SinSinSin

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Michiah-Imla

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2020
6,168
3,287
113
Northeast USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
A hate to break the news to you but Paul's INSPIRED words take precedent over anything you can claim or make up in your mind.

What have I claimed or made up in my mind?

ALL the inspired words of God, by ALL the Apostles and Prophets take precedent over ALL.

Ephesians 2:19-20 KJVS
[19] Now therefore ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellowcitizens with the saints, and of the household of God; [20] And are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner ston

Did you catch that?

The ApostleS and ProphetS
 

BarneyFife

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2019
9,122
6,356
113
Central PA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Do your know he meaning of the gospel ?

It’s the equivalent of saying you believe in God but refuse to define who or what God is.

next.......
Why must you be so obnoxious, C? Do you think the "next.........." thing is a fruit of the Spirit? It is plain and simple goading. Can you picture Christ or Paul doing that?
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I think that I have not sinned for some time now; and when I have done so, I confessed it to the Lord so it was cleansed (1 John 1:9).


In the future, when it’s too late .....you are going to discover that your Delusional “ Victory” over sin was never even the issue..... You bet on the “Wrong Pony”, So to speak....
Had you been a man of FAITH, like BB ( Jesus Plus Nothing ) instead of a “ religionists” ( do do this and don’t do that—-MAKE yourself “worthy” by turning in your stellar Performance at the Judgement Seat and MOST IMPORTANTLY making a Point that you had the “ Luck” to Repent Of all of your known sins right before you died )
It all boils down to my “ IMPUTED “ Righteousness versus your “SELF” Righteous.JBF never “ got” the take-away That He should have learned from the life of Jesus .Jesus was a Friend to Sinners—- the only Ones He attacked and loathed were the “SELF” Righteous .Between the two of us, JBF.....which one of us most resembles a “ self- Righteous “ person that Paul said was going to Hell ( His Jewish Brothers who tried to establish their “ OWN” Righteousness, refusing to SUBMIT to God’s Righteousness—- Faith in Christ ALONE for the Forgiveness) or which one Of us two does what God Commanded in Hebrews 3 and 4....REST in Paul’s Gospel Of GRACE Plus NOTHING , lest you be declared by God to be an UNBELIEVER ?
It’s probably a mistake to ask a Blind Man a question like this, so I will pose the question to the readers out there....Hopefully Newbies , not yet Ruined by the Tares and Legalists that spread their Leaven....
One MUST BELIEVE Paul’s Gospel Found In 1Cor15:1-4 in order to be Saved .If you don’t REST in it—- you have proven that you never believed it to begin with.....
I actually Believe and Rest in the Truth that “ Jesus died for my Sins”..... so “ YOU” tell “ ME” , what sins can God “ CONDEMN” me for If that is the Case? None. That is why There “ IS “ NO” CONDEMNATION For those in Christ Jesus...
No matter what I do now.....it’s paid for .....I am forgiven from my sins even before I commit them ...that’s Grace.I “ Could” go out and Sin up a Storm if I “ Wanted” to .When you truly understand and appreciate Grace, you don’t “WANT” to Sin anymore....You Love God too much to derive any lasting pleasure from Sinning .Thats what the Religionists never come to understand.....they choose to remain in their “ Fool’s Paradise”..... thinking that their one-two Punch Of sin and repentance is what makes them Fit For Heaven . In other words....their Performance.God is certainly interested in Performance .The Performance Of His Son .
God has given every man “ a measure of Faith”.Where you put that Faith , be it Allah....be it Buddha or be it YOURSELF ( the essence of all religions and ESPECIALLY those that turn Christianity into just another mere religion) ) or be it Jesus is going to determine where you spend Eternity....many in here pay Lip- Service to Jesus , But they are really just trusting in themselves and their Performances and in their ability to repent of all of their sin in the nick of time.They are SELF Trusters....not “ Jesus Trusters.God won’t have it.....
 

Michiah-Imla

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2020
6,168
3,287
113
Northeast USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Jesus was a Friend to Sinners—- the only Ones He attacked and loathed were the “SELF” Righteous

Jesus told his friends this:

Luke 12:4-5 KJVS
[4] And I say unto you my friends, Be not afraid of them that kill the body, and after that have no more that they can do. [5] But I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: Fear him, which after he hath killed hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, Fear him.

One MUST BELIEVE Paul’s Gospel Found In 1Cor15:1-4 in order to be Saved

One must believe the gospel found in all the New Testament in order to come into the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man (Ephesians 4:13).

