Once saved always saved

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

PeterAndroz

Well-Known Member
May 15, 2026
1,480
375
83
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
So you wont answer it the same as peter?

V45 and v43-44 are the same servant YES OR NO?


I know if you say NO your know thats not true but if you say YES it shows osas isnt true.... so be careful and a simple YES or NO and nothing else..... then we can move on to another question....
You refuse to answer whether whome also requires WORKS/PERFORMANCE to be & or remain saved.
Either you don't know or want to hide you believe
 

PeterAndroz

Well-Known Member
May 15, 2026
1,480
375
83
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
We know in v42 thru 46 is Jesus cause in v40 Jesus gives a warning to be ready for his coming..


And if your doing the work of a servant your rewarded but if not your apointes with the unbelievers
For those who are being referred to which you obviously believe you are
Conc :- whome rejects Paul as the Christ chosen Apostle for today
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,755
16,019
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Luke 12:42-48

43-44) the servant is saved (eph 2:8) and when the Master comes (rapture) and finds that servant (doing works of a servant) he is blessed

45-46) BUT IF THAT SERVATE instead falls back to his old life (before he was saved) the master comes (rapture) he will be cut asunder (left not taken) and NOW he is apointed with the unbelievers.


Is the servant in v45 the same servant being mentioned in v 43-44


YES OR NO?

yes or no is 1 word btw..........





Taken says: nothing to do with being SAVED

WHO ME replys... who else can it be other than Jesus who appoints this person with the unbelievers?


Still waiting on peter and taken to answer a plain and simple YES OR NO - just 1 word period....
Your narrative does not present express facts, to give your demanded Yes or No response.


I addressed your accusation toward me.
Why no answer?
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You refuse to answer whether whome also requires WORKS/PERFORMANCE to be & or remain saved.
Either you don't know or want to hide you believe
If you peter read my first reply tonight you would see I wrote that being saved was eph 2:8 Gods grace through the believers faith.... no works needed....got it?

So you were already answered had you took the time


So Now YES or NO peter...is the servant in v45 the same servant as in v 43-44?
Again Yes or no.....
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Your narrative does not present express facts, to give your demanded Yes or No response.


I addressed your accusation toward me.
Why no answer?

You stated that it had nothing to do with being saved which I answered and said who else but Jesus can appoint you with the unbelievers?

I also showed were in v40 jesus was talking about being Ready when he comes.....


Simple 1 word....
Can you answer YES OR NO... is the servant in v45 the same servant from v 43-4YES OR NO then we can move onto another single question....
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The following statements are true about 12:40 - 46

1.) Jesus is talking about being ready for his coming to believers v40
2.) There is only 1 servant in verses 43-45
3.) Jesus is the master who rewards in v 43-44 if your doing works of a servant at His coming.
4.) Only Jesus would be able to appoint you with the unbelievers
5.) Osas is a false teaching
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If peter or taken or anyone else cannot give a simple answer to if the servant in v43-44 is the same servant in v45 then I have nothing to discuse...

the reason no one solves anything on this site is they go with multiple questions and verses and should try just 1 at a time....


YES OR NO
for the 10th time or more
 

PeterAndroz

Well-Known Member
May 15, 2026
1,480
375
83
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
If you peter read my first reply tonight you would see I wrote that being saved was eph 2:8 Gods grace through the believers faith.... no works needed....got it?

So you were already answered had you took the time


So Now YES or NO peter...is the servant in v45 the same servant as in v 43-44?
Again Yes or no.....
""I wrote that being saved was eph 2:8 Gods grace through the believers faith.... no works needed..""
Hooray, part of the teachings of Paul that teaches eternally saved REGARDLESS of works/rewards
..
v45 - relist the chapter/verse
 
Last edited:

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,755
16,019
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You stated that it had nothing to do with being saved which I answered and said who else but Jesus can appoint you with the unbelievers?

I also showed were in v40 jesus was talking about being Ready when he comes.....


Simple 1 word....
Can you answer YES OR NO... is the servant in v45 the same servant from v 43-4YES OR NO then we can move onto another
You present “References” not Scripture…
Add your personal belief…
Then demand a limited answer.

So as expected … no simple answer from you.
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Luke 12:40-46

40 starts by Jesus giving a warning about being ready for his coming..


Question is: the servant in v 43:44 is the same in v45 where it says: But if THAT servant


YES or NO.... 1 word answer as its either yes or no.... nothing else is needed
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You present “References” not Scripture…
Add your personal belief…
Then demand a limited answer.

So as expected … no simple answer from you.
Its all in 12:40 thru 46 luke.... geeeez its in your bible too.... nice way to defer


Limited answer?

Is the servant in v43-44 and 45 the same servant yes or no... it can only be yes or no correct?

So yes or no...if your not willing to answer this simple question then youve shown you wont cause it condemns your osas..

Yes it is or no its not... its one or the other
 
Last edited:

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Youd think out of 2 people you could get an answer of yes or no.... but they keep refusing to answer and will come back with another excuse why they wont....
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,755
16,019
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You stated that it had nothing to do with being saved which I answered and said who else but Jesus can appoint you with the unbelievers?

I also showed were in v40 jesus was talking about being Ready when he comes.....


Simple 1 word....
Can you answer YES OR NO... is the servant in v45 the same servant from v 43-4YES OR NO then we can move onto another single question....
And?

When He “comes” … TO Earth …His Saved IN Christ are with Him…
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I believe Ive been asking YES OR NO since page 4..... lets work on 1 thing before moving on to others.... solve 1 thing...makes sense
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
30,755
16,019
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Youd think out of 2 people you could get an answer of yes or no.... but they keep refusing to answer and will come back with another excuse why they wont....
This thread is OSAS…
Not go look up Scriptures that interest you and demand an answer you decide.

Are you Saved?
If yes How many times?

I haven’t referenced Scriptures for you to look up, nor mentioned the Lord Jesus, or a random lord (employer)…

You made an accusation to me personally…
So why not respond to my question?
 

PeterAndroz

Well-Known Member
May 15, 2026
1,480
375
83
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Luke 12:40-46

40 starts by Jesus giving a warning about being ready for his coming..


Question is: the servant in v 43:44 is the same in v45 where it says: But if THAT servant


YES or NO.... 1 word answer as its either yes or no.... nothing else is needed


N/A , those verses are not spoken to those saved by the 1 Cor 15:1-4, Eph 1:13 Gospel exclusively taught to Paul by Christ in Gal 1:11-12
..
So what point are you trying to make ?
I believe Ive been asking YES OR NO since page 4..... lets work on 1 thing before moving on to others.... solve 1 thing...makes sense
If you are asking regarding a different age/audience than believers 'today' then I will happily answer YES or NO
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
N/A , those verses are not spoken to those saved by the 1 Cor 15:1-4, Eph 1:13 Gospel exclusively taught to Paul by Christ in Gal 1:11-12
..
So what point are you trying to make ?

If you are asking regarding a different age/audience than believers 'today' then I will happily answer YES or NO
My question was is the servant in v43-44 The same as v45.... yes or no either it is or it is not......
 

WHO ME

Member
Jun 22, 2026
231
86
28
62
Jupiter
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Told you theyd never answer such a simple question..... either the servant is the same or he is not the same.... yes or no...


Hey if you dont want to you dont have to but that tells people alot.......