minimum for a normal family life.
So tell me straight: are you actually saying Christians should just give up on marriage, kids, and society altogether and go full monastic? Because that’s what it sounds like. If not, then what exactly are you proposing we do—just sit back, watch birth rates collapse, housing become unaffordable, and culture rot, all while repeating “this world is not my home”?