YOU” tell “ ME” , what sins can God “ CONDEMN” me for If that is the Case? None

For these:

Hebrews 10:26-27 KJVS
[26] For if we sin wilfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins, [27] But a certain fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour the adversaries.

There “ IS “ NO” CONDEMNATION For those in Christ Jesus...
No matter what I do now....

Oh it does matter:

Romans 8:1 KJVS
[1] There is therefore now no condemnation to them which are in Christ Jesus, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.

..I am forgiven from my sins even before I commit them

Uh, no. No scripture exists that teaches this.

When you truly understand and appreciate Grace, you don’t “WANT” to Sin anymore...

Wrong. The Bible says those who walk after the Spirit will not sin:

Galatians 5:16 KJVS
[16] This I say then, Walk in the Spirit, and ye shall not fulfil the lust of the flesh.

It does not say “appreciate grace and you shall not fulfill the lust of the flesh.”

But I guess you don’t understand the concept of crucifying the flesh that Paul wrote about:

2 Peter 3:15-16 KJVS
[15] ...even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you; [16] As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
[26] For if we sin wilfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins, [27] But a certain fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation, which shall devour the adversaries.


I’m beginning to think that “ willful ignorance” is as terrible as “ willful Sinning”...
What a tragedy to see how the entire Bible can be twisted by an on- going , willful misunderstanding of one simple and easy to understand Bible verse.....
Nine chapters precede Hebrews 10. The entire discussion in these previous chapters is about the Sin Of Unbelief ...nothing else of importance except that.Hebrews 10, when it refers to “ Willful Sinning” continues the discussion of hearing the Gospel , Rejecting the Gospel and returning to the Temple, still putting trust in animal sacrifices instead of putting Total Trust in the Blood Jesus....
I’ve pretty much had it with the Stiff-Necked religionists out there.....Newbies have seen both sides of the debate now......I pray that you take this matter to Jesus and pray to Him that your eyes be-opened as you become “ an approved worker who need not be ashamed...one who correctly divides the Word Of Truth...”
Some that post here lack the God-Given Gift to “ Rightly Divide” or “ Figure Out”The Word Of God... Being “ stiff- necked “ as they are, eventually they will “ stand ashamed” before the world and God—- Count on it .
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
There are those who have latched onto OSAS theology to their own destruction, thinking that they have fire insurance because they walked forward at a church service or Crusade...but there is no desire to follow Jesus and no desire to be set free from a lifestyle of sinning. Such people are truly condemned; and they do not understand that God is holy (1 Peter 1:15-16) and that they have misunderstood Paul's writings (see 2 Peter 3:15-16).

I have never “ walked an aisle” or anything close to that.....Everything you think about me and everything you think about me is Wrong. I “ Do” have the Desire to follow Jesus.I do what He told me to do , which is to “ Follow Paul as he Follows Christ”
I have already been “ set Free” from a “ Lifestyle Of Sinning”, once again by doing what He told me to do. It’s the “ Penultimate” Goal Of Christianity ...To REST in Paul’s Gospel Of Pure Grace....Do That one thing.Everything else of any Eternal Value Will Follow That....
You have no idea about the things that I teach , yet I know “ EVERYTHING” that you promote.....I used to be a confused, weak Believer that put my Trust in “ being good enough” and “ repenting Of all of my sins before I day” in order to be Saved.Yeah, I understand all their is to know about “ Self Faith” instead of the “ Jesus Faith” thatvi Know now.....I have LIVED both ways , and I know the one that is correct and the one that is not. All you can do is espouse “one side”—— you are totally Ignorant Of the other side that just happens to be correct...How can you make any worthwhile contribution when at best you might know one half of what is being talking about
 

ChristisGod

Well-Known Member
Aug 15, 2020
6,912
3,864
113
64
California
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Why must you be so obnoxious, C? Do you think the "next.........." thing is a fruit of the Spirit? It is plain and simple goading. Can you picture Christ or Paul doing that?
Defining words should not be considered obnoxious. Defining the gospel is no different than defining God, Christ, Faith, Justification, Sanctification, Salvation , Sin, heaven, hell etc........

I asked a simple question and the poster keeps running away from defining it yet keeps quoting me so obviously he/ she wants to engage or discuss the gospel yet refuses to define the gospel. So if he continues to quote me on this topic I will continue to ask for a definition.

hope this helps !!!
 

