Yea but he got stained by the whole drug fiasco.
Yea. Barry Bonds should be disqualified for the same reason. I'm very ambivalent on this topic and consider it a measure of commitment.
My understanding with Armstrong is that it was less drugs and more super oxygenated blood transfusions. What is a drug, anyway?
I don't know enough about ice hockey to have an opinion. I like watching it but. Low scoring but fast with big hits.
Unlike soccer, hockey can have a shot on goal nearly every 30-seconds.
I'm not sure about the lighter weight divisions but in the Heavy weight I choose Rocky Marciano with his funny style he could fight in a phone box. He beat Joe Louis.
The IRS ruined Louis' life. During WWII, Louis fought exhibitions and patriotically gave the money to veteran charities. The IRS considered that taxable. Fines and penalties piled up and he was crushed, so he came out of retirement desperate for money. Obviously, a shell of his former self. Marciano said Louis was the best ever and for that reason, chose not to come out of retirement himself.
About 14 years ago I did a comprehensive analysis of heavyweight champions. I had a whole spreadsheet on it, even a tab dedicated to the parameters of the analysis including age+ at becoming champion, physical size and most importantly,
championship record. I gave a point for each win and 2 points for a knockout, biasing the analysis toward dominance.
Marvin Hagler was so dominant as a middleweight champion, he knocked everybody out except 2 hall of fame fighters, Duran and Leonard.
John L Sullivan had over 435 fights, blowing away the record of modern champions. However, most of them were bar room fights with questionable talent and sobriety, often 5 - 10 per night when out celebrating his fame. Not championship fights. When you draw the line at championship fights, Gene Tunney was only 2-0; Marciano only 8-0. Based on this analysis 3 champions stand head and shoulders over the rest with twice as many championship wins as the rest of the crowd.
- Joe Louis, 25
- Larry Holmes, 19?
- Ali, 17?*
I also included an analysis of their competition. Here, Marciano really falls away due to no fault of his own. He fought during a historically low level where his competitors lost nearly 1/3 of their fights. Ali fought at the peak. The combined record of his top 3 opponents was something like 99-1. Sonny Liston (1 loss), Joe Frazer (undefeated) and George Foremen (undefeated).
If you want to send me a PM, I'll email you the spreadsheet.
+ A young heart can handle more bpm, functioning at a higher rate of activity.
* One must speculate how many championship fights Ali would have won during the lost years they took away from his
prime. (We never got to see him at his best). He was averaging more fights per year than any champion at 5. Could be 4/year x 4 years, or 16 more championship wins added to his already awe inspiring record.