Search results

Yet, Paul preached to Israel, and Peter preached to Gentiles, so... Paul even rebuked Peter for being out of step with the Truth of the Gospel... but whose Gospel was Paul calling Peter to obey? Is it just a coincidence that the very same issue Paul corrected Peter about (causing Gentile...

The guy is completely lost, and incorrigible.

Yeah, dogmas related to faith and morals are "infallible". I didn't say I'm disproving Papal Infallibility, necessarily, just the infallibility claim of your Church on dogmas related to faith and morals, and I gave the examples of their dogmas where they erred.

The first post shares it. You didn't bother reading it before responding to it, apparently. That is the norm with people around here (Proverbs 18:13). If you crave that discussion, go ahead and post a thread about it, but that is not the topic of this thread, and it won't be made to be the topic.

Dogmas fall under "infallibility".

I already proved it; you're welcome to address my proof.

Nah, the discussion isn't shifting : Irenaeus erred, and your Church followed his error, then codified it as "infallible", so you believe Mary is the New Eve, when only the Church even could qualify as the New Eve. That is only one among your many errors--but, again, have a go at the actual...

Infallibility of the Pope Papal infallibility is a Catholic dogma that asserts the Pope, when speaking ex cathedra (from the chair) on matters of faith and morals, is preserved from error by the Holy Spirit. This doctrine, formally defined at the First Vatican Council in 1870, doesn't mean the...

2nd century AD. I don't mind if you mock, but I'd also like a substantive response, which I notice you did not (could not?) provide.

The Roman Catholic Church says it cannot err in teaching, among other things, dogma.

I'm your brother, and I am glad it's sorted out. Please do pray for me, so that, by God's grace, He will be glorified in every aspect of my life.

Yeah, and Paul identifies the Jews he preaches to, and who believe, as "the remnant of Israel" (Ro 11). LOL Well, it was fun while it lasted, but you're done.

OK I just wanted to make sure you weren't objecting to the idea that they preached the same Gospel as a means of trying to preserve Israel--again, I don't really know what is motivating your insistence that they preached different Gospels.

Both Peter (Acts 2:21) and Paul (Romans 10:13) preached salvation through calling on the Name of the LORD, citing literally the same verse of Scripture. Peter preached Christ's death and resurrection, as well--and "the blood" was preached when Peter references his crowd's having crucified God's Son.

Peter didn't just preach Jesus was God's Son : Peter preached that Jesus was a miracle-worker, and was the Messiah they had been waiting for, but that they had crucified Him, but that God had raised Christ from the dead, and sat Him at God's right hand, and that they can be forgiven of their...

The two are one and the same doctrine : "come together, it's not a sin anymore, Peter"; "there is no distinction between Jew and Gentile...". Again, Paul rebuked Peter for not walking in accordance with THE TRUTH OF THE GOSPEL in Galatians 2... so, WHICH Gospel was Paul bringing Peter in line...

So, would you deny that the ones who you say are "in Christ", but not "Christ's body", share in Christ's death and resurrection?

How could Paul not be part of the "remnant of Israel"? Do you know what "remnant of Israel" means? It refers to the small part of Israel that is saved and not lost. Paul refers to this in Romans 11--just as in the days of Elijah, God preserved for Himself 7000 who had not bowed the knee to Baal...

So, if the remnant of Israel is "in Christ", why are they not "the body of Christ"? What do you think it means to be "in Christ"? They are mystically unified with the body of Christ, partaking in both His death and resurrection. In what sense do they partake? Well, in the sense that the Jewish...

Well, if Peter was abiding in Christ, how is Peter not considered to be in the body of Christ? LOL!