Ferris Bueller

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2020
9,979
4,552
113
Middle South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As Paul said the law was a schoolmaster till faith came. NOw that we are under faith we no longer need a schoolmaster!
That's right. We no longer need, for example, the literal Mosaic Feast of Unleavened Bread to point us toward the reality that gets accomplished in us through the New Way of Christ and faith in him.

Paul also said the laws in stone minister death not life!~ Don't think I want to be under something that kills instead of making me alive.
In this New Covenant the law is written on your heart, so that you can keep what's left for us to literally keep (summarized in 'love your neighbor as yourself'). It doesn't kill you because you are able to keep it now, and, when you fail to keep it through weakness or ignorance, the blood of Christ cleanses you from that sin guilt. The law engraved on tablets of stone only kills unbelievers, not believers. They are the ones who do not have the Holy Spirit writing the law on their hearts, nor do they have the blood of Christ applied to them to forgive transgressions of God's commands.
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
11For the grace of God has appeared that offers salvation to all people. 12It teaches us to say “No” to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age


You assume this has not taken place in “my” life.......you assume wrongly...
You think I’m a big- time Sinner NOW? Lol.....you should have seen me before I had the Holy Spirit in me!
You talk out if ignorance....you don’t know me at all.....either dies your ironically named “ buddy” “
Justbyfaith.........
I’m sure you are familiar with the saying in regard to those that “ assume”.... if not....ask somebody....
Sinning did not faze me my entire life until I asked God to Save me.....when that happened he gave me a New Heart, But He did NOT take away my Freedom.....A Free Man like me , does what he “ wants” all the time—- just like you do—- I have been made a “ New Creation ! I do what I want . The difference is that now that I am Saved , God HAS CHANGED MY “ WANTS” ......for some reason , you religionists and Tares can’t grasp that....
I am a “ FREE” man whose biggest desire is to be a SLAVE to God ! Christianity sure is crazy isn’t it?Its a crying shame you don’t understand it. “ Religionists” never do.Nor do Tares and Spreaders Of Leaven.....just sayin’......lol.....
 

Ferris Bueller

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2020
9,979
4,552
113
Middle South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You assume this has not taken place in “my” life.......you assume wrongly...
You think I’m a big- time Sinner NOW? Lol.....you should have seen me before I had the Holy Spirit in me!
Do you sin PURPOSELY? That is the point that evades you. Do we need to revisit all the scriptures pointing out the difference between unintentional and intentional sin?

You talk out if ignorance....you don’t know me at all...
I don't recall saying I did know you. But I do have a personal opinion formed in my mind about you, just as you do of me, which, by the way, is horribly inaccurate. I know all about the dangers of legalism. More than you. Trust me, I ain't no legalist, lol.

Sinning did not faze me my entire life until I asked God to Save me.....when that happened he gave me a New Heart, But He did NOT take away my Freedom.....A Free Man like me , does what he “ wants” all the time—- just like you do—
I get that. I agree completely that you are free to PURPOSELY sin if you want to. I'm also very aware that you're also going to sin out of ignorance or weakness. Once again, don't miss the point that seems to be evading you. This is about PURPOSELY sinning. Not losing a brave confrontation with the temptation to sin.

I have been made a “ New Creation ! I do what I want . The difference is that now that I am Saved , God HAS CHANGED MY “ WANTS” ......for some reason , you religionists and Tares can’t grasp that....
I'm not a religionist, trust me. Religion is the exact thing that drove me to faith in Christ.

If God has changed your wants, why are you purposely and willfully sinning where there is no battle with sin for you to struggle in? If you belly up to the bar and get drunk just because you want and there's no inner battle of 'should I, or shouldn't I?' then you are willfully sinning and denying Christ. You are rejecting the grace of God in deliberate unbelief. If you die in that state and don't repent you will go to hell, not into the kingdom of God.

I am a “ FREE” man whose biggest desire is to be a SLAVE to God ! Christianity sure is crazy isn’t it?Its a crying shame you don’t understand it. “ Religionists” never do.Nor do Tares and Spreaders Of Leaven.....just sayin’......lol.....
I understand Christianity better than you. All you have to do is read the Bible to see yours is a counterfeit grace while mine is the real thing. But I know I can't make you see the error of your ways. Only God can. You think grace was given so you can languish in your sin ON PURPOSE if you want and be free from the eternal condemnation of that sin. But the Bible says grace was given to us to be free of our sins. And that being free of your sin is the SIGN that you are born again, while purposely remaining in your sinful lifestyle is the SIGN that you are a child of the devil. That's what the Bible says. But you say that's not true.

1 John 3:
he appeared so that he might take away our sins. And in him is no sin. 6No one who lives in him keeps on sinning.

