I know catholic priests that believe the above.Yes, this is right until they are consumed and the darkness will be complete for them. Where will the darkness be then? Gone!
When sin and all those who love and practice a lie are destroyed, the whole universe, both animate and inanimate, once more will pulse with harmony and reflect the glory of God.
Attempting to fit living eternally with weeping and gnashing of teeth is not only contrary to the justice, it is an insult to God.
Imagine.... Taking the position of eternal weeping and gnashing of teeth etc....Jesus taking the place of the sinner in bearing his punishment would mean that his torture on the cross should be ongoing for eternity. No, no, no, this is contrary to scripture and and reveals the nature of the Devil.
What I don't understand in your position is this...
The bible speaks of eternity. If we have a soul, it is surely eternal.
How would a soul become consumed if it's not something that can be felt?
And what scripture verses do you use?
The ones I know who believe as you do just trust that God is merciful and good and would never subject a person to an eternal darkness without Him and also because they feel He's responsible for making us in the first place if He knew what would happen..I mean knowing what would happen.