And you are engaging in spurious reasoning.
For this scheme to be true would mean that Jesus died only for believers. But the opposite is true. Jesus died for the sins of the whole world. As in...for God so loved the world...not just the church. ALL men were seen as unbelievers at Jesus' death.
So if Jesus only died for the church then why pour out His wrath on Jesus for believers...only to have to later pour His wrath on unbelievers?
The bible does not support a God who has preferences or respect for men. THAT is an invention of self-gratifying humanity.
Notice what the bible actually records....
1 Tim 4:10
For therefore we both labour and suffer reproach, because we trust in the living God, who is the Saviour of all men, specially of those that believe.
Jesus died for ALL men. It is
the resurrection of Christ that is specifically for believers. So that we may walk as Jesus walked.
1 John 2:2 He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world.
So either the wrath for the whole world was poured out on Jesus....which is ridiculous and heretical...OR...Jesus died for the sins of the whole world...and whoever rejects Christ is under wrath...and refused life in the resurrection to come.
The righteous are justified by the death of Jesus. The holy are justified by His resurrection and the grace derived from that...to walk in.
So
the resurrection life is reserved for they who believe. But the wrath of God is to come. Jesus was crucified by evil men. And He continues to be crucified by many who profess to love Him.
Jesus was put to death by men because they hate truth...just look at they who speak evil of Him today...both believers and unbelievers. Each has their own agenda.