See, Protestant Christians instantly see 'taking away our sins' as the legal pardon we have received in Christ, not what we actually do. But you can see that John is talking about Christ taking away the sins we do. And that the person who lives in him is the one that has their sinful life taken away. That's the sign that you are born again. But you say that is not true and that you can purposely sin and not have your actual sinful life taken away and you are in him nonetheless. That's just not what the Bible says, friend. You're entertaining a false, counterfeit grace taught to you by false, counterfeit teachers. You're in a very dangerous place. Repent of this false gospel while you still can. And stop leading others astray with it. Especially, young people caught in the clutches of our sexualized, substance abusing culture. Your gospel isn't going to set them free from that. It's going to give them false comfort that they can stay in it and still be saved when Jesus comes back.
 
Last edited:

Ferris Bueller

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2020
9,979
4,552
113
Middle South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The entire discussion in these previous chapters is about the Sin Of Unbelief ...nothing else of importance except that.Hebrews 10, when it refers to “ Willful Sinning” continues the discussion of hearing the Gospel , Rejecting the Gospel and returning to the Temple, still putting trust in animal sacrifices instead of putting Total Trust in the Blood Jesus....
You don't seem to understand that when you willfully return to your sins you also are rejecting the Gospel. You are in the same willful unbelief as the Jew who willingly goes back to his old life of Mosaic temple worship.
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hi BB53,

Which false Gospels are wrecking the Faith?? There are thousands of Protestant churches teaching hundreds of different "truths" sooooo which one do you think is teaching The Truth???

Keep responding to me....It shows your soul.

Merry Christmas....Mary



Here is your “ False Gospel”........when you hear ANYBODY say , “ Jesus Saves— B U T” you can rest assured everything on the other side of that “ BUT” is a False, Perverted addition to Paul’s Gospel Found In 1Cor15:1-4. A Gospel Of Grace Plus NOTHING.....for Salvation.
When somebody says,( and it can be a Protestant or a Catholic ) That “ Nothing But The Blood Of Jesus” should REALLY go “ Nothing But The Blood Of Jesus Plus obeying the Commandments, Plus Repenting From all know Sins, etc. , etc.......you can KNOW you are indulging a False Gospel.
There are many things that are Good- many things that we SHOULD do as part of our “ Reasonable Service” AFTER we are Saved......they are NOT the Gospel.....
The Gospel is not a THING “ to do” .....it is a PROMISE to be “BELIEVED”......If you Believe it to the point of RESTING in it ( one and the same, actually) , God will put His Spirit in you and you will FIND YOURSELF doing the things that please God.....if you are foolish and/or weak, God will chastise you like any loving parent would to get you back on track....you may not like that and you may not understand that, but God chastises His Children for their OWN good.....
So you got your False Gospels Of “ do do this and dint do that”, and you also have the proper Gospel that one MUST TRUST to be Saved , but most people PROVE that they don’t Trust it because they have to ADD to it.....Paul said those that ADD to it with ANYTHING are “ Fallen From Grace” (Gal 5 )
90% of the Protestant Church members are in that state and 100% of all of those that adhere to Catholic Doctrine.They are completely oblivious to that Truth.Some very gifted Bible Teachers maintain that “ falling from Grace” is tantamount to Damnation.....others , like myself, disagree with that . Who knows for sure? A wise person would not gamble with their Eternal Salvation being on the line....Be ASSURED of your Salvation! Pray that God show you how to “ Rest in the Gospel Of Grace” as He Commanded you to do in Hebrews 3 and 4....... God bless....
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Do you believe that there are multiple gospels in the New Testament?

You seem to imply this by isolating 1 Corinthians 15 as “the gospel God will ask us about.”


I don’t care if there are 50 “ gospels” in the Bible .... I know there are at least 4 times that Paul referred to 1cor 15:1-4 as “ HIS” Gospel ....Paul said it was the One that Saves us if Simply Believed and He also said that “ HIS” Gospel will be used by God to judge Mankind on Judgement Day.....
Paul probably said “ His” Gospel to differentiate it from among others....probably the False ones that existed then and still exist today. Like this one—- “ Jesus Saves.... BUT!” It should ring a bell here...
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Listen.

I was accused of going over top for pointing out that those who say that only Paul’s gospel is the true gospel are essentially saying that the Bible contains other gospel’s; making the Holy Spirit guilty of being accursed for inspiring writers to write other gospels.

Now instead of replying with dismissive words, why don’t you answer the question:

Are there other gospels in the New Testament?


