I have been watching this thread with more than a little fascination. A couple of things have jumped out at me as very interesting.
First, how quickly we are to "judge" the pastor in this situation, who, by the way, is not here to defend himself (assuming he would), all the while commenting on how the pastor should not judge. It is incredible to see how quickly a straight line can be drawn from being over weight to gluttony, as if there were no other reason he could possibly be over weight. A few of the comments have even been by people whom I would believe would defend anyone that was being blasted for being overweight on a normal day. Why the jump straight to gluttony? Very interesting, could something else be in\at play?
Second, I am not, nor have I ever taken a single drink of alcohol, of any kind. I will never drink. This statement may disqualify me in some eyes as being able to rightly discern anything along this line of conversation. I do not try to stop anyone from drinking, nor will I. It is, quite frankly, none of my business. If asked, I will tell you that I believe it is wrong....especially for a Christian. Is it sin? Yes. Is it worse sin than I have in my life having never taken a drink? No.
I can not rightly judge the struggle with the sin of drinking having never taken a drink, but I do have sin in my life that I do struggle with on a daily basis, and on that same principle, I can tell you, it is easy to try to justify myself, tell myself why I got trapped in the same pattern again, how I got trapped, and it's not really my fault. I, like many, struggle laying aside the sin which does easily beset me. (Hebrews 12:1)
Grace and mercy are amazing concepts. I can not fully grasp them. Grace (obtaining something I do not deserve to obtain) is something I hope we have all experienced here, and it is something we can not hope to deserve in it's purest form. God does caution us in intentionally doing something knowing we can count on His grace to cover us. We would count the blood of Christ an unworthy thing and in that case...It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God. (Hebrews 10:26-31)
Mercy (not getting what I do deserve) is definitely something we all get everyday from God. One of the truest marks of a Christian is how compassionate you can be toward your fellow man...knowing that ultimate mercy God has poured out on you. You can easily put yourself into their shoes...so to speak. But this compassion still does not confuse right\wrong, good\evil.
All this being said, my heart breaks for this situation, and I have been keeping it in my prayers lately. It is so hard some days in our struggle with sin...others it seems like an easy task. My hope is, we have all obtained grace and mercy. My hope is, we all understand what we deserve. My hope is, we will be willing to extend that same grace and mercy....even to the pastor...even if he is a glutton not a drinker.
SL