Yep....around Seven of them , I believe....
 

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
71
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You don't seem to understand that when you willfully return to your sins you also are rejecting the Gospel. You are in the same willful unbelief as the Jew who willingly goes back to his old life of Mosaic temple worship.


Nope.....when you “ willfully sin” as YOU will do today before the day is over, you merely show that you still have the Old Adamic Sin Nature In you you that can be “ enticed” into the Sin “ that so easily besets us “ and causes us to “ stumble” as James taught.....
The Gospel, which you do not understand and the one that you reject , is the “ Good News” That Jesus actually died for those sins.....He paid the Price for Willful Sins . Willful sins like the following:
The willful sin where the man had sex with his own Mother .....the willful sins of getting drunk at the Lord’s Table .....the willful sin where David willfully murdered a man so he could willfully commit on- going Willful Adultery with her.....the willful sins of Lot......a “ HERO of Faith” that had sex with his daughters and died drunk in a cave with NO RECORD of Repentance for His terrible Sins....would you like more examples?
These guys are in Heaven as we speak . For Two reasons and two reasons only....” CHRIST’S Blood ( retro- active in some of those cases) and “THEIR” Faith.....
Nothing has changed.....as John the Baptizer proclaimed....Jesus came here to die for the SINS of the World .....All the Work for Salvation was FINISHED at the Cross........some will “ cash in” on what Jesus ALREADY did for them by simply Believing that Jesus died for their Sins and that He rose from the Grave ( from the Gospel That Saves, 1cor15:1-4 ) Others will refuse to believe the Gospel and will prove their “ UNBELIEF” by Adding to Paul’s Gospel...
The BIG ADDITION to the simple Gospel Of Grace in Paul’s day was Circumcision——- the Big , False Additions these days are, “ The Gospel Saves , But once you know “ that” , ya gotta Repent Of all of your known sins or at least be “ willing” to do that in order to actually be Saved and STAY Saved ...
The other BIG ADDITION to the Gospel Of Grace says, “ Sure, Jesus Saves, But after you know that you must keep all of the Commandments!”
All of this stuff “ sounds” good and in fact Are Good.....they just don’t Save you or Keep you Saved.Faith in the Gospel alone does that. Additions to it make you “ Fall from Grace”..... read Galatians 5.....then read Hebrews 3 and 4.....Pray that God opens your eyes to show you the Eternal Consequences Of NOT RESTING in Paul’s Gospel Of Grace—— Plus NOTHING!
God bless...
 
Last edited:

Michiah-Imla

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2020
6,168
3,287
113
Northeast USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I don’t care if there are 50 “ gospels” in the Bible ....

Galatians 1:8 KJVS
[8] But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

By “any other gospel” you believe this implies any other gospel than what Paul preached.

So you believe that all the other Apostles (Peter, James, John), by inspiration of the Holy Spirit, preached another gospel. Which means they should be accursed based on your false doctrine.

Boy, you should care. But since you’re Once Saved Always Saved you are free to be reckless with scripture “dividing”
 

ChristisGod

Well-Known Member
Aug 15, 2020
6,912
3,864
113
64
California
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Galatians 1:8 KJVS
[8] But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.

By “any other gospel” you believe this implies any other gospel than what Paul preached.

So you believe that all the other Apostles (Peter, James, John), by inspiration of the Holy Spirit, preached another gospel. Which means they should be accursed based on your false doctrine.

Boy, you should care. But since you’re Once Saved Always Saved you are free to be reckless with scripture “dividing”
Define the gospel
 

Michiah-Imla

Well-Known Member
Oct 24, 2020
6,168
3,287
113
Northeast USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Define the gospel

Hey, smarty pants.

If someone called you saying, “I have bad news for you, X has just happened...”

Would you ask them to define “bad news” for you?

But here’s your definition since you can’t seem to find a dictionary:

Gospel

1. Glad tidings; especially, the good news concerning Christ, the Kingdom of God, and salvation. And Jesus went about all Galilee, teaching in their synagogues, and preaching the gospel of the kingdom. Matt. iv. 23. The steadfast belief of the promises of the gospel. Bentley.

But I do have bad news for you by the way; you are this person:

1 Timothy 6:3-4 KJVS
[3] If any man teach otherwise, and consent not to wholesome words, even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the doctrine which is according to godliness; [4] He is proud, knowing nothing, but doting about questions and strifes of words, whereof cometh envy, strife, railings, evil surmisings

You should repent my friend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 07-07-07
Status
Not open for